This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Universal Suffrage Essay

1323 words - 6 pages

Debate on Universal Suffrage: Kent vs. Buel, N.Y
In the midst of the revolutionary war in 1777, New York states constitution became official. In the constitution it stated that white male property owners were the only ones allowed to vote in the state elections. Between 1816 and 1821, the population of citizens who did not own property flourished; leaving about 10 percent of New Yorkers eligible to vote (Unit 3: Great Debates in American History). In September 1821, the state of New York held a convention to revise its constitution; eliminating property ownership as a requirement to vote was a key issue. A great debate ensued between committee members David Buel and James Kent, resulting ...view middle of the document...

Kent expressed that universal suffrage would “jeopardize the rights of property and the principles of liberty” (Unit 3: Great Debates in American History). Kent warned that universal suffrage would allow the growing poor to vote to seize property from the wealthy. In his speech, Kent explains that France and Europe have millions of manufacturing and commercial labors who do not own property, yet their societies continue to thrive. He expresses distaste for the citizens of New England, who granted universal suffrage, because New England’s citizens are, “plain and simple republics of farmers” (Unit 3: Great Debates in American History). Kent believes that New York City will grow in size, wealth, and importance; therefore becoming the London of America, that is, as long as voting rights stay as they are. Kent goes on to state that people who only contribute one cent to the common stock compared to those that pay thousands, should not have any say regarding property concerns. Although Kent’s position was supported by many committee members, he faced strong opposition from committee member David Buel.
David Buel was born on October 22, 1784, in Litchfield, Connecticut. After graduating from Williams College in 1805, Buel studied law in Albany, N.Y. In 1808, David Buel was accepted as an attorney in the New York Supreme Court; 10 years later he was named first judge of the Rensselaer County Court, he resigned in 1828 (Hon. David Buel, Jr.). Compared to Kent, Buel and his supporters were unfamiliar, but that did not stop the convention from approving their proposition. Buel wanted the states suffrage requirements revised to all white male taxpayers, not just property owners. Buel argues that American society cannot be compared to European society because they are exceedingly different. Buel states that in America, the real property “will be in the hands of the many”, whereas in the European society, the aristocracy keeps property in the hands of only a few (Unit 3: Great Debates in American History). Buel disputes Kent’s claims on New England’s society by pointing out that their citizens are content, and have appreciated universal suffrage without destructive effects. Judge Buel explains that while suffrage being limited to property holders may have worked in the beginning, wiser laws have come into effect which steadily increased property owners, resulting in a transformation of interest in its protection. He points out the fact that farmers make up a large amount of the population, and that the agricultural population will grow in the future, therefore the taxpayers should be allowed suffrage( Unit 3: Great Debates in American History). Buel believes the rights of suffrage should not lie in the hands of a few men from a large population that is rapidly increasing, but with hardworking taxpayers that want just as much security as the next man....

Other Papers Like Universal Suffrage

The History Of Women Essay

3271 words - 14 pages . After several years it became apparent that battling the two simultaneously was not working. The focus had shifted from “women” to “black women” and women were excluded from the 15th amendment; thus a rift developed between the women involved. The AERA and universal suffrage was not working. Susan B. Anthony and Elizabeth Cady Stanton were two women with a vision of equality in their hearts. These two women would become the face of the “new

Womens Rights Essay

3330 words - 14 pages several years it became apparent that battling the two simultaneously was not working. The focus had shifted from “women” to “black women” and women were excluded from the 15th amendment; thus a rift developed between the women involved. The AERA and universal suffrage was not working. Susan B. Anthony and Elizabeth Cady Stanton were two women with a vision of equality in their hearts. These two women would become the face of the “new” suffrage

US Constitution Foundation Of Democratic Plan Or Not

1314 words - 6 pages individuals and private organizations to carry on with there social and economic activities with little to no interference by the government. The United States Constitution is a democratic plan of government because it ensures the rights of the people through the Bill of Rights, checks and balances, and universal suffrage which give everyone of age and citizenship the right to vote.The important features of modern democracy include individual freedom

Great Depression

1432 words - 6 pages end to the women’s suffrage movement, turning suffrage into a universal human right. The Progressive Era set the stage for the rapid evolution of corporate legislation. The creation of the Department of Commerce and Labor in 1903 and the passage of the Hepburn Act in 1906 were, probably, the two most important points in the development of complex relationships between business, government, and society. The creation of the Department of Commerce


572 words - 3 pages chamber of deputies and a 315-member senate. Except for afew life members of the senate (including former presidents and someprominent citizens nominated by the president), both houses are electeddirectly by universal adult suffrage for 5-year terms unless dismissed earlier.The president of the republic is head of state and is elected to a renewable 7-year term by a joint session of Parliament and three delegates from each ofthe regional

Gender's Power

1502 words - 7 pages women held a lower career stature. On the contrary, in Poland, the capitalism was limited and the economy was weak. For her, the policy was liberal democracy and universal suffrage, women’s education was less restricted, and women were on a higher stature. The study shows these historical causes are the basic reasons between the uneven status of men and women. This has lead to the unequal power of gender. The American economic and

Karl Liebknecht Described the Reichstag as a “Fig Leaf Covering the Nakedness of Absolutism” How Far Do You Agree?

1197 words - 5 pages the Prussian elites who made up the administration of the Reich. Therefore, the premise cannot be entirely true as the absolutism was not latent in nature and was infact enshrined in the constitution. However, a nascent democracy is to be argued present by the very existence of a representative body elected by universal –male- suffrage more than can be said about most of the contemporary first world nations. Firstly, I would argue as would Rohl

Essentials Of Democracy In 1928

1582 words - 7 pages Essentials of Democracy in 1928 Democracy is definable as a form of government where there is a fair representation system, universal adult suffrage, the right of the electorate to participate in the political process, freedom of speech for all, a government dependant on majority support in the commons and regular elections, free of corruption. In the eighteen hundreds various events, such as the French revolution

Chapter24 Notes

557 words - 3 pages at the mercy of irrational forces -He was against Christianity “God is Dead” -There were superior intellectuals that could free themselves from the conforms of thinking and therefore lead – “Superman” -He was anti-democracy, social reform and universal suffrage Neutrality: -Soreell combines Burgson’s ideas and Nietzsche to create a revolutionary reform led by an elite ruling body -Sigmund Freud – psychoanalysis

Jeremy Bentham

575 words - 3 pages Jeremy Bentham (1748-1832) Born February 15, 1748, Jeremy Bentham, was an English philosopher, economist and theoretical jurist, the earliest and chief expounder of utilitarianism. (Plamentaz, 2013) He was the first to produce a utilitarian justification for democracy with much to say about prison reform, religion, poor relief, international law and animal welfare. As a visionary well before his time he also advocated universal suffrage and

Russian History

1303 words - 6 pages appalling. This led to workers questioning the Tsar’s authority and the way he just turned them aside. On the 9th of January 1905, a peaceful procession of peasants and workers slowly marched towards the Tsar’s palace. They were led by Father Gapon a Russian Orthodox Priest and a working class leader to present the Tsar with a petition that asked for civil liberties, universal suffrage and a constituent assembly. They believed that he would be there

Related Essays

Women's Rights Essay

753 words - 4 pages ] {text:bookmark-start} {text:bookmark-end} Suffrage, the right to vote {draw:a} {draw:a} Inez Boissevain at a NAWS parade, Washington 1913 For more details on this topic, see Women's suffrage. The ideas that were planted in the late 1700s took root during the 1800s. Women began to agitate for the right to vote and participate in government and law making.[24] The ideals of Women's suffrage developed alongside that of universal suffrage, and women's

Ap Suffrage In England Essay

1541 words - 7 pages vote, it was a step in the right direction for the British. (Spartacus Educational Website) After the Reform Bill of 1832 was passed a group of citizens formed the Workingman's Association, supporters of which were called chartists. The chartists believed in universal manhood suffrage and the secret ballot. The proposals were made known in the People's Charter, which was denied by the Parliament. The chartists attempted to achieve their goal of

The End Of The Virtual Liberalism Essay

597 words - 3 pages -liberalism, people were still the subjects of the former colonial master and under the governance of the previous colonial system but with a new name called “one country two systems”, and they were just fail to see it. However, the Umbrella Movement indicated that the virtual-liberalism is no longer exist now. From the Umbrella Movement, the major participants were well-educated youngsters and they were appealing for universal suffrage. The movement was

Difference Feminisim In British Suffrage: N Essay About A Specific Event In The 20th Century Pertaining To Any Civil Movements

1347 words - 6 pages suffragists envisioned a universal womanhood unified in its goals of emancipation. This expectation, based in difference between the sexes and sameness among women, undercut the importance of feminists cultural identity. British feminist may have looked down upon Indian women from their imperial vantage point. In correlation, the British suffragists movement adopted ideas about international feminism and universal suffrage which failed to focus on the