This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Women In Combat Essay

3082 words - 13 pages

Alexandria Taylor Esquivel
Professor E. Perez Romero
Philosophy 8
4 June 2014
Should Women Serve in Combat?
Whether women should serve in combat has been up for debate for many years. Feminist and equal rights activists argue that women should be allowed to serve in combat, but there are many military and government officials as well as American citizens who feel differently (America’s Military 1). Some argue that women should not be allowed to serve in combat, although women have served during wartime in roles that have exposed them to combat, death, and capture since the American Revolution (Women’s Memorial: Casualty 1-3; Women’s Memorial: POW’s 1-2). Women have been ...view middle of the document...

Direct combat is further acknowledged as that which takes place while closing with an enemy by fire, maneuver, and shock action to destroy or capture him while repelling his assault by fire or counter attack (Trainor 60). Identifying front lines is not an easy task in today’s modern battlefield. The lines become blurred when women in combat support roles are sent closer and closer to the front lines and are actually exposed to ground combat. Support roles actually put female soldiers in combat areas. If a female flight surgeon on an Apache helicopter is shot down it would be impossible for her to avoid the combat zone. In Desert Storm, scud missiles were launched deep behind front lines where there were many women soldiers (Campbell 43-44). One such missile landed in a military barracks in Dhahran, Saudi Arabia far behind front lines resulting in three women being killed (Womens Memorial: Casualty 2). When a woman is put in the position of being hit by a scud missile or having her helicopter shot down, it seems that she surely meets the definition of serving in combat. Although the military does not acknowledge that women serve in combat roles, they have throughout history and have shown to be capable of handling the job. It does not seem fair for the military to enforce the combat exclusion rule when jobs that they are allowing women put them in a position of being in combat. If a woman is capable of serving in combat support roles that may put them in actual combat then she is capable of serving in the actual combat role.
The military has always been concerned about women being captured by the enemy during wartime. They worry that it would cause problems with the moral of the citizens back home (Campbell 46). Although it is not a widely known fact, women have been held as prisoners of war as far back as the Civil War when the Confederates held Doctor Mary Edward serving with the 52nd Ohio Volunteers with the Union Army for four months. Since that time, there have been eighty-seven women held as prisoners of war in World War II, two in Operation Desert Storm, and two during Operation Iraqi Freedom (Women’s Memorial: Casualty 1-3). So it seems strange for our nation to act surprised when Soshannna Johnson and Jessica Lynch, who both served in combat support units were captured during Operation Iraqi Freedom (Blankenship 14). As an American citizen, I was just as appalled that there were men captured by the Iraqi’s during Operation Iraqi Freedom, as I was that there were women that were captured. No matter what gender is being held captive, both are still subject to the same atrocities of being a prisoner of war such as starvation, deprivation, psychological and physical torture, and possible rape. Some opposed to women in combat argue that direct combat will put women in positions of becoming prisoners of war. Without a doubt there is much greater probability of acts of sexual molestation and rape with the...

Other Papers Like Women in Combat

Women In The Military Essay

2687 words - 11 pages Running head: WOMEN IN THE MILITARY Women in the Military: Controversy of Direct Combat Strayer University Women in the Military: Controversy of Direct Combat Section I: Introduction Women have been in the military, or associated with combat for decades. “The most famous example of the ability of a woman to not only be involved in combat but to lead forces is that of Joan of Arc's legendary battles leading the French army when she

The Role of Women During World War Ii

785 words - 4 pages factories, munitions plants, and farms. They drove trucks, provided logistic support for soldiers, and entered professional areas of work that were previously the preserve of men. American women also saw combat during World War II. First they were nurses in the Army Nurse Corps and United States Navy Nurse Corps during the Attack on Pearl Harbor, and later the Japanese invasion of the Philippines. The Women's Army Auxiliary Corps (WAAC), Women’s

Women in the Canadian Military

658 words - 3 pages obtain any job in the Canadian Military. At first women were only given the option of thirty different jobs, a number which slowly raised to fifty-five before the end of the war effort. The number ever increasing to what it is today.[viii] Finally, in 1991 the first three women graduated as officers in combat arms.[ix] The women of the Canadian Womens Army Corps are some of the most dedicated of people. They stopped at nothing to be equal to men


1016 words - 5 pages described PTSD-like symptoms as "Da Costa’s Syndrome" during the Civil War ( In World of Criminal Justice, Gale, 2002). In combat situations, military veterans experience the death of others, including their close battle buddies. They are also exposed to a high level of stress every day while they are in combat with their opposing side. Men and women in combat also have to deal with the colleagues they see every day which can also cause stress. Not

The Women's Army Corp (Wac)

2612 words - 11 pages military as the fighting was now taking place overseas and the need arose for a larger army, women were now able to begin serving a role that would be recognized in the various branches of the military; the Army, Navy, Marines and Coast Guard. These positions were still considered civilian positions and the women did not serve in combat or receive military benefits, instead they served the purpose of enabling the military to send more men to the front

Post Traumatic Stress Disorder in War Veterans

2536 words - 11 pages , American Psychiatric Assocation) 3.0 PTSD IN WAR VETERANS 3.1 Facts & Figures Operation Iraqi Freedom has become the deadliest American military conflict since the Vietnam War. Uto 13 percent of the troops returning from the deployment have reported symptoms of post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). With the daily violence in this war torn country, service men and women are subjected to increased levels of stress which can trigger PTSD

Human Society

1144 words - 5 pages in the military could be this whole essay, but I will try to just go over a few points. Even though, the ban has been lifted for women to serve on the front lines in combat, there is still a long way to go. An example of this is rape. 1 in 3 women serving in the U.S. military in Iraq are raped. This will continue to go on because this behavior is shoved under the rug and the military doesn’t want this to get out in to the media’s hands. The

Dove Beauty English 102

1023 words - 5 pages Olivia Fortier March 14, 2014 C. Hellwig English 102-038 Rhetorical Analysis Women Don’t Have to Be One Shape to Be Beautiful Dove’s Real Beauty advertising campaign is meant to promote a positive body image for young girls and women alike. The campaign was designed to combat problems women have been facing for decades, even centuries: self esteem issues and unrealistic views on body image. If you ask a woman her definition of

Iron Jawed Angels Essay

595 words - 3 pages donations to the NWP, he took away her children and threatened to file divorce. This only fueled Emily’s passion to get equal rights. She temporarily gave up her family to fight for her vote, so in the future she could have a fighting chance for her children. Iron Jawed Angels illustrates instances where women were left feeling powerless, so they band together to combat the forces that treated them so unfairly. Through their journey the women of the NWP had to change how society viewed them as a gender, and overcome established societal norms. Some of them suffered the consequences of trying to change a countries habit, but in the end they were triumphant.

Group Therapy Interventions for Combat Veterans Suffering from Ptsd

1385 words - 6 pages post-traumatic stress disorder only compounds the difficulty of treating this persistent disorder. Post-traumatic stress disorder causes great difficulties in all areas of life for the individual with the diagnosis as well as friends and families of the combat veteran. Fortunately, there are several evidence-based practices and interventions that therapists can employ to help these brave men and women including thought-stopping, exposure therapy

Gs1140T - Paradigm Shift

608 words - 3 pages lifesaving impact could be the incorporation of this device into the military combat training. Wars happen and what if we could possibly save the lives of our men and women on the battlefield by reducing the unnecessary risks with this device. This could be achieved by giving our soldiers a human sensory system to use in a virtual experience of simulated combat missions. This could possibly be a huge thing to our government. We could lower training

Related Essays

Women In Combat Essay

1175 words - 5 pages Student’s Name Professor’s Name Course Name 27-03-2016 Women in Military Combat: Should they be Allowed to Serve or Not? The question of whether women should be allowed to serve in military combat has always been a contentious issue with some of the people claiming that women should be allowed to serve in military combat positions while others insisting that military combat positions are meant for men. This paper is going to give an in-depth

Women And Combat Essay

520 words - 3 pages Women and Combat Women should not be allowed in combat situations. As a woman I know all the arguments of equality in the work force. Also being in a family with former and current military persons I see the arguments and effects of military life. The pentagon has changed some of its rules but not many. Physical limitations, psychological effects, maternal instinct with the possibility of becoming a target are still all reasons women should

Women In The Military Essay

930 words - 4 pages women in W.W.I/W.W.II include nurses, munitions factory workers, sewing bandages, selling war bonds, shipyards and spies. Some also worked on planes as mechanics and pilots. Korean Conflict: During the Korean Conflict most women were restricted to clerical and nursing duties. Vietnam: During Vietnam women served as nurses and were close behind fighting troops and were exposed to combat conditions and fighting forces. They were trained on how to

This Is A Man's World Essay

1109 words - 5 pages This is a Man’s World This is a Man’s World War is mentally and physically straining. When a country goes to war it depends on its military to be up for any challenge war has to offer. 50 years ago the thought of a woman joining the ranks were laughable; today it is a reality. Women have proved that they can doubtfully be called the weaker gender, and recently have been able to serve in combat roles. Combat roles are the most dangerous and