This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Which Theorist Best Characterizes The Nature Of World War I Jomini Or Clausewitz?

1046 words - 5 pages

The Swiss Antoine-Henri Jomini and the Prussian Carl von Clausewitz were two important military theorists emerged from the wars of the French Revolustion and Napoleon. Clausewitz explained military theory and war in relative terms, ever changing standards, and values with unknown outcomes. In contrast, Jomini's view of the military theory was static and simplistic with predicted outcomes. 1
World War I was the most disastrous war ever fought in history with 13 million estimated death from 1914 to 1918. 2 Loss of life, and destruction of property were so immense that no side could declare clear victory at the conclusion of the war. Clausewitz’ military theory best characterized the nature ...view middle of the document...

Both side fought to drain their economic and military power to until one side cannot sustain its expenditure. During the Great War, whole nations had mobilized. The workers in the factory were as important as the soldiers at the front in manufacturing the weapons and supplies. Clausewitz argued that when the opposing armies were symmetrical and cancelled each other out at the tactical level, battles in that circumstances would be a prolonged firefight. He best described this in Book IV, chapter 2.
So the battle smolders away, like damp gunpowder. Darkness brings it to a halt: no one can see, and no one cares to trust himself to chance. The time has now come to reckon up how much in the way of serviceable troops is left on either side-troops, that is, which are not burned out like dead volcanoes. 3 (Clausewitz, On War, ed. Howard and Paret, book IV, chapter 2, 226.)

World War I was a defensive war in tactics. Existing technology such as machine guns and artillery provided more firepower to the defense than the office in World War I. Clausewitz explained the strength of the defense in tactical warfare. Clausewitz emphasized that well-prepared, well-manned, and well-defended entrenchment must generally be considered an impregnable point. 32 Ibid, book VII, chapter 10, 536. According to Clausewitz, the defender enjoys great advantages since he can waits for the attack in position, can choose it location, fortify its position, survey the battle and plan for counterattacks. 33 Ibid 390-391. On the contrary, Jomini emphasized well planned deployment of forces, movement of military assets in time and space to achieve victory, which was not easily achievable in World War I.

World War I was Clausewitzian in its outcomes. World War I ended not purely by military blunders but also by the political and strategic errors. In 1918, the German military was able to achieve tactical success with their storm troops, but failed to achieve any operational and strategic success. In fact, loss of troops and logistic difficulty maintaining their advances exhausted German’s offensive capabilities. In addition, Unites State’s involvement in this War finally tipped the military...

Other Papers Like Which Theorist Best Characterizes the Nature of World War I-Jomini or Clausewitz?

World War I Essay

1756 words - 8 pages World War I Bill Johnson DeVry University Professor Kevin Muir DeVry University June 22nd, 2014 World War I 1914-1918 will be dates forever ingrained into the history of the world. These dates bring about and highlight the human thirst for expansion, oppression, and war. These four years of time depict a flaw in human nature that goes against all common sense in the belief in peace. This is proven in the fact that humans have

World War I (Aftermath) Essay

3488 words - 14 pages On January 8, 1918, Woodrow Wilson went to Congress to announce his ideas regarding the war affairs of America. He created something known as the Fourteen Points, a plan that would determine the foreign affairs of the United States after World War I (Brower). When looking at the points, it is easy to identify how these were similar in nature, allowing them to be grouped. The first group deals with the points one, two, three, four, and five

World War I

1476 words - 6 pages WORLD WAR I Era Bella: growing tension between powers, as a result of economic globalization and the rise of colonialism 1882 Triple Alliance: linking Germany with Austria-Hungary and Italy, to maintain the beneficial state for Germany. Weltpolitik: world hegemony policy driven by William II, after acceding to the throne in 1888 and in 1890 to dismiss the Chancellor Bismark • Withdrawal from Russia in 1890 to renew the Reinsurance

World War I

722 words - 3 pages wanted Bosnia to be joined with the independent nation of Serbia. Few thought this act could start a world war, but it was the straw that broke the camels back.(cliché I know..) During this time the United States stayed neutral, following Wilson’s Moral Diplomacy. Believing that international disputes should be solved through negotiation rather than force. There were many reasons the United States entered the war, one of them was cultural

World War I - 849 words

849 words - 4 pages The Great War "The war that would end all wars," or at least that was the idea of the time.WWI had many downfalls, but the outcome was oddly successful. The U.S.A. took many steps in order to ensure the safety of their soldiers and the effectiveness of their entrance into the war. These steps included the U.S.A.'s preparation for the war, it's national support, and its effectiveness at the battle lines. Through all of these steps, the U.S.A

World War I - 683 words

683 words - 3 pages World War I The First World War is also known as the Great War that ended all wars. The First War World began on August 4, 1914, when German troops poured into Belgium. When American first have knowledge of the military tension in Europe, they wanted to stay out of the war and declared neutrality. Many believed that the First World War is caused by nationalism, imperialism, militarism, and the system of alliances. As national interests and

Developments in the Balkans Leading to the Outbreak of World War I

3457 words - 14 pages of the Empire which expedited after the disastrous Russo-Turkish war of 1768-1774.4 The Ottomans were eventually labelled as being the ‘Sick Man of Europe’ by the Tsar Nicholas I of Russia in the 1850s.5 The downfall of the Ottoman’s raised the prospect of the ‘Eastern Question.’6 Yet despite their shortcomings, the Ottomans managed to linger and survive due to French and British attempts at maintaining the ‘Balance of Power.’ Previous wars in

Nature Vs. Nurture: Which Is The Origin Of Virtue?

1152 words - 5 pages A classic debated topic of nurture versus nature has been and always will be an argumentative subject in the scientific world. Some psychologists and scientists believe that one’s behavioral aspects originate only from the environmental factors of one’s upbringing, while other opposing specialists argue the outlook in science that agrees with the naturalist idea. The concept of naturalistic ideas supports that one’s genetic makeup, inherited

American Propaganda and the Suppression of Dissent in World War I

3493 words - 14 pages by those in authority. Propaganda campaigns can only be won through the support of subordinated groups, and individuals who believe that allowing government domination and control either makes good sense, or is not worth fighting. World War I, like all wars, offered many opportunities to those who wanted to promote their own self-interests. It opened a playing field in which commercial, artistic, and industrial opponents claimed clear winners

The Alliance System Led To World War I

991 words - 4 pages There are many reasons why World War One occurred in 1914, many are complex and remain controversial which is why the matter has been disputed to this day by historians all over the world. My theory is that a lot of those reasons and the trigger factor all links to one thing; the alliance system. The alliance system is what made countries oppose each other and become rivals making it the most significant factor. It had an impact on who

World War I - Paper 2

865 words - 4 pages World War I World War 1 goes by many aliases – The Great War, even “the war to end all wars” – and, during the time period, these names were justly given. World War 1 was extraordinarily devastating. Nearly all of the known world was dragged into the conflict, hence the name of the war. This war was not only devastating, but it was the first of its kind. This war shattered the traditional methods of war, rendering them useless, with

Related Essays

Support Or Refute The Argument That The Prolonged And Bloody Stalemate Of The World War I

1124 words - 5 pages  Support or refute the argument that the prolonged and bloody stalemate of the World War I stemmed from a slavish adherence to the theories proposed by Clausewitz. By Major Billy Stubbs H100 Outline Argumentative Essay June 22, 2015 General Carl von Clausewitz is one of the best-known translators of Napoleon’s success during war and is considered to be a genius on military theory

Which Had A Greater Impact On Singapore; The Great Depression Or World War One?

597 words - 3 pages Depression was a period of worldwide economic slowdown that impacted many countries, including Singapore. It began with the stock market crash in the US in 1929, which spread to the rest of the world. During the 1920s, also known as the Roaring 20s, there was a economic boom and many people rushed to buy stocks, thinking that it was a good way to earn more money and at the same time believing that it would not drop. However, the stocks soon began to

How Did The Interdependency Of The Alliance Systems Help Lead To The Outbreak Of World War 1? Was It Only The Alliance Systems Which Led To War Or Are There Other Factors To Consider?

1158 words - 5 pages In 1914 the First World War broke out. This was no surprise as unrest had been building up between several European countries for a number of reasons. Already in place were two alliance systems. These consisted of the Triple Alliance which was Germany, Austria-Hungary and Italy, and the Triple Entente which was Britain, France and Russia. These alliances involving the major powers were brought in to try and avoid a war in Europe. Then, there was

Causes And Effects Of World War I

527 words - 3 pages Causes and Effects of World War I The assassination of Archduke Franz Ferdinand of Austria-Hungar in June 1914 was the beginning of WWI. It was a Serbian nationalist that assassinated him and his wife while they were in Sarajevo, Bosnia which was part of Austria-Hungary. This was done in protest of Austria-Hungary having control of this region. Serbia wanted to take over Bosnia and Herzegovina. The assassination led to Austria-Hungary