What Makes Romeo And Juliet A Tragedy And Who Or What Is To Blame?

1695 words - 7 pages

Romeo and Juliet is written by William Shakespeare and is a Shakespearian tragedy about two young lovers who are destined to be together. Their two families hate each other bitterly, which forces them to realise that they would rather be dead than live their lives apart.

In this essay I am going to look at who or what is to blame or responsible for this tragic loss of life.

Most people see a tragedy as a sudden unfortunate event, which leaves people sad, upset and possibly grieving. A Shakespearian tragedy is very different. A Shakespearian tragedy had to have more than one unfortunate event leading up to one major tragic event. The audience needs to feel pity, fear and a sense a ...view middle of the document...

For example, the letter sent by the Friar does not reach Romeo by a random incident. Secondly, fate puts Romeo and Juliet in opposite Houses and therefore puts their relationship under jeopardy. However, there is a conflicting side to fate. Romeo and Juliet made their own choices through out the play. Romeo goes to the Capulet ball despite his premonitions and knowing that Capulet is bitter enemy. Juliet makes a choice when she discovers that Romeo is her bitter enemy she has the chance to end her relationship. Although they make their decisions they may have been under the influence of ’True’ love and this could have been a series of unfortunate coincidences. This relates to Shakespeare’s idea of a tragedy where a tragedy was not one major unfortunate event but a series of unfortunate events or coincidences.

The first lines of the prologue tell us about the hate and envy between the two houses.

\"Two households, both alike in dignity... From ancient grudge to new mutiny“ Prologue, 1-3.

No leader of either household ever though about making peace, they were all too busy to spoil everything for the rival family. This made it impossible for Romeo and Juliet to have an open relationship, which made them have to go around in secret. They were forced to keep this secret to themselves and the nurse and they were not allowed to talk or see each other in public. The feud meant that Tybalt was automatically up for a fight whenever he saw a Montague this did not help Romeo and Juliet with their problems. Also the fact that it was ”wrong“ for Romeo and Juliet to be together made them stronger and willing to do all the could to be together in life or death.

The Nurse’s name is Angelica. I doesn’t suit her as she is slightly two-faced and she failed Juliet by not supporting her decision to remain married to Romeo. When Juliet first informs the Nurse of her love for Romeo, she is excited and encourages Juliet and help with preparations for the wedding. In Act 1 scene 4 the Nurse agrees to be the messenger to Romeo as she likes and wants to get involved in the relationship. After Romeo’s banishment and Tybalt’s death the turn Nurse turns on Juliet and takes Tybalt’s side as she is part of the Capulet household and Tybalt was Juliets cousin and realises blood is thicker than water. The Nurse tells Juliet to marry Paris after Romeo’s banishment which is bigamy and a sin and Elizabethan’s were very religious. The Nurse fails Juliet in Act 3 scene 5 as she defends Juliet when her father is shouting at her to marry Paris then she tell Juliet to Paris.

Capulet is responsible for the death of the young lovers as he fails Juliet and contradicts what he says about her marriage to Paris. First of all, in the play Capulet feels that he should wait a couple of years until Juliet and Paris know each other properly.

”Let two more summers with her in their pride, here we may think her ripe to be a bride.“

Capulet also feels that he should give...

Other Papers Like What Makes Romeo and Juliet a Tragedy and Who or What Is to Blame?

The Tragedy in William Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet

793 words - 4 pages Romeo and Juliet - The Tragedy     The Tragedy of Romeo and Juliet is a play written by the well-known author, William Shakespeare. The setting of the play is the 1400's in Verona, Italy. This is a play based on two families who have had an ancient grudge for many years, and their children who fall in love. What makes the story of Romeo and Juliet such a tragedy are the various decisions made by the characters of the

Exploring The Ways That Shakespeare Makes Act 1 Scene 5 Of Romeo And Juliet Dramatically Effective

2895 words - 12 pages , and could tell a whispering tale in a fair Lady's ear.' (Lines 6-7) This means that Romeo and Juliet can meet each other, as they will not know who each other is as they have masks on. This is what the audience have been waiting for; they knew they were going to meet from the prologue. Capulet's speech tells us a lot about him, one aspect that you learn about Capulet is that he is a player 'Ah my mistresses'. Capulet is

To What Extent Is Friar Laurence Responsible for the Deaths of Romeo and Juliet?

1095 words - 5 pages looking through a nine year old boys eyes is fitted in the text very well, it makes the reader feel like Bruno is moving away from a regimental home to a isolated one, and his only friend is his adventures till he spots the huts and smoke racks. “Bruno remembered a book he had read in which a man was lost in the desert and because he hadn’t had any food or water for several days had started to imagine that he saw wonderful

Who Makes What Cool

1289 words - 6 pages Who makes what cool? Where do today's teenagers get their idea of individuality? An answer for these questions lies in a television network called MTV. Using music videos and popular teen stars they are able to convey a message of what to wear and how to act. MTV started out simply showing music videos, now they have television programs and events. One specific show on MTV called TRL (total request live) shows the most popular music videos that

Romeo And Juliet Is It Fate Or Free Will?

1016 words - 5 pages "Chaos is found in greatest abundance wherever order is being sought. Chaos always defeats order because it is better organized." Terry Pratchett (author of DISCWORLD series) This quote relates to Romeo and Juliet in the sense that they are battling for order among the families and that chaos wins in that Romeo and Juliet must die before the chaos ends. William Shakespeare's, Romeo and Juliet, is a dramatic tragedy that teaches us of the

What Caused The Second World War? Who Was To Blame?

2205 words - 9 pages to withdraw their savings. The banks, who couldn't cope with this, withdrew their German loans which caused thousands of new and vulnerable German businesses to go bankrupt, 30% unemployment, poverty, homelessness and starvation. In Germany's terrible position, people began to look for someone to blame and Nazi propaganda helped to direct the blame at those that had signed the Treaty -the democrats. This is why there was a sudden increase in

Fate or Destiny for Romeo and Juliet

671 words - 3 pages Fate or Destiny for Romeo and Juliet? Summary:   Why did the star-crossed lovers Romeo and Juliet die the way they did? Their deaths ended in tragedy because they were victims of the society in which they lived, malignant fate, and their own passions. [pic] "From forth the fatal loins of these two foes, a pair of star crossed lovers take their life." As we all know, Romeo and Juliet is a tragic story of romance. Romeo and Juliet's death was a


1070 words - 5 pages Romeo's suicide, Juliet wakes up from her deep sleep and finds Romeo dead. Juliet's condition is more or less like Romeo's when he found out about Juliet's death. Likewise, Juliet kills herself using a dagger and falls cold beside Romeo's body. The attraction between these two young people is too much for them to stop and think before doing anything. These impulses finally cause their death and an end to what could have been a very passionate and

How Do We Assess Whether A City Is Global? What Other Criteria Could Be Used? This Essay Seeks To Identify Criteria’S And Different Aspects To Assess What Makes A City Global. Firstly, It Will Outline...

336 words - 2 pages How do we assess whether a city is global? What other criteria could be used? This essay seeks to identify criteria’s and different aspects to assess what makes a city global. Firstly, it will outline and explain the concept of globalisation and a global city, showing evidence from the use of academic sources and giving examples if necessary. It shall then continue to examine and focus on a specific global destination, discussing different

What Makes a Roman

1671 words - 7 pages What Makes a Roman Cato imposes a great honor upon Juba, the Numidian prince, by declaring him to be a fellow Roman. Caesar, however, continues to be referred to as Roman, despite Cato’s hatred of him. The despotism displayed by Caesar in his conquests does not, even in the remotest sense embody the Roman ideals that Cato holds so dear. Caesar, however, is continually referred to as a Roman tyrant. After one reads or experiences the play

What Is the Ethical Issue or Problem? Identify the Issue Succinctly. | |Moral Agent Is a Corrections Officer with the Ethical Dilemma of a Recommendation for the Husband Who Is Convicted of a 3rd...

1466 words - 6 pages University of Phoenix Material Ethical Worksheet Sample Incident Review |What is the ethical issue or problem? Identify the issue succinctly. | |The moral agent is a criminal defense attorney. The attorney knows of another criminal defense attorney who is an alcoholic and | |ignores his client obligations. What should the moral agent do

Related Essays

Romeo And Juliet, A Tragedy Essay

626 words - 3 pages . Since Romeo and Juliet did meet it makes this story what it actually is, a tragedy. Lastly, but certainly not least, if there weren't so many deaths in the story, the stress wouldn't be so high. The main reason Romeo and Juliet is a tragedy is because they choose to kill themselves instead of living their lives like they should ( Best, Michael. 2). Maybe Romeo and Juliet wouldn't have committed suicide. The main reasons why they even

The Tragedy Of Romeo And Juliet By William Shakespeare. What Makes The Tragic Heros Tragic? Theme Of "Moderation"

2320 words - 10 pages The Tragedy of Romeo and Juliet, written in the late 1500's by William Shakespeare, is a beautiful play about two young adults from rival families whose love brings them to destruction through their irrational decisions and passionate feelings. Throughout the tragedy, Shakespeare chooses intellectual characters. Some who wear their hearts on their sleeve, some who have common sense, and others, while overly passionate, find a way to become noble

Romeo And Juliet A True Aristotelean Tragedy

1161 words - 5 pages Romeo and Juliet a True Aristotelean Tragedy Aristotle defines a tragedy as “an imitation of an action that is serious, complete, and of a certain magnitude”. However, it is his claim that a story must contain six parts in order to be a tragedy that causes much controversy. Many critics argue that William Shakespeare does not follow the guidelines for a tragic story in his famous piece Romeo and Juliet. Their main argument is with the way he

Who Is More Mature? Romeo Or Juliet?

775 words - 4 pages Nick Hotujec English 4/26/2010 Who is more mature? Have you ever been in love before? I don’t think I have been before, but I know what it feels and looks like to be in love. But if you have been in love, you may have wanted to move very fast in your relationship and may have to be reminded to slow down. If you don’t slow down in relationships, you may be making a mistake. This topic can be related with the story "The Tragedies of Romeo and