This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

United Brands Company V. Commission Of The European Union

3307 words - 14 pages


United Brands Company v. Commission of the European Communities Case 27/76

Coursework for EU Law and Institutions Winter Semester 2013 Lecturer: Dr. Anke Steinhoff Tobias Wilms BA International Business

Table of contents
Introduction 1. 1.1 1.2 2. 2.1 2.1.1 2.2 2.2.1 2.2.2 3. F The Existence of a dominant market position The relevant market UBC´s position on the relevant market Abuse of the dominant position Behavior vis-à-vis the ripeners The clause prohibiting the resale of bananas while still green Price policy Discriminatory prices Unfair Prices urther Submissions

4. 5. 6.

Relevance of Case 27/76 Reference List Affidavit

...view middle of the document...

In this regard, the Commission imposed a fine of one million units account for on United Brands Company, because of the infringement of Article 86. Furthermore the UBC was told to bring to an end without delay the infringements of this article which were accrued: a) by requiring its distributors and ripeners to refrain from reselling bananas while still green. b) by charging different trade parties in the member states dissimilar prices for equivalent bananas of the brand „chiquita“. c) by imposing unfair prices for the „chiquita“ bananas. d) by rejecting deliveries to the corporation Th. Oelsen, Copenhagen, Denmark. Case 27/76 The UBC an its subsidiary UBCBV claimed against the Commissions decisions at the European Court of Justice with the purpose of the decisions annulment, the payment of

compensation for immaterial damages and, as alternative, the annihilition or reductio of the fine. The European Court of Justice made its judgement in this case on 14 February 1978 and agreed in its Judgement with the European Commission in all specifications accept of one. Article 1 c of Commission Decision was annuled and the fine imposed on UBC and UBCBV was reduced to the amount of 850 000 units of account. The rest of UBC´s applications were dismissed and each party had to pay its own costs of proceedings. Relevance of the Case 27/76 The case United Brands Company v. Commission of the European Communites was one of the first cases of this type and it had important effects on future jurisdictions. Vague expressed Articles in the Treaty of Rome and the absence of interpretations by authorities lead to the situation that corporations were not sure whether they are violating laws by doing business within the European Economic Community. The Courts explanations and decisions made during the Case 27/76 clarified some of these issues. One of the most important aspects were, that the court declared that a corporation with a market share of less than 45% can be in a dominant market position. Previously no company with a market share less than seventy perecent was considered as marketdominating. The Court however explained that the assessment of a dominant market position cannot be conducted by focussing only on the market share but on a combination of several characteristics. Another game-changing aspect was that a price policy which may produce national market segments can be considered as trade-barriers and therefore an infringement of competition laws. The Courts decision in Case 27/76 from 14 February 1979 did not only clrified vague articles of the Treaty. It lead to a situation in which a considerably larger quantity of businesses had to consider that their practices might be subject to infringement of competition laws. Furthermore, and that might be the most important aspect, it was a clear signal for an increasing willingness of the European Communities to protect the competition within their boarders. In the following coursework the Case 27/76 and...

Other Papers Like United Brands Company V. Commission of the European Union

Why Does the European Union Have Such a Strong Court of Justice?

3337 words - 14 pages Inland Revenue Administration, 1963, ECR 1. Case 6/64, Flaminio Costa v E.N.E.L., 1964, ECR 585. Europa, Press releases Rapid, Court of Justice of the European Communities, Press release No 104/09, The Treaty of Lisbon and the Court of Justice of the European Union, Luxembourg, 30 November 2009. Available at:, (consulted on

European Union: Is the Media Friend or Foe?

592 words - 3 pages European Union: Is the Media Friend or Foe? Over the past several decades, the French, Italians, Spaniards, Germans, Austrians, Swiss, and so on have been tempted to surrender their identity to the newly formed culture, “European.” Formed in 1993, The European Union consists of 27 European countries that have agreed to abide by the same foreign and security policies, such as accepting a new currency, the Euro. The European Union mainly formed

Co2 Emission of European Union Countries: a Short Review

546 words - 3 pages showed me the accurate way to complete the assignment. CO2 EMISSION OF EUROPEAN UNION COUNTRIES: A SHORT REVIEW Beginning… “EU promises 20% reduction in carbon emissions by 2020” –it was published as headline in 21st February, 2007 in a number of leading newspapers of the world. From that commitment it is clear that the amount of carbon emission in the countries of EU is at an alarming state that vibrates their concern to

United States of America V. Angevine

917 words - 4 pages Case: United States of America v. Angevine `````````````````````````````````````````````` Question 1: How did the police find this illegal material? Professor Angevine’s wife tipped the authorities of her husband’s activities. Officers from the Stillwater, Oklahoma Police Department seized the computer and turned it over to a computer expert who used special technology to retrieve the data that had remained latent in the computer's

Scrapping of the Planning Commission- Discuss Scrapping of the Planning Commission-

729 words - 3 pages Scrapping of the Planning Commission- Discuss Scrapping of the Planning Commission- Discuss With the development of Constitution there were several constitutional bodies which established. Constitutional body is one whose functions are mentioned in the Constitution, for any change in their functionalities Constitutional amendment is required with special majority Eg, Finance Commission. Such bodies are integral part of our Constitution

State of the Union

735 words - 3 pages Toney Lee February 8, 2014 ECO-512-26 Spring 2014 Summary: Obama’s 2014 State Of The Union Address The president of the United States addressed our nation on many different issues, achievements, and opportunities for our future moving forward. During his five years in office, he has experienced the highs and lows of economic growth. Under his reign as president, the graduation rate is at its highest level in more than three decades

Meta-Luxury: Brands and the Culture of Excellence

1784 words - 8 pages Book Review Meta-luxury: Brands and the culture of excellence Manfredi Ricca and Rebecca Robins Palgrave Macmillan, Basingstoke, United Kingdom, 2012, hardback, 224pp., £26.00, ISBN: 978-0230293571 Luxury strategy in action Jonas Hoffmann and Ivan Coste-Manière Palgrave Macmillan, Basingstoke, United Kingdom, 201 hardback, 224pp., £26.00, 1, ISBN: 978-0230354548 Journal of Brand Management (2012) 19, 637–640. doi:10.1057/bm.2012.26

Case Study Analysis Of Palsgraf V. Long Island Railroad Company

858 words - 4 pages Case Study Analysis of Palsgraf v. Long Island Railroad Company Michael J. Roberts Liberty University Palsgraf v. Long Island Rail Company is a case where the plaintiff, Ms. Palsgraf, was on one end of a train platform when a package was knocked out of the hands of another passenger who was attempting to board a moving train with the assistance of a guard, the defendant, on the other end of the train platform. The package being knocked

The Fall of Soviet Union

3837 words - 16 pages Pengenalan “Workers of the world, unite!”, itu merupakan slogan atau manifesto bagi pemegang fahaman komunis dan ini termasuklah Union of Soviet Socialist Republics/Kesatuan Republik Sosialis Soviet (USSR). USSR merupakan sebuah negara sosialis yang amat besar dan juga dikenali sebagai Soviet Union. Soviet Union terletak di kawasan Eurasia di mana negara ini terletak di utara Asia tetapi

Penn Central Transportation Company V. City of New York

1402 words - 6 pages Penn Central Transportation Company v. City of New York CASE SUMMARY The New York City had adopted its Landmarks Preservation Law in 1965. It empowered the city to designate certain structures and neighborhoods as "landmarks" or "landmark sites." Penn Central, which owned the Grand Central Terminal, was not allowed to construct a multistory office building above it. The Trial Court supported the Penn Central. The Appellate court reversed

Collapse of the Soviet Union

775 words - 4 pages take. Author D, Germany Re-armed. Chicago: Institute of European History Press, 2001. Author D’s book Germany Re-armed brings together a large amount of statistical sources generated by Germany’s rearmament programme. Using sources such as the invoices for rifle straps and army census documents, Germany Re-armed is useful to my essay as it provides me with statistical evidence to support my argument. Author E, The Wermacht. London

Related Essays

The European Union Essay

969 words - 4 pages can be lower, causing loss of monies in trade.      Another disadvantage that comes with a membership in the European Union is the language difficulties, and ethical backgrounds. Experts suggest that such unions can only be successful if the whole area is covered by a single currency and has the same legal framework, as in the United States where a common language and laws consists in a large geographical area. This is

Transportation In The European Union Essay

2030 words - 9 pages concern to the Community, which had adopted a Directive laying down the ground rules for enquiries into air incidents in civil aviation. Lastly, in the White Paper "Freeing Europe's Airspace", the Commission advocates introducing a unified system of air traffic management.After having analyzed all transport infrastructures it would be very useful to observe two comparison boards of those transport infrastructures in EU (European Union } and CES

Social Policy, Economics Of Labor Markets In The European Union

2813 words - 12 pages When we turn on the television we always hear something to be mentioned about the European Union. But what does European Union mean and why is it created? "The European Union has its origins in the European Coal and Steel Community (ECSC), established on 18 April 1951 by the Treaty of Paris"(Waller-Thody, 1997). It is a union of many states joining together through different enlargements. Their main purpose is to solve economic and political

Tax Federation V/S Union Of India

3819 words - 16 pages FIRST INTERNAL ASSIGNMENT TAXATION LAW SUBMITTED BY: KONIKA JAIN PRN:15010143061 All India Federation Of Tax Practioners (Petitioner) v/s Union Of India & others(Respondent) 21st August 2007 (Date Of Judgement) CITATION: (2007) 7 SCC 527 AIR 2007 SC-2990 NAME OF THE JUDGES: S.H. Kapadia & B. Sudershan Reddy FACTS: * On 1st June 1998 finance bill was introduced in which Clause 119 of the