The Shield Project Essay

2630 words - 11 pages

Orion Shield Project Case Study

Executive Summary

Scientific Engineering Corporation (SEC) is competing for the contract of the Orion Shield Project, funded by Space Technology Industries (STI). Henry Larsen, the director of engineering at SEC has insisted on having Gary, an engineer with no previous managerial skills, be the program manager. Over the last 14 years Gary had established a reputation as a respected and talented project engineer; he has never managed a project before. Henry Larsen chose Gary to be the project manager, because he thought Gary could be easily manipulated and would not challenge Larsen’s unethical ways. This case study explores the ethical, technical, ...view middle of the document...

” For Larsen, holding information would not have been a big deal as long as they had the contract, any problems could have been fixed later.

2.) Should Gary have followed up on his ethical concerns? If so, how?

Yes, Gary should have followed up on his ethical concerns. If later was to come and Gary still could not get the project to its desired specifications the SEC would have a big complaint on their hands from the customer. This lie could cost the SEC its credibility and cost many of those involved their jobs. Furthermore, if Gary was to concede his morals this time, he would be nudged to do it again, as he would be viewed as the unethical guy that does what you need him to do. That might not be a problem for some, but when consequences arise, the fall and penalty will be harsh. Gary should voice his concern in an attempt to sway Larsen’s suggestion. If Larsen pushed harder, Gary should go above Larsen and voice his concerns to the next person in the hierarchy. If Gary doesn’t want to go to that extreme, he should just remove himself from the project entirely, and request that one of his peers take his spot.

3.) Should Gary accept the position of project manager? Explain.

No. Gary should not accept the position of project manager. If Gary is unable to achieve the desired specifications, then his reputation and job are put in jeopardy. It is unethical for Gary to lie about the outcome of his test runs, and he should voice his disapproval of the situation. Also, accepting the project manager position would result in a high risk/high reward situation. If everything goes smoothly, Gary can rocket up the “ladder of success,” not thinking twice about how he got wherever he reaches. But, if Gary is unable to achieve the desired specifications, then Gary would fall very hard. Larsen tells Gary, “I don’t know of an engineer who failed in program management and returned to his job.” Gary has a lot to think about, does he want to go from being a top talent who feels good about what he is doing, to being a failed disgrace without a contingency plan. Gary has no previous experience as a project manager! Is what he is giving up worth it??

4.) Why might a company not allow a project manager to return to his functional department?

A company might not allow a project manager to return to his functional department because it is very difficult to go backwards in a career path and be satisfied. Plus in his absence, someone new would have been hired in his functional department to take over his job. This would cause confusion in the work environment, as we all know that it is easier to promote rather than demote. When a person is hired for a job, they are expected to be there long term. If a person cannot “step up” when needed, then they are deemed as stagnate with no potential. If you can’t move up, you get moved out!

5.) What mistakes did Gary make? What did he do right?

The first mistake that Gary made was allowing himself to be...

Other Papers Like The Shield Project

Request for Proposal Essay

1575 words - 7 pages vendor’s time details needed to complete the project. Submit Proposal To: The Vice President in charge of Training and Development BLUE CROSS / BLUE SHIELD Mailing Address: 550 Club Dr. Suite #215 Montgomery, TX 77316 936.582.7120 FAX: 936.582.7130 Email: For Additional Information or Clarification, Contact Director in charge of Interactive Media Education BLUE CROSS/BLUE SHIELD

CoughCough Solutions 1 Essay

1284 words - 6 pages tax shield per year in the first 15 years is 0.35 x (65000-4674)/15 = 1408 Real cost is 10000, so nominal cost is 10000 x 1.03^15 = 15580 Similar to Q2, depreciation tax shield per year in the last 10 years is 0.35 x (15580-4188)/10 = 399 Price is currently (at date 0) $3.50, so nominal price at end of 1st year of production is 3.50 x 1.05 x 1.03 = 3.79 Nominal price per bottle at end of year 10 is 3.50 x (1.05^5) x (1.02^5) x (1.03^10

Solution to New Economy Transport

993 words - 4 pages Study Case I - New Economy Transport A&B, BMA p168-169 New Economy Transport (A) Before mentioning the assumptions made to find out the best project, it is important to point out three main assertions given in the text. First, the firm is said to be conservatively financed, and consequently the 11% nominal cost of capital is an adequate discount rate for the project. Also, the overhaul happens in period 0, and consequently the Cash Flow

Making Capital Investment Decisions

2125 words - 9 pages Topic: EROSION COST 11. A project will increase sales by $60,000 and cash expenses by $51,000. The project will cost $40,000 and be depreciated using straight-line depreciation to a zero book value over the 4-year life of the project. The company has a marginal tax rate of 35%. What is the operating cash flow of the project using the tax shield approach? a. $5,850 b. $8,650 c. $9,350 d. $9,700 e. $10,350 Answer: c Feedback: OCF

The Orion Shield

596 words - 3 pages The Orion Shield Case had many problems from the beginning. The case demonstrates that technical expertise isn’t enough to be an effective project manager. Gary was a great engineer and proficient at Research & Development (R&D), but the lack leadership skills needed to run this project effectively. There where some ethical issues that Gary didn’t handle well and he allowed Henry Larsen, the senior executive to make up his mind. Gary should

Google Inc

1172 words - 5 pages Explanation: In the net present value (NPV) method, after-tax cash flows should be used instead of pretax cash flows when taxes are a consideration. Diff: 2 Terms: capital budgeting Objective: 5 AACSB: Reflective thinking 24) In calculating the net initial investment cash flows, any increase in working capital required for the project should be included. Answer: TRUE Diff: 2 Terms: capital budgeting Objective: 5 AACSB: Analytical

Course Project 2

861 words - 4 pages cause an increase in the projects (PV) Present Value, due to the fact that, it would save on the amount of taxes and realizes tax shield. 5. Provide examples of at least one of the following as it relates to the project: (5 pts each) a. Sunk Cost b. Opportunity cost c. Erosion 6. Explain how you would conduct a scenario and sensitivity analysis of the project. What would be some project-specific risks and market

Stephenson Reacpitalization

1368 words - 6 pages land will subsequently be leased to tenant farmers. This purchase is expected to increase Stephenson’s annual pre-tax earnings by $14 million in perpetuity. Kim Weyand, the company’s new CFO, has been put in charge of the project. Kim has determined that the company’s current cost of capital is 12.5 percent. She feels that the company would be more valuable if it included debt in its capital structure, so she is evaluating whether the company

Finance 516 Week 2

551 words - 3 pages PROBLEM 14-11 BASED ON CHAPTER 14: WACC AND MODIGLIANI & MILLER EXTENSION MODELS WITH GROWTH ASSUMPTIONS Consider the entrepreneur described in Section 14.1 (and referenced in Tables 14.1–14.3). Suppose she funds the project by borrowing $750 rather than $500. a. According to MM Proposition I, what is the value of the equity? What are its cash flows if the economy is strong? What are its cash flows if the economy is weak? Equity=1000-750

Fin516 Week 2

532 words - 3 pages Problem 14-11 Based on Chapter 14: WACC and Modigiani & Miller Extension Models With Growth Assumptions Consider the entrepreneur described in Section 14.1 (and referenced in Tables 14.1–14.3). Suppose she funds the project by borrowing $750 rather than $500. a. According to MM Proposition I, what is the value of the equity? What are its cash flows if the economy is strong? What are its cash flows if the economy is weak? E

Road King

1697 words - 7 pages efficient vehicles. I have prepared the cost benefit analysis based on the projected financial data provided by various departments within the Company. I have considered the initial investment requirement, annual income and operating cost and financing cost of the project for the purpose of giving my recommendations. I am of the opinion that the project of manufacture of “The Transit Bus” will increase the overall net present value of the company

Related Essays

Orion Shield Project Case Study

1839 words - 8 pages Project Management Orion Shield Project Case Study Helen Turner UMUC Executive Summary: The basic concepts of project management calls for proper planning, organization and the management of a variety of resources in order to successfully achieve a certain goal. The most important job of a project management is to deliver results within time constraints as well as according to a budget

Sampa Video Essay

1740 words - 7 pages Adjusted Present Value (APV) Approach • APV = PV of asset flows + PV of side effects associated with the financing program. EBIT (1 − t ) tk D D VL = + = Vu + tD k su kD Adjusted Present Value (APV) Approach • 1. Calculate PV of project (or enterprise) assuming it is all equity financed (i.e. no interest expense) • 2. Calculate value of tax shield. Compare tax payments with vs. without debt. The difference equals the tax savings available

United Metal Essay

587 words - 3 pages have to make the extension in Year 3. If we “Make” we will make the extension in Year 4. The difference in timing has an impact on the NPV of the project. 7. Other • Additional machine (sensor) capex and depreciation tax shield in case we go for buy option. • Existing machine depreciation tax shield in case of make (since the capex was done a year ago and it is a sunk cost, ignore it). 8. Issues and Alternatives • Quality and Delivery

Heat Transfer Project Essay

1167 words - 5 pages Introduction/Background The purpose of this project was to perform a radiation analysis of a storage tank of liquefied methane and its distribution. The net radiative transfer to the liquid without a radiation shield was found and compared to the radiative transfer with a shield to understand the effects of the shield. The calculated flow rate for each case was then compared to the boil-off gas compressor requirement of .2% full tank capacity