This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Failures Of Environmental Multilateralism Demonstrate The Need For A World Environment Organisation

2705 words - 11 pages

‘The failures of environmental multilateralism demonstrate the need for a World Environment Organisation.’ Critically evaluate this claim.


One of the main challenges that face environmental politics today is a significant lack of integration between the global governance structures that address ecological matters. The international trade system has some of the most powerful institutional actors, such as the World Trade Organisation, where legal rules are supported by a dispute resolution body, trade sanctions, as well as the power to authorise other retaliation tactics when a country does not comply with a ruling (Eckersley 2003.) In contrast, the existing multilateral framework for ...view middle of the document...

Following this will be a specific proposal to consolidate the many ecological governance structures into a World Environment Organisation. Finally, I will conclude by appraising the potential outcomes of implementing the WEO.

Current Failures of Environmental Multilateralism

Poor management in response to climate change and other ecological challenges has prompted interest in reforming the framework of environmental governance. Evidently, there are a number of environmental problems which can be handled from a national scale itself, but an increasing number of transboundary ecological issues have started to emerge, including natural resource distribution, atmospheric pollution and energy security (Esty & Ivanova 2001.) Threats to the 'global commons' thus highlight the necessity of effective coordination between all sovereign nations.

Multilateral environment management, however, has not been as efficient as it needs to be. There is a huge challenge of coordination at both national and international levels. Intergovernmental actors currently include: the United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP); the Commission on Sustainable Development (CSD); the United Nations Development Programme, which has a large environmental portfolio; as well as agencies like the World Meteorological Organization, and the Food and Agriculture Organisation (IISD et al. 2007.) As a result of the multitude of organisations currently influencing environmental politics, effective joint coordination has not been possible (Esty & Ivanova 2001.) In fact, this issue has even led to an increase in the number of institutions responsible for coordinating joint action, including the Environmental Management Group (EMG) and the Global Ministerial Environment Forum (GMEF.) As quoted by the International Institute for Sustainable Development et al (2010), “the irony is that although there are many institutions, the key players - i.e., the Member States - within all these institutions are the same. The failure of coordination, therefore, has to be seen not just as a failure of the institutions, but as a failure by the “owners” of these institutions: the Member States themselves.”

Another adverse consequence of increased institutional actors is that organisations in charge of addressing sustainable development are often limited by insufficient funds or a lack of executive powers. The United Nations Environment Programme, for example, is currently mandated as the global environmental body, and has achieved quite a few advances over the years. Notably, this includes facilitating the establishment of new Multilateral Environmental Agreements (MEAs), such as the negotiations on ozone depletion, desertification, and the implementation of the Kyoto Protocol on climate change (UNEP 2004.) It has also developed partnerships with the World Meteorological Organisation (WMO) and World Conservation Union (WCU) to advance the climate change debate (Biermann & Bauer 2005.)...

Other Papers Like The Failures of Environmental Multilateralism Demonstrate the Need for a World Environment Organisation

Do The Achievements Of The Soviet State, 1945-65, Demonstrate The Effectiveness Of A Centrally Planned Economy?

1002 words - 5 pages surplus of supplies arising . However, these advantages and shortcomings are theoretical and it is vitally important to look at the actual successes and failures of the USSR between 1945 and 1965.Of the successes made by the Soviet Union in this twenty year period, perhaps the most well known is their victory in the race to put a man in space. When Yuri Gagarin orbited the earth April 12th 1961 , the event heavily added to claims that the USSR was

The Need of a New Career

525 words - 3 pages Susan G. WANTED: Scholarship Association willing to award a mature and hard working student a position to attend the school in Fall 2008.  Will demonstrate to be worthy of investment through diligence, dedication, and determined work ethic. Am ready to work hard and succeed. Asking for an opportunity. S.M. H. As a child, we imagine our dream career.  I wasn’t the average Lawyer, Teacher, but a Dentist.  Seeing others smile makes me

Concern for the Environment

1122 words - 5 pages roads; more need for space resulting in the deforestation of the forest areas; more of dust, more of smoke; more of factories more of effluent wastes; dirtier the air, polluted the water — to say the least, more of men, more of problems. A survey conducted by the Jawaharlal Nehru University disclosed that Inspire of all incentives and disincentives given to the people for controlling population and even by the drive of ‘selling’ the family

The Need of a Professional Teacher

755 words - 4 pages of teacher is often formal and ongoing, carried out at a school or other place of formal education. The professional teacher strives to create a learning environment that nurtures to fulfillment the potential of all students. The professional teacher acts with conscientious effort to exemplify the highest ethical standards. The professional teacher responsibly accepts that every child has a right to an uninterrupted education free from strikes

The Need for a National Health Care Plan

1027 words - 5 pages influx of aging baby boomers infiltrating the healthcare system in conjunction with the homeless, underinsured, unemployed, and uninsurable demonstrate the immediate need is for us is to settle the debate accept facts for what they are and forge ahead with the plan. Works Cited Harris, Robert D., Arguments for Universal Health Access in the United States: A Radiologist’s Perspective, http://w.w.w.ajronline.org/content/188/3/617 retrieved from the internet 2/25/13 Dying for Coverage the Deadly Consequences of Being Uninsured: Families USA, retrieved from the internet 2/25.13

Success and Failures of the Irish Community

1204 words - 5 pages The Successes and Failures of the Irish Community Sociology of Developing Countries The Successes and Failures of the Irish Community Throughout history many communities were formed for many different reasons. Some communities were able to become successful cultures while others did not. The reasons why communities are successful stem from many different reasons. “Some theories conclude that communities thrive and others do not because of

Compare the Reasons for Successes and Failures of Democracy Movements in Asia and Africa

1624 words - 7 pages Compare the reasons for successes and failures of democracy movements in Asia and Africa Democracy means the government by the people.(4) The historians and philosophers of the Aegean world invented the term, situated it within a larger political vocabulary, again of their own invention, and provided a mode of politi- cal analysis that enjoyed authority well into modern times. Greek political institutions did not survive; Greek

Failures Of The American Criminal Justice System

1936 words - 8 pages dire need and desperation. Additionally, the mentally ill are in prison at higher rates than the general population and more mentally ill people remain in prisons than in hospitals. Furthermore, a program in Louisiana seeking to expand the state prison system has led officials scrambling to imprison as many people as possible, making it the prison capital of the world. In order for justice to be properly served, the teachings of King must be

The Need For Project Management

347 words - 2 pages Unit 1 Assignment 1: The Need for Project Management In Recent years why is project management Important? Project management is important because business professionals have been arriving on the scene with unique skills to start, coordinate, and complete organizations small and large projects. In the past these projects were usually given to a supervisors or managers regardless of his or her skill set. Now these highly trained professionals

The Need for More Staff

639 words - 3 pages . She does all the purchasing and inventories herself. She also does a lot of the restocking herself, much of the time before and after store hours. Kathy likes to do this herself because much of the food she carries is perishable. Kathy also goes to all of her stores daily to take inventory and does the purchasing. Currently Kathy is spread very thin. She also handles all of the finances as well determining how much each product should sell for

How Does The Development Of Core Competencies Provide Both Advantages And Disadvantages For An Organisation?

1651 words - 7 pages combination of existing ones in new ways; or a complete renewing of the resource base,depending on how dynamic the environment is, in order to sustain competitive advantage and address external changes. What is important here is the managers’ perception of the environmental dynamism that providesthe basis for their ability to identify the need for changes and extend those changes when necessary. According to Amrosini et al (2009), managers who fail to

Related Essays

What Are The Dangers And The Benefits Of Corporate Social Responsibility, For Employees, Management, Organisation, Society And The Environment?

2326 words - 10 pages What are the dangers and the benefits of corporate social responsibility, for employees, management, organisation, society and the environment? An organisation have the leading and progressively essential role in our daily life, for example, the growing of most of the large firm and increase globalisation that refer to the organisation operating their businesses competing with the corporation in the world. One of an idea that has been the

Understanding The Purpose Of An Organisation And Its Operating Environment

1153 words - 5 pages 3HRC Understanding the purpose of an organisation and its operating environment. 1.1 Describe the purpose and goals of an organisation Network Rail (NR) own and run the railway infrastructure; the tracks and equipment needed so that the people who do run the trains – Train Operating Companies (TOCs) / Freight Operating Companies (FOCs) – can keep their trains going. NR are responsible for maintaining the infrastructure, signaling, timetabling

The World Trade Organisation (Wto) Essay

2657 words - 11 pages the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT) created in 1947. Most of the WTO's current work comes from the Uruguay Round of negotiations (1986-1994). Headquartered in Geneva, Switzerland, the WTO has 151 members (as at 27th July 2007), accounting for over 97% of world trade. The organisation is governed by a Ministerial Conference, which meets every two years, a General Council which implements the conference's policy decisions and a

Discuss The Need For World Order And Evaluate The Effectiveness Of Responses In The Maintenance Of World Order

1321 words - 6 pages World order is a term used to describe the balance of power among the nations of the world. It is linked with the political, economic and social framework in the world at a particular time and the effect that this situation has on the relationship between countries. There is an increasing need for world order in the global community due to growing conflict both within and between nations and regions. The increased trade between countries has