Xbcom/275 Final Debate Paper

2000 words - 8 pages

Final Project: Debate Paper
XBCOM/275
October 6, 2013

Should a Death Row Inmate be Granted a Last Meal
One of the most controversial debates today is regarding the ability for death row inmates to order a last meal before execution. What sparked the debate most recently is when a man named Lawrence Russell Brewer, a death row inmate housed in a Texas prison, ordered a meat lovers pizza, two chicken fried steaks with gravy and fried onions, tomatoes, bell peppers, onions, and jalapeños, a large bowl of fried okra and a side of ketchup, three fajitas, one pound of barbequed meat with a half of loaf of white bread, one triple patty cheeseburger, a pan of peanut butter fudge topped ...view middle of the document...

” The condemned are often sedated before execution. They are generally not allowed to listen to music, lest it induce an emotional reaction. Last words are sometimes delivered in writing, rather than spoken; if they are spoken, it might be to prison personnel rather than the witnesses. Still today, it is traditionally common for family and friends to share food for a visitation, funeral services and after, so when someone dies, is there a connection in food and death? With society now basically excluded from the execution process, much of the larger societal meaning of capital punishment, and last meals, has been lost.
For years, the public has been fascinated with death row inmates and their fate. Notorious murderers, serial killers, and con men have been in the news with their terrifying crimes reported. It is the morbid fascination the public has with when, where, and how these prisoners will die. As a courtesy, for many years to date, these prisoners are given the opportunity to order a “last meal.” Typically, these last meals contain comfort foods such as fried chicken, pizza, ice cream, and chocolate. Inmates have also been known to make simple requests such as a cup of tea, a cup of coffee, or toast and eggs. People whom are sympathizers, typically religious, feel that the last meal of a condemned man is important. Normally, the comfort foods ordered prior to execution is somewhat of a comfort to the individual. The meal has been allowed in most of the United States because it brings down the level of stress and negative excitement and anxiety of the inmate to a more manageable level for the executioners and public at large. One theory of granting the last meal is, the American citizens want to be more humane toward the person that is being prepared for execution. If this is so, was the crime they committed to get on death row, humane? After all, the American citizens have to distinguish the violence of its punishment from the punishing, so by allowing a last meal and a final statement, this shows a level of dignity and compassion are extended to the condemned that the inmate didn’t show their victims. Should the last meal be replaced with time for the inmate to have extra time to offer an apology to their victims or the victims’ family or to proclaim their innocence for the last time? The importance of the last meal stems from the Bible, and Jesus’s last meal. Jesus was to be crucified the next morning and was given an opportunity to have a last meal with his closest friends. We should also keep in mind that the Bible states that we are not to judge one another, so should we even be depriving a death row inmate from being granted a last meal? Many proponents of keeping the last meal request feel a sense of compassion and forgiveness toward the condemned. However, it seems these people are also NOT the family members of the victims that these killers left behind. Mostly, the people in favor of keeping this last request...

Other Papers Like Xbcom/275 Final Debate Paper

Acc 555 Wk 5 Midterm Exam - All Possible Questions

1225 words - 5 pages fallacies in the argument. Format your rebuttal consistent with APA guidelines. BCOM 275 week 3 Team Assignment Learning Team Debate Paper Outline Resources: Debate Paper assignment requirements located in Week Five. Create an outline for the Debate Paper that will be used to write the paper. Include all references to be used in the paper. Resource: “Over 30 Workers Trapped After Chilean Copper Mine Collapse” article found in the

Bcom 275 Entire Class Individual and Team Assignments and Dqs Bcom 275 (Business Communications & Critical Thinking)

1225 words - 5 pages . • Identify any logical fallacies in the argument.  Format your rebuttal consistent with APA guidelines.   BCOM 275 week 3 Team Assignment Learning Team Debate Paper Outline Resources: Debate Paper assignment requirements located in Week Five. Create an outline for the Debate Paper that will be used to write the paper. Include all references to be used in the paper.  Resource: “Over 30 Workers Trapped After Chilean Copper Mine Collapse

Professor

2247 words - 9 pages . | | | | | | | | | |Note: Final Examination questions are adapted from Communicating in the Workplace and | | | | |Critical Learning. | | | |Learning Team |Resource: Learning Team Debate Paper

Gays In The Military

574 words - 3 pages Gays in the Military Keith Shaheen BCOM/275 June 14, 2010 Gays in the Military In this paper, the writer will locate an article on a controversial subject. Controversial is defined as “subject to controversy; debate” (Dictionary, LLC.. 2010, para. 1). In addition, the article will include an argument the writer does not agree with. In earlier times of the Crusades, the Knights Templar had been persecuted and many of their group was

debate paper

1005 words - 5 pages  Debate Paper BCOM/275 January 25, 2015 Debate Paper Over the years and across the nation the subject of legalizing the recreational use of marijuana had been a controversial topic. There are those who believe marijuana is bad for you and should remain outlawed and carry heavy consequences if caught using or selling. While on the other side of the spectrum, there are those who believe it is not dangerous and should be

Ethical Health Care Issues Paper

1082 words - 5 pages Ethical Health Care Issues Paper HCS/545 July 28, 2014 In the last decade, the debate over the ethics of organ and transplant allocation has intensified and the attention sensationalized in the media. At the core of this issue, critical questions remain. They include but are not limited to those regarding economics, race, and geographic inequity and about the moral relevance and weight of geography

Lockheed Tri Star Case Write Up

1913 words - 8 pages project reached economic break-even with the production of 275 planes at $12.5 M per unit but did not reach value break-even at that level of production. We found that to reach value break-even Tri-Star would have to produce about 400 planes at $11.75 M per unit. The NPV at this rate was $42 M. It is clear that the decision by Lockheed to embark on the Tri Star program was not a reasonable one. Lockheed’s share price plummeted from $64 (Jan

English

661 words - 3 pages Gurdon and Alexi Summary Opinion Paper – W 130 The objective of this paper is to practice introducing a conversation/debate, briefly summarizing two article’s main points in your own words, and offering your position in regards to the debate by responding to the arguments in an academic way. -Utilize the templates provided to structure your paper. -Avoid quoting any text. Use your own words and sentence structure, not the author’s

Nature vs Nuture

1542 words - 7 pages Running Head: NATURE VS. NUTURE FINAL Nature vs. Nuture Final Paper Jodie Gilkey Liberty University Psychology 101 – D37 LUO Nature vs. Nurture Introduction Nature vs. Nuture has been a big question for psychologists for many years. Is it hereditary the way that we think and behave or is it nature from the environment that we were raised in? I personally think that behavior is determined by both. The genetic

Gun Control Debate

2487 words - 10 pages Gun Control Debate By Mary Dyke, Lindsey Kjer, Stuart Moneymaker, Christina Marquez and Josh Marr BCOM/275 April 15, 2013 Gun Control Debate Gun control is a heated topic for debate right now in the United States. Many people are pro-gun control while others are against it. One fact is: “The Second Amendment only restricts the federal and state governments from imposing gun control that would completely deprive citizens of the right

To What Extent Is Security a Necessary Precondition for Development?

3117 words - 13 pages consideration of the latter, and not considered within this particular analysis. The third and final manifestation of this development instrumental link is where the ‘social contract’ has broken down between the state and its citizens. Each of these elements, it is put forward, lead to a breakdown of security, and thus conflict. Conflicts related to group motivation arise in situations where there are two distinct groups of people; one agitating for power

Related Essays

Xbcom/275 Final Paper Should Welfare Recipients Be Required To Drug Test?

2448 words - 10 pages the results and the efficacy of that drug-testing programI. Proponent Argument for a Law Requiring Drug TestingPro Argument A: There are valid arguments on both sides of this debate and deciding which side to take might depend on proportionality and degree rather than absolutes and principles, though claiming, "It's the principle of the thing" is valid in its own right. A small flaw in this aspect of the argument though is that it presumes that

Bcom/275 Debate Paper Marijuana Legalization

2071 words - 9 pages Should medical marijuana be legalized nationwide? Team A BCOM/275 October 9, 2011 UoP Instructor Should medical marijuana be legalized nationwide? The use of marijuana for the treatment of patients with serious health conditions is currently one of the top contentious debate topics in the United States. Until its prohibition in 1937, marijuana was one the top three most prescribed medicines in the United States. To

Audience Analysis

370 words - 2 pages Validity, Credibility, and Reliability Jannilka DeLeon XBCOM/275 June 1, 2014 Monica Galante Validity, Credibility, and Reliability Some reasons I consider data or information to lack validity, credibility, or reliability is when there is no supporting evidence. When you read something and it is not coming from a credible source than you now that the information provided is not accurate. Especially when doing research for a project

Articual Rebuttal Essay

833 words - 4 pages Article Rebuttal XBCOM/275 Tynia M. Landry 03/14/2014 Article Rebuttal In this paper the subject discussed concerns the 2008 introduction of California Proposition 8. It will contest the statements made by the author and provide meaningful information that will rebut the misleading assertions documented in the article. Statement 1 According to Laura Brill, the author of the article – It’s time for Prop. 8 opponents to re-engage