Using The Right Financial Reward System In Indonesian Public Sector

2154 words - 9 pages

Motivation in the workplace: using the right financial reward system in Indonesian public sector

Indonesia is one the most populous nation in the world, which happen to sit in one the most dynamic region between Australia and Asian industrial countries like Japan, China and South Korea. With Asia and Australia nearby, Indonesia is trying to leverage its strategic position by building its economic capacity. As commonly seen in developing country, Indonesia’s public sector is seen as inadequately equipped to bolster development in Indonesia. As a way to increase its economic development, Indonesian government decided to initiate bureaucratic reform for its public employee. ...view middle of the document...

However, this essay is limited to financial incentive aspect of motivation especially the alternatives to seniority-based reward system such as performance-based reward system and how it could be implemented in Indonesian public sector to improve motivation in workplace.
Government of Indonesia uses membership-based and seniority-based rewards uniformly for all civil servants irrespective of their fields and even responsibilities. This means that a security guard at Ministry of Public Works who have been working for thirty years would earn more than a geologist at the Ministry of Mineral Resources with ten years of service. Of course, there are other factors that influence the salary, such as formal education and promotion to managerial position. But by far the biggest factor in determining how much an employee earn is the number of years they spent serving the government. Seniority-based reward system indeed have some advantages, its implementation is relatively easy and straightforward. Government only need small resource to count the number of years employees have in service. And in country like Indonesia, employee with loyalty and experience is seen as desirable. Therefore government of Indonesia decided to use seniority-based reward system in the first place.
While seniority-based rewards have the advantages of minimising stress of insecurity and may attract applicants, It does not directly motivate performance and may discourage poor performers from leaving (McShane, Olekalns & Travaglione 2013). Furthermore, this kind of financial reward practice is essentially a golden handcuff which could potentially weaken job performance because they generate continuance rather than affective commitment (McShane, Olekalns & Travaglione 2013). It is this kind of situation that exactly happened at Indonesian government. Government of Indonesian have no problem attracting applicants for public service position, because in a developing country like Indonesia, the prospect of having predictable income is very attractive. However, the Government of Indonesia fail to provide sufficient way to motivate its employee. As a result, employee has no incentive to improve performance and competence. One of the most alarming statistic is that 95% of Indonesian civil servants do not have appropriate competence (Pratama et al. 2015). Therefore Indonesian government need to devise a new financial reward system to motivate employee in order to improve performance and competence.
Other thing that make membership-based rewards unsuitable is that it is alienating high performing employees because this system reward employee not based on performance, therefore it could be perceived unfair by high performing employees. Equity theory principle infers that people should be paid in proportion to their contribution (McShane, Olekalns & Travaglione 2013). Treating employees fairly is good for employee motivation and there are two forms of...

Other Papers Like Using the Right Financial Reward System in Indonesian Public Sector

Abc in Public Sector Essay

5228 words - 21 pages management problems which impacts adversely on efficient service delivery. This study argues that the problems facing PSO in South Africa can be addressed by using ABC methodology instead of the traditional cost accounting. While traditional cost accounting (TCA) was developed to comply with external financial reporting requirements, it falls short in providing public sector organizations with the strategic information needed in today’s

Reward System in Google Company Essay

1789 words - 8 pages organizations need to be aware how important human resources are – and in order to retain and invite effective employees, reward systems must be enhanced. This paper discusses the reward system of Google Company. Google Inc. gives a standard package of fringe benefits plus a first-class dining facilities, free gyms, laundry and dry cleaning rooms, massage and haircut services, carwashes, shuttles and buses, play area, sleeping quarters, and a lot more

Should Jails Be in the Private or Public Sector

721 words - 3 pages Stefan Wolf Staertzel Thursday, September 16 2010 Should Jails be publically or privately owned? Should Jails be in the Public or Private Sector? The Public Sector is the area of nation’s affairs under governmental control rather than private control, when the Private Sector is the area of nations economy under private control rather than governmental. A Jail in most cases is ran by the government and ran by the public sector, except for some

Should Mandatory Regulation Be Applied in the Financial Sector

3175 words - 13 pages international due to the interconnectedness and interdependence caused by globalisation, and it needs to be mandatory due to the predatory nature of the financial system. Introduction: In light of the 2008 financial crisis, this report will argue for international mandatory regulations in the financial sector to enhance its Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR). The banks for International Settlement and the Basel Committee have made positive

Working For The Public Sector Versus The Private Sector

733 words - 3 pages As with most choices, especially in the work world, there are benefits and consequences of working for both public and private sectors. There are different sets of needs to be met in each criterion but they may slightly relate to each other as well. The public sector mostly relate to Government work. There are special exams a person has to take whenever they apply for any work with the government. There are some very strict rules and

Financial Crisis Problem: IS The Government Bailout Right? It Is An Essay About The Financial Crisis In 2008, In My Economy Class

1630 words - 7 pages becoming economic crisis, and avoid the vicious cycle of financial crisis and economic crisis.The cons of bailout are also obvious. The reason why it takes two times vote for the bailout to come out is due to the rejection of the public. And that is also why Bush called it "rescue" rather than "Bailout". Many people think that "Bailout is just wasting tax payer's money to pay debt for tycoons and big brothers in economic system; it is for the benefit

Outline Some Of The Challenges To The Police Service In The 'post-Macpherson' Era. Discuss This Statement With Reference To The Contribution Of Public Sector Partnerships

1754 words - 8 pages service as a result of the Macpherson report. I plan to look at the contribution of public sector partnerships in the post Macpherson era.Macpherson reportThe Macpherson Report was an inquiry into the failure of the Metropolitan Police to successfully apprehend the killers of Stephen Lawrence. Stephen was an 18 year old black man murdered by a gang of white racists in South London in 1993. He was fatally stabbed in an unprovoked attack as he waited

The Issue Of Character In The United States Public Education System

1587 words - 7 pages whether there is in fact a correlation between character education implementation and student achievement. The population for the research study will include one comprehensive public high school that plans to begin implementation of a character education program. At least 5% of the school’s population will be included in a random sample of students evenly distributed in grades 9, 10, 11, and 12. For example, if the school’s population consists

Role Of The US Financial System

1170 words - 5 pages The U.S. financial system is a market for buying and trading of securities in the U.S economy for raising capital for companies in financial need. Financial markets are generally separated into short-term and long-term markets. The short-term markets comprise securities with maturities of one year or less and are referred to as money markets. Security markets are divided into organized exchanges and over-the-counter markets. The long-term

Complexities of the U.S. Financial System

884 words - 4 pages Complexities of the U.S. Financial System Briefly describe one (1) way the U.S. financial markets impact the economy, one (1) way the U.S. financial markets impact businesses, and one (1) way the U.S. financial markets impact individuals. Companies sell stock to raise money. Once a stock begins trading in the secondary market, its change in price has no direct effect on the company that issued it. Regardless of the wavering of the stock

Complexities of the Us Financial System

993 words - 4 pages The U.S. financial system has many complexities and it is impacted by several environmental factors including federal regulations and the economy. The U.S. financial markets impact the economy, businesses, and individual by the movement of funds among financiers, businesses and governments. It involves investments in the area of sales or marketing of securities, the management of investment risk through portfolio diversification and the analysis

Related Essays

Abc In The Public Sector Essay

4188 words - 17 pages visibility and understanding to the latter – fulfilling the needs of the service recipients and customers consuming the organizational outputs. It focuses on the demand side for resources. Removing the blindfold – outputs, not just resources and expenditures The traditional financial accounting system has evolved in such a way that all public sector managers reasonably know what expenditures they have made in past time periods. But none of them

Causes Of The Indonesian Financial Crisis

1195 words - 5 pages high. Transparency issues in the government with several people especially the President's sons and daughters controlled many major companies in Indonesia. * Weak legal and regulations for the financial system. Lots of unhealthy banks running on very low capital. * Indonesian central bank (Bank Indonesia) had allowed rupiah to float with a range of 8% allowing a 4-5% annual depreciation from 1995. This band would later be increased to 12

Managing Out In The Public Sector

1894 words - 8 pages ; collectively they are referred to as citizens. Key Factors The key factors underpinning public sector reform include, but are not limited to the following:- - Demand by the public for improved quality of service and improved service delivery. This may also include customisation of services so they are relevant to the individual, community or organisation; - Changes in public policy or direction which includes stakeholder engagement that ensures

Intercultural Communication In The Public Sector

517 words - 3 pages evaluate the efficacy of Los Angeles County criminal justice services. It will compile and aggregate criminal justice related records from law enforcement, the court, prosecution, probation, defense, public health, mental health, and social service to generate anonymized sets of statistical reports that met the needs of policy makers and impacted agencies. The initial focus of this system will be to generate statistical reports related to realignment