This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Wage Dispute Essay

850 words - 4 pages

Marikana: a story about unresponsive leadership
2012-09-20 08:10
Pin It
Eusebius McKaiser

There is an incredibly basic but crucial leadership lesson to be learnt from the Marikana disaster. It is this: unresponsive leadership will not be tolerated forever. The Congress of South African Trade Unions released a statement “urg(ing) all the workers who have left the National Union of Mineworkers (NUM) to return”.

This “urge” is fascinating. The union leaders view these workers as delinquents; as naughty children who ran away from home and who should return if they know what’s good for them.

Even last night on my radio show, Talk At Nine, general secretary of NUM, Frans Baleni, ...view middle of the document...

They have lost faith in the union leadership. Why else would you not allow the regular processes to play out? When I put this issue to Baleni on my radio show yesterday, he simply said that workers opted out of the usual processes because they – the workers at Marikana – have been inspired by the successful use of illegal strikes at other mines previously.

This retort from Baleni is disingenuous in two ways. Firstly, as was pointed out by a mineworker who called in, the mineworkers did not resort to illegal activity from the outset. If Baleni’s hypothesis is true, then illegal activity would have been chosen from the start. It wasn’t. Rather, workers started losing confidence when the normal processes did not bring about the desired outcomes for them. This means it is hasty pop psychologising on NUM’s part to simply dismiss the workers as engaging in copycat anti-social behaviour. It is a desperate attempt to avoid introspecting about the quality of union leadership at Marikana.

And that is the second problem with Baleni’s retort. It is a lost opportunity to reflect on what NUM could have done differently from a leadership viewpoint. If you do not think you failed, then you will never reflect on what leadership lessons to learn from a crisis. And the stubbornness on Baleni’s part to even think of the possibility that NUM’s leadership was found wanting, is itself reason to predict that the relationship between workers and union leadership, going forward, will remain tense.

We want responsive leadership

Other Papers Like Wage Dispute

Development of Bangladeshi Rmg Sector Essay

970 words - 4 pages per cent of the country's industrial workforce most of which are from the rural areas. They did not have any opportunity to be part of the formal workforce. * Efficient and large amount of labor force. Disadvantages * Since then labor unrest has been taking place in the sector almost every year. Most of the experts often think that labor unrest at garments is caused mainly by issues related to wage. The wages of the RMG workers in

Labour Relations Essay

2233 words - 9 pages of job security -unfair or biased policies/practices -inequities in pay -lack of opportunity for advancement -unionized employees earn 8% more than non-unionized workers -on average, unionized female workers earn 93% of hourly wage men earn Step 2: Union Organizing Campaign Five steps involved in this process: 1. Employee/union contact. (during these initial discussions, employees investigate the advantages of union representation

Labour Relations

1528 words - 7 pages accorded to collective bargaining unions with a view to streamline them. Second, revise minimum wages, wage increases and dispute resolution policies in line with the latest economic developments in the country and international standards to ensure fairness and equity. Third, ensure that negotiations involving unions that represent essential emergency professionals do not break down and go to strike since people’s lives could be at stake. Finally

Thai Ethical Culture

1146 words - 5 pages that Thai women are able to climb up the corporate ladder. * In Thailand disrespectful behaviour against the women is not accepted but still there are cases where women are still the victims of sex discrimination within the workplace. Wage discrimination * In the private sector, women generally receive equal wages in low wage jobs, but not in higher wage jobs. Age discrimination * In most of the job advertisements in


520 words - 3 pages named biotech as one of their top two targets for industrial development. Regions with a significant amount of biotech companies venture capital during the past three years. Many San Diego are trying to lure biotechnology and attract other high-wage professionals to support the industry. The tax and revenue potential of these concentrations of biotech companies puts hope in the eye of chamber of commerce and government leaders. In a state

The South Seceding from the Union

591 words - 3 pages infuriated; after all they had been using slaves to help on plantations and farms since the early 1700’s. The Dred Scott Decision was thought to have settled the dispute in 1857, by deciding that no black slave or free could be a citizen in the United States. Popular sovereignty, which allowed the voters who lived in a territory to vote whether or not to allow slavery there, was still a hope in Kansas for the Republicans. In 1855 hundreds of Missouri


541 words - 3 pages Government Everyone is fond of freedom but too much freedom can be harmful. Every society has to have a limit on their freedom in order to civil in order whereas if there was total freedom, anyone can do anything regardless if it is just or not. Any civil dispute can result in death which can create a chain reaction in civil disputes. This is where the government comes in. in order to maintain civil order; the government has to regulate society

What Are the Four Legal Means That Affect Employment Practices in Canada? Identify and Briefly Describe Each One

599 words - 3 pages written act, statutory rules and the rules of common law. It also includes conventions which are derived from British constitutional history [1]. “All law in Canada come into force on a dispute between private person and the branch of government fall under this constitution.” [2] According to textbook, Employment law sometimes refers a section of constitution which describes (section 15, Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedom) the principle of

Honda Case

1093 words - 5 pages Abstract: The case study focuses on the HR problems faced by Honda Motor Cycle & Scooters India (HMSI). The case discusses the various reasons which led to the dispute between the management and employees of HMSI. It elaborates the incidents, which led to the strike at the company that resulted in HMSI workers being severely beaten up by the police. Labour strife and the management's inability to deal with it effectively had resulted in huge

A Manager's Handbook

3505 words - 15 pages A Manager’s Handbook: “All people, regardless of race, religion or culture, harmoniously living and working together into the future”   Contents Introduction to Law and Business Ethics and Social Responsibility 3 Legal Dispute Resolution Process and Alternative Dispute Resolution Mechanisms 4 Business and the Constitution and Administrative Law 5 Business Crimes, Business Torts, and Product Liability 6 Contracts 7 Business


1676 words - 7 pages Management The main objective of the function is to develop and maintain a good salaried and wages system which is reasonable both internally and externally. Factors affecting Salaries and Wages * Cost of living * Supply and demand of labor * Government requirements (minimum wage rates) * Competitor wage scales * Trade Union influences * Labor productivity (3)Training and Development Training is the process by which

Related Essays

The Disadvantages Of International Business Ethics

631 words - 3 pages Reading * The Code of Ethics of Auditors * The Advantages and Disadvantages and Pros and Cons of Social Obligation * ------------------------------------------------- * ------------------------------------------------- * ------------------------------------------------- * ------------------------------------------------- Print this article 1. Wage Ethics * Few consumers would profess that 8-year-olds

Claim: Critical Analysis Of Worker's Benefit Of Protection By Milton Friedman's Free To Choose

876 words - 4 pages responsible for protecting workers and improving their lives, workers see the most benefit. Friedman’s conclusion is that workers lot will improve most if the influence of union and government is reduced (247). Since 1980, when the book was published, there has been a steady decline in the percentage of workers who are members of labor unions, while the minimum wage has fallen behind inflation, effectively decreasing. Given that

The Burma Road Riot Essay

1021 words - 5 pages started to commit crimes and other serious offences. Not being able to enter those places made them upset as well and would have made them more angry and start to do wrong. A wage dispute was another factor that led to the riot. Blacks and white Americans did the same job which was truck driving. The black’s workers got paid 50 ¢ less than white Americans. After this had happened there was a chaotic situation in the streets

What Are The True Benefits Of A National Minimum Wage; A) For The Employees B) For The Employers

4628 words - 19 pages INTRODUCTION:The topic that I have chosen to discuss is the very controversial National Minimum Wage, which has recently (April 99) been introduced into the British Economy for the first time. In the preceding work I will be undertaking a research review of the affects that the Minimum wage will have, I will especially be focusing upon the costs and benefits of the scheme for employers and their employees. Therefore the question of which I have