This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Tv Portrayal Of 1950s Housewives Vs Today

4684 words - 19 pages

I Love Lucy vs.
Desperate Housewives

The 1950s housewife was the epitome of a woman. She had poise and grace and cared for her family more than having a career. She had a smile on her face, dinner on the table, and her child always used please and thank you. At least on TV. Fast forward 50 years and much has changed in our history and the way that women are portrayed on television. With women no longer expected to give up their careers in order to raise a family, working moms are represented more with each passing decade. Two television shows that can be examined to explore the difference in television’s portrayal of ...view middle of the document...

I Love Lucy was the most watched television show in America in four of its six seasons and is commonly regarded as one of the most successful TV shows of all time. 2 Lucy is a true 1950s New York City housewife, as she does not have a job and stays home all day. In the first season of I Love Lucy, Lucy and her husband, Ricky, do not have any children. This gives Lucy the opportunity to keep busy doing other things that make for good television, such as trying to break into showbiz. Ricky, a Cuban American bandleader, spends most of his nights at a nightclub, Club Tropicana. Lucy and Ricky Ricardo become best friends with their landlords Ethel and Fred Mertz. The Mertz couple is much older than Lucy and Ricky and serves as an older, wiser source of comedy and insight for the show. I Love Lucy ran for six seasons, from 1951 to 1957. After the show ended in 1957, a modified version continued for three more seasons with 13 one-hour specials, running from 1957 to 1960, known first as The Lucille Ball-Desi Arnaz Show and later in reruns as The Lucy–Desi Comedy Hour.
Over 50 years passed before a new primetime drama would air on ABC depicting housewives once again. In that time span much happened in history to change the gender climate and ultimately effect the definition of a “housewife.” In the 1970s the feminist movement led women to seek fulfillment outside of the household and women went back to work.3 With this shift, the role of the “housewife” became outdated and undesirable, and because of that, there was a significant decline in the number of housewives portrayed on television.4 The modern woman could do everything herself and didn’t need a man to help her and television followed in that direction. Television shows started portraying women as having careers, but most shows still misrepresent the careers that the modern woman had.5 TV also misrepresented the amount of time the modern woman devotes to her career, although that is an aspect of many shows, regardless of gender. While the urban female generation is running towards their dream jobs and away from minivans and soccer balls, there is a suburban exception to the rule: and that’s where Desperate Housewives come in.
Desperate Housewives is an American comedy-drama that was first broadcasted on ABC on October 3, 2004. Desperate Housewives follows the lives of a group of women who live on Wisteria Lane, a fictional street in the fictional American town of Fairview in the fictional Eagle State.6 The all female ensemble includes Teri Hatcher as Susan Mayer, Felicity Huffman as Lynette Scavo, Marcia Cross as Bree Van de Kamp, and Eva Longoria as Gabrielle Solis. Brenda Strong narrates the show as the deceased Mary Alice Young, a housewife who committed suicide in the pilot episode. The show works through every day domestic struggles and family life, all while exposing the secrets, crimes and mysteries hidden behind the doors of their seemingly beautiful and perfect suburban neighborhood....

Other Papers Like Tv Portrayal of 1950s Housewives vs Today

The Power of the Screen Essay

849 words - 4 pages The Power of the Screen When television was first introduced, writers and social scientists thought that this new invention would better life. For example, psychologist Joel Gold predicted that it would make family bonds much stronger (as cited in Guwern, 2008, p. 103). Pictures which advertised television in the 1950s invariably showed a happy family gathered together in the living room, sharing the TV viewing experience. Who could have

Maasmedia Essay

608 words - 3 pages National Eating Disorder Association (2012) reports that the media and its portrayal of beauty is acknowledged as one of the factors contributing to the rise of eating disorders. In our culture, the media portrays tall and thin as the ideal image of beauty. Magazines, television , movies, commercials, and more portray attractive women as being extremely thin. It is nearly impossible to escape the influence of the media and children today are

Suburbia - Essay

630 words - 3 pages  The 1950s was a time of great economic prosperity for many Americans and the United States as a whole. During this decade, the middle class became a larger and more powerful force than it had ever been before. Many middle class families moved to the suburbs. Suburbs often were less crowded than urban areas which made it attractive for families to move there. They also offered much larger home than they could hope to find in the cities

Feminism a Dirty Word

1298 words - 6 pages father), in real-life most fathers were not around to solve issues with the children. This role as well as that of cook, and housekeeper belonged to the mother, roles which “TV shows insisted that good mothers, like true princesses, never complained, smiled a real lot, were constantly good-natured, and never expected anything from anyone” (Douglas 44). Similarly, in the quest to return women back to fulltime domesticity women were bombarded

Reality Tv

830 words - 4 pages Mariah Priester The Reality TV Phenomenon Many of us spend countless hours a week enjoying the shows that come on t.v. Years ago, television shows focused on the family, the strong bonds they shared, and building strong family ties. Shows like “The Brady Bunch”, “The Cosby Show” “Full House” and “Family Matters” were shows that could be enjoyed by the entire family. Today, television has taken on a new role, and it’s called “Reality T.V

Tv Violence and Its Effect on Children

4010 words - 17 pages (TV) viewing and children is relevant today as it Does watching violence on TV increase or alter the antisocial or aggressive activity of children? The possibility that widespread watching of violent TV programs by children and youth is increasing the level of violence in American society continues to be the most controversial and emotionally arousing issue related to the TV medium. This is because the concentration of violence portrayed on TV has

Media Images of Women

5218 words - 21 pages that gives her new power. In a recent opinion poll by All India Democratic Women’s Associtaion (AIDWA) and the Working Women’s Co-ordination Committee (WWCC), the subject of which is ‘Women’s portrayal in TV serials and advertisements’ the women uttered dismay over they being shown in bad light in advertisements and serials. The ‘soaps’ cast women as ‘scheming’ who are instrumental in breaking up the family bond. Polygamy, adultery and extra


526 words - 3 pages McCarthyism Between the late 1940s and 1950s, Americans had suffered a political and cultural hysteria which have been caused by fear and anxiety of communism as communism quickly spread around the global. McCarthyism is the use of the charge of communism to discredit political ideas, cultural values, and individual's lives and reputations which had been originated and preserved by US Senator McCarthy in the 1950s. The senator was strongly

Lucille Ball

2565 words - 11 pages accurate was this portrayal and what differences did Lucille Ball have in comparison to the millions that tuned in to watch? As a cultural icon, Ball was able to utilize her power and ideas to shape herself as the woman she wanted to be portrayed as on screen. Was there another side off? Like majority of celebrities, there is always two sides to someone or two a story, but whether the other side is made public is something of its own.Starring


1563 words - 7 pages , irresponsible sex".St. Louis Today: 18 February 2002..Hamer, Jennifer. What It Means to Be Daddy: Fatherhood for Black Men Living Away from Their Children. New York: Columbia University Press, 2001.Kunjufu, Jawanza. Hip-Hop Vs. MAAT: A Psycho/Social Analysis of Values. Chicago: African American Images, 1993.Steinhorn, Leonard, and Barbara Diggs - Brown. By The Color Of Our Skin. New York: Plume, 1999.

American Dream vs American Reality

1674 words - 7 pages , this idea of the American Dream has not coincided with the American reality shown through the segregation of class, race and ethnicity, unhappiness in the home, and the failure of public education. Immigrants during the Industrial Revolution were exposed to unjust treatment and stifled growth in society, women in the 1950s faced an identity crisis spawning from the materialized idea of perfection, and at the turn of the century public education

Related Essays

Tv Portrayal Of 1950s Housewives Vs Today

4684 words - 19 pages TELEVISION PORTRAYALS OF HOUSEWIVES IN THE 1950s VERSUS TODAY: I Love Lucy vs. Desperate Housewives The 1950s housewife was the epitome of a woman. She had poise and grace and cared for her family more than having a career. She had a smile on her face, dinner on the table, and her child always used please and thank you. At least on TV. Fast forward 50 years and much has changed in our history and the way that women are portrayed on

Gender & Media Essay

2414 words - 10 pages Summary of the content – image 1 - Extract taken from: Women in Twentieth Century Britain ‘mothers place in the home’ plate 17.2 – Woman 1937 The document presents initially the image of the perfect housewives; she appears to be perfectly neat and tidy in her attire down to her hair not being out of place. It depicts her in the image of a home taking care of the children, fulfilling the role of the housewives and mother, Basow (1992) states

How Useful Is The Notion Of Either ‘Objectification’ Or ‘Stereotyping’ For Issues Of Gender Representation In Contemporary Advertising?

2839 words - 12 pages understanding of gender roles and stratification (Tuchman, 1979). Tuchman (1979) argued that the sexism in media can be described by two dominant explanations, women’s position in media organisation s and the socioeconomic organisation of the media. Some researchers take the view that the toxic or harmful portrayal of women is common because women do not have any responsible positions within the media. There were women hired in the TV stations

Social, Cultural, Historical Elements Of A Taste Of Honey

2468 words - 10 pages dialogue: Helen: ‘’You prefer to stay in this hole with that pansified little freak.’’ (page 67) Racism - Jo’s first boyfriend is a black boy called Jimmie. She doesn’t seem bothered about his race, obviously due to her attraction to him. However, he is aware of what others might say, as in the 1950s black people were not very common in England like today. This is indicated in Act 1, scene 2: Boy: ‘’She hasn’t seen me.’’ (page 23