What Is The Difference Between Prosocial Behaviour And Altruism?

1646 words - 7 pages

What is the difference between prosocial behaviour and altruism? Does genuine altruism exist? Discuss in relation to social psychological aspects of evolutionary theory and related research.

Word Count: 1472
Prosocial and altruistic behaviours are both behaviours that serve for the good of others and society. However, research has shown that there are important differences between the two types of behaviours. The purpose of this paper is to distinguish between prosocial behaviour and altruism, as well as discussing whether or not genuine altruism exists. Following this discussion, a brief conclusion will be made in relation to whether the research agrees or disagrees with the concept of ...view middle of the document...

The 19th century philosopher Auguste Comte (1875) described two forms of helping behaviours that have been studied in depth (Baumeister & Bushman, 2008). Egoistic helping is performed if the helper’s goal is to increase his or her welfare. The helper expects something in return for their help. In contrast to egoistic helping, altruistic helping is performed if the helper’s goal is to increase another’s welfare. Therefore, the altruistic helper should expect nothing in return for their help.

The rest of this paper will discuss whether altruism truly exists, or if all helping is simply egoistic. The following are examples of acts of altruism that were cited in Peterson & Seligman (2004):
- Angela Salawa of Krakow, Poland who looked after WW1 soldiers of all nationalities.
- Oskar Schindler of Nazi Germany who rescued some 1200 Jews during the holocaust.
- Katherine Drexel of Philadelphia who founded a number of mission centres and schools for Native Americans
- Numbers of individuals and organisations (e.g., Red Cross) who fly to terror attacks (e.g., 9/11) and natural disasters (e.g., Hurricane Katrina) to help others in need.

One example that Peterson & Seligman (2004) did not mention was the heroics of Chiune Sugihara from Japan. Chiune Sugihara was the Deputy Consul General to Lithuania. Chiune Sughiara saved 5,000-10,000 Jews. He did this by illegally giving out visas to stranded Jewish refugees who were seeking to escape from Nazi persecution (The Chiune Sugihara Centennial Celebration Committee, 2000). There is no doubt that the costs and risks associated with his behaviours far outweighed the benefits, that is, if there were any benefits at all.

Empathy is the ability to either experience the emotional state of another or to display a pitiful emotion associated with the downfall of another (Peterson & Seligman, 2004). Empathic concern is a strong predictor of altruistic behaviour (Unger & Thumuluri, 1997). It also explains a significant variance of these behaviours (McNeely & Meglino, 1994). Bierhoff, Klein, & Kramp (1991) postulated the presence of empathy in individuals who help in emergencies. Warneken & Tomasello as cited in Baumeister & Bushman (2008) used 18 month-old toddlers in a study where an adult confederate would either drop something or simply throw something down. If the adult dropped the object and made it look like an accident (as shown by a facial expression), the toddlers were more likely to help pick-up the object for the adult. If the adult simply threw the object on the ground and didn’t seem to care then toddlers were more likely not to care. There is certainly some solid evidence concerning the existence of the role of empathy in altruistic behaviour.

The empathy-altruism hypothesis states that empathy acts as a strong motivator in the performance of altruistic acts, in order to reduce another’s distress (Batson, Batson, Slingsby, Harrell, Peekna, & Todd, 1991). In contrast to the...

Other Papers Like What Is the Difference Between Prosocial Behaviour and Altruism?

The Difference Between China and France

1158 words - 5 pages Cultural Comparison Between China and France Introduction From my first step in france 3 months ago, the first thing I could say is that France is facinating and fancy me. I also wonder that france and china are really different countries. In fact, France and China have a different economy, and don’t have the same culture. The purpose of this report is to compared with the diference between France and China ,since the difference exists in

The Difference Between College And High School

694 words - 3 pages Graduating high school is a rite of passage to every teenager. It symbolizes all of the hard work and the actions taken to prepare you for the real world. Some high school graduates enlist in the military and join government branches such as the army and navy. Other graduates enroll in a trade program and become electricians and plumbers. The remainder of high school graduates continue their education and enroll in college. Even though

What Is the Relation Between Heavy Metal and Religion?

2459 words - 10 pages Semih BOZ 21102153 Section: 5 ABSTRACT One of the discussion topics of music world is the relation between heavy metal music and religions. It is generally thought by non-authority people that heavy metal is music of Satanism. This remains as a prejudice, because the truth is different from what is thought of. The early times metal bands are even conservative and they have nothing to do with Satan in terms of religion. But most of the metal

Similarities and Difference Between Oceania in 1984 and the Usa

1655 words - 7 pages will likely be arrested by the police. I believe in my own opinion that this is a first step to a government as the one in the book. The first difference that I see between the United States government and the one in the book is that here, in our country we have the constitutional right to “Due Process” which guarantees right to a fair and public trial and right to be heard in one’s own defense. To be arrested by the police, the court has to have

The Difference Between Male and Female Brain in the Workplace

2181 words - 9 pages Maria Fernanda Paredes 10 June 2015 The Difference between Male and Female Brain in the Workplace Human beings are the main creature on the earth because they are rational people with an amazing knowledge which has been demonstrated since they establish as a society by implementing new science areas, developing more technology day by day and so on. Even though male and female have the same purpose and thoughts to be better as a person

Difference Between Competence and Competency

698 words - 3 pages (1998), in which he differentiated between “competence” and “competency”. He describes competences as what people need to be able to do a job well; so the emphasis here is on ability to accomplish the desired results. Competency, on the other hand, are those dimensions of behaviour lying behind competent performance which is often referred to as behavioural competencies, “because they are intended to describe how people behave when they carry

The Difference Between Jc Series Jaw Crusher and Pe Series

579 words - 3 pages technology and manufacturing standards. However, do you know what the difference between the JC series and the traditional PE series are? if you do not know it, you can read this article. becuse this article will intriduce something about it. The difference mainly display at the following several points: 1. in structure: JC Series jaw crusher apply the modular design, which use the split frame structure that both sides of the plate will be

Difference Between Socialism and Capitalism

1114 words - 5 pages profit. On the other hand, socialism is an economic system that supports the state ownership and administration of the means of production. (Salihoğlu, 1997) First difference between capitalist and socialist economic systems is ownership. In capitalist economic systems, private ownership, which is the right to own the means of production, is emphasized. However, in socialist economic systems, the government decides what to produce, how to

The Difference Between Citizenship Education And Civic Education

1325 words - 6 pages This essay endeavors to discuss the connection between citizenship education and civic education. It will further look at whether there is a difference between   the two or if they are the same. Lastly, the conclusion will be drawn. Before going into a detailed discussion it is prudent to define the key words, that is , Civic education and Citizenship education respectively. Civic Education is a broader field and therefore can be defined in

Difference Between Journals and Diaries: -

618 words - 3 pages Difference between journals and diaries:- The difference between a diary and a journal is that a diary is where you can write down what happened during the day and keep a record of stuff. A journal is to write your own personal feelings in, and things that happened, and how they happened. A diary is a report of what happened during the day—where you ate, who you met, the details that what was happened in the office, and who took whose

The Difference Between Chines Medicine and Western Medicine

670 words - 3 pages The difference between Chines medicine and western medicine In the ancient times, people thought that illnesses were caused by the evils and believed inShamanism and divination. Gradually people knew that illnesses were caused by bacteria and a science called medicine started to develop. As times goes by, Chinese medicine and western medicine become the two most important medical systems in the

Related Essays

Form Of Gdp And What Is The Difference Between

712 words - 3 pages Gradable Assignment 1 1.     Full form of GDP and what is the difference between GDP per Capita Ans: GDP–Gross Domestic Product GDP per Capita – An estimate of an individual spends as a consumer compared to the total population spending on products and services. GDP is gross domestic product, the total economic output of a country, i.e., the amount of money a country makes. GDP per capita is the total output divided by the number of

What Is The Difference Between True Spiritual Realization And Contemporary Drug Use?

530 words - 3 pages What is the difference between true spiritual realization and contemporary drug use? Spiritual realization is a fundamental and permanent shift in our sense of reality, and all our conclusions about it. It is not a single secret that a person or a book can reveal to us and there is no single act or path that can bring about spiritual realization for all people. Some people may follow a religion all of their lives and do everything

Topic “Prosocial Behaviour Is The Outcome Of Multiple… Factors” (Eisenberg & Fabes, 1998, P.742)

2599 words - 11 pages Developmental Psychology | PSY 484 - X 2010 | TOPIC: “PROSOCIAL BEHAVIOUR IS THE OUTCOME OF MULTIPLE… FACTORS” (Eisenberg & Fabes, 1998, p.742). | DISCUSS THIS STATEMENT WITH REFERENCE TO: (A) CULTURAL FACTORS (B) SOCIALISATION OF PROSOCIAL BEHAVIOUR WITHIN THE FAMILY (C) THE CHILD’S INDIVIDUAL CHARACTERISTICS | Contents Introduction 3 Cultural Factors 3 Socialization within and outside the family

The Difference Between Monotony And Boredom…

1009 words - 5 pages What is boredom and what causes it? Boredom is a mental weariness, dullness, dreariness, tedium, and a monotony. Boredom is experienced when a person lacks activity or when a person becomes uninterested in tasks that surround them. A person who has been on a job for an extended period of time often becomes bored by the repetition of doing the same thing for such a long period of time. When a person becomes bored from doing the same type job