Why The Golden Rule Does Not Work

965 words - 4 pages

The Golden Rule is a universally recognized guideline for proper ethical behavior. Many support it because it has a feel-good factor, and this rule is viewed as ‘good’. Unfortunately, this ethic of reciprocity may not always work. It seems to be merely a goodwill gesture, and is not necessarily a practical belief to enforce.
There are different ways that people seem to practice the Golden Rule. There is the high end of the rule, in which we are taught to be kind to our enemies. While this action might be truly selfless, this aspect has often been the catalyst of historical atrocities. Indoctrinated masses, failing to revolt against corrupt and ruthless rulers, have easily been led ...view middle of the document...

Following this guideline, they are given free reign to do as they please, simply because someone else may do it to them. This is confirmed in Oliver Thompson’s statement, “At the lower end, this is the rule of vendetta, 'an eye for an eye'. Violent behavior by one group tends to produce a justification for the morality of violence by any opposing groups.” (Thompson, 1993)
Our golden rule theorem says: "Treat others only as you consent to being treated in the same situation." To apply the Golden Rule, I'd imagine myself in the other person's place on the receiving end of the action. The Golden Rule forbids the combination of my performing an action to another, then I'm unwilling that this be done to me in the same situation. (Gensler, 2003) The Golden Rule doesn't tell us what to do in this situation. It doesn't replace regular moral norms; it only prescribes consistency.
The essence of the Golden Rule is that person A can act, affecting person B, if A would not object in B's position. In turn person B can react, if A would not object to the reaction. (Crabtree, 2001) When all actions in a society follow this procedure, the society cannot be said to be wrong or unjust. The logical flaw in this is that the image involves and affects only two people. However, social reality does not often consist of simple one on one interaction without further consequences. The most obvious failure of the Golden Rule is that it contains no provision for transference of perspective to third parties. The Golden Rule is so limited, that it cannot even give a preferred outcome if three people are involved. Remember the film cliché, where gangster A has a gun to the head of gangster B, who has a gun to the head of gangster C, who has a gun to the head of gangster A, completing the circle?

Other Papers Like Why the Golden Rule Does Not Work

Why Boston Should Not Host the Olympics

1444 words - 6 pages benefit for hosting the Olympics will be the major boost in to the local economy. I would imagine the boost would work its way all the way up into New Hampshire. Many restaurants, hotels and tourists spots will be rolling in the money for the few weeks everyone is in town. I think this is the main reason Boston should place a bid for the games. For all the positives for hosting the Olympics, I can think of many reasons not to host the games

How Does Change Affect The People At Work?

908 words - 4 pages Q.1 How does change affect people at work? Managing Change : Change is Charming Embrace it ! A change means any process involving a difference in some feature of an organization at two points in time. Change is a fact of life for any organization. It is unavoidable that all organizations need to change their practice time to time as per requirement to remain in competitive market. In current scenario the organization who have made the changes

Ecstasy; the Party Drug That Does Not Feel so Good

2141 words - 9 pages Running Head: Ecstasy Ecstasy; the Party Drug That Does Not Feel So Good College students and party people love to go out on the town and feel good, but what they do not realize is that the very drug that makes everyone love each other is just a killer in disguise. Ecstasy popularly known as MDMA can cause great harm for just a fun dancing filled night. Ecstasy is becoming more and more popular to be used as a rave drug (Kalant, H. 2001

Why Is the Law so Important in Social Work?

1129 words - 5 pages translated by the social worker and used with the individual. Although a social worker does not need to study the law in detail and does not need to understand all of its many facets, a good appreciation of the law and even in some cases its origins can help a social worker provide a safe, responsible and well rounded level of service. Bibliography Braye, Suzy/ Preston-Shoot, Michael and Thorpe, Amanda (2006) Social Work Law in Practise

Does the Existence of God Show That God Does Not Exist?

1199 words - 5 pages Does the existence of evil shows God does not exist? Most folks in the world are disheartened by the bitter fact that evil happens. People are astonishment as to why God can exist and at the same time allow the evil we see and experience each and every day in our environs to prevail (Braine 1-10). They fail to fathom the reason why the capable God would by genuine reasons agree to the notion that the power of choice should be bestowed in humans

Why Does The Government Only Have Two Parties

1197 words - 5 pages candidates take a stance and try to win votes. This hurts the third parties because they don’t have tradition and know one really knows about them. The two parties give the other parties a chance but they can’t win because they two party system almost makes it impossible Discuss public opinion polls. How do they work and why are they not more accurate? To understand public opinion, pollsters divide the population into three groups based

Do Managers Need Emotional Intelligence to Manage Successfully in the Workplace? Why or Why Not?

1258 words - 6 pages affective commitment to improve the effect of job insecurity . This kind of frequently results in increased work commitment and effort, positive coping behaviors (problem-focused), and reframing of perceptions of insecurity as an existing challenge.Bradberry, Travis concludes that mnagers need to be familiar with their emotions, why you're having them, and how they factor in to the situation at hand. Here, there is no substitute for the core

"The Kind Of Knowledge Plato Has In Mind In His Theory Of Forms Is Not The Kind Of Knowledge Needed To Rule A City"

2096 words - 9 pages creation of the ideal state (Horowitz). The reason why an ideal state is needed is to guarantee the existence of justice. This does not mean, though, that there cannot be states without justice. Actually, Plato provides at least two reasons why the formation of a state cannot be avoided: human beings are not self-sufficient so they need to live in a social environment; and each person has a natural aptitude for a specified task and should

Music; What's all the hype? Mucis does not influence teens. This is a persuasive essay

526 words - 3 pages Lately there has been a lot of attention to the theory that certain kinds of music are bad influences, particularly focusing on heavier rock like Marilyn Manson, and even going so far as to blame him for the Columbine shootings. Researchers and parents say that this music has a negative effect on their children. I do not agree with this argument and in the remainder of this article, I will argue as to why I think what I do.         I

Why Does Hobbes Describe the State of Nature as a State of War?

605 words - 3 pages Sample Exam Question: Why does Hobbes describe the state of nature as a state of war? Before answering the question why Hobbes describes the state of nature as a state of war it is to be clarified what is meant by those two terms. For Hobbes, as pictured in his work “Leviathan”, the “state of nature” is the condition before the foundation of the state. In this condition of anarchy, literally everybody has the freedom to do everything he wants

Why Does the European Union Have Such a Strong Court of Justice?

3337 words - 14 pages but suggest that is subject to various qualifications; the Court may even find some reason why it should not be applied to the particular facts of the case. The principle, however, is now established. If there are not too many protests, it will be re-affirmed in later cases; the qualifications can then be whittled away and the full extent of the doctrine revealed. The Court’s case law not only contributed to its empowerment, but it acted as

Related Essays

Why Profit Does Not Equal Cash

844 words - 4 pages WHY PROFIT DOES NOT EQUAL CASH Why is profit not equal to cash coming in?   Some differences such as loans received which do not impact the profit and loss statement are pretty obvious.   Others may not be as obvious but you can break them down into three main areas: -       Revenue is booked at sale.   In many cases a sale is recorded for accounting purposes in the profit and loss statement when a company delivers a product or service.   In

The Golden Rule Essay

4601 words - 19 pages if my life depended on it, because in truth and in a very real sense, it does. Yet, I would not be honest, if I did not confess to you that in spite my best efforts to live according to The Golden Rule, I do so only very imperfectly. And that is where my faith in God comes into the picture. It is really quite simple: The stronger my faith in an all-knowing, all-loving and all-powerful God, the more perfectly I am able to love myself and to love

Why Can It Be Difficult To Decide Whether Or Not A Person Is A Carer And Does It Matter? Base Your Answer On The Case Of Someone You Know

820 words - 4 pages Name: Asha Renah 23 February 2011 Part A: Essay Title: Why can it be difficult to decide whether or not a person is a carer, and does it matter? Base your answer on the case of someone you know. In this short piece of writing I will talk about the reason why it’s a great significance to be able to say who is and who isn’t a carer. The value of being recognised for the work being done helps lift the feeling of isolation and

Why The Us Should Not Annex

580 words - 3 pages Philippines because the Filipinos are not capable of self-rule. Senator Albert Beveridge of Indiana argues the point well. Yes, he says, government should be by the consent of the governed, but only when the people are mature enough to govern themselves. He said “we govern our children without their consent” (Doc. B). Like children the Filipinos need our protection. President William McKinley made a similar point. lf the United States left the