Weapons Of The Weak Essay

2163 words - 9 pages

Maiyo Shahrawan
University of Toronto
Kevin Edmonds
Analyzing and Deciphering James Scott’s Concept of “Weapons Of The Weak”
There is an array of divergent groups, collectives and associations around the globe that consistently proceed to spread their opinions and display their presence in the largest scale possible. Among these factions include, social movements, social non-movements and civil society organizations. These groups have historically been successful in overcoming their oppressors and doing what is in their nature to complete the necessary tasks in order to have their voice heard by those they wish to protest to. Examples of mainstream social movements ...view middle of the document...

This is what James Scott refers to as “Weapons of The Weak”. Scott refers to weapons of the weak as an “everyday form of resistance” that occurs generally between periods of rebellion or direct uprising (Scott, 1985: 17). These situations occur especially in instances and societies where in which the power dynamic is uneven and the citizens who are being oppressed don’t have the freedom, confidence and/or power to directly protest against their oppressors. Scott proceeds to argue that weapons of the weak can be perceived as a “social movement with no formal organization, no manifestoes, no dues, no name, and no banner” (Scott, 1985: 35). This paper is going to use evidence from both James Scott’s piece and other scholarly articles and journals that this statement by Scott regarding weapons of the weak is actually true. Ultimately, weapons of the weak is an everyday form of resistance that does not have to specifically include organizations, banners, manifestoes, and/or a formal strategy, however can still stimulate protest and widespread action on as large a scale as possible.
Social movements can be defined as a type of formal or informal crowd action that can differ in size but ultimately rallies individuals together for a common belief. Social movements are organizations that tend to focus primarily on political and social issues and tend to fight for the induction or expulsion of certain social and political changes. Suzanne Staggenborg explains in her article the dynamic tactics and behavior social movement organizations use to have their voices heard by those they wish to protest to. She says in her piece, “Social movements around the world have used a wide variety of protest tactics to bring about enormous social changes, influencing cultural arrangements, public opinion, and government policies” (Staggenborg, 1). Charles Tilly however, explains how social movements commonly indulge in contentious politics by writing in his piece that social movements are, “contentious in the sense that social movements involve collective making of claims that, if realized, would conflict with someone else's interests, political in the sense that governments of one sort or another figure somehow in the claim making, whether as claimants, objects of claims, allies of the objects, or monitors of the contention” (Tilly and Wood, 2009: 3). Charles Tilly is essentially explaining that as Social Movements have progressed historically, their tactics and the way they approach their potential protests has advanced as well. Tilly goes on to note that of the many tactics that have been introduced by social movements throughout the years, certain contentious campaigns and aggressive altercations with authorities have been continuously used by these social movement organizations. Social movements are important organizations and figures in the global community because in many societies, they hold the levers of public thought and perception of the state. Social...

Other Papers Like Weapons of the Weak

Assault Weapons Ban Essay

1329 words - 6 pages Assault Weapons Ban Within the past few years there has been several mass shootings with in the United States like Sandy hook and Columbine. These crimes were done assault weapons, due to these crimes the proposal of an assault weapons ban is being brought up. This interests me as an active gun owner and activist. But with as much of an unbiased view I look for the answer. Should there be a ban on assault weapons? The most popular method for

The Transnational Security Threats from Failed States

1334 words - 6 pages Mittelman has led to unmonitored establishment of nuclear, chemical, biological and radiological weapons (Mittelman, 2010). As mentioned earlier, failed states do not have reliable border controls. According to the International Atomic Energy Agency, these weak border controls have served as transit points for chemicals used to develop nuclear weapons in countries such as Iran. The main sources for uranium include failed states that are found in

Weapons of Mass Destruction and Its Threat to Global Security

4518 words - 19 pages States during the final stages of World War II in 1945. These two events represent the only use of nuclear weapons in war to date. [2] Following a firebombing campaign that destroyed many Japanese cities, the Allies prepared for a costly invasion of Japan. The war in Europe ended when Nazi Germany signed its instrument of surrender on 8 May, but the Pacific War continued. Together with the United Kingdom and the Republic of China, the United States

Nuclear Weapons - Essay

599 words - 3 pages , technology, and equipment to start building nuclear warheads. Even if Iran made nuclear missiles they would not be able to hit the United States because they would not have intercontinental ballistic missiles. The only way they could hit the United States as if they came up to the coast of the United States and launched them from boats. There are some countries that borrow nuclear weapons. As of now there are five countries that have borrowed nuclear

In Support Of The American Nuclear Arsenal

2463 words - 10 pages In Support of the American Nuclear Arsenal August 5, 1945. A day that the entire world will remember, as it was the day that the first of two nuclear strikes against Japan ended World War Two. Although at the time “Fat Man” and “Little Boy” were the lesser of two evils, they started an arms race like the world has never seen. The Soviet Union, America, Great Britain, France, and later China, all started to produce nuclear weapons. The arsenals

Atom Bombs

887 words - 4 pages Union and some decided to stay neutral. The world has been in a peace state has been and a lot more stable since the cold war has begun. But can it stay that way? Nuclear weapons are scary and deadly. We all know that. They can wipe out a whole city in just a fraction of a second and kill millions and millions of innocent people. Their radiation is long lasting and fatal which can be found up to several hundred miles away from the impact zone

Resolution 1344215

2129 words - 9 pages A/RES/68/45 United Nations Distr.: General 10 December 2013 General Assembly Sixty-eighth session Agenda item 99 (v) Resolution adopted by the General Assembly on 5 December 2013 [on the report of the First Committee (A/68/411)] 68/45. Implementation of the Convention on the Prohibition of the Development, Production, Stockpiling and Use of Chemical Weapons and on Their Destruction The General Assembly, Recalling its

Nuclear Brinkmanship

592 words - 3 pages “The world would be a better place if…”      Mutual Assured Destruction. Nuclear holocaust. The destruction of whole nations in the blink of an eye. We cannot hide from the threat that nuclear weapons pose to humanity and all life. These are not ordinary weapons, but instruments of mass annihilation that could destroy civilization and end all life on Earth. Nuclear weapons are morally and legally unjustifiable. They

Nuclear Non Proliferation

959 words - 4 pages General AssemblyNuclear Non-ProliferationNorwayNuclear Non ProliferationBackground of TopicDaily the human race can be seriously threatened by thousands of nuclear weapons on hair-trigger alert. Nuclear weapons are the most dangerous, catastrophic and lethal weapons ever created by the human race. It all started back in World War II when the United states bombed the cities of Hiroshima and Nagasaki. Since then, all the permanent members of the

Military Force

590 words - 3 pages cannot conceive of deterrence without a strategy of mutual assured destruction. We have written previously that reliance on this strategy is becoming increasingly hazardous. With the spread of nuclear weapons, technology, materials and know-how, there is an increasing risk that nuclear weapons will be used.” (Shultz, George P., Perry, William J., Kissinger, Henry A., Nunn, Sam; Deterrence in the Age of Nuclear Proliferation; Wall Street Journal

Nuclear Safety and Security

1209 words - 5 pages such ignominy has befallen ever since. But it does not mean that the danger of a nuclear warhead being used by some rogue state is not there. Today, so many countries possess nuclear weapons and the day when a war between countries goes nuclear, the results will be catastrophic. It is therefore extremely necessary that steps are taken at international level to maintain nuclear safety and security. The Group of 8 (G8) have established a

Related Essays

The Devastating Impact Of Weapons Of Mass Destruction

1239 words - 5 pages The Devastating Impact of Weapons of Mass Destruction A burning ball was so bright and vivid overhead. Confusion arose when they realized that it was 8:15 a.m., and that the sun had already risen that day. The people of Hiroshima remember that day as "the day the sun rose twice" (Motro). They ran in a state of panic as the images of people's shadows were burned into the cement. This mayhem happened all because of the use of a weapon of

The Dangers Of Atomic Weapons And Nuclear Energy

802 words - 4 pages "The Dangers of Atomic Weapons and Nuclear Energy"To further explain how the use of nuclear energy and the construction of atomic weapons is a threat to the United States.Millions of homes around the United States are being powered by nuclear energy and have no idea how much damage it is causing. It is taking lives, damaging the environment, and hurting the economy.Originally, I explained to you a basic idea on how nuclear energy and atomic

Artificial Intelligence What Is Artificial Intelligence (A.I.)? Strong And Weak A.I. The Turing Test Branches Of A.I

521 words - 3 pages simulate it." He now defines A.I. as "the science and engineering of making intelligent machines, especially intelligent computer programs." A.I. is generally associated with Computer Science, but it has many important links with other fields such as Maths, Psychology, Cognition, Biology and Philosophy, among many others.Strong and Weak A.I.Artificial Intelligence is often divided into two classes: Strong A.I. and Weak A.I.. Strong A.I. makes the

The Effects Of Biological Weapons On The Past And Presents Society

1530 words - 7 pages -Organisms ii. Toxins b. History of biological warfare i. Definition ii. Affects it has on people III. Reasons why biological warfare should be stopped. a. Biological weapons are inhumane. b. Impossible to control or predict its effect. c. Pollutes the environment d. Genetic Mutation IV. Countries that still produce biological weapons V. Biological and Toxins Convention VI. Conclusion The Effects of