The Policy Process Part Ii Essay

1829 words - 8 pages

The Policy Process: Part II
March 18, 2013
Jay Cutspec

Any significant policy amendment or introduction of new legislation in the United States is always fraught with the perils of partisan politics. Health care policy is a particularly divisive issue, one which seems to summon a lot of passion on both sides. President Barack Obama’s Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (PPACA), which, combined with the Health Care and Education Reconciliation act (HCERA), formed the Health Care Reform Act of 2010, is a perfect example of how difficult it is in America to push through health care legislation. Together, Obama’s reforms were directed at solving many ...view middle of the document...

Cockrel explains:
After a new policy is implemented, advocates, opponents, or “interested parties” begin to consider the consequences of the decision and its implementation. At this point, the final stage of the policymaking process has begun. Either through formal means such as data analysis or through informal means such as citizen reaction, evaluating a policy reveals its success, failure, or the need for modification. If a problem is observed in a particular policy, the “stages” begin again. (IP-19)

On the surface, as Theodoulou and Kofinis (2004) explain, the evaluation stage seems straightforward: it simply seeks to identify whether or not public policy has, or has not, achieved its objective(s). However, the process is just as divisive and acrimonious as any other phase of policymaking. As Theodoulou and Kofinis (2004) contend, the evaluation process is not free from the intervention of “political interest groups” and “policy actors” (Political Science 490).
The PPACA, while extremely relevant to American politics, is perhaps a poor choice for analyzing the evaluative process of health care policy, because of its timeline: introduced in March of 2010, its implementation ends in 2018, with the establishment of a high-cost plan excise tax (“Affordable Care Act Implementation Timeline”). However, it may be possible to focus on one aspect of the PPACA, and discuss its possible trajectory through the evaluation, analysis, and revision stages.
Essentially, the process moves through stages, as outlined by Birkland (2011): issue emergence, agenda setting, alternative selection, enactment, implementation and evaluation. The main point, however, of Birkland’s scheme is that the process is a feedback loop: the policy is evaluated, and the “results of evaluation provide feedback to the process, where it begins anew” (with issue emergence) (p. 26). Therefore, the process is blurred. As Birkland (2011) emphasizes, “one cannot separate the implementation of a policy from its evaluation, because evaluation happens continuously as a policy is implemented” (p. 26). This is very apparent with the PPACA, which, as mentioned, is politically divisive; therefore, as the policy is implemented, it is expected that legal assaults may be launched as to its constitutionality – and against other aspects of its provisions.

One main issue with the PPACA that imperils its proper implementation is its constitutionality – in particular, its provision for mandatory insurance coverage has been claimed as unconstitutional, violating the Commerce Clause. The provision that is under fire is minimum coverage, sometimes known as “individual mandate.” Basically this provision simply acts upon Obama’s goal of universal health care. Individuals must be covered either individually or through their employer, or pay a fine. Remaining uninsured is not a crime; the fine merely deters healthy people...

Other Papers Like The Policy Process Part Ii

‘Because Professional Personnel in Construction and Real Estate Industries Are Key Actors in the Process of Converting Sales Leads Into Purchases, Specific Training in Sales, Pr and Advertising...

3084 words - 13 pages ‘Because professional personnel in construction and real estate industries are key actors in the process of converting sales leads into purchases, specific training in sales, PR and advertising technique should be part of their professional training’ Debate this statement illustrating your answer with examples from your own experience. You may elect to discuss either the construction or real estate industry for your examples. The

In Part Ii Of The Assignment (Due Week 4), You Will Write A Paper To Synthesize Your Ideas

978 words - 4 pages Minimum Legal Drinking Age Debate Name University Affiliation Date There are many topics where people have different opinions whereby they either agree or disagree. An example of these topics is should the drinking age be lowered from 21 to a younger age. All states in the United States have their minimum drinking age stated as 21 although there are some exceptions in some states based on consumption at home, medical

The Duty of Loyalty: Whistleblowing

660 words - 3 pages following? I. organization of unions II. passage of Sarbanes Oxley Act III. raising of public policy issues IV. promise of implied-contract or covenant-of-good-faith a. I only b. II only c. I and II d. I, II, III, IV ANSWER: D 4. In the essay, Work Matters, by law professor Marion Crain, all of the following are the result of working except: a. People become self-sufficient. b. People become more engaged in the democratic process

Itt It255 Unit 4 Aup

1345 words - 6 pages with respect to their responsibilities associated with computer resource use. This Acceptable Use Policy contains four policy directives. Part I – Acceptable Use Management, Part II – Ownership, Part III – Acceptable Use, and Part IV – Incidental Use. Together, these directives form the foundation of the Richman Investments Acceptable Use Program. Section 2 – Roles & Responsibilities 1. Richman Investments management will establish

Growth Policies of Bangladesh

1340 words - 6 pages , averaging 7.1 percent in China, 8.6 percent in India, and 9.2 percent in Pakistan. Policy Stances: Monetary vs. Fiscal As an integral part of the national macroeconomic stabilization policy, monetary and fiscal policies are designed to fine-tune the fluctuations of the economy—in particular, fluctuations in economic growth, inflation and unemployment rates. In line with the national macroeconomic policy framework, the monetary policy is

Whistle Blower Policy

2121 words - 9 pages Blower to the designated personnel under this policy. g. “Unethical practice” means and includes, but not limited to, the following suspected activities/ improper practices being followed in the Company: i. Manipulation of Company data / records; ii. Abuse of authority at any defined level in the Company; iii. Disclosure of confidential / proprietary information to unauthorized personnel; iv. Any violation of applicable legal law and

Policy Analysis 2

606 words - 3 pages Policy Analysis II Lotina Kelley University of Phoenix CJA 464 Dec 3 2014 Theresa Cruz Policy Analysis II Police and corrections are two important components of the criminal justice system. They are involved in the public policy on a daily basis. Team “A” chose to research police and correction policies and describe how these policies affect the operations and decision-making process. According to Welsh and Harris, policies are

Consumer Bahavior

2659 words - 11 pages 1. ABSTRACT Consumer behavior refers to a discipline dealing with how and why consumers purchase (or do not purchase) goods and services (Schiffman, 2011). I did the qualitative analysis for this research. This report expounds an interview of two consumers who purchased 5D Mark II recently, and sorts the answers into five decision-making process steps (Problem recognition; search for information; evaluation of alternatives; outlet selection and

Case 10: Anti-Nepotism

2503 words - 11 pages intends to hold onto its rights to enforce the no-relative policy as contained in the manual since it has full rights to do so. The no-relative policy has been in effect since before Mr. Walters applied for the job and was hired, so it pertains to his employment. The company also argues that the anti-nepotism policy has been around since before World War II, so it is not a policy written specifically for Manatee or a “new” policy. It has

Is4550 Week 5 Lab

1642 words - 7 pages ------------------------------------------------- Week 5 Laboratory: Part 1 Part 1: Assess and Audit an Existing IT Security Policy Framework Definition Learning Objectives and Outcomes Upon completing this lab, students will be able to complete the following tasks: * Identify risks, threats, and vulnerabilities in the 7 domains of a typical IT infrastructure * Review existing IT security policies as part of a policy framework

Audit Program Design

923 words - 4 pages prior year to ensure that the data matches up ii. Determine if there are any risks 3. Ship goods and record revenue and costs a. Tests of controls i. Obtain shipping records ii. Obtain revenue records for shipping iii. Obtain records for costs associated with the shipping process b. Substantive tests of transactions i. Sample the shipping records to ensure correct recording ii. Sample the revenue records to

Related Essays

The Policy Making Process Essay

1914 words - 8 pages process going to create an infrastructure to accommodate the needs of a not only an expanding, but also a largely socially diverse population? There are going to be strings pulled in so many directions, that the policy making process is going to have a very difficult time efficiently making decisions to deal with pressing problems. And, the scary part about all this, is the fact that the policy making process is basically a game.   &nbsp

The Policy Process Essay

1005 words - 5 pages The Policy Process Part 2 Lateisha Bellmon University of Phoenix 455 Susan Brown October 21, 2013 The Policy Process Part 2 Introduction  Managers’ role and responsibility in implementing change in the department             Modification management, in any organization, is the role of management and administrators. In modification management, managers and administrative must manage modification with in a manner that workers can

The Policy Process: Formulation, Legislation And Implementation

1159 words - 5 pages The Policy Process: Formulation, Legislation and Implementation HCS/455 24 November, 2014 The Policy Process: Formulation, Legislation and Implementation In order to first start a policy process, the problem for which a policy is to be created must be identified and the policy holding a solution to the problem. Researchers and stakeholders will investigate the problem to identify if the policy will reach the policy making

Policy Process The Affordable Care Act

1832 words - 8 pages Policy Process: The Affordable Care Act Dinah Riveron HCS/455 May 18, 2015 John Cutspec Policy Process: The Affordable Care Act The Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act signed by President Obama on March 23, 2010 as the means to enforce Health Insurance reform. Its main object is to make Health Insurance and Preventive care accessible and affordable to the American population. The Affordable Care Act The ACA major components