This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

To What Extent Is Security A Necessary Precondition For Development?

3117 words - 13 pages

To what extent is security a necessary precondition for development?


It is put forward that security is not necessarily a precondition for development, but rather, both concepts of security and development are inextricably linked. With neither one being predominant over the other; rather the influence of both oscillate, dependent upon the individual circumstances within the State or region. In essence, what this answer will aim to illustrate, is the extent of this link, the theories which explain it, and whether or not security underpins development. Before we begin however, it would be prudent to first, define the concepts of ‘security’ and ‘development’.
From the ...view middle of the document...

Horizontal and Group Inequalities

According to Stewart, three links between development and security exist: First, the influence of security or insecurity on the development process itself, where the former is an objective which the latter aims to achieve[4]. Second, is when insecurity affects unconnected aspects of development and economic growth, where security is an instrument to development[5], and third, where development impacts upon security; the development instrumental role[6], and as stated earlier, will be the focus of this particular section.

This link is maintained in three processes. The first is via group motivation and horizontal inequalities. Second, is private motivation; which is a slight modification of the greed and grievance approach, and thus, will be amalgamated within the consideration of the latter, and not considered within this particular analysis. The third and final manifestation of this development instrumental link is where the ‘social contract’ has broken down between the state and its citizens. Each of these elements, it is put forward, lead to a breakdown of security, and thus conflict.

Conflicts related to group motivation arise in situations where there are two distinct groups of people; one agitating for power, and the other looking to cling on to power[7]. For example, the current situation in Syria highlights this group motivation, where the power struggle is concentrated between and divided upon, religious grounds. The Sunni majority agitating for power from what it perceives as the unjust and autocratic Alawite, Baathist minority.[8]
Horizontal inequalities refer to situations where inequalities and grievances emerge within collectives, which could then exacerbate situations and lead to conflict. These inequalities may not necessarily occur within the conflict-affected nation, but can contribute to the situation in any case. Take for example, the situation of the predominantly migrant Muslim communities of continental Europe and Britain, where much of the community faces socio-economic deprivation, political under-representation, discrimination, or an amalgamation of all three[9]. Such resentment and disparity with, and within society, can provide the conditions for conflict, which as stated earlier does not necessarily have to occur within the states where the expatriate communities find themselves in, but in other Muslim-majority states where conflict is pre-existent. Such as, British Muslim fighters in the Syrian Civil War,[10] the suicide bombing in Tel Aviv of 2003 which had been perpetrated by British Muslims of Pakistani origin,[11] and the presence of British Muslims, from a range of cultural backgrounds, within the conflict zones of Kashmir, Chechnya, and Bosnia during the 1990s.

In regards to the third link, the ‘breakdown’ of the social contract, the social contract is characterised by Luckham, as being the situation where “the state guarantees the safety of citizens; and...

Other Papers Like To What Extent Is Security a Necessary Precondition for Development?

To What Extent Is the Uk a Two Party System

772 words - 4 pages To what extent is the UK a two party system (25 marks) It is often argued that in the UK we have a two party system this is a system where two major political parties dominate politics within a government. One of the two parties typically holds a majority in the legislature and is usually referred to, as the majority party while the other is the minority party. Traditionally in the UK this is the Conservatives and the Labour party. However

The Mexican America Fence Is a Necessary Security Measure

894 words - 4 pages The Fence: A Necessary Security Measure Built in 2006 (Wikipedia), the Fence between the U.S and Mexico has raised many debates on whether it is necessary or xenophobic. In reality, the fence has greatly decreased illegal traffic, and the effectiveness of border control points has tremendously risen from 69.11% in 2006-the year the fence was built-to 83.98% in 2011 (Graham). Building a fence between the United States and Mexico is important

To What Extent Have the Millennium Development Goals Been a Success?

1771 words - 8 pages To what extent have the Millennium Development Goals been a success? by Name Presented to: Instructor Course Institution City Date Introduction The Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) provide a comprehensive framework through which the society can address pressing issues of poverty. The MDGs are made up of eight major objectives, which are all related to global development. In 2000, 189 world leaders

To What Extent Is Germany Responsible for World War I and Ii?

1164 words - 5 pages To what extent should Germany be held responsible for causing both the First and Second World Wars? It has long been argued by historians whether or not Germany is to blame for causing both the World Wars. This essay will examine to what extent was Germany responsible for causing both the First and Second world wars. On one side, it is argued that Germany’s expansionist aims brought about both the World Wars, whereas on the other side, it is

To What Extent Is Friar Laurence Responsible for the Deaths of Romeo and Juliet?

1095 words - 5 pages treats Bruno not being sensitive to his needs and feelings. That is one example on the way the chapters explain the negativity of the chapter and it works with most of the headings in the book that is what I have noticed from John Boyle also trying to get across with a couple of words gives you a brief summary of what lies ahead for Bruno and the family, it makes the reader excited. I think that is one way of narrative structure, tone

To What Extent Was Empire a Source of Pride for People in Britain

1551 words - 7 pages To What Extent was Empire a source of pride for people in Britain during the period you have studied so far? By 1868 the British Empire governed 10,000,000 square miles of territory, and 400 million people came under the control of the Empire. Britain by this period had adopted the role of policing the world, and was un-matched by any country in terms of power and influence. The Empire has always been a topic of intense historical debate

Is It Necessary To Use Animal Skin For Clothing

358 words - 2 pages Is It Necessary to Use Animal Skin for Clothing Today, the debate over animal rights is widely spread around the world. A lot more leather and fur companies found the business over making clothes from real animal skin, very beneficial for making a lot of money. Usually, those companies follows fashion and demands of famous people because they can bring the companies a lot of money. Therefore, many non famous people look up to the famous ones

To What Extent Were The Bombs Dropped On Hiroshima And Nagasaki Necessary To End World War II? Includes Bibliography And Footnotes (If You Care To Message Me For Them)

1677 words - 7 pages leading up to the dropping of the bomb. The dropping of the atomic bombs on Hiroshima and Nagasaki were not necessary to end the war, Japan had been actively looking for a way to end the war and while there was some factioning with in the powers, there are suggestions that Japan had already offered a surrender to the allies. That the Americans would except nothing less then 'Unconditional Surrender' is the reasons that they justified dropping the

To What Extent Is an E-Commerce Strategy the Best Way for Businesses to Increase Their Profits? (40 Marks)

1432 words - 6 pages To what extent is an e-commerce strategy the best way for businesses to increase their profits? (40 marks) E-commerce is the online transaction of goods and services, which has completely revolutionized business and the way in which businesses can operate. It’s now easier for customers to compare prices/products with a little time spent browsing the Internet opposed to dragging themselves to the stores. This means that e-commerce is having

To What Extent Is Inflation Damaging to the Economy? 18

1048 words - 5 pages To what extent is inflation damaging to the economy? 18 Inflation is a sustained rise in the average price level. Inflation is measured in two ways the CPI and the RPI. CPI is a measure of the price level used across the European Union and used by the bank of England for setting its inflation target which is currently at 2%, it is calculated using a weighed basket of goods. This basket contains 650 goods. 100,000 households buying patterns

What Is Computer Security?

286 words - 2 pages , conscious, knowledgeable and free decision on the part of legitimate authorities in order to make it insecure. Audit trails tracking system activity, so that when a security breach occurs, the mechanism and extent of the breach can be determined. Storing audit trails remotely, where they can only be appended to, can keep intruders from covering their tracks. Full disclosure to ensure that when bugs are found the "window of vulnerability" is kept as short as possible.

Related Essays

To What Extent Is Csr Beneficial To A Company’s Performance?

1260 words - 6 pages To what extent is CSR beneficial to a company’s performance?           The area of corporate social responsibility has been laid great emphasis recent year. Corporate social responsibility means a company concerns its business operations in an environmental-friendly way and interacts with its shareholders and customers voluntarily (Commission of the European Communities, 2001, as cited in Dahlsrud, 2008). Nowadays a large

To What Extent Is David Cameron A New Right Politician

1151 words - 5 pages To what extent is David Cameron a New Right politician. When Thatcher acted by defending the Falklands in 1982, it proved she was patriotic and willing to invest in the military, £200 million was spent on defence and harrier jump jets were introduced. The investment in the military and the defence fits into the New Right ideology as it developed those areas into a more powerful body. This came into place because Argentina's military landed on

To What Extent Is Death A Driving Force Of Hamlet

1541 words - 7 pages mother and so in this case, women are not victimised, rather they are placed on an untouchable pedestal that Hamlet must reach. Therefore, death is seen as a necessary route for Hamlet to reach the end goal, an unavoidable thing that must be done. Where Hamlet is our protagonist, death (much more than Claudius) is our antagonist in the play. Hamlet is driven by the knowledge that he too will some day perish, and this death drive is what compels

To What Extent Is Fptp A Viable Electoral System?

717 words - 3 pages To what extent is First Past the Post a viable electoral system? First Past the Post, also commonly known as FPTP, is the main majoritarian system used in the UK. It has many effects, including usually resulting in a single party government, which therefore results in a strong government. The most important effect of FPTP is the election of a stable government that can stay in power for the full term, and govern effectively while