The Ethical Analysis On The Issues Of Whistle Blowing

1831 words - 8 pages

ENGINEERING ETHICS – CASE STUDIES
1. 2. 3. 4. What is Engineering Ethics? Why study Engineering Ethics? The scope of Engineering Ethics Case studies in Engineering Ethics a. Killer Robot b. DC - 10 c. Whistle Blowing d. Citicorp Building e. The Challenger case 1. Sample Codes a. Hammurabi’s code b. ABET code 1. Further case studies a. Bhopal b. Three Mile Island c. Chernobyl 7. Concluding remarks

WHAT IS ENGINEERING ETHICS

Engineering Ethics is the study of moral issues and decisions confronting individuals and organizations engaged in engineering.

The Study of related questions about moral ideals,character,policies and relationship of people and corporations involved in ...view middle of the document...

The Robot arm struck Matthews, throwing him against a wall and crushing his skull. Matthews died almost instantly. According to the indictment, Samuels wrote the particular piece of computer program responsible for the robot malfunction. “There’s a smoking gun!” McMurdock announced triumphantly at a press conference held in the hall of Justice." We have the hand written formula ,provided by the project physicist, which Samuels was supposed to program. But he negligently misinterpreted the formula leading to this huge gruesome death. Society must protect itself against programmers who make careless mistakes. The Sentinel – observer has obtained a copy of the handwritten formula in question. There are actually three similar formulas ,scrawled on piece of yellow legal pad paper.

Each formula describes the motion of the robot in one direction: east-west, North-south and up –down. The Sentinel-Observer showed the formulas to Bill Park a professor of physics at Silicon Valley University. He confirmed that these equations could be used to describe the motion of a robot arm. The Sentinel – Observer then showed Park the program code written by the accused in the programming language. We asked Park who is fluent in C and several other languages, whether the program code was correct for the given robot – arm formulas.

Parks response was immediate. He exclaimed, “By Jove! It looks like he misinterpreted the formula. He's guilty as hell, if you ask me”. The Sentinel – Observer was unable to contact Samuels for comment. “He is deeply depressed about all this,” his girl friend told us over the phone," but Randy believes he will be acquitted when he gets a chance to tell his side of the story. Issues:

CASE 2: DC – 10 JUMBO JET
The fuselage of the DC – 10 Jumbo jet of which the cargo door is a part was developed by Convair, a sub contractor for McDonnell Douglas. Convair’s senior engineer directing the project, Dan Applegate had written to the Vice president of the company: “The Cargo door could burst open, leading to crash of the plane. Hence the door has to be redesigned and the cabin floor has to strengthened”.

Top Management at Convair neither disputed the technical facts or the predictions made by Applegate. The liabilities and the cost of redesign were to high. Two years went by. In 1974 the cargo door of DC – 10 Jumbo burst open and the jet crashed near Paris killing 346 . Issues:

CASE 3: WHISTLE BLOWING
 Definition: Whistle blowing is alerting relevant persons to some moral or legal corruption, where “Relevant persons” are those in a position to act in response.
 No topic in Engineering ethics is more controversial than

whistle – blowing.

 Carl Houston was a welding supervisor for a nuclear

power facility in Virginia (1970) for Stone & Weber

He saw
   

Improper welding procedures Use of wrong materials Welders were not trained properly The Situation was dangerous

He reported to Stone & Weber’s...

Other Papers Like The Ethical Analysis on the Issues of Whistle Blowing

The TARES Test Of Ethical Advertising On Fast Food Companies

1394 words - 6 pages advertisers for targeting children, and advertisers blame the problem on parents because they are in control of what their kids eat and do not eat.Ethical Issues Involved in the AdvertisingThe examples of fast food advertisements revolve around the same ethical question: are there certain types of audiences who deserve special protection from advertising messages? In keeping with thousands of years of ethical thinking, U.S. law has answered this

Application of the Normative Ethical Theories on Case 1.2

1567 words - 7 pages Case based on both the Ethical Issues Applying Rule Utilitarianism The Rule Utilitarian Ethic is a kind of Utilitarianism which emphasis on rules as the core essence according to its name. In this ethic rules play a crucial role over pleasure. Rule Utilitarianism believe that rules brings goodness and thus gives happiness if followed (2). Rule Utilitarianism is motivated by rules, behaviors and moral values that bring human happiness. Rule

P5:Research the Legal and Ethical Issues and Constraints in Relation to the Use of Business Information in Organizations

631 words - 3 pages to protected files of someone else's compute. Also in this task I will be looking at Ethical issues.Ethical issuesare not laws but are reasonable rules which a business expects its employees to abide by. I am going to describe ethical issues with regards to: - Email - Internet - Whistle blowing - Organisational policies Email –most organizations have a code of practise in regards to the use of email accurately. These codes of practise

Essay Module 4 - Nov 2014 Using Mr X’s Case Study Provided at the End of the Module: • Identify the Client’s Issues • Explain the Client’s Issues • Devise a Course of Treatment for Him • Take in...

2127 words - 9 pages Anne Swindley Course code: READI 1S(B) 14 Tutor: Amrita Chapman Number of words = 2023 Essay Module 4 - Nov 2014 Using Mr X’s case study provided at the end of the module: • Identify the client’s issues • Explain the client’s issues • Devise a course of treatment for him • Take in account any ethical issues Introduction My client, Mr X is in his mid-forties. He has worked as an Estate Agent in

The Concept of Ethical Obligation

1343 words - 6 pages for the ethics program of any organization; ensuring that an organization receives consideration and requisite overlooked is received (Leffler 2011. Elaborate on four notions for designing ethical maps for defining and prioritizing ethical obligations. George Tenet’s primary priorities were to improved employee morale, improved work conditions, better execution of intelligence reports and analysis, reinforcement of units with new recruits and

The Concept of Ethical Obligation

1799 words - 8 pages facing former CIA Director George Tenet and assess their impact on his leadership abilities. Secondly, analyze four ways in which Tenet addressed the prioritization of ethical concerns. Then, I will identify and explain four strategies used in competing ethical obligation in relation to the many intergovernmental organizations that overlapped his office. I will also elaborate on four relevant notions for designing ethical maps for defining and

Teleological Suspension of the Ethical

1516 words - 7 pages A clear understanding of what Soren Kierkegaard (1813-1855) meant by the `suspension of the ethical' can be achieved upon careful study of his wider philosophies on stages or aspects of an individual's life. In this short text I will examine these philosophies, exploring what Kierkegaard meant by each one. I'll then put into context these stages of life by looking at them in relation to that which Kierkegaard's text `Fear and Trembling' (in

The Ethical Negligence of Parents

695 words - 3 pages premise is that the rightness or wrongness of actions is determined by the goodness or badness of their consequences” (McGraw, 149). When viewing the above situation from utilitarian view I can say that Mill will agree with vaccinating children since it focus on the “Greatest Happiness Principal or considering the greatest good for the greatest number when making difficult moral or ethical decisions” (McGraw, 149). His argument will be that it is

Explain the Ethical Teachings of Jesus with Special Reference to the Sermon on the Mount

1808 words - 8 pages Explain the ethical teachings of Jesus with special reference to the Sermon on the mount. Jesus of Nazareth was born a Jew. He was raised in the Jewish faith, as both his parents were Jewish, and some theologians would argue that Jesus never taught anything that was against the Jewish faith, and was just another new thinking Rabbi. The understand Jesus’ teachings, however, it is fundamental to have a comprehension of the Jewish way of like, and

Ethical Responsibilities Of The Media

1526 words - 7 pages link between violent TV programming and violent, anti-social behavior in children. Now, we have a chance to do something about it," (Hearn). Hollings was referring to the V-chip that allows the parents to block cable channels inorder to prevent their children from watching violent shows on television. But he was not speaking about the news channels because these channels are supposed to have an ethical responsibility in terms of informing the

Ethical Analysis of Abortion

1307 words - 6 pages \ In “A Defense of Abortion” Judith Jarvis Thompson weaves an argument built on the assumption that a fetus is a person to build her arguments to defend abortion. She uses a quantitative approach to the rights of the mother, fetus, and that of the right to life to create linear steps in the logic that lead to a morally sound rationalization of abortion for the mother, fetus, and third parties. However there are a few sticking points but

Related Essays

The Issues On Euthanasia Essay

847 words - 4 pages Essay Firstly, for this individual assignment, I would like to introduce my topic which is the euthanasia issues, which is being debated for many years already. I’ve chose to take up this euthanasia issues, as I found that this issues is an amazing and interesting to do for my individual assignment. Euthanasia, which is also called mercy killing or assisted suicide is an intentional and planned killing of the humans by direct act, for

Ethical Issues For The Integration Of Religion And Spirituality In Therapy

964 words - 4 pages Ethical Issues for the Integration of Religion and Spirituality in Therapy Ethics and Standards of Professional Psychology Patricia Elias Kaplan University   Abstract Over the past ten years, new developments in the psychological treatment and assessment of clients of diverse spirituality and religiosity has occurred. These changes have prompted the need for a broader understanding of therapeutic practices related to client spirituality

Ethical Issues Regarding The Use Of Performance Enhancing Drugs In Sports

4543 words - 19 pages athletics. Winners make money, losers don’t. The temptation of fame, notoriety and million dollar contracts in all venues of sport is a lure for many athletes. Elite professional athletes are worshiped in today’s society. This paper will elaborate on the use of performance enhancing drugs in the sporting world and the associated sports ethical issues. It is a majority belief in all sporting circles that the “true” spirit of sportsmanship does not

Legal And Ethical Issues In Relation To The Use Of Business Information

5604 words - 23 pages Ellie Richards Unit 4 P5 P6 M2 P5- explain the legal and ethical issues in relation to the use Of business information Email Policy Within Strode College, they recognise how important it is to have efficient communications between all the colleagues who work within the college. Electronic mail, also know as Emails is one of the most popular methods of communication, it’s quick, easy, and can be done at anytime. It also means you don’t