This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Margreiter V. New Hotel Monteleone

533 words - 3 pages

1. During an appeal, the appeals court is required to rely on the evidence submitted during the trial. The "record," which is made by both parties during the trial, including all objections and other submissions of evidence, is binding on the appeals court, unless it was erroneous or not reasonable to believe or accept that evidence. Further, decisions of fact and credibility are typically left to the jury to make, and appeals courts prefer not revisiting those decisions (unless they are beyond the weight of the evidence or defy credulity.) Because the jury can weigh the body language of the witnesses during trial, and the record on appeal can't show that, appeal courts prefer allowing juries to make "fact-finding" ...view middle of the document...

Now review the Nordmann case. The Margreiter court used this case to assist it with making its decision (see line two of paragraph #4 of the Margreiter opinion.) What did the Nordmann court say was the "duty of care" a hotel owes to a guest to protect him from injury by third persons? Provide that here. Then, review the facts that the Nordmann court relied on to determine there had been a breach of the duty by the Nordmann court. Briefly recite those here as well. (Points : 10)

3. Notice that the Margreiter court doesn't state which duty it imposed on the hotel – it simply recites as "precedent" the Nordmann case for its legal basis. Now that you know the duty of care that the Margreiter court used in its decision, briefly compare the two sets of facts from the two cases. Then answer these questions:
a) Do you feel that the Margreiter case had as strong facts as did the Nordmann case for holding the hotel liable? Why or why not?

b) Which facts do you feel most strongly weigh in favor of the court's decision in the Margreiter case?

c) Which facts do you feel were a stretch by the court in Margreiter?

d) Which case do you feel was more of a "slam-dunk" case to decide and why?

4. Do you agree with the decisions by the Nordmann and Margreiter courts? Do you feel that the decisions were ethical in nature? Why or why not? Use one of your ethical dilemma resolution models to analyze the court's decision of one of the two cases to help support your answer and include that analysis in your answer (i.e., Laura Nash, front page of the newspaper, Blanchard & Peale, Wall Street Journal). Make sure to set out the steps of the model and apply your reasoning and facts to the model in your answer. (Points : 10)

Other Papers Like The Margreiter V. New Hotel Monteleone

Negligence Essay

870 words - 4 pages The five elements of negligence that apply to the case of Mr. Margrieter V. New Hotel Monteleone, Inc are Duty, breach, cause in effect, proximal cause and harm (damage suffered as a proximal result of the defendant’s breach of duty). Duty refers to an obligation one has to another party. If duty “constrains and channels behavior in a socially responsible way” (Owen, 2007), then the Hotel Menteloene has a duty to take reasonable

Negligence Essay

870 words - 4 pages . Without evidence, cause in fact and proximal cause are hard to prove. Owen, D. (2007). The Five elements of negligence. Hoefstra Law Review, 35(4). Retrieved from http://law.hofstra.edu/pdf/Academics/Journals/LawReview/lrv_issues_v35n04_i01.pdf. United States Court of Appeals, 5th District (1981). Douglas T. MARGREITER, Plaintiff- Appellee, NEW HOTEL MONTELEONE, INC. and Liberty Mutual Insurance Company, Defendants-Appellants. No. 79-3149. Retrieved from http://openjurist.org/640/f2d/508/margreiter-v-new-hotel-monteleone-inc.

Comparison

2212 words - 9 pages formerly as apartel for long staying guests regardless for what ever their nationality. When the owner Mr. Eduardo V. Diaz plan to convert it to become one of the Hotel and Restaurant in Dasmarinas, due to there is no hotel in town in Dasmarinas. They name it the KALIPAYAN RESORT INC. arrived from the Visayan words means Happiness. Kalipayan Hotel & Resort Inc., is located 29 kilometers South of Manila in the heart of Dasmarinas, Cavite

Tax Research Case

1278 words - 6 pages hotel building or purchase of the replacement furniture and furnshings? Authorities Issue 1 IRC Sec. 1033(a)(2)(A) IRC Sec. 1231(a)(3)(A)(ii) Rev. Rul. 64-237, 1964-2 CB 319. Issue 2 IRC Sec. 1033(a)(2)(A), (B), (g)(4) Reg. Sec. 1.1033(a)-2(c) Massillon-Cleveland-Akron Sign Company v. Commissioner, 15 T.C. 79 (1950). Rev. Rul. 70-501, 1970-2 CB 163. Conclusion 1. In applying the “functional test” the undeveloped beach property

Marketing Plan

3601 words - 15 pages and supply for hotel rooms. After we evaluated the customer quality, satisfaction level and perceived value as well as internal marketing, we finally developed a new marketing strategy for Coogee Sands Hotel & Apartment which we think will fit Coogee Sands Hotel & Apartment’s structure better. We also came up with the budgets plan, Implementation timeline, as well as the evaluation and control plan. We found that Coogee Sands Hotel

Makati Palace Narrative Report Sample

2105 words - 9 pages for days or so, that makes it an eye sore and unpleasing to the guest. And due to lack of qualified personnel or less trained staff the hotel work gets over delayed and customers receive unsatisfactory service, which create a bad impression about the hotel in the guests’ mind. And once the guest leaves the hotel after unsatisfactory service, the guest doesn’t come back. 1.10.3 Opportunities New services will help One Greenbelt Hotel to

Davenport Hotel

653 words - 3 pages was always surrounded by its visitors’ sympathy because this architectural piece is a true miracle. Anyone who had visited the hotel would agree that this building is a perfect example of a building harmoniously combining new and old together. No matter from what site the building is being observed, it always impresses with beauty, royalty and harmony presented in every part of the hotel. No one passing by could resist going inside and

Something

316 words - 2 pages , pedestrians are not allowed to cross at street level. Instead, the MGM Grand is linked by overhead pedestrian bridges to its neighboring casinos: to the south across Tropicana Avenue, the Tropicana, and to the west across the Strip, New York-New York. Abraj Kudai hotel and MGM Grand hotel are great hotels in the world. I think when Abraj Kudai hotel has built; there will be a lot of tourists are attracted to come to Mecca. Will you want to go there?

Issues Of Guanxi Neglect Management Essay

306 words - 2 pages This proposal addresses the issues of guanxi neglect at Chinese based hotel Roaring Dragon Hotel (RDH), a state owned enterprise that was taken over by an International management called Hotel International (HI) to arrest the declining resources of the RDH and how the employees faced the cross culture difference trying to adapt to the new modern practices set by HI. Initially RDH was a guanxi based hotel where social connections were important

Feasibility Study On The Hotel Industry

3169 words - 13 pages P: The Leading Hotels of the World Q: Air France R: Seiko Mitsukoshi S: Lancel T: ZaraU: Mango V: Old England X: Apple store Y: Hotel Scribe Paris Z: Galeries Lafayette1. InterContinental Paris Le Grand (4*) 2. Hotel Scribe Paris managed by Sofitel (5*) 3. Citadines Prestige Opéra Vendome Paris 4. Hotel Volney Opéra 5. Dounou Opéra (3*) 6. Hotel Choiseul Opera (3*) 7. Mansart (4*) 8. VV Paris Opera (5*) 9. Edouard 7 (4*) 10

Buisness Desicion Making

1690 words - 7 pages clean atmosphere. In some hotels it is present but if not so there should be a changing station for small kids, there should be a TV security if not should be in the doors of every room. The hotel staff should be co operative with customers, because the repeat customers give more business then the new ones. The new trend which also increases the market in hospitality industry is because of different deals in different seasons like Christmas deal or

Related Essays

Questions Essay

465 words - 2 pages hotel liable? [Margreiter v. New Hotel Monteleone 640 F.2d 508 (5th Gr. 1981)] 1. What are the elements of negligence that Mr. Margreiter will need to prove against the hotel in order to win his case? List the five elements here. (Points : 5) 2. Applying the facts you have from the case problem above only, lay out a case for negligence against the hotel. Use the elements to outline the case. Start with the first element, explain what

Business Ethics And Hotel Injury Essay

1724 words - 7 pages Business Ethics and Hotel Injury Here are links to TWO cases. The first case, the Margreiter v. New Hotel Monteleone, Inc. case, is the decision to the case in your homework problem. Within that case, you will find mentioned the second case: Nordmann v. National Hotel Company, 425 F.2d. 1103 (5th Cir. 1970). That case establishes the basis by which the court in Margreiter determined the level of duty the New Hotel Monteleone owed to Mr

Week 3 Hm Wk Gm 520

2188 words - 9 pages and met his fate outside the hotel. Is the hotel liable? [Margreiter v. New Hotel Monteleone 640 F.2d 508 (5th Gr. 1981)] 1. What are the elements of negligence that Mr. Margreiter will need to prove against the hotel in order to win his case? List the five elements here. (Points : 5) The elements of negligence that Mr. M will need to prove against the hotel are: Duty, Breach of duty, Causation, Proximate cause and

You Decide Essay

2398 words - 10 pages there was deficiency of coherent memory of Margreiter 6. It states that he failed to return to New Orleans to describe his attackers and to prosecuting them. (640 F2d 508 Margreiter v. New Hotel Monteleone Inc | OpenJurist) Comments: Grading Summary These are the automatically computed results of your exam. Grades for essay questions, and comments from your instructor, are in the "Details" section below. Date Taken: 8/5/2011 Time