The Housekeeper Essay

2092 words - 9 pages

Short Story Comparative Essay
Kate Wang
Student # : 602285
ENG 3U0-E
From the beginning of time, the role given to men has always been the breadwinner and the women as the housekeeper. These stereotypes have been broken as more women are entering the work force due frustration with their limitations in society. Women are happier being less dependent on men and more reliant on themselves, opposite to society’s beliefs. In The Wedding Gift and “The Company of Wolves, Thomas Raddall and Angela Carter show in order to achieve freedom and independence, it is necessary for women to break society’s expectations. Raddall and Carter use characters, locations and symbols to convey this message. ...view middle of the document...

The second husband beat the women for showing compassion towards her first husband. No matter what the woman does, she is always victimized by men. In order to be free from control, it is important for her to be independent and break free from the domestic role. In The Wedding Gift, the snow represents the feminine nature of Kezia. This is shown when Raddall states, “Kezia had prayed for snow, storms of snow, to bury the trail and keep anyone from crossing the cape of Bristol Creek. But now they were setting out from Harper’s farm, with Harper’s big brown horse, and all of Kezia’s prayers had gone for naught” (Raddall 1). Kezia believes if it snows, she will not have to go on her journey to marry Mr. Hathaway. But when it does snow, her journey becomes more difficult. The snow represents Kezia’s inability to make her own decisions. As well, snow is frozen water and water represents femininity. The fact that the water is frozen shows how Kezia is trapped to play the domestic role and marry Mr. Hathaway. At the end of the story, the snow stops showing the reader Kezia breaks free of the domestic role, society’s expectations and gains freedom. Next, Little Red’s Shawl is used as a symbol of her innocence and womanly self. This is evident when Carter says, “She closed the window on the wolves’ threnody and took off her scarlet shawl, the colour of poppies, the colour of sacrifices, the colour of menses. She bundled up her shawl and threw it on the blaze, which instantly consumed it” (Carter 6). Little Red is described as an innocent girl with her shawl on but by the end of the story, she removes that shawl. She breaks society’s expectations and uses sexuality as power to seduce the wolf. The wolf had played the part of the predator but Little Red is now playing the predator with her shawl off. Through that act, she saves her life, achieves freedom and ultimately changes her fate. Lastly, the tinderbox symbolizes how Kezia is forced to marry Mr. Hathaway and play the domestic role. At the end of the story, Raddall adds, “Then, swiftly, she undid her bundle and took out the thing that had lain there (and on her conscience) through the night-the tinderbox-Mr. Barclay’s Wedding Gift to Mr. Hathaway. She flung it into the woods and walked on” (Raddall 12). Kezia, after deciding not to marry Mr. Hathaway, throws away the tinderbox. This shows her freedom from Mr. Hathaway’s, her domestic role and Mr. Barclay’s commands. She is capable of being independent and making her own decisions instead of having to follow society’s expectations. Overall, the four symbols show how women are capable of breaking free from society’s expectations and being surpressed by men, in the end gaining freedom.
The next element of narrative form used in both stories is location. Both stories use location is used to emphasize how women are isolated and absent from society. To begin with, Little Red is put in a dangerous location where she is made vulnerable. The...

Other Papers Like The Housekeeper

Montana 1948: Life of David Hayden

534 words - 3 pages Montana 1948, by Larry Watson, is an interesting, exciting novel about a boy, David Hayden, who lives in Bentrock, Montana, and the life-changing events which happen to him one summer. David tells the story of his uncle Frank murdering his housekeeper, an Indian. David's dad, the sheriff, has to arrest Frank, his own brother, for the murder. The crisis of the story occurs when David's uncle commits suicide by cutting his wrists with broken

Wuthering Heights Essay

950 words - 4 pages not to trust Lockwood, and leaves him alone in a room with a group of snarling dogs. Lockwood is saved from the hounds by a ruddy-cheeked housekeeper. When Heathcliff returns, Lockwood is angry, but eventually warms toward his taciturn host, and—though he hardly feels that he has been welcomed at Wuthering Heights—he volunteers to visit again the next day. Summary: Chapter II On a chilly afternoon not long after his first visit, Lockwood

Unit 1 P1

1321 words - 6 pages commination. The communication cycle – 1 – idea occurs - When an idea occurs it usually means an individual has seen someone which may have reminded them about a scenario or something that they need to ask. At this stage you can only tell by seeing someone’s body language on how they will be and react to your conversation. When a housekeeper is going round the ward, he thinks about what the patient may want for dinner. 2 - message coded

Crash Movie

994 words - 4 pages -American director and his wife are upper class in terms of education and income while the African-American detective has worked his way into a middle-class job and his mother is a drug addict and his brother a criminal. The DA’s wife, who lives in the wealthy Brentwood area of Los Angeles, is constantly complaining about her housekeeper/nanny, a struggling Latina. Inhumanity is yet another idea explored in the film: a policeman sexually

Doc Insignificant Gestures

740 words - 3 pages . He became a good psychiatrist, and in a few years he would be a consultant. He didn’t enjoy much in his normal everyday life, but he did enjoy one person, that was Celia, his housekeeper. She lit up his life, especially when she sat next to him every evening while drawing. But one night she suddenly became one of his patients at the hospital. According to a woman from the village, her boyfriend had beaten her up. She was almost unrecognizable

Great Expectations

801 words - 4 pages seeking revenge for past rejections of herself.7. Estella Havisham: a haughty, cruel girl whom Miss Havisham has adopted.8. Mr. Jaggers: A London lawyer for several characters in the novel: Miss Havisham, Abel Magwitch, Molly, and Pip.9. Dolge Orlick: a journeyman for Joe and a lifelong enemy of Pip.10. Biddy: a kind village girl who teaches Pip and who becomes the housekeeper for the Gargerys.11. Herbert Pocket: The pale young gentleman who, in

Insignificant Gestures

785 words - 4 pages thinking that he could make a difference in the world, as if he knows he can not now. As mentioned, he had a maid in Africa called Celia. Celia was not busy at all at work, because she only had to wash and iron the narrator’s clothes, because he did not make a lot of mess, since he was not home that much. He only kept her as a housekeeper, because he knew that her family relied on the income Celia brought them. As also mentioned before, the

Great Expectations

914 words - 4 pages Pip loved. “I looked at those hands, I looked at those eyes, I looked at that flowing hair; and I compared them with other hands, other eyes, other hair that I knew of, and with that those might be after twenty years of brutal husband and a stormy life. (p331). Pip was enjoying dinner when he had observed Molly, Jaggers housekeeper. Pip studied her well when she entered the room he had a belief he already seen this women before which he had not

Legal Research Paper

1767 words - 8 pages Elizabeth Gomez Saratoga Hostel v. Avila (2009) In 1999, Maria Avila was hired as a housekeeper by Saratoga Hostel; she was 42 years old. Her duties included: cleaning twelve rooms a day, doing some laundry, and cleaning the hallways as well. Due to the economic crisis of 2009, Saratoga Hostel hired a new business consultant to find ways to reduce costs and personnel. The housekeeping department let go 3 of

The Yellow Wallpaper

518 words - 3 pages woman shaking the bars at night. She thinks that her husband and the housekeeper know about the wall paper, so she peels as much of it down when they are not around. She bites, tares, and rips the paper to try to free the woman. The narrator thinks there are many women like the one from the yellow paper around. She also thinks that she came out of the wallpaper. Her husband tries to break into the bedroom of his wife which is locked and when he does and sees the condition of her he faints in the doorway.

Families in to Kill a Mockingbird

651 words - 3 pages close friends, but only Dill who comes to visit each summer. Atticus is one of the only parents that takes time with his children. Him and Scout would read everyday for example. the only motherly touch in the house comes from Calpurnia, the african american housekeeper. Nevertheless, the Finch serves as role models I mean The novel traces the life of Scout, her brother Jem and Atticus over many years. Meanwhile, Harper Lee uses great

Related Essays

Roles Of The Housekeeper And Nursemaid In Bronte's Jane Eyre

1298 words - 6 pages Roles of the Housekeeper and Nursemaid in Bronte's Jane Eyre   Just as servants played an essential role in Victorian England, they also played an essential role in the novel Jane Eyre. Bronte uses servants in a variety of ways. For example the housekeeper is used to bring terror and utter rejection on Jane. The nursemaid is used to teach Jane to love and nurture without neglecting discipline. The housekeeper was most often a widow

Leadership Essay

969 words - 4 pages REPORT – 1 Student Name: Robin Singh Samra Student no: 300678899 Field Placement Hotel: Hilton Toronto Airport Hotel and Suites Supervisor: MJ Title: Executive Housekeeper Work Schedule: 40 hours a week. Learnt About Hotel I am currently pursuing my internship at Hilton Toronto Airport Hotel and Suites as a Trainee Supervisor in Housekeeping Department. The hotel is located at 5875 Airport Road

Describing How The Society Has Stereotypically Defined A Male And Femal, Boy And Girl

887 words - 4 pages in the script, and no people or groups are marginalized. However, there are still very definite constructions of masculinity and femininity that can be observed in the way the characters dress and act, and in the jobs they perform. For example, the program implies that women always do the cooking and cleaning. Not only does Wilma do the cleaning in her house, but also when Fred tries to hire a housekeeper, there are only women to choose from

The Necklace 1 Essay

658 words - 3 pages have throughout her household, she describes them as "drab", "threadbare", and "ugly" (paragraph 3). It's apparent that the author is portraying the characters Mathilde and Loisel to being categorized as upper-middle class due to the fact that the Loisel's currently have a housekeeper. Mathilde looks down on the housekeeper seeing her as a lower class worker. The author states that "the sight of the young country girl ... awakened in [Mathilde