To Be Or Not To Be

799 words - 4 pages

Hobbes versus Locke: State
of Nature and Legitimacy
By David Feinman
In the study of political theory and the analysis of
the role of the sovereign in western society,
Thomas Hobbes and John Locke are two of the most in
fluential figures. Their philosophies on the way
in which man lived before forming societies have be
en the backbone of the discussion of the state of
nature and the legitimacy of the sovereign for ma
ny centuries. Hobbes, seeing the natural world as a
nasty, brutish place of perpetual war, sees the legitim
acy of a sovereign as being
unquestioned and that of
a paternal figure that instills order in a world without
law or reason. Locke, in opposition, ...view middle of the document...


3
Inhabitants of Hobbes’ state of nature have
a “nasty, brutish, and short” life in which no
1
Hobbes, p. 70
2
Ibid.
3
Ibid.
progress, no prosperity, and no peace can be found.
4
There are no rules, chaos reigns, and there are no
definitions of what is right or wrong,
good or evil, or morally virtuous.
Locke, however, sees a very different state of nature. In
The Second Treatise of Government
, he
describes this world as “a state of perfect freedom [in
which people can] order their actions and dispose of
their possessions and persons as they think fit, within
the bounds of the law of nature, without asking
leave, or depending upon the will of any other man.”
5
This is a world of “equality...without
subordination or subjection...[and] liberty,” but this st
ate of nature has a law of nature which governs it,
as well as reason, which teaches man that “no one ought
to harm another in his life, health, liberty or
possessions.”
6
Locke’s state of nature is one of self-deter
mination, but with regulation to ensure no one’s
freedom is compromised.
These opposing views of the state of nature bring about differing opinions relating to the
legitimacy of a sovereign. Following his view of a
nasty,...

Other Papers Like To Be or Not to Be

To Be or Not to Be One of the Smart Kids

1009 words - 5 pages To Be or Not To Be One of the Smart Kids In the article, Anti-Intellectualism: Why We Hate the Smart Kids, Grant Penrod writes how society stereotypes intellectuals and how their efforts are trivialized. He states that the football players are held up on a pedestal and treated as if they are gods, that they receive all the attention. Intellectuals are on the other hand are treated as outcasts because they are smart. That they are left out of

Death is not to be Feared

593 words - 3 pages Could I possibly die tomorrow? In a week? Or do I still have many years ahead of me? These are some questions many people often ask themselves. The fear of death affects many individuals, but it certainly didn?t affect a philosopher by the name of Socrates. He argued that death is not to be feared and personally I both agree and disagree with him. Death, it surrounds us, it could be waiting for us at any corner, whether it is a car swerving

Religious Practices Not to Be Ignored

715 words - 3 pages Employers must address issues in an appropriate manner when it comes to respecting employees’ religious beliefs. We live in a diverse world that not everyone has the same religious beliefs as Muslims. That does not mean that those particular individuals need to be treated or disrespected in any way. That is why the United States Equal Employment Opportunity Commission is there to help address issues of discrimination or violation of a person’s

A Business Owner Should Not Be Able To Hire Or Fire Anyone Without Interference From The Government

802 words - 4 pages A Business Owner Should Not be Able To Hire Or Fire Anyone Without Interference From The Government Byron E. Hercules Embry-Riddle Aeronautical University   Abstract The recent economic downturn has forced many industries to change the way in which they do business in order to survive. Managers must find ways in which in to motivate their employees to overcome their employees natural resistance to change. Mangers must find ways to

What Factors Need to Be Considered When Determining Whether or Not Identified Actions Are Within the Domain of Nursing Practice

799 words - 4 pages activities to the nursing assistant. (Kathleen R. Weinberg, n.d.) According to (DL, 1994), the purpose of nursing center influenced the scope of practice in nursing in different areas. These areas are, how nursing affects the faculty, the community, or specialty in nursing practice. The nurse managed center “requires high quality nursing services, public and community support, healthy relationships with other health care providers, and documentation

See the Ball Mill Not to Be Underestimated Role

928 words - 4 pages See the Ball mill not to be underestimated role_Ivylm522so that products reach the final moisture in the vertical roller mill materials can be dried up to 12 ~ 15% water, dry milling, only drying water for 3 to 4 percent of the material within the material in the mill residence time is short, easy detection of the product particle size and chemical composition of and control, product quality is stable rotation of the blade raised material was

Should Social Network Be Banned or Not

747 words - 3 pages Ning Xi Jan.13.2011 GADVI/A Should Social Network Be Banned or Not With the social network being more and more popular among young people, some researches were conducted to find out its importance and influence to the users. For instance, a university in Pennsylvania is trying to block social network like Facebook, Twitter on the campus, which resulted in many controversy (Gonzalez, 2010). So should other universities like UD do

Should Euthanasia Be Legalised Or Not?

1212 words - 5 pages Should euthanasia be legalised or not? Euthanasia may be defined as bringing about the death of another person with that person's consent There is no straightforward answer to the question of whether euthanasia should be legalised or not. In this essay l will therefore first ofall consider the arguments against legalisation and then the reasons in favour. I shall conclude by arguing that euthanasia should be legal, but only under certain

To Drill Or Not

363 words - 2 pages To Drill or Not To Drill? by Eli Turnup While reading this article I found myself thinking of the positives that come with alternate sources of energy, and I had to take into account what be negative in going that route. What I got from the article was the idea of using alternate sources of energy to replace usage of oil in an attempt to provide an everlasting source for the future. By attempting to provide an alternate source of energy

To Immunize or Not?

1575 words - 7 pages school children. This legislation allows parents to opt out of vaccine schedules. A form is signed and is put in the student’s file stating he or she is exempt from any vaccinations. All other provinces in Canada do not have any sort of legislation. This usually leads to public health nurses coming into schools and using scare tactics on students and doctors doing the same to parents, threatening that their children will not be allowed to go to school

To Perform Cpr or Not

1518 words - 7 pages individuals is if the Glenwood Gardens policy pertaining to not giving CPR to a patient was ethical or not. The biggest argument against their policy is that many people feel that an individual should not be left to die. When put in a situation like the one at Glenwood Gardens, individuals should do everything in their power to save the person. It’s a moral obligation. If the nurse didn’t feel comfortable breaking company policy, then she should

Related Essays

To Be Or Not To Be

689 words - 3 pages spouse may cause friction between you and your new spouse because you didn’t handle it they way that your spouse would have. Usually former spouses are not happy with their new lives and they do not want their former spouse to be happy either. Therefore they do everything that they possibly can to cause unhappiness and friction between their former spouse and new spouse. Marital Happiness is very important during life. One must always make an effort for that happiness to occur whether it be through time, energy, or communication with their spouse. When it is achieved it is definitely worth all the work that was put into it.

To Be Or Not To Be

3774 words - 16 pages shadow role to a Business Advisor based in a Retail or Commercial Branch to gain portfolio management skills. Essential Requirements:  You will need to be forward-thinking, adaptable and ready to question ways of thinking but fundamentally communication and relationship-building skills are critical. We're looking for creative thinkers - people who don't always assume the obvious or accept conventional wisdom. The other essential requirements

To Be Sane Or Not To Be Sane

912 words - 4 pages To be Sane or Not to be Sane One of the biggest arguments in Hamlet is whether the main character, Hamlet, is sane or completely insane. This question is left up to the readers to digest and interpret for themselves. I believe that Hamlet was sane throughout the story and only trying to get revenge on those he believed deserved it. For my reader’s journal, I am going to focus on the reasons why I think Hamlet was completely sane, just smart

To Be Schizophrenic Or Not Schizophrenic

2403 words - 10 pages To Be Schizophrenic or Not Schizophrenic “Roses are red, violets are blue, I’m schizophrenic, and so am I.”- Oscar Levant There’s a fine line between genius and madness. In Shakespeare’s Hamlet, Prince Hamlet is bent on getting revenge on his Uncle Claudius after life altering events have occurred. Hamlet’s father was murdered by his Uncle Claudius, his mother remarried Claudius, and said uncle took Hamlet’s rightful title to