To What Extent Was Empire A Source Of Pride For People In Britain

1551 words - 7 pages

To What Extent was Empire a source of pride for people in Britain during the period you have studied so far?

By 1868 the British Empire governed 10,000,000 square miles of territory, and 400 million people came under the control of the Empire. Britain by this period had adopted the role of policing the world, and was un-matched by any country in terms of power and influence. The Empire has always been a topic of intense historical debate. Recently there has been constant debate among historians about the effects the British Empire had on Victorian and Edwardian society. Historians have debated whether Victorian and Edwardian society felt a sense of pride towards the British Empire. ...view middle of the document...

From songs like ‘Tommy Atkins your Alright’ historians can show that Empire was a source of pride for people of the time, but also part of their everyday life as it was sung about, through a popular source of entertainment. However in Frank McDonough book The British Empire 1815-1914 (1994), Penny Summerfield argues1 against the music hall being a source of pride for the society at the time. Summerfield goes on to argue how pro-conservative imperialists ‘Pushed jingoism at the working classes’2 by using the music hall. Summerfield goes further to say that an emphasis on English racial superiority began to appear widely in the music halls after 1900.3

John Mackenzie goes on to further discuss in his book Imperialism and Popular Culture4 (1986) that through forms of Victorian and Edwardian popular culture that imperialist propaganda was fashioned into these cultural forms. This is especially evident in the press and literature of the time. Both Rider Haggard and G.A Henty, were prominent imperialist writers of their time. Haggard and Henty’s protagonists were always white and held Christian values and usually of nobility. In contrast the characters they discovery in the foreign lands they adventure to, are usually uncivilised and lack the ‘The English Qualities’ which make Haggard and Henty’s characters succeed. McDonough goes on further to say how ‘Their stories glorified the use of force to achieve Britons imperialist aims.’5 While McDonugh promotes the theory that Haggard and Henty promoted jingoism6 in their books, other critics argue that both Haggard and Henty showed both sides of the coin when it came to imperialist themes. Africans are shown both in the stereotypical Victorian fashion but also as heroes and civilised people. This therefore contrasts MacDonough and Mackenzie’s view, that literature was a propaganda tool. Even though Haggard’s books are not devoid of racism, they do expresses much less prejudice than other books in this genre of the time, you could argue they express a sense of mystery, and delight towards the empire. This shows the literature could evoke a sense of pride in Victorian and Edwardian society towards the empire.

Through pieces of art done at the time it is possible to argue that art was used as a platform to promote a sense of pride towards the Empire. There is an emphasis during the later years of the 19th century for grand military paintings of epic battles, depicting the Empire up against the foreign savage enemy. Paintings such as Charles Edwin Fripp’s painting of the British defeat at the Battle of Isandlwana is able to give a sense romance to a disastrous British defeat during the Zulu War of 1879. Paintings like this and many more done around the late 19th century and early 20th century would have invoked a huge sense of pride for the Empire among the classes, especially the upper and noble classes. Portraits like Fripp’s demonstrate the British imperial qualities such as being heroic, standing up...

Other Papers Like To What Extent Was Empire a Source of Pride for People in Britain

To What Extent Was Khruschev Successful in the Destalinisation Policy

801 words - 4 pages to what extent he succeeded in his efforts. For example, although he made investments into agriculture, he was criticized for not focusing on seemingly more rewarding areas such as the military and space explorations. In terms of agriculture, although some improvement had been made, Khrushchev attempted to experiment with other grains such as maize, thus encountering a problem as many areas such as Kazakhstan had unsuitable soil. By 1963, the USSR had to import 20 million tonnes of grain from the USA and Australia.

To What Extent Was Political Faction Was the Most Important Cause of Rebellion in the Tudor Period?

2223 words - 9 pages martyrs came from. Therefore, religion was an important source of discontent and was often either a main or subsidiary cause for rebellion in England at this time. It can also be argued that economic and social problems were more significant causes of rebellion in the Tudor period, especially taxation and enclosures. For example, the rebellion of 1489 sparked a revolt in Yorkshire as people were unwilling to pay taxes to fund the war in France

To What Extent Should We Embrace the Ideological Perspective(S) Reflected in the Source?

867 words - 4 pages every one responsible for each other; but that individuals are only responsible for themselves. Supporters of individualism, like Adam Smith, see economic freedom as leading to the most efficient and beneficial economy for the greatest number of people, because it encourages competition and they assume that people generally act in their own self- interest. We must embrace the source to a great extent and view individualism as an ideology that

‘to What Extent Was Superior Military Leadership the Main Reason for the Success of the First Crusade?

997 words - 4 pages ‘To what extent was superior military leadership the main reason for the success of the First Crusade?’ In 1099 the First Crusade had succeeded their objective and captured the Holy City of Jerusalem. The use of military leadership provided by key figures including Bohemond of Taranto, Raymond of Toulouse and Adhemar of Le Puy were considered a main reason for the crusaders success. Due to the failure of the First Wave it was considered by

To What Extent Was Spain’s Financial Weakness the Main Reason for the Success of the Dutch Revolt?

1387 words - 6 pages To what extent was Spain’s financial weakness the main reason for the success of the Dutch revolt? Traditionally revolts correlated with the seasons but the Dutch Revolt resulted not from famine but from the want for religious and political freedom which Philip would not allow. Philip refused to let Protestantism survive in his territory, he envisioned himself as the last Catholic crusader in a Europe falling to the Protestant domino effect

Some People Have the View That the Events of Dunkirk in 1940 Deserve to Be Remembered as a Triumph for Britain and Its People. How Far Do These Sources Support or Contradict This Interpretation

1778 words - 8 pages as prisoner or to what happened to the 150,000 French troops. This source was a speech made by the British Prime Minister and would have been broadcasted to millions of people across Britain. Churchill knew that boosting morale plays a big part of winning a war and therefore his speech needed to be as persuasive as possible in achieving its purpose. During the war Propaganda was widely used in Britain and by not providing the negative aspects

To What Extent Is Security a Necessary Precondition for Development?

3117 words - 13 pages To what extent is security a necessary precondition for development? Introduction It is put forward that security is not necessarily a precondition for development, but rather, both concepts of security and development are inextricably linked. With neither one being predominant over the other; rather the influence of both oscillate, dependent upon the individual circumstances within the State or region. In essence, what this answer

To What Extent Was the Leader (Stalin) of One Single Party State Succesfull in Achieving His Aims?

719 words - 3 pages . It seemed that all other state enemies where eliminated as well, by the purges. A disadvantage is that the extreme purges killed a lot of citizens and workers, so that they had to stop for a while. Otherwise there had not been enough people to achieve the industrial goals.. Also the economy achieved the set aims. The focus was turned on heavy industry, four third in cole and six third in steel production were achieved and new modern machinery

To What Extent Was Does Fear of Communism Explain the Usa’s Increasing Role in Vietnam During the Years 1954-64?

1742 words - 7 pages Vietnam were dictated by what the public wanted, this need was created solely by the ‘Red Scare’, as powers such as the USSR became more militarily powerful with an increase in armed power and nuclear weapons since the end of the Korean war, another country converted to communism was another reason to fear the “Red under your bed” as media had put to the country, in a time of such changing facilities such as television, propaganda was given a national

To What Extent Were the Army Generals Responsible for the Outbreak of Civil War in 1936?

1610 words - 7 pages such as a lack of political consensus during the time of the Second Republic. This essay will consider the extent to which the different factors were responsible for the outbreak of civil war in 1936. The assassination of Calvo Sotelo, a leading monarchist who opposed the Popular Front, by the Assault Guard was responsible for General Mola ordering his instructions for the coup to go ahead that ultimately led to civil war. On 13th July 1936, in

‘Most Comedies Can Be Criticised for a Lack of Seriousness’. to What Extent Do You Believe This to Be the Case in the Play ‘Much Ado About Nothing’?

1713 words - 7 pages ‘Most comedies can be criticised for a lack of seriousness’. To what extent do you believe this to be the case in the play ‘Much Ado About Nothing’? ‘Much Ado About Nothing’ contains comedy throughout but it could be argued that seriousness is present in equal measure. They are portrayed simultaneously by Shakespeare in his play: where one scene is comedic to one part of the audience, seriousness could be interpreted by others. The writer uses

Related Essays

To What Extent Was Britain A Divided Society At The Beginning Of The Second World War?

854 words - 4 pages To what extent was Britain a divided society at the beginning of the Second World War? After the First World War came to an end, Britain, as were many other countries, was in a rather fragile state. Unemployment was as high as 70% in some areas of the country and the British Empire was fast receding. Due to factors such as these the 1930’s have been referred to as ‘The Devil’s Decade’, insinuating hardship for everyone involved. However, I

To What Extent Was There A ‘Post War Consensus’ In British Politics From 1951 To 1964?

945 words - 4 pages To what extent was there a ‘post war consensus’ in British politics from 1951 to 1964? (900 Words) Whether or not there truly was a ‘post war consensus’ in British politics from 1951 to 1964 is a highly debatable topic of which historians can often appear to be in two minds about; on one hand, Labour Prime Minister Harold Wilson infamously described the period as ‘Thirteen years wasted’, whereas historian Robert Blake (a supporter of the

To What Extent Was The Papacy Responsible For The Growing Criticism Of The Roman Catholic Church?

520 words - 3 pages translation to the church, but they rejected it as it exposed the illiteracy, and people questioned what the papacy had to say during their services. The sale of indulgences is a very important cause for criticism. It was used as one of Luther’s main arguments against the church. He believed that this was purely a money making scheme by the Pope, in order to fund the building of St. Peter’s Basilica. Indulgences promised time off purgatory for

To What Extent Was Alexander Ii A Reformist Tsar?

1259 words - 6 pages listed the trials, and it meant the Russian people stood a fairer chance in court, judged by regular Russians rather than Tsar Officials. This-much like the introduction of the Zemstva- showed Alexander II as a liberal leader, as both these and reforms in education and press did not help the Tsar in any way –but the Russian people. Alexander II was to a large extent reformist, as his reforms affected the empire which had remained the same –in a