This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Unit 4 [P1 M1] Essay

1741 words - 7 pages

Nathan finds out that his girlfriend Tanya has been having an affair. Rather than confronting her on this, Nathan decides to punish her by making her sick. He decides to poison her, and goes to his local hardware store and buys rat poison.

Nathan puts a small dose in Tanya's morning coffee, intending to give her a number of very small doses of poison in order to keep her sick for a few days (the amount he gives her is not enough to kill most people). However, Tanya is particularly sensitive to the rat poison, and collapses.

Tanya is taken to hospital by Nathan, who regrets what he has done. He does not tell the doctor what he has given her, and the doctor wrongly diagnoses her and ...view middle of the document...

In this letter I will discuss whether you had the Actus Reus and Mens Rea for Tanya's death and I will describe the meaning and the processes of how the court will see if they are present.

First, for murder to be present there must be a death to a human being. This occurs when the brain stem stops functioning and a human being must be a person who can independently take a breath once born on their own. If Tanya's brain stem has stopped working than she has not died as there is a chance of resuscitation; however, if her brain stem has stopped functioning than she will have died. Tanya is a human being as she was able to breathe while separate to her mother, on her own.

Actus Reus

The Actus Reus is the act of the crime this is the same for all homicide offences. The court will look to see if you have caused the death of the victim. This is usually very simple and the court has to see if there is Factual Causation and legal Causation present for Actus Reus to be considered.

Factual causation consists of the "but for” test and the De Minimus rule.

The "but for” test questions whether the victim; in this case Tanya, would have died at the same time without the defendant doing what they did. This means that if you didn't poison her, and lie to the hospital, would Tanya still be dead. For example in the case of White (1910) the defendant gave his mother poison but, before it had time to take effect, she died of a heart attack which wasn't caused by the poison. This shows that he is not liable for her death, as she still would have died of the heat attack without him poisoning her. In this situation you poisoned Tanya via her coffee, if you had not the act of poisoning Tanya then she would not have died and therefore you were the main reason for her death as she shouldn't have collapsed and gone to the hospital if she wasn't poisoned. In addition if you hadn't lies to the hospital then they would have given her the correct treatment and wouldn't have caused her death.

The de minimus rule look to see if the defendant actions were more than minimal cause of the victim's death. This suggests that when a person kills another they are speeding up the time of which the person would die; and so the defendant's actions which caused the acceleration of death must be more than trivial. In your case, you gave Tanya poison in her morning coffee as punishment and knew that it would cause harm to her. Therefore, the court would see that this is more than minimal cause as by poisoning her; she collapses and as a result goes to the hospital with causes her getting the wrong treatment. Furthermore, you lied to the Hospital which caused them to give her the wrong treatment and then die which again accelerated her death; this could be foreseen as lie to the hospital would result in the wrong treatment that may cause harm Tanya. Because of these points you pass the de minimus rule.

The legal causation, consists of was the original injury a...

Other Papers Like Unit 4 [P1-M1]

Unit 1 – Developing Effective Communication in Health and Social Care P1, P2, M1

4442 words - 18 pages UNIT 1 – Developing Effective Communication in Health and Social Care * ------------------------------------------------- Understand Effective Communication and Interpersonal Interaction In Health and Social Care (P1,P2,M1) INFORMATION PACK ADEN COURT NURSING HOME ADEN COURT NURSING HOME What is communication? Communication simply means when information is transferred from one person/place to another person/place. Communication

Unit 4 P1 Essay

932 words - 4 pages P1 In this initial stage of the assignment I will be explaining types of information that Samsung have and use within their business. Due to the fact that Samsung sell such a wide variety of products I will be narrowing it down to their Mobile Phones department in order to make sure focus can be kept on one particular area. There are two main types of business information, internal and external. Internal: The first key source of

Unit 2 Business Resources P1/M1

980 words - 4 pages – e.g. Birth certificate and/or any other appropriate document required to confirm your right to work in the UK as required by the Asylum and Immigration Act 1996 Yes No 3. EDUCATION From To Type of School (i.e. Grammar/ Secondary) Examinations taken and Qualifications Gained (Specify Grades) 4. FURTHER/ HIGHER EDUCATION From To Name of Institution (state if Full or Part Time) Subjects Taken and Qualifications Gained (Specify

Unit 4 Business Communication P1

808 words - 4 pages Communication Verbal Information – The sharing of information between two or more individuals by using speech. It is important for a business to use verbal communication in their work place as they would need to communicate with customers etc. Verbal communication is important throughout a business as it is used in all businesses and all sectors of a business. Workers using verbal communication must ensure that they are using the correct tone

P1 Unit 4 L3 Ups

1706 words - 7 pages appropriate programmes and preparing these offenders for release. HM Chief inspector of fire and rescue The former position of HM chief inspector of fire and rescue was replaced in 2007 by chief fire and rescue advisory unit. While the former inspectorate was responsible for inspecting fire and rescue service reporting to the government, the new unit, established by the department for the communities and local government, is responsible for

Health And Social Care Level 3 Unit 2 P1,P2,P3,M1

1519 words - 7 pages P1: Explain concepts of equality, diversity and rights in relation to health and social care Equality, diversity and rights are the core elements in health and social care. It affects every single person using the health and social care sector as well as those working within them. It is important for health and social care workers to understand the importance of treating all individuals equally no matter their ethnicity, gender, race, beliefs

Bery Good

760 words - 4 pages Chace Community School- BTEC Business Assessment Front Sheet |Name | |Form | | |Course |BTEC Level 3 Extended Diploma in Business | |Unit |Unit 4 |Assignment Title

Leadership In Sport P-1

4823 words - 20 pages Course Tutor: Jon Davy | Year: 2012/2013 | Unit: 13 Leadership in Sport | Tutor: Jon Davy | Assignment Title: Effective Sports Leaders | Handout date: W/C 24/9/2012 | Submission date: W/C 8/10/2012 | Leadership in Sport Outcomes Covered | Outcome | P1 | M1 | D1 | | | Achieved | | | | | | Learner declaration: The work submitted is entirely my own work. Any help or information from other sources has been acknowledged in

Business Btech

867 words - 4 pages BTEC National Extended Diploma in Business Assignment Brief – ASSIGNMENT ONE Unit title | Unit 41 Business Markets and the Economy | Assignment | Business organisation and objectives | Start date | 10th March 2014 | Draft deadline date | 19th March 2014 | Final deadline date | 26th March 2014 | Assessor | Mr Muhammad | P1 - identify the objectives of a range of organisations | P2 - explain how organisations meet their

Btec Level 2 Unit 1

976 words - 4 pages feature article on local businesses Task: 1. Learners must describe (P1) the type of business, purpose and ownership of two contrasting businesses 2. Learners must describe (P2), explain (M1) the different stakeholders who influence the purpose of two contrasting businesses 3. Learners must describe (P3) how two businesses are organised 4. Learners must explain (P4) how their style of organisation helps them to fulfil their purpose 5. Learners


1140 words - 5 pages Qualification suite covered | Edexcel BTEC Level 3 Diploma/Extended Diploma, Health and Social Care | Assignment title | Life Stages | Unit number and title | Unit 4:Development Through the Life Stages | Assessor | Kelly Ocloo | Learning aims covered | On completion of this unit a learner should:1. Know the stages of growth and development throughout the human lifespan 2. Understand the potential effects of life factors and

Related Essays

Unit 3 P1,M1,D1 Essay

3475 words - 14 pages Unit 3 P1 I am going to describe how marketing techniques are used to market products and evaluate the effectiveness in two organisations (Sainsbury and Samsung). These companies use marketing techniques such as branding, relationship marketing and growth matrix. Branding Branding is very important to marketing because it helps establish a product in a market and build the brand. Most brands have certain things that make them

Unit 4 P1 Essay

2060 words - 9 pages Unit 4 (P1) - Developing Through The Life Stages Conception - This is where it all begins, a female becomes fertile and releases one egg cell each month, it then travels from the ovary to the uterus, in the fallopian tube. if sexual intercourse takes place while the egg is in the fallopian tube and the male has an orgasm millions of sperm will ejaculate inside of the woman. All it takes is one sperm to fertalise an egg this is when the sperm

P1 M1 Unit 4 Business Essay

851 words - 4 pages Unit 4 – Business Communication Introduction: In this assignment I am going to explain different types of business information, their sources and purposes and analyse different types of business information and their sources. Verbal information: Verbal information is given from one person to another by speaking; this can be done in interviews face to face and interviews over the phone. Tesco will have an internal human resource department

Unit 7 P1, M1 Essay

1307 words - 6 pages United Nations The United Nations is an organization established 24 October 1945. It was a replacement for the League of Nations. The UN was created following the Second World War to prevent another such conflict. The organization is financed by giving its member states a substantial fee. Its objectives include maintaining international peace and security, promoting human rights, fostering social and economic development, protecting the