Understanding Prescriptive Vs. Descriptive Grammar Essay

1337 words - 6 pages

Top of Form
Bottom of Form
Understanding Prescriptive vs. Descriptive Grammar
When people hear about linguistics, they often believe that linguists are very much like the character Henry Higgins in the play My Fair Lady, who expresses sentiments like in the following song, where he bemoans the state of English and the lack of proper pronunciation:
However, as you will learn in this first week of class, there are two different ways that language has been talked about in disciplines that focus on the use of language. We can talk about these different approaches to language as descriptive grammar vs. prescriptive grammar. 
Prescriptive ...view middle of the document...

Linguistics takes this approach to language.
A key contrast is to be found between these two approaches. A descriptive grammarian would say that a sentence is “grammatical” if a native speaker of the language would produce that sentence in speaking. The descriptive grammarian would then try to describe how that sentence is produced through theorizing about the mental processes that lead up to the surface form. A prescriptive grammarian, on the other hand, would say that something is grammatical only  if the surface form conforms to a set of rules that the grammarian believes should be followed in order for a certain grammar style is achieved. (Note that I have tried to emphasize that the descriptive grammarian hears a form and tries to describe the mental processes underneath the produced (spoken) form, while a prescriptive grammarian does not hypothesize about the mental grammar at all, but is merely concerned with ‘editing’ the surface form.)
Again, Linguistics aims to provide a descriptive grammar of language. In this course, we will use data based on surface forms (i.e. ‘spoken’ or ‘produced’ data) and will try to describe how these surface forms occur through processes in the mental grammar.
Descriptive vs. Prescriptive
Linguistics takes a descriptive approach to language: it tries to explain things as they actually are, not as we wish them to be. When we study language descriptively, we try to find the unconscious rules that people follow when they say things like sentence (1). The schoolbook approach to language is typically prescriptive. It tries to tell you how you should speak and write.
Notice that there is a place for both description and prescription in language study. For example, when adults learn a foreign language, they typically want someone to tell them how to speak, in other words to prescribe a particular set of rules to follow, and expect a teacher or book to set forth those rules. But how do teachers know what rules to prescribe? At some point in time, someone had to describe the language and infer those rules. Prescription, in other words, can only occur after the language has been described, and good prescription depends on adequate description. We obviously don't want to be teaching people the wrong things about language.
In an ideal world, descriptive and prescriptive approaches to language would follow this harmonious relationship: linguists would describe the rules of a language, and pedagogues would use those descriptions to make textbooks to teach language learners. In the real world, however, practitioners of the two approaches often separate themselves into hostile camps. Prescriptivists accuse descriptivists of being anarchists who want to do away with all rules of language. Descriptivists accuse prescriptivists of uninformed bigotry. With each side posting guards at the ramparts to repel the enemy, both tend to ignore the work and concerns of the other. Grammar textbooks used in K-12 education often...

Other Papers Like Understanding Prescriptive vs. Descriptive Grammar

Ethical Issues Essay

627 words - 3 pages through different types of enterprises are descriptive and prescriptive. According to Gill (2005), a descriptive enterprise is one that investigates the understanding and explaining of how people and organizations make their ethical judgments and decisions. In a prescriptive enterprise, the ethics of business tend to seek for the justifiable and right judgments of business concerns in ways of business practices. Many ethical issues within today’s

Final Project Essay

612 words - 3 pages to IFRS GAAP vs. IFRS: Financial Statement Meets “Proficient” criteria and explanation shows a nuanced understanding of the differences between IFRS and GAAP Submission is free of errors related to citations, grammar, spelling, syntax, and organization and is presented in a professional and easy-toread format Explains how a financial statement would differ under IFRS as opposed to GAAP Articulation of Response

Traditional Grammar Method

1512 words - 7 pages important person who played key roles of the brand new attitude this time. By-product of physics, leads some ideas of thinking to the structural linguists. They try to describe and explain the information of language, which founded on the system of language, without the prescriptive attitudes of traditional grammar. With this descriptive way, the structural linguists have no need to look back at the historical antecedents. They only concern with

Why Do I Need to Add a More Descriptive Title?

1399 words - 6 pages Journal, Vol 12, 95-117, 1991. Ginsberg A: ‘Connecting Diversification to Performance: A Sociocognitive Approach’, Academy of Management Review, Vol 15, No 3, 514-535, 1990. Porter, M E: ‘Clusters and the New Economics of Competition’, Harvard Business Review, November-December, 1998. Corporate Strategy and Strategic Management Syllabus The concept of Strategy. Prescriptive and descriptive dichotomies. The

Descriptive and Inferential Statistics

1251 words - 6 pages of future issues or events. In other words, statistics are a part of everyday life in civilization. The fact that statistics is in use so abundantly, a basic understanding of statistics is essential to determine fact and fallacy (Malone, 2005). Statistics are an important part when conducting research. There are two branches of statistical methods that can be used: descriptive statistics and inferential statistics. The method used in research

Usm - Understanding Strategy Module

1194 words - 5 pages CFairbrass (Module Leader for USM) of the ect. Excellent concluding section drawing together the various points made and adding an original perspective. Articulate & persuasive use of language. Consistently accurate user of grammar/spelling. Structure guides reader through argument. Presentation excellent. Subject relevance Conclusion – problem solving Written communication – spelling & grammar Structure & presentation Irrelevant or

Project Management

898 words - 4 pages academic debate | Understanding of contemporary academic debate, with some creative input and insight | Descriptive while demonstrating reasonable understanding | Limited/poor understanding demonstratedAny creative input is some what off the point | Non submission (0)Non serious attempt e.g. answer irrelevant to set question or completely insufficient | Content and Exploration of theories and ideas | Outstanding selection that makes a

Alternative Fair Value

1205 words - 5 pages , complete and internally consistent CF from existing frameworks Problems & Criticisms Of The Conceptual Framework • It is ambiguous The principles are too vague Too much room for alternative interpretations. • It is descriptive not prescriptive The Conceptual Framework simply describes current accounting practise. Should be prescriptive (normative) and try to improve practice. Problems & Criticisms Of The Conceptual Framework Cont


1304 words - 6 pages Analytics Concepts and Definitions Types of Analytics Descriptive Analytics: * Post Event Analytics * Add features to website and measure its effectiveness in form of clicks, link sharing, page views * Descriptive Analytics Tools -> Google Analytics, Optimizely Diagnostic Analytics: * Post Event Analytics * Analytics used to diagnose why something/phenomenon happened the way it did * It basically provides a very

International Business Finance

865 words - 4 pages students: The assignment is to be no longer than 3000 words and should contain critical analysis, relevant empirical evidence and examples. Purpose of the module:This modules aims: • To provide an understanding of the theories and empirical evidence related to foreign exchange markets, and the implications of these for international firms. • To generate an understanding of the methods available to international companies to finance international


2432 words - 10 pages state, the source of human achievements, and collective representations that specify both descriptive and prescriptive principles. Miller beliefs these representations help to mandate symbolize and interpret social relationships, and the broadcasting of these representations takes both direct and indirect paths. He also discuss one’s knowledge and states this knowledge does not overthrow one’s Self-Interest propaganda and that Self-interest

Related Essays

Prescriptive Approach Vs Descriptive Approach To Language

946 words - 4 pages mistress of it be, save I alone." In spite of their history, grammarians still object to the double negative in English. There are strong contrasting views to the rules of correct usage of language, and to whether rules are prescriptivist or descriptivist. For example, in some dialects double negation is commonly used, so sentences such as, 'I didn't do nothing' is not a descriptive rule of grammar. But, in places, and

Correctness In English Essay

563 words - 3 pages 'Correctness in language use is determined by what native speakers accept, not what grammarians dictate'. Both prescriptive and descriptive complement the correctness in language. Because language is uniquely human, it tells a story about a people, it holds mysteries of their traditions, heritage as well as culture. Imposing grammar rules on the language that the native speakers; dictating how they ought to use their language does not mean that

Perfect Position Paper

1589 words - 7 pages contribute to leader effectiveness. Theories that focus almost exclusively on either the leader or the follower are less useful than theories that offer a more balanced explanation. Another important distinction among leadership theories is the extent to which they are descriptive or prescriptive. Descriptive theories explain leadership processes, describe the typical activities of leaders, and explain why certain behaviors occur in particular

Language Analysis: The Brothers Grimm And Fairy Tales

2332 words - 10 pages as Grimm's law. There are two different types of grammar; prescriptive and descriptive. Prescriptive grammar is a set of rules about language based on how people think language should be used. Descriptive grammar is a set of rules based on how language is actually used and describes the way one speaks language. There are four rules of language discussed in this class. The study of phonetics is the study of the sounds of language. The