The Ethical Ambiguity Concerning The Death Penalty

1400 words - 6 pages

The question of ethical behavior is an age-old conundrum. The prevailing issue with ethics is that it is extremely difficult to measure. A person’s moral fabric is largely based on their particular personality traits, as well as, their psychological state and environmental influences. Many believe that ethics are tied to a person’s conscience, and that good morals are often facilitated by a strong religious background. Furthermore, a person’s moral development can be linked to their economic situation and cultural differences. Interestingly, even while examining the status of one’s moral code is challenging; everyone seems to have their own unique array of ethics.
While this is an ...view middle of the document...

No one should have to endure such needless suffering.
Capital punishment used to be a routine universal practice. The torrid history surrounding executions dates back thousands of years and includes the majority of civilizations around the world. Throughout history, the death penalty has been utilized as a tool to manage society. Hammurabi, a successful Babylonian king, established what many scholars thought to be the first code of laws. Charles F. Horne, author of “The Code of Hammurabi,” explains: “The code . . . regulates in clear and definite strokes the organization of society” and these “grim retaliatory punishments take no note of excuses or explanations, but only of the fact” (Horne Online). Obviously, Hammurabi was aware of the advantages of capital punishment and eagerly supports it! Furthermore, according to the Death Penalty Information Center, “In 1612, Virginia Governor Sir Thomas Dale enacted the Divine, Moral and Martial Laws, which provided the death penalty for even minor offenses such as stealing grapes, killing chickens, and trading with Indians” (DPIC Online). While capital punishment is clearly unnecessary for such trivial delinquencies, it is evident that this practice has been widely employed and passed down through the ages.
If someone were to survey the ethical issues associated with capital punishment, the sheer number of contentions would be astounding! However, the principle argument against the death penalty maintains that a human life is too valuable to execute. On the surface, this appears to be the appropriate ethical assessment, but is it? In the pure sense of the word, no, the act of deliberately taking another person’s life is not ethical; but, if one were to disregard the initial definition and avoid the superfluous, often, technical phrasing, then the ethical debate becomes more lucid. Enigmatically, the ethical concept is closely linked to emotion, and as sentiments and beliefs change, the moral compass of an individual is understandably altered. Quite often, in a case that is predominantly driven by emotion, there is an anomic shift in the morality of an individual and, sometimes, an entire society.
For instance, the latest high-profile and faithfully monitored trial, involving Casey Anthony, has sparked a great deal of controversy and civil unrest throughout the nation. For those that firmly advocate her guilt (ME!), there is a sense of bitterness and acrimony resulting from her acquittal. Unfortunately, when determining the proper sentencing in a capital court case, the notion of ethics and justice intertwine. When the boundaries between the two begin to merge, a person’s perception of apposite ethics becomes obscured by this emotional eclipse. The effects of this subsequent shift can, and frequently does, shake the very foundation of this seemingly finite word.
The convergence of justice and ethics tends to sway people away from the conventional definition in order to gratify an arcane...

Other Papers Like The Ethical Ambiguity Concerning The Death Penalty

The Death Penalty Essay

621 words - 3 pages The death penalty is a growing concern in today’s society; however, many criminals who are sentenced to the death penalty have no respect for the value of life. The three reasons that society might find the death penalty beneficial include the following: retribution or moral issues, incapacitation, and the role of vengeance. Retribution means that a murderer must be executed because the prisoner deserves the death penalty for the criminal acts

The Death Penalty Essay

1267 words - 6 pages The Death Penalty Can one justify an action of a cold killer? Furthermore, should death penalty be abolish? Lastly, is it possibly to end the debate about death penalty and the abolition of it? William Otis comes with his arguments in “The Death Penalty Saves Lives”, 2006, for why death penalty should not be abolish and his opinion of the abolitionists own arguments for it. The death penalty or capital punishment is a legit system where a

The Death Penalty

666 words - 3 pages THE DEATH PENALTY Death penalty is an issue that brings a lot of controversy in our society, this is an important topic because the life of a person is on the hands of a group of people that decide whether this individual should live or die. Different opinions exist in our society about this action, because some citizens believe that these murderers should pay with their lives for the crimes they committed. On the other hand, another group of

The Death Penalty

2287 words - 10 pages The Death Penalty PHI103: Informal Logic Professor Donald Ceplenski March 26, 2012 The Death Penalty Capital punishment, also known as the death penalty, is the lawful infliction of death as a form of punishment. It is considered to be one of the most controversial and a debated topic across the United States which leads to the logical question; is the death penalty just and applied fairly? Although in theory sentencing a

The Death Penalty--Against

1046 words - 5 pages Mirko Wagner 11/20/08 Death Penalty Paper I am against the death penalty because I think a planned death is a punishment that no human should go through. Why am I against the execution? You will have to get to know in the following paragraphs. In my opinion, it is a better punishment to have someone in jail for life than to execute him or her. If you are in jail for life, you have to think about what you did and why you did it. You have

The Penalty of Death

1502 words - 7 pages 06-29-2010 H. L. Mencken’s “The Penalty of Death” Essay By Angelo Bolden References A Mencken Cornucopia by Gibbons Burke Death Penalty – Internet Articles (Google) Capital Punishment – Internet Articles (Google) Sociology 100 - Wayne County Community College Text H. L. Mencken is an author and critic who write about societies need for katharsis. First, Mencken uses logical symbolism to justify the validity of capital

Info on the Death Penalty

1080 words - 5 pages Oscar Cruz General Purpose. To inform my audience to/ that/ about: The Death Penalty Thesis Statement: The horror facts about the Death Penalty. I. Introduction A. If someone is guilty of committing a horrible crime, and the family of the victim wants the perpetrator be executed, do we want to live in a society that gives that to them? I would say no, you may reasonably say yes. B. The death penalty is one of those topics that no one

Benefits of the Death Penalty

2162 words - 9 pages ! So is murder. Death penalty is not revenge. Rather, it is a matter of putting an end to a life that has no value for other human lives. Sentencing a murderer to death is in fact a favor to the society. Despite the moral argument concerning the inhumane treatment of the criminal, we return to the "nature" of the crime committed. Can society place an unequal weight on the tragically lost lives of murder victims and the criminal? This is not an exam

Issues in the Death Penalty

2423 words - 10 pages Issues In The Death Penalty More than an estimated 18,800 Americans have been executed since the creation of the death penalty dating back to colonial times (University of Alabama). The decision of death for the punishment of a murder in the United States has declined in recent years. In 2009, the number of new death sentences was 112, the lowest level in 30 years. Unfortunately, the U.S. fails to recognize capital punishment as a

Juvenile and the Death Penalty

535 words - 3 pages The question of whether juveniles should receive the death penalty is a controversial subject for many. There are so many variables to consider regarding this subject. I believe this subject is relevant because in recent news reports we are increasingly hearing about juveniles committing some violent and heinous crimes. We don't normally think of juveniles as rapist, robbers or murderers, but when these crimes are committed by juveniles should

Should The Death Penalty Be Abolished?

1873 words - 8 pages innocent people themselves have an absence of a sense of morals for the life of others. That lack of morals on their part only intensify the morals of those who think that the death penalty should not be abolished. Beside the part that morals play when discussing the death penalty there are also legal and ethical issues that come into play. I think that most of us will agree that death is unethical, but is the death penalty an ethical decision for

Related Essays

The Death Penalty Is Ethical Essay

1316 words - 6 pages victim’s family, and protects citizens from criminals under the Constitution. One of the reasons that capital punishment is ethical is because it is a deterrence factor for criminals. The theory concerning the death penalty is that the threat of death discourages criminals from a life of crime. This theory has not been proven or disproven thus far. The FBI Uniform Crime Report from 2009 showed that the highest murder rate was in the south and

Is The Death Penalty Ethical Essay

2483 words - 10 pages Is the Death Penalty Ethical?             It is clear in our society that violent crimes, such as murder, should carry some sort of stiffer punishment than that of other, lesser crimes.  What is not clear is what that punishment should be.  One punishment that is a constant source of debate is the death penalty.  In this paper, I will examine whether the death penalty is or is not ethical.  Both sides of the issue will be explained, through

Is The Death Penalty Ethical Essay

1727 words - 7 pages person deemed a sexually violent predator under South Carolina law. Both changes were effective 7/01/2006. Another revision was added as an aggravating circumstance murder committed while in the commission of first degree arson. A Mark Lipsky wrote the New York Times about the death penalty here is what he had to say. To the Editor: Mark Lipsky (letter, Feb. 6) claims the death penalty is "not only ethical but essential." Ethical? Every

The Death Penalty Debate Essay

1173 words - 5 pages The death penalty has been around for a very long time. The first recorded death penalty laws date back as far as the Eighteenth Century B.C. in Hammurabi’s Code, which gave the death penalty to 25 different crimes. Hanging was the usual method of execution in Britain during the Tenth Century. In the century after, William the Conqueror did not allow people to be hung or executed unless it was during a time of war, but this quickly faded out