The Morality Of Incest: A Catholic And Secular Comparison

1301 words - 6 pages

“We can’t allow gays to marry! What would be next? Incest?” Opponents of gay marriage frequently cite a common philosophical fallacy known as the "slippery slope", to relate same-sex unions to incestuous relations. According to the Purdue University writing center, a slippery slope is defined as “a conclusion based on the premise that if A happens, then eventually through a series of small steps, through B, C,..., X, Y, Z will happen, too, basically equating A and Z” (“Logical Fallacies”). However, we often ignore the true moral implications of these “next level” immoralities we would slip into. Incest, in nearly all modern cultures and faiths, is considered wrong, including the Catholic ...view middle of the document...

Incest is denoted as a “grave sin” by the Catholic Church; St. Paul is quoted in the official Catechism as saying, "it is actually reported that there is immorality among you . . . for a man is living with his father's wife. . . . In the name of the Lord Jesus . . . you are to deliver this man to Satan for the destruction of the flesh. . . . " Later in the same portion of the Catechism states, “incest corrupts family relationships and marks a regression toward animality” (“Catechism of the Catholic Church: 2388”). Incest can be seen as corrupting family relationships because it defies the four kinds of love believed in by many Christians. Whereas loving a spouse would fall under the category of Eros love, that is a physical, romantic attraction, loving a relative would fall under the category of Storge love, an affectionate, loyal bond (Lewis). Incest, by definition, corrupts these loves by tainting one with the other, combining two separate relationships that are believed entirely separate. Arguments against incest often cite the fact that healthy familial relations can never be romantic due to the separate kind of love and loyalty one feels towards family members compared to non-related individuals. In essence, we trust our relatives to be there for us and love us as family–a completely platonic love.
Additionally, Catholics believe that sex before marriage is wrong, but it would be against Church teachings to ever marry incestuous couples, because according to the Catechism, the purpose of “the matrimonial covenant, by which a man and a woman establish between themselves a partnership of the whole of life, is by its nature ordered toward the good of the spouses and the procreation and education of offspring” (“Catechism of the Catholic Church: 1601”). Since it has already been established that the union between two relatives should not result in children due to birth defects, an incestuous marriage would not adhere to the definition of Catholic marriage. Therefore, incestuous relations are wrong on the level that the Church deems gay marriage as wrong. Thus, the combination of familial corruption and the impossibility of a holy matrimonial covenant between relatives are the core arguments of the Catholic Church’s view on incest.
Not many people disagree with the stance of the Catholic Church on this topic, for varied and numerous reasons. However, when approached from a certain secular standpoint, incest can be justified as a moral action. The secular core of the incest dispute looks to science to explain why the mention of any form of incest frequently receives a “yuck!” response. Psychologist Jonathan Haidt is credited with creating the most famous incest-centered moral scenario (as well as being referenced in this class’ first seminar on moral instinct). Haidt’s scenario tells of Julie and Mark, a brother and sister who decide to have sex. The scenario assures that there is no chance of pregnancy and recounts Julie and Mark thinking...

Other Papers Like The Morality Of Incest: A Catholic And Secular Comparison

The Meaning of "Catholic" Essay

570 words - 3 pages On Earth today, stewardship is demonstrated in many situations. Each and every human being performs daily acts that express their responsibility to be a good steward for the sake of God. Some people do not recognize their duty to try to do good in the world, so they blindly go through life with out the joy and satisfaction of assisting others. If you're looking to better yourself and follow Gods plan of having us as stewards of one of his most

The Religious and Secular Arguments Surrounding Prevention and Termination of Pregnancy

1062 words - 5 pages procreative or unitive so again this argument for contraception is dismissed by the Catholic Church. Non-religious and religious groups both support contraception for a number of good reasons one of the arguments they use in favor of contraception is that in the USA, about 56 percent of women between 16 to 45 years old practice birth control. When birth control is not used about 85/86 percent of sexually active parents experience a pregnancy

Tolkien's Lord of the Rings as a Catholic Epic

3984 words - 16 pages Tolkien's Lord of the Rings as a Catholic Epic It will be the contention of this paper that much of Tolkien's unique vision was directly shaped by recurring images in the Catholic culture which shaped JRRT, and which are not shared by non-Catholics generally. The expression of these images in Lord of the Rings will then concern us. To begin with, it must be remembered that Catholic culture and Catholic faith, while mutually supportive

The Internet and Business, a Comparison of Asos and Topshop

3822 words - 16 pages evaluation of two online fashion store websites; Asos and Topshop. While Asos exists exclusively online, Topshop's website is an expansion of the high street business. They both have a similar target audience, and the same aim of providing customers with fashionable clothes they want. However, do the strengths of both companies lie in different aspects. With the increasing importance of online activity such as marketing and sales, it is

Evolution of The Catholic Church

1381 words - 6 pages Evolution of The Catholic Church Over the last thirty years, the Roman Catholic Church has undergone changes. These changes range from the position of the Alter to the language of the Mass. This paper will illustrate a broad overview of changes in the Catholic Church after the 1960s Before the 1960s, Mass was said in Latin. The priests and the parish both knew the prayers, songs, and Scriptures in Latin. Around 1965, the

Comparison of Oedipus Rex and a Raisin in the Sun

1883 words - 8 pages sacrifices. Sometimes even of their near and dear ones, as the sacrifice of a child, made by the Greeks at the outset of the Trojan war, for favorable winds. It was a period when the oracle of Delphi held sway. Even Alexander the great no less, visited Delphi and had the oracle predict his conquering of the world. Oedipus Rex (King Oedipus) brings out the worst fate any society can think of, as it deals with the societal taboo of incest. So

A Comparison of the Christian and Ancient Greek Cultures

1722 words - 7 pages A Comparison of the Christian and Ancient Greek Cultures Most Christians (or those religions that follow the basic principles of the Bible) believe in the stories told in the Bible. In fact, these stories are usually regarded not only as mere stories, but also as actual historical accounts of important people, events, and concepts of the Christian faith. However, stories of Greek and Roman mythology are typically regarded as nothing

The Science of Morality

2029 words - 9 pages of the earth are just a few revelations made using objective evidence. With this, science has been able to defeat religion in the many ways we perceive the world. It has rendered religion useless as a source of truth. The one thing left untouched is morality. It is often believed and agreed upon that science cannot answer questions about morality. It is argued by many that science is based on facts and morality is based on values, therefore

The Morality Of Abortions

2786 words - 12 pages The Morality of Abortions Abortion’s legalization through Supreme Court’s Roe v. Wade, has allowed for one in three pregnancies to end in abortion. This means that 1.5 million abortions are performed in the United States each year (Flanders 3). It ranks among the most complex and controversial issues, arousing heated legal, political, and ethical debates. The modern debate over abortion is a conflict of competing moral ideas and of

The Morality of Capitalism

2718 words - 11 pages Thesis Capitalism has been the subject of ethical criticism since it was first introduced into society. I defend the morality of capitalism because it gives people incentive to work, establishes a web of trust between them, satisfies their material well-being, and generates a wide spectrum of prosperity. Exposition As citizens of the United States, we are members of the leading capitalist economy in the world. Our production and

The Effect Of Morality And Justice On Law

1164 words - 5 pages The Effect of Morality and Justice on Law Over the years, the legal personnel of the English Legal System have tried to separate law from morality and justice. This has proven to be quite a hard task considering the fact that even the House of Lords judges allow their morals to influence their decisions on certain cases. I think it is difficult to separate morality from law because most of the laws in Britain are

Related Essays

Abortion Legality, Morality And The Catholic Church. This Paper Discusses The Legal And Moral Issues Surrounding Aborion, Also The Veiw Of The Catholic Church

1467 words - 6 pages impermissible. While this decision made an attempt at establishing a legal precedent, from a moral and religious standpoint, it is wrong. Upon the moment of conception, the human embryo is a person; and as a result, ensoulment of the fetus occurs simultaneously, making its abortion an act at odds with moral rectitude, and a sin within the teachings of the Catholic Church.In accordance with the 1973 decision, \"the Court believed that the State

Modern Russia Is In Search Of A Secular Model Of Relationships Between Religions And The State

962 words - 4 pages Article 14, Section 1 establishes the basic principles of the modern Russian statehood, especially concerning religious associations. Article 14, Section 1 provides that “the Russian Federation shall be a secular state. No religion may be instituted as state-sponsored or mandatory religion”. Article 14, Section 2 provides that “religious associations shall be separated from the state, and shall be equal before the law”. These two provisions are

A Look At The Prevalence Of The Catholic Religion In Spain, Catholic Saint Blessed Jose Maria Escriva, And The Controversial Catholic 'cult' Of Opus Dei. 1400 Words

1427 words - 6 pages would even see it in the special pastries of Santiago de Compostela, which bear little crosses on the dough. Most of all, the Catholic religion is apparent in the very lives of the Spanish - their celebrations and their daily habits of life, a morality and style of reverence that recalls the days when the Catholic Church enjoyed its greatest popularity.Blessed Josemaria EscrivaJosemaria Escriva de Balaguer was born in Barbastro in 1902, in

Assess The Arguments And Evidence For The View That Britain Is Becoming A Secular Society

1001 words - 5 pages Assess the arguments and evidence for the view that Britain is becoming a secular society Sociologists argue that in Britain, there has been an overall steady decline in the importance of religion since the 19th century, which has led some sociologists to suggest there was a ‘golden age’ of religiosity. Many sociologists have proposed explanations for the secularisation thesis, for example Weber, Berger and Bruce. However Postmodernists