The Effectiveness Of Mccloud’s Appeal Essay

1980 words - 8 pages

The most common art forms artists and writers utilize to express their ideas and creativity are fine arts, novels, and films. They are widely accepted and pedestrian. All three have renowned awards ceremonies for the best in their field, displays in galleries and museums, recognition in the news through the media, and have classes teaching or analyzing them in schools. Against traditional media that have already achieved international public acceptance, a relatively new, and different art form like comics, does not stand a chance in gaining the respect it deserves. However, there are some people who have tried to build a reputation for comics and help others better understand them. Scott ...view middle of the document...

Even in bookstores, this book is placed in the “Graphic Novel” section, where adults rarely browse. However, it is common for teenagers and college students to frequent that section, and be interested by what is available there.
For teenagers and college students who have not strayed too far from their childhood memories when they were exposed to cartoons and picture books, reading a comic book is both more alluring and relaxing than an assigned 500 page novel or complex textbook. In contrast, an adult would be much more likely to pick up a more serious looking novel filled with pages of text rather than one with a plethora of cartoons, pictures and colors accented with short inserts of conversation and narration. Unsurprisingly, there is usually a lack of picture books in the areas of the library or bookstore where most adults are frequently seen browsing, for example, the fiction and nonfiction areas. Even the young adult sections lack books with pictures but possess plenty of thicker text-filled novels. However, the children’s sections are stocked with books packed with color and illustrations. Even McCloud himself recognizes the fact that many adults do not respect comics, and shows this with a small panel on page 3 depicting two middle-aged men using the phrase “comic book talk” to regard some “talk” as unworthy (McCloud 3). Comics essentially fulfill all the characteristics adults use to deem a book unimportant and easily dismissive. In this case, the comic book form of the pedagogical Understanding Comics fulfills those characteristics and can easily be dismissed by adults but rather welcomed by teenagers and college students.
The comic book format is not the only technique that McCloud employs that ends up appealing to the younger crowd. Throughout Understanding Comics, there is one drawing on almost every page—the cartoon depiction of McCloud himself. This mechanism’s original intention might have been to smoothly lead the reader through all of McCloud’s points, and to act as a tour guide and facilitate clarity. Yet, the simple character with basic features and glasses dressed in a checkered blazer and black pants is too “cute” for an older reader. McCloud tries to depict himself as plainly as possible to seemingly create an unbiased, neutral tour guide, but the cartoon ends up as more of a likeable and aesthetically pleasing character than anything else. The cartoon McCloud never just stands there and states his thoughts, instead he performs different body movements and gestures, creating a certain degree of interaction with the reader. McCloud’s cartoon presence and behavior throughout suggests a childish nature to the book. However, adults do accept instructions as they learn new things, but usually in a more formal manner. For example, if a doctor was learning about a new form of cancer treatment, he or she would read articles and books showing diagrams. A computer programmer learning a new computer language would read a...

Other Papers Like The Effectiveness of Mccloud’s Appeal

Comparing The Effectiveness Of Internet Search Engines

679 words - 3 pages Comparing The Effectiveness of Internet Search Engines There are various search engines located on the Internet, which allow for numerous amounts of information to be recovered. The search engines I focused on are: Findwhat, Google, Webcrawler, Excite, Lycos, and Northern Light. While using these search engines my searches focused on topics of Ghana, teach abroad, and computer lesson plans. On Findwhat.com results are ranked on an open

Why Do The Works Of Salvador Dali Hold Such An Appeal For Teenagers

1274 words - 6 pages Why do the works of salvador dali hold such an appeal for teenagers Salvador Dali Salvador Dali was born in 1904 and passed away in 1989. He had been what the critics call an eccentric genius, a self proclaimed madman, and had lived a life of fame and fortune, mingling with the zenith of society and living what is popularly known as the high life. He was renowned for his insanity, the king of the absurd, and this came through in his

Critically Analyse the Effectiveness of Leadership in the Nhs

1014 words - 5 pages HS 3001 LEADERSHIP AND CHANGE Critically analyse the effectiveness of leadership in the NHS Summary This essay will discuss and critically analyse the effectiveness of leadership role of senior nurses in the NHS. The essay will examine the definition of leadership, different theories of leaderships and how it can be implicated to nursing practice including changes that should be made to make nursing leaders more effective in NHS health

The Genocide Convention: Effectiveness of Punitive and Interventional Measures

3585 words - 15 pages debate has surrounded its effectiveness in preventing the occurrence of acts of genocide. The following paper will briefly discuss some theories on the causes and nature of genocide before assessing the effectiveness of the convention in preventing acts of genocide. The Convention will be assessed through its efficacy in two areas of prevention: 1) its ability to take punitive action against perpetrators of genocide in order to act as a

The Effectiveness of Business Ethics in Education and Today’s Workplace

2556 words - 11 pages The Effectiveness of Business Ethics in Education and Today’s Workplace October 13th, 2012 Introduction What do Bernard Madoff, Kenneth Lay and Rob Blagojevich all have in common? They all operated with no apparent ethical behavior even though each had received educational backgrounds in which ethical business practices were taught. As L. Zingales states, “While every firm can have its bad apples, when these apples are at the top, it

Critically Evaluate the Comparative Transnational Effectiveness of Benetton and Zara

2118 words - 9 pages Critically evaluate the comparative transnational effectiveness of Benetton and Zara Zara and Benetton are two of the most acknowledged clothing companies in the fast fashion industry. The different international business strategies they adopt result in different transnational effectiveness. To begin with, this essay will give a brief overview of the motivation, means and mentality of these two companies, and then compare how they sustain

The Long-Term Safety and Effectiveness of Low-Carbohydrate Diets

1123 words - 5 pages . unluckily, most research have been based on facts gathered for ninety days or less. Dieters and medical doctors alike could benefit from lengthy-time period research reporting on safety and weight reduction after a 12 months or greater. In 2003, there have been three trials reporting on the lengthy-term effectiveness and facet results of the Atkins weight loss plan. these studies accompanied obese dieters who were following the Atkins low

The Impact Technology Will Have on Effectiveness of Education

3729 words - 15 pages The Impact Technology Will Have on Effectiveness of Education What fundamental assumptions of our society will be altered as a result of the computer revolution? The first thing to understand regarding the question posed is that this revolution is not an event but ongoing evolution. I believe that fundamental assumptions that will be altered by computers are centered on the role of computers. In relation to

Assess the View That the Collapse of the Weimar Republic Was Primarily Due to the Appeal of Hitler and the Nazi Party

3180 words - 13 pages The fall of the Weimar Republic was not only due to the appeal of Hitler and the Nazis but a number of other factors as well. Essentially in order to make a judgment on the collapse of the democratic German government numerous social, political and economic problems factors must be accounted for. In 1918 various conflicting problems were concurrent with the eventuation of that from the outset its first governing body the socialist party (SPD

How Far Do You Agree That the Limited Appeal of Mazzini's Ideas Was the Main Reason for the Slow Progress of National Unity in the Years 1815-48?

1530 words - 7 pages . Despite his charisma and determination, his ideas are very questionable in their effectiveness in eventually securing unification. The process of unification, specifically between the Congress of Vienna and the revolutions of 1848, was undoubtedly a drawn out, arduous process, and to an extent, the limited appeal of Mazzini and his ideas were to blame. However, the role that the power of Austria and the Papacy played, as well the lack of unified

Effectiveness of Credit Risk Management on the Financial Performance of Philippine Universal Banks

1604 words - 7 pages Effectiveness of Credit Risk Management on the Financial Performance of Philippine Universal Banks Marylet H. Ilagan Master in Business Administration Lyceum of the Philippines University-Batangas Effectiveness of Credit Risk Management on the Financial Performance of Philippine Universal Banks Banks are considered to be in the business to safeguard money and other valuable of

Related Essays

The Effectiveness Of Tutoring Essay

997 words - 4 pages only is one person helping another, but the individuals are learning together. Most of the time students understand each other better than a teacher to student relationship. Students are on the same level with each other which may be helpful in the effectiveness of tutoring. One aspect that he touches on regards participation. He implies that in a tutoring session tutees have a greater chance of answering questions or problems. He compares this to

Evaluating The Effectiveness Of Workplace Law Reform

1849 words - 8 pages Evaluate the effectiveness of law reform in achieving justice for the employer and employee in reflecting community standards and expectations from 2009 to present. The law aims to achieve justice for employers and employees as well as reflect the standards and expectations of the community. In order to judge the effectiveness of workplace law, as well as workplace law reforms, numerous factors must be taken into account. The law must be

The Effectiveness Of Social Studies Solutions

5034 words - 21 pages Effectiveness of the Social Studies Solutions at Harnett Central High School Jerry L. Sarchet, Jr. Education 622: Research April 24, 2007 Abstract Overwhelming evidence in numerous studies demonstrated the value of student performance linked with their ability to take and review notes. Teachers have sought the best way to provide notes for student. In 2006, Harnett County Schools adopted an alternative approach to note taking and

Effectiveness Of Banner Advertising On The Web

648 words - 3 pages matched their relevance. And it also let the advertiser to track the number of visitors clicked on banners. Banner ad received high amount of online advertising budget than any other type of adverting. Banner ad effectiveness based upon many factors like placement which refers to three contents like where the banner is located on website and the banner relevance to the information on page. Exposure level factor includes four different levels such as