This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Was Hitler A Weal Dictator Essay

3392 words - 14 pages

Was Hitler a Weak Dictator? David Williamson examines two seemingly irreconcilable schools of though
Perhaps of all the exam questions set on the Third Reich, `Was Hitler a Weak Dictator?' is the most difficult. It leads to the heart of the complex Intentionalist-Structuralist debate. On the one hand, there are the Intentionalist historians who argue forcefully in the words of Norman Rich that `Hitler was master in the Third Reich', while the Structuralists stress the many constraints on Hitler's power which range from his own personal inadequacies to the limits imposed upon him by the structure of the Nazi party and state. Mommsen, for instance, argues that he was `in many ways a weak ...view middle of the document...

It may be, as Gregor Strasser argued, that these tactics showed a dangerous indecision and that Hitler was only saved from failure by the notorious `backstairs intrigues' of von Papen and the banker Schroder; but at least they were held to consistently, and the Party was forced to follow them.
In power once he had consolidated his position by the autumn of 1934 Hitler was, theoretically at least, omnipotent. He was both Chancellor and Head of State, and, to quote Hans Frank, `supreme judge of the nation'. (4) After 1937 Cabinet meetings ceased. Legal principles such as equality before the law and civil rights were suspended by a series of arbitrary laws such as the Decree for the Protection of the Nationalist Movement. He had too the means to enforce this power. The Gestapo, reinforced by the SS, prison camps and informers, effectively broke any opposition. It was not surprising then that von Weiszacker, the State Secretary in the Foreign Office, believed his `omnipotence existed to a large extent in fact and was highly effective'. (5) How is it then that, despite this very visible evidence of Hitler's power, he can still be called a weak dictator?
Definitions of weakness
In exploring this problem Ian Kershaw has produced what he calls `three categories of possible weakness': (6)
* Hitler's reluctance to make decisions
* The extent to which his decisions were either ignored or altered by his subordinates.
* The degree to which his policy was ultimately determined, or at least influenced, by such factors as the international situation, pressures from the Party, the threat of social unrest from the workers and the inadequacies of the German economy.
Decision-Maker and Source of Authority
Hitler's eccentric working habits have been well described by Albert Speer, his favourite architect and later Minister of Munitions and Armaments, in his memoirs:
`I would often ask myself did he really work? Little was left of the day;
he rose late in the morning and conducted one or two official conferences;
but from the subsequent dinner on he more or less wasted his time until the
early hours of the evening. His rare appointments in the late afternoon
were imperilled by his passion for looking at building plans. The adjutants
often asked me: "please don't show any plans today."' (7)
Hitler was, then, obviously not a workaholic like, say, Frederick the Great of Prussia, who would in the summer rise at five in the morning to start working on state papers. To have somebody with such lax working habits at the centre of the decision-making process did inevitably make the conduct of state business slow,...

Other Papers Like Was Hitler a Weal Dictator

Amniocentesis Essay

959 words - 4 pages Adolf Hitler Adolf Hitler, a military dictator, was a very brutal man during World War II, and caused many deaths to people. Mr. Hitler was a terrible man to many in the eyes of many people today. Historians guess that Adolf killed about eleven million people.Adolf Hitler was born on April, 20, 1889, in Braunau, Austria. Adolf Hitler's dad was born in the third marriage of his father and was the fourth child in that marraige.Alios (Adolf

Hitler Essay

320 words - 2 pages Adolf Hitler (German: [ˈadɔlf ˈhɪtlɐ]; 20 April 1889 – 30 April 1945) was an Austrian-born German politician and the leader of the Nazi Party (German: Nationalsozialistische Deutsche Arbeiterpartei (NSDAP); National Socialist German Workers Party). He was chancellor of Germany from 1933 to 1945 and dictator of Nazi Germany (as Führer und Reichskanzler) from 1934 to 1945. Hitler was at the centre of Nazi Germany, World War II in Europe, and the

How Convincing Is the Argument That Hitler's Responsibility for the Outbreak of the Second World War Been Exaggerated

1307 words - 6 pages because Hitler was a dictator who could not be trusted to keep his word, especially because he had made it clear that he wanted an Empire in the East to give German Lebensraum and would only be stopped by war. Appeasement also made Britain look weak and encouraged Hitler to keep demanding more and more. Not only that but Britain, France, Italy and Germany agreed to meet in Munich to hold a conference to find a peaceful solution to the Sudetenland

Adolf Hitler's Rise to Power

884 words - 4 pages . But Hitler stepped in to fill the void and his party, being the entire parliament, transferred all presidential powers and the role of president on him. In short, Hitler was decreed the Führer und Reichskanzler of Germany. He also became the Supreme Commander of the armed forces. He was now Germany's dictator and this marked the Nazi party taking over Germany.  Whether Adolf Hitler's rise to power could have been prevented or not, one thing is for certain, Hitler had a purpose and a task in mind and he let nothing stand in his way. His will and force changed the course of human history forever.

Analyse the Problems of the Weimar Republic

2109 words - 9 pages revolution: Weimar republic was incapable of suppressing the revolts, but the Nazis looked capable enough to suppress the revolts, which seemed like a big advantage for landowners. d. Hitler himself had extraordinary political abilities: Hitler was a great dictator and orator who had the capability of influencing and brainwashing people, which the government lacked. e. The striking contrast between the governments of the Weimar Republic and the

Weimar and Nazi Germany Timeline

650 words - 3 pages ) was destroyed in a fire, and in the ruins a young communist was found. | March 1933 | Enabling Act | Passed by Hindenburg that granted Hitler four years of power as a dictator. | 2nd August 1934 | Hindenburg’s death | Hindenburg died peacefully. | August 19th 1934 | Hitler declares himself President | Hitler took over once Hindenburg died and declared himself President and combines this role with Chancellor. He gave himself the title


642 words - 3 pages started invincible to regress. When Hitler took his last decision on the process of the attack called Barbarossa plan, the military commanders had nothing to do unless to comply with the decision, so they decided to conduct a very fast attack, whatever the human cost will be. In the Russian side who had signed the 1939 non-aggression treaty in order to keep the risk German from Russia for 10 years, the Russian leader STALIN was also a dictator, which

European Conflict After World War II

1191 words - 5 pages dictator and fascist Mussolini. Not only did Italy become under dictatorship, but Germany also fell under dictatorship in another form. A small German rightist party known as the Nazis was led by Adolf Hitler to achieve national dominance. At the end of World War I, Adolf Hitler entered politics after his four-year service on the Western Front. Two years later, in 1921, he took control of the German Workers’ Party and turned it into the Nazi Party

Hitler and His Power

525 words - 3 pages following these promises up. Only the Jews and communists were left out of plans for Germany. The Nazis were also well organized. They were disciplined, and portrayed Hitler as a strong leader who would save Germany. All the things the Nazi party had said and promised had paid off. Nazi election campaigning was effective. The elections of 1933 brought Hitler to power and he quickly established himself as dictator

Hitler And The Rise To Power

2507 words - 11 pages Adolf Hitler was born into a poor family in a small Austrian town on April 20, 1889. Hewanted to be an artist as a young man. Many have come to wonder how a man who had thedream of becoming an artist, would eventually become known as one of the most feared tyrantsof all time. How could someone from such a lousy background rise to so much power in such ashort time. As the dictator of Nazi Germany he was responsible for the death of nearly 46

To What Extent Was Hitler Successful in Consolidating Nationalist Socialist Power After Being Appointed Chancellor in 1933?

2804 words - 12 pages his diaries that the dictator not only could chat very pleasantly among his close acquaintances, but absolutely knew how to listen as well.” This was a huge accomplishment for Hitler and played a part in his successful campaign to consolidate Nazi power. Historians recognise various key events in Hitler’s consolidation of power after becoming Chancellor. Arguably, one of the most important events was the Reichstag Fire of 27th February 1933

Related Essays

Hitler: Was The Structure Of The Nazi Government To Chaotic To Enable Hitler To Be A Strong Dictator In The Years 1933 1939?

549 words - 3 pages The question of if Hitler was able to be a strong dictator lays in the arguments of functional and intentionalists. A functional argument is the belief that Hitler didn't have a plan but used what was in front of him to his advantage, and an Intentional view is that Hitler had a plan and stuck by his plan therefore leading us to the question was Hitler strong enough to have a plan and succeed it. Although it is too simplistic to define Hitler by

Spina Mla Bio Essay

761 words - 4 pages difficult life. He lost his two siblings at a very young age. which inspired him to become chancellor of germany in 1933. Adolf hitler was chancellor from 1933-1945. he ruled over germany as a dictator stating that the jews were evil. everyone in germany believed his lie so they all agreed to kill the jews in a sick and vile way which was torture and gas chambers. Adolf hitler was indeed vile , but he was always stubborn so he had

Adolf Hitler Essay By Nicole Yr 9

1960 words - 8 pages strongly, it is all based on personal opinion. Within this essay I will find out why Hitler was a; Political genius, a mass murderer, a dictator and a psychopath. Hitler was known as the dictator of Germany. It was alleged he was an extremely powerful and commanding man. It was confirmed as he led a country of thousands and generally got what he wanted. From the year 1921-1945 he was the leader of the Nazi party (German workers). He took power of

Hitler Coming To Power Hitler Came To Power In On

553 words - 3 pages propaganda Hitler never would of came into power. The propaganda consisted of many different pictures ranging from anything to everything. If you were to walk down the streets of Germany you would see propaganda every where. Hitler was a great public speaker he was able to show his point of view very well and be convincing of his topic. He gave many public speeches throughout his clime to becoming a dictator. His speeches were said to be very