This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Why Does The European Union Have Such A Strong Court Of Justice?

3337 words - 14 pages

1- Introduction

The aim of this paper is to provide an explanation why nowadays the European Union has such a strong Court of Justice (the Court). The paper is composed of four main parts. In the first part we will present a brief overview of the evolution of the Court of Justice through time. The second part deals with the creation of the legal doctrines as a means of empowerment of the Court. In the third part we will discuss the cooperation between the national courts and the Court, and finally the last part is dedicated to the relations between Member States and the Court. It should be noted that in each part of the paper we will bring arguments and various examples to develop a ...view middle of the document...

While, a Member State as well can bring an action against another Member State in front of the Court , but they almost never do that, they prefer to do it via the Commission, which acts as an “arbiter in this situation”.
2. Judicial review of the EU’s legislative and executive acts
3. Preliminary rulings - In case the national courts have any doubt about the interpretation or validity of EU law provisions, they may ask the Court for preliminary ruling. It is mainly done to ensure the uniform interpretation of the EU law.
The power to interpret the EU law allowed the Court to issue important and sometimes tough rulings such as those about the removal of the national non-tariff barriers to trade and the illegal subsidisation of the national industries. The Court went even further in its rulings by entering some policy areas that are particularly domestic as environmental and social policies, gender equality, competition policy, etc. Moreover, the Court had an influence over the EU policy on such issues as who will represent the Member States during the negotiations for international agreements or if they can enter into bilateral trade agreements with the third countries.
Taking into account this wide range of the influence of the Court, it is to be questioned whether the Member States could expect that the Court, using its competence to interpret the EU law, could change the EU legal system and make bold rulings that undermine considerably their sovereignty and national interests. Furthermore, could they suppose that the Court will become a tool for the domestic actors to challenge their national policies? These are powers that the Court created for itself without taking into consideration Member States’ will and intentions.
3- Direct effect and Supremacy of the EU law

Pollack has described the relations between the Member States and the Court of Justice by the principal-agent theory. This theory states that principals have interests that are different from those of agents: principals want to have control on the agents, while the agents want to have as much autonomy and authority as possible.
In fact, the Court of Justice, the agent, has shaped its authority gradually by taking important decisions, namely those establishing the principles of direct effect and supremacy of the EU law. These two doctrines are not included in the treaties; as Mancini says, they are the products of the “judicial creativity” of the Court. The principle of direct effect (in the case of Van Gend en Loos ) defines that the EU law not only imposes obligations on the individuals, but it confers upon them rights that they can claim in front of their national courts. Whereas, according to the principle of supremacy (in the case of Costa v. ENEL ), if a conflict arises between a provision of the EU law and the national law, the EU law takes precedence. These principles allow the individuals to rely on the EU law before their national courts,...

Other Papers Like Why Does the European Union Have Such a Strong Court of Justice?

Co2 Emission of European Union Countries: a Short Review

546 words - 3 pages showed me the accurate way to complete the assignment. CO2 EMISSION OF EUROPEAN UNION COUNTRIES: A SHORT REVIEW Beginning… “EU promises 20% reduction in carbon emissions by 2020” –it was published as headline in 21st February, 2007 in a number of leading newspapers of the world. From that commitment it is clear that the amount of carbon emission in the countries of EU is at an alarming state that vibrates their concern to

United Brands Company V. Commission of the European Union

3307 words - 14 pages relevant market. (276) 1.2 UBC´s position on the relevant market The European Court of Justice interpretated a dominant market condition according to Article 86 of EEC as followed: „The dominant position referred to in this article relates to a position of economic strength enjoyed by an undertaking which enables it to prevent effective competition being maintained on the relevant market by giving it the power to behave to an appreciable

Social Policy, Economics Of Labor Markets In The European Union

2813 words - 12 pages When we turn on the television we always hear something to be mentioned about the European Union. But what does European Union mean and why is it created? "The European Union has its origins in the European Coal and Steel Community (ECSC), established on 18 April 1951 by the Treaty of Paris"(Waller-Thody, 1997). It is a union of many states joining together through different enlargements. Their main purpose is to solve economic and political

Transportation In The European Union

2030 words - 9 pages concern to the Community, which had adopted a Directive laying down the ground rules for enquiries into air incidents in civil aviation. Lastly, in the White Paper "Freeing Europe's Airspace", the Commission advocates introducing a unified system of air traffic management.After having analyzed all transport infrastructures it would be very useful to observe two comparison boards of those transport infrastructures in EU (European Union } and CES

Does Csr Have a Real Impact Outside of Marketing ?

738 words - 3 pages Carpe Antoine Does CSR (Corporate Social Responsibility) have a real impact outside of marketing ? « For each product bought, a tree planted ». In 2011, the french firms Danone and Casino, as many others, answered the SOS Sahel association call to fight massive deforestation. This operation was an environmental success, and allowed more than one million trees to be planted in different areas. But it also was a marketing success, boosting the

Why Does Hobbes Describe the State of Nature as a State of War?

605 words - 3 pages Sample Exam Question: Why does Hobbes describe the state of nature as a state of war? Before answering the question why Hobbes describes the state of nature as a state of war it is to be clarified what is meant by those two terms. For Hobbes, as pictured in his work “Leviathan”, the “state of nature” is the condition before the foundation of the state. In this condition of anarchy, literally everybody has the freedom to do everything he wants

Explain why brands have become a critical issue in the marketing of products

540 words - 3 pages relationships with consumers and is a guarantee that what they like about a product will be there every timeBrands have become a critical issue in the marketing of products because it is everything you do to get your business known and to enhance its reputation. It's advertising. It putting your business name on your vehicle. It's sending out your invoice on an attractive letterhead or invoice form. It's an attractive logo. It's telling the guy in line

European Union: Is the Media Friend or Foe?

592 words - 3 pages European Union: Is the Media Friend or Foe? Over the past several decades, the French, Italians, Spaniards, Germans, Austrians, Swiss, and so on have been tempted to surrender their identity to the newly formed culture, “European.” Formed in 1993, The European Union consists of 27 European countries that have agreed to abide by the same foreign and security policies, such as accepting a new currency, the Euro. The European Union mainly formed

What Impact Does the Organisational Structure of a Multinational Corporation Have on the Transfer of Knowledge Between Its Subsidiaries?

3202 words - 13 pages have competitive advantage in order to gain a good position in the market. However, it is not easy for every multinational corporation to transfer knowledge. Because there are four different organisational structure of multinational corporations, and different organisational structure could have different impact on knowledge transfer. Then, the four structures’ detail and impact on knowledge transfer would be showing in the following

Capital Punishment, The Road To A Corrupt Criminal Justice System, Must Be Abolished For The Sake Of Society. The Death Penalty Is Unfair Towards Society Members, Such As Tax Payers, Innocent People,...

2653 words - 11 pages expensive because conclusive evidence must be found to support or contradict a death sentence, thus, proving innocence or guilt. It is mandatory for death sentences to be reviewed by the Supreme Court, and these reviews can cost between $70,000 and $275,000, depending on whether or not the appeal advances into the Federal Court. So why should the states have to deal with such high costs? Life imprisonment achieves the same goal of the death

European Visitors To The Mughal Court In 17th Century India

1932 words - 8 pages , he was the sole determinant of his of his financial security and would have to work hard to continue enjoying all the benefits of life as an English noble. Aggrandizing his importance within the Mughal court would likely increase the probability of a speedy ascension through the ranks of the English nobility, ensuring his financial security as well as bolstering his prestige. It is entirely plausible that Roe depicted himself with more

Related Essays

Why Has Abortion Become Such A Political Issue? Who Should Have The Final Say?

969 words - 4 pages Why has abortion become such a political issue? Who should have the final say?It is hard to imagine a more troublesome, emotional decision for a woman, than whether to end a pregnancy or to let it proceed and bear a child. It is hard to imagine how anyone could believe someone had the right to prevent a woman from making that decision for herself.To qualify for an abortion in New Jersey, a woman must be over 18 or have a parent or guardian over

Why Does The Government Only Have Two Parties

1197 words - 5 pages Why does the United States only have two principal political parties? What role can 3rd parties play? There are many reasons why America has only two major political parties. It could be the cause of the federal government. The major parties reflect its decentralized structure. Candidates are recruited at the state or local level and are responsive primarily to their own state or local constituencies. At the national level, they consist of

The European Union Essay

969 words - 4 pages UK economy is currently growing reasonably well, while Germany is having problems economically, the policy of a single interest rate will prevent the EU from setting the rates at the appropriate for each country. The only way a country like Germany could have a independent interest rate would be if had a free floating currency such as England does; the pound. Also by setting a standard interest rates, some of flocculating rates outside of the EU

International Court Of Justice Essay

4562 words - 19 pages permanent members of the Security Council being able to veto enforcement of cases, even to which they consented to be bound. Because the jurisdiction does not have binding force itself, in many cases the instances of aggression are adjudicated by Security Council by adopting a resolution, etc. There is, therefore, likelihood for the permanent member states of Security Council to avoid the responsibility brought up by International Court of Justice, as shown in the example of Nicaragua v. United States.