The Right To A Child Is An Absolute Right. Discuss

554 words - 3 pages

The right to a child is an absolute right. Discuss. (10 marks) – Madeleine Pengelly

Originally rights were seen to come from God, being made by God and being scared gives us rights. Some still hold this view while others now believe our rights com from nature simply because we are human and therefore have a higher intrinsic value than other creatures. However, others argue that our rights come from duties or responsibilities that we gave towards others. The right to a child is certainly not seen as an absolute right when applying to all ethical theories, each either believe it is a natural gift or will weigh up the situation and decide depending on the consequences making it a relative decision and right.
Followers of natural law would tend to focus of the ‘sanctity of life’ that is the ...view middle of the document...

However, it could be argued that the doctrine of double effect could counter the argument seeing the destruction of embryos as an unintended consequence of IVF. Overall, however, Natural Law would reject any means of a right to a child disagreeing with the idea that it is an absolute right.
However, followers of utilitarianism would weigh up the pleasures and pain of those involved and decide based on the situation and the consequences. They would consider the greatest pleasure for the greatest amount of people involved, possibly concluding that the amount of funding required by IVF would be better spent in life saving operations as it would support and benefit more people. Preference Utilitarianism would consider that no one’s happiness is more important than another is, so the happiness of a couple is considered. However, unlike natural law does not protect the status of the embryo or see it as sacred in any way as they don’t agree in the sanctity of life from conception.
Conversely, Kantian followers demand through the categorical imperative that people are treated as ends not means therefore ruling out the possibility of other people involved in actions such as IVF, sperm donors and surrogates. They believe that all humans should have the same moral treatment but see that there is a danger of treating the human life such as an embryo as another consumer good. The categorical imperative of universalisation would question whether it was possible to offer IVF to every infertile couple and if not arguably refuse it.
Overall, the right to a child is certainly not viewed as an absolute right but one that is either absolutely wrong as in the majority of cases of strong natural law followers and followers of Kantian ethics, or completely relative to the situation and the consequences of those involved in the case of utilitarianism.

Other Papers Like The Right to a Child Is an Absolute Right. Discuss

Education Is a Right Essay

630 words - 3 pages Is education a right or a privilege? In my own perspective, Education should be treated as a right of every person. Every person has the right to know everything he needs to know. But as seen in today’s context, it seems that Education is becoming a privilege of certain students especially those that have the resources to be able to stay at school. It is no doubt that Education plays a very important role in every person’s life. That is why

Is It A Right? Essay

1286 words - 6 pages USSR, a communist nation itself, had an obligation to stop anything that poses a threat to established communism in any country. This came to be known as the “Brezhnev Doctrine”, and was seen as a clear warning to other eastern European countries. This example is one of many in history that has raised the issue of whether or not great nations are justified in exerting influence over the affairs of lesser states. The issue of whether or not great

What Is the Right Things to Do?

1039 words - 5 pages based on what their society believes are the right standards, are thought to be the ones that determine natural justice. Natural justice is known to be right or wrong. There were many examples specified in Michael Sandel's Harvard video but he discusses more on the following topics. First, given an abstract choice between the death of 1 person and the deaths of 5 people, almost everyone will choose the 1 person. However, given a

The Price Is Right

1151 words - 5 pages with a larger pool for organ donation. Many proposals have arisen to increase the number of organ donors in the United States, ranging from presumed consent to financial incentives for organ donation. The latter, financial incentives, is a common suggestion drawing much controversy. While some assert that financial incentives could save lives, others argue that paying for organs will erode altruism and will cause an ethical collapse in organ

The Right Age To Have A Beer

1537 words - 7 pages get home, and at 18 your considered an adult and gain the right to vote, so why wouldn’t you be able to have a beer. Many arguments that are for the drinking age of 21 state that one of the main reasons why the drinking age hasn’t lowered is because they don’t want more teenagers being able to get alcohol and abuse it. I argue this point because already, even with the drinking age at 21, 80% of teens in high school admit they have drank alcohol

The Right To Choose

2156 words - 9 pages the abuse is wrong and not their fault. A child has not yet fully developed the true sense of the meaning of life. She has not been allowed to fully develop both in the physical or mental state. If the child has become pregnant form the abuse is right for her to have an abortion? Pro-Lifers believe that for no reason a person should abort. However does it make sense to put a young woman life in this position?. As I read “Prenatal tests

The Right to Abort

1140 words - 5 pages child can cause other medical issues including emotional, mental and psychological damage. In these instances, abortion may be the best recourse so that a pregnancy that was conceived from an unwanted sexual encounter is not carried to term. The emotional, physical, mental damage done can be irreparable which oftentimes leads to therapy. Even in the states that typically require parental consent for minors to obtain an abortion are willing to

The Right to Die

1266 words - 6 pages Amanda Rougeaux English 2 Professor Campos 1/14/2016 The Right to Die Everyone has the right to control the healthcare they receive, completely and totally. Now, if this statement were really true, should that not also include ones right to choose death over terminal suffering? Although human euthanasia is a tender subject for many people, an assisted dying law would not result in more deaths but is an economically beneficial practice

The Right to Speak

1153 words - 5 pages This essay is based on Patsy Rodenburgs’s book The Right to Speak. In this essay I will describe and compare a natural voice and a habitual voice. The psychological and physiological factors that inhibit our natural voice will be also described and explained. A definition of ‘hegemony’ will be given and a deeper understanding of things that can affect the way we speak because of our different genders or race will also be discussed ,examples will

The Right to Die

732 words - 3 pages The Right to Die December 23, 2012 The Right to Die Imagine for a minute this scenario: For the last 3 years your Mother’s health has been deteriorating from an incurable disease. She has been in and out of the hospital with no improvement and is now unable to eat, has lost

The Right to Die

1886 words - 8 pages debate about legalizing assisted suicide or euthanasia is certainly hotly contested. Although there is no easy solution to such an issue, we must remember many other issues suffer from this problem too. Those who oppose legalizing such a right often point to problems that may occur or use religion in their argument, and neither argument appears strong enough to hold up against the reasons given by those who support such a right. Those who support

Related Essays

Explain The Issues To The Claim To The Right Of A Child. 25 Marks

1087 words - 5 pages . Rights are then simply a result of being human; this has an impact on every part of society. This raises many issues in today’s society. The main question surrounding fertility treatment is “Is having a child by artificial means playing God?” Fertility treatment raises a few ethical issues, such as: “Who has the right to fertility treatment?” “When does life begin?” and “Do homosexual couples and single women have the right to fertility treatment

Bothparents Should Assume Equal Right For Raising A Child

987 words - 4 pages who can operate as an independent individual in the adult world. Dominance is not the fundamental of a relationship; love is. If either companion cannot express themselves there is no love, openness is what makes a lasting family. There is no specific role expected from the two but you're supposed to be born into a family that has a mother and a father. In an article I read the young boy’s mother divorced his father because he was a drug abuser

Debate Topic – Couples Wishing To Undergo Ivf Treatment Should Be Awarded The Legal Right To Choose The Sex Of Their Child

5118 words - 21 pages as appearance, height and intelligence etc, blurring the line of what is right and what is good. Sex selection based on parental preference leading to designer babies creates an environment where having a child becomes more a shopping experience rather than a natural spiritual process of new life. Justice as a principle is referred to as the obligation to be fair to all people, including the fair distribution of medical resources and equal

The Right To Food Is The Right Of Every Person

1178 words - 5 pages The right to food is the right of every person. Every individual must have regular access to sufficient, nutritionally adequate and culturally acceptable food for an active and healthy life. At present, this is a major development in-challenge in India. We cannot feel proud of our achievements in different areas until this basic need of each individual is met. About 21 per cent of the population was undernourished in 1997. In 1999, over 53 per