Trade Secret Essay

3647 words - 15 pages

Trade secret
In regards of Schlossberger’s suggestion that the duty to respect trade secrets has limit and is overridden, it seem more emphasizing in whistle blowing aspect. So the question rises that under what conditions is whistle blowing moral justified? In my opinion, it does not matter what one’s obligations or confidentiality agreements, one is never exempt from the general obligations we have to our fellow human beings. One of the most fundamental of these obligations is not to cause harm to others. In particular, obligations of confidentiality and loyalty cannot take precedence over the fundamental duty to act in ways that prevent unnecessary harm to others. Agreements to keep ...view middle of the document...

Engineers only have the obligation to do their jobs as best they can. This includes reporting concerns about safety of products to management, but does not include the obligation to insist that their perception or standards should be accepted.
It is absolute unethical to violate a patent, however, by making a few minor modifications to the patented, an engineer often may legally duplicate a product or process. Hence is it unethical to make a minor change in a patented product or process to avoid copyright infringement? Creators and innovators should deserve to enjoy the fruits of their labors. The fairness argument says that it is unfair for someone to free ride on the work of another. If some company invests time and money in developing a product, then it should have a protected period of time in which it can try to recoup its investment and make a profit. For any other party to copy that product immediately upon its appearance and sell it more cheaply because it has no development costs to recoup is unfair. Moreover, to deprive benefic of their innovations would be unjust and socially harmful. With patents violating, the incentive to innovate would be lessen and resulting in fewer innovations. Creators or innovators would have to depend on secrecy hence undermining the knowledge sharing and cooperation necessary to achieve progress.
However, engineer profession in particular or society in general always has an interest in improvement of innovations in order to benefic technologies. The ethics of copyrights and patents tried to balance fairness to innovators and improving technology to advance human welfare.
According to Schlossberger’s article, the following factors engineers should consider. First, has the patent holder had a chance to benefit from it? Some patents yield immediate profits, while others may take a long time. It is less troubling to market a modified patented product if the patent holder has had a reasonable chance to profit already. Second, if the modification a real improvement or was it developed only to get around patent laws? If the modification makes the product safer, more precise, more useful, or less environmentally harmful, then the modification is generally justifiable. Third, how significant is the modification? Changing a few unimportant details is more trouble than making major alterations. Finally, is there any doubt about the legality of the modification? Engineers should never engage in illegal practices.


Student: Emin Gurbanov




1. Importance of Trade Secrets it today's business world

2. Nondisclosure Agreement as effective tool to protect Trade Secrets

3. Elements and definition of Trade Secrets

4. Requirements for qualifications of secrets and Trade Secrets

5. Legislative definitions and protections of Trade Secrets

6. Limitations of...

Other Papers Like Trade Secret

How to Save Water Essay

2174 words - 9 pages ABOUT US Founded in 1997, Secret Recipe made its mark, renowned for its extensive range of fine quality gourmet cakes. It has since evolved to become one of the fastest growing lifestyle cakes and café chain in the region with over 300 café outlets to date. Secret Recipe Cakes & Café's concept can be found in prime urban locations and shopping malls in major cities in the region including Singapore, Kuala Lumpur, Jakarta, Bangkok, Manila

Introduction to Business Essay

1782 words - 8 pages of competitive advantage and should not be generally known outside of the firm. A company must be able to demonstrate that it has taken every reasonable step possible to keep the information private if it hopes to obtain court assistance in protecting its rights. Courts require that trade secret holders take 'reasonable' steps to maintain the secrecy of their trade secrets. Courts do not require that companies take all measures conceivable to

Industrial Relations

3204 words - 13 pages to indicate whether there is any contestant in the secret ballot * If yes, the contestant has to submit a list of its members showing the prescribed particulars * If the union is a federation then it has to submit a list of its affiliated trade unions together with a list of members of each such trade union along with their said particulars 2. Every employer shall * Submit a list of all workers employed in the

Risk Arising in Tangible Property and Intellectual Property

573 words - 3 pages be mitigated through alarm systems, security fences, and security guards. Protection from internal threats can be mitigated through background checks of all employees as well as screening of personnel and vehicles when they depart the premises. Intellectual Property Intellectual property in the automotive industry comprises: Trade Secrets - Product formula, pattern, design, compilation of data, customer list, or other business secret

Employment - Restraint of Trade

4490 words - 18 pages with his employer’s trade secrets as would enable him, if competition were allowed, to take advantage of his employer’s trade connection or utilise information confidentially obtained (Herbert Morris Ltd v Saxelby (HL) affirmed by Faccenda Chicken Ltd v Fowler) From this basic principles, certain important points arise. 1) Difficulty to define trade secret. What is trade secret?? It is an important concept which must be distinguished from

Ethics in Technology

733 words - 3 pages Karen Walker Ac1108748 Ethics in Technology-PY360 Assignment #3 11/20/2013 1. Copyright Software copyright is the relatively recent extension of copyright law to machine-readable software. It is used by proprietary software companies to prevent the unauthorized copying of their software. 1. Trade Secrecy Trade secret law provides probably the best protection for the source code of a computer program. It simply requires

Assess The Influence Of Military And Industrial Manufacturers And Secret Service Organisations

1071 words - 5 pages The military industrial manufactures and secret service organisations played pivotal roles in the Cold War as they worked to encourage the continuation of the cold war. Both influenced the Cold War by by maintaining an atmosphere of tension, uncertainty, and suspicion between the superpowers for the duration of the Cold War.This can be seen through the actions of the secret services for each superpower; the KGB (USSR), and CIA (USA). It was due

Intellectual Property

2008 words - 9 pages exclusion factor into a case ("BOWMAN v. MONSANTO"). The Uniform Trade Secrets Act defines a trade secret as “information, including a formula, pattern, compilation, program, device, method, technique, or process, that derives independent economic value, actual or potential, from not being generally known to or readily ascertainable through appropriate means by other persons who might obtain economic value from its disclosure or use; and is the


832 words - 4 pages consists of very wealthy people who controls all the International banks, the oil-businesses, the most powerful businesses of industry and trade, they infiltrate politics and education and they own most governments - or at the very least control them. They even own Hollywood and the Music Industry. What is driving them is power, money and control over the government. A good example is the American election for presidency, It is no secret that the

Intellectual Property Clause

1120 words - 5 pages legally protect every aspect of IP, which is especially true with trade secrets and patents. Misappropriation, the violation of trade secret law, can sometimes be difficult to establish, even if important elements of a trade secret are disclosed. If a person were able to recreate information considered to be a trade secret on his or her own, or if a product was reverse engineered by a person to figure out how it was made, that would not be

Product Strategy Coca Cola

1439 words - 6 pages list of secret ingredients known as merchandise flavoring 7x herbal extracts which give the unique flavor to the drink and the recipe has been guarded by the company for a century. (See Appendix 3) Coca-Cola’s recipe has remained one of the most heavily guarded trade secrets in the world for 125 years (Time, 2011). Because of the unique flavor, Coca-Cola has always tasted the best and cannot be cloned despite endless efforts by other competitors

Related Essays

Business Law Essay

935 words - 4 pages that helps trade secret theft. The District of Columbia and forty seven states have adopted laws from the UTSA. The states that have not adopted laws from the UTSA follow common law principles (NDAS, n.d.). Greenleaf Corporation is located in the State of Pennsylvania which has adopted the UTSA. The definition of the Uniform Trade Secrets Act is as follows; 1. “Improper means” of the company trade secrets, including theft, bribery

The Lego Company: Publish Or Protect

2511 words - 11 pages developed further strategies and technologies to ensure their growth and success in the area. The company is therefore faced with the difficulty in deciding how to protect this internal process and technology. Should this information be patented, kept as a trade secret, or published? This paper explores the options and proposes a possible solution for Lego Group, through careful research and analysis. Table

Department Of Homeland Security Essay

1190 words - 5 pages domestic terror attack in New York on the world trade center. That attack on the world trade center cause extreme damage and destruction on the building. American since then has seen more attacks. Till now more intense from the Oklahoma city bombing in 2014 , to the (3) 2012 Tri-State killing Spree these are all forms of domestic terrorism. The united states secret service has done its part since the year 2000 with keeping the domestic

Case Brief #2 : Foxconn V Byd, Part B

409 words - 2 pages was to increase investment in R&D of smartphones. As a result, it was imperative for Foxconn to enhance its IP management strategies. According to the case, Foxconn implemented a series of measures to prevent trade secret theft. For example, computer security was significantly tightened and filing patent applications to protect its R&D investments. However, more things should be emphasized on. First of all, Foxconn should foster a sense of