This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

This I Believe Essay

3557 words - 15 pages

Grading 'Waiting for Superman'
Dana Goldstein | September 23, 2010

Here's what you see in Waiting for Superman, the new documentary that celebrates the charter school movement while blaming teachers unions for much of what ails American education: working- and middle-class parents desperate to get their charming, healthy, well-behaved children into successful public charter schools.
Here's what you don't see: the four out of five charters that are no better, on average, than traditional neighborhood public schools (and are sometimes much worse); charter school teachers, like those at the Green Dot schools in Los Angeles, who are unionized and like it that way; and noncharter ...view middle of the document...

On September 20 The Oprah Winfrey Show featured the film's director, Davis Guggenheim, of An Inconvenient Truth. Tom Friedman of the New York Times devoted a column to praising the film. Time published an education issue coinciding with the documentary's release and is planning a conference built in part around the school reform strategies the film endorses. NBC, too, will host an education reform conference in late September; Waiting for Superman will be screened and debated there, and many of the reformers involved in its production will be there. Katie Couric of CBS Evening News has promised a series of segments based on the movie.
Meanwhile, mega-philanthropist Bill Gates, who appears in Waiting for Superman, hit the road in early September to promote the film; while he was at it, he told an audience at the Toronto International Film Festival that school districts should cut pension payments for retired teachers. Other players in the free-market school reform movement, most of whom had seen the documentary at early screenings for opinion leaders and policy-makers, anticipated its September 24 release with cautious optimism.
The media excitement around the film "is beginning to open up an overdue public conversation," says Amy Wilkins, vice president at the Washington advocacy group Education Trust. "Do I think the coverage is always elegant and superior and perfect? No. Of course there is going to be some bumbling and stumbling. But the fact that the film is provoking this conversation is really important for teachers and kids."
Indeed, a tense public sparring match over the achievement gap, unions and the future of the teaching profession is already under way. In August the Los Angeles Times defied the protests of unions and many education policy experts by publishing a searchable online database of elementary school teachers' effectiveness rankings. The newspaper's calculations were made using a new statistical method called value-added measurement, which is based on children's standardized test scores and which social scientists across the political spectrum agree is volatile and often flawed.
In Washington, Mayor Adrian Fenty lost his re-election bid in part because of black voters' skepticism toward his aggressive school reform efforts, led by lightning-rod schools chancellor Michelle Rhee, who pursued an agenda of closing troubled neighborhood schools, instituting a privately funded merit-pay program for teachers and firing teachers and principals deemed ineffective. And at the federal level, President Obama's signature education program, the Race to the Top grant competition, pressures states to implement many of the most controversial teacher reforms, including merit pay based on value-added measurement.
Yet under the radar of this polarized debate, union affiliates across the country are coming to the table to talk about effective teaching in a more meaningful way than they ever have before. These stories of cooperation, from...

Other Papers Like This I Believe Essay

This I Believe Essay

532 words - 3 pages This I Believe   After reflecting on what is important to me in my professional career, I have defined my professional values as courtesy, dependability, and challenge. Throughout my career and jobs that I have held over the years I have worked in a customer service industry a great deal. From retail, to restaurant service, to financial planning, my job structure has been based around serving and working with the public and clients. I have

This I Believe Essay

756 words - 4 pages ‘This I Believe’ I believe in the freedom of all the citizens of the U.S. It is seen as heinous to restrain and revoke the freedoms of an American because of the color of the skin. Yet it is STILL seen as righteous to deny the rights of those Americans who are "unique" in their sexual orientation. I'm here to say that gays are no different from the common American in all aspects and ought to be given equal liberties: same sex marriage

This I Believe in Music

1597 words - 7 pages THIS I BELIEVE IN MUSIC Life is full of ups and downs. Some may write to work through their challenges; others may talk to someone for support. Growing up in Indianapolis, IN, I’ve faced many of my own battles, and found ways to make the world around me seem to disappear. My escape, my support, my life revolves around music. Ever since I was a little baby, music has been in my life and in my heart. My grandmother would sing Hymnals to me

This I Believe

533 words - 3 pages and I concluded. “Man, I’m no Mikey Powell or Kyle Harrison(major league lacrosse players) I’m only me; I need to go out there and prove myself.” Turns out I was first on the waiting list so if someone opted out I was on the team; and that’s exactly what happened. With my newfound attitude I came into practices and gave it my all. I believe that you should not give up; then when the moment comes you must prove to others that you are worthy of

This I Believe - 764 words

764 words - 4 pages back to New York. While he is on the train, he remembers fond memories that he shared with his father when his family went to Cape Cod for vacation. He recollects what his father said to him, "'Remember that you and I made this journey, that we went together to a place where there was nowhere left to go."' (Lahiri, 187) This symbolizes the new life Gogol and his family will have to adapt to without having a father or husband. Because of his grief

This I Believe Memoir

1302 words - 6 pages else. Half a mile through, I began to notice that most of the girls were about fifty meters ahead of me. They all had passed me. My short legs moved as fast as they could on the last two hundred meters left of the 5k but I just couldn’t catch up. As I came closer to my final steps, my legs were so worn out, that they began to wobble like a bridge in an earthquake. I reached the finish line and collapsed to the ground. This was my first year of

Personal Code Of Ethics. "I Believe" Personal Essay

2211 words - 9 pages ...I believe Darwin...I believe in beauty...I believe we have the worst justice system in the world with the exception of every other system...I believe in Wally and the Beaver...I believe I didn't learn anything in kindergarten...I believe we are all in this together...I believe that breakfast is the most important meal of the day...I believe the ozone layer is just fine...I believe in dedication...I believe my daughter is a prodigy...I believe

I Used This Essay At My Speech Class. It Will Tell You About Tofu And Its History, Ingridents, And Health Benefits

756 words - 4 pages introductionI believe everybody want to live with healthy like. Today I like to introduce a tofu which is funny looking and sponge like white block. Tofu is perhaps the most widely consumed soyfood in the world today. It is a regular part of the diet in many asian nations and is available across the United states and in most western nations. This soft, white, almost cheese like product is favored for its versatility, mild flavor, and high

This Is An Essay For Ethics Class On What Moral Theories I Would Adopt And Follow

573 words - 3 pages yourself, and inorder to be moral you must do your duties in good will at all times in life. I believe people should always have respect for everyone at all times in their lives. In order to respect someone else though you must have self respect without that it would be imposable. Without respecting yourself and others you would not be doing your duty and could not be moral. According to the categorical imperative you must do the duties at all times

This Is A Descriptive Writing Essay Based On An Experience That I Went Through, Belmont Park

708 words - 3 pages just been made. I reached out my other hand to my little brother, and said “Come on David!” He smacks his small, gooey hand into mine as if I were saving him.We start skipping to the ticket booth. I hear a faint voice saying, “Watch out!” And then, I look down at this big curb in front of us and I know I cant jump over it with David in my hand. So I quick, let go of his hand and leap over the curb like a pro-athlete track runner

This Was A Short Essay Pertaining To The Art Of Ancient Greece. I Titled It "The Art Of Ancient Greece."

1446 words - 6 pages rather vague. Some believe that these people were more involved with myths and legends, rather than those spoke of by the poet Homer. It is during this period that the Trojan wars occurred (1200 BC). It is believed that the Mycenaean people attacked the people of Troy because of commercial reasons.The third period of Greek civilization is known as the Doric Period. This period lasted from 1000 BC to 800 BC. During this short span of time, the Dorian

Related Essays

This I Believe Essay

542 words - 3 pages This I Believe Essay June 4, 2014 Family Should Come First Most of my earliest memories do not have my biological father in them, even though he lived less than a 5 minute walk away. I grew up in what is now considered to be a "broken home" environment. Back in the seventies I lived in a trailer court with my mom and her new husband, the infamous step-dad. During this time, my ‘real' dad was moving on with his life as well

Exploratoy Essay This I Do Believe

683 words - 3 pages Running head: THIS I DO BELIEVE ASSIGNMENT 5 EXPLORATORY ESSAY: THIS I DO BELIEVE KIM CARTER ENGLISH COMPOSTION PROFESSOR JANET WILLMAN NOVEMBER 07, 2011 THIS I DO BELIEVE This I do believe Some people have many different things or beliefs that they focus on to maintain and live by during challenging times in their lives. I have established a belief that gets me through challenging times in my life. “I can do all things through

This I Believe 7 Essay

618 words - 3 pages This I Believe FYE This I Believe Essay This I Believe I believe death brings people closer. When I was in high school I always had plenty of friends to socialize with. However, out of these friends there were only some I considered to be a “true” friend. One of those friends was a boy named Tommy. He was your typical jock, he played football, baseball, basketball and even was considering joining a UFC club. He was one of the nicest

This I Believe Essay 521 Words

521 words - 3 pages Jonathan D. Dube Professor Kimberly Parker ELA 7-8 18 August 2015 This I Believe Instincts are defined as animalistic, innate responses to certain situations. Instincts are not something that humans typically employ; we are constantly stopping to think and ponder our actions. Should I eat this entire cake? Should I stay up till 2 watching Netflix so I only get 4 hours of sleep before school? Should I really wait to start my essay, which is