The Drone Strikes Again Essay

985 words - 4 pages

The Drone Strikes Again
Take a moment and imagine this: for every terrorist killed by a U.S. drone strike, 50 Pakistani civilians fall victims to these ruthless attacks. According to an article written by David Kilcullen and Andrew McDonald from the NY Times, “press reports suggest that over the last three years drone strikes have killed about 14 terrorist leaders. But, according to Pakistani sources, they have also killed some 700 civilians. This is 50 civilians for every militant killed, a hit rate of 2 percent — hardly “precision”” (Killcullen, McDonald 9). Regardless if the number of casualties of innocent people caused by drone strikes has increased or decreased, the policy itself ...view middle of the document...

S. Military killing terrorist without their knowledge, someone “up the ladder” decided that the act alone is acceptable because it would result in “the greatest good for the greatest number of people” (Bentham). Kant was not a consequentialist theorist as his fellow philosopher, Bentham, was. As stated before, Kant believed that our actions should be based on the rightness of themselves, regardless of the result. Therefore, if the military did in fact decide to eliminate a group of leading terrorist, they have duties as humans to do it the right way. What is the right way, though? It would be permissible to say that the best way of going about the task of eliminating terrorist would certainly not be to use drone tactics; instead, both militant parties would have to come to an agreement of how to end the terrorism. The most important aspect of the scenario would be this, the individuals partaking in terrorism would have to render themself to the U.S. military and agree that there is in fact a tolerable punishment; death not being one of them. The reason death could not be an option is because ultimately the U.S. military would be taking away the autonomy of that individual, they are not choosing to die out of free will, but instead are acting based on heteronomy, which is the opposite of Autonomy. To act heteronomous “is to act according to laws (or rules) that we do not give ourselves. It is an action that is influenced by a force outside the individual.” (Riley Inks)
The other reason why using drone tactics to eliminate terrorists is wrong, is because of the innocent lives that are being subjected to an unjust death penalty, simply for being in the wrong place at the wrong time. The U.S. military is consciously making the decision to use drones as a means to take out high-risk terrorist. However, if we were to use Kant’s Categorical Imperative and apply the...

Other Papers Like The Drone Strikes Again

The Ethics of Unmanned Drones Essay

3331 words - 14 pages unmanned drones in the War on Terror. One of the few disadvantages to drone attacks is civilian casualties. It is obvious that drones have taken innocent lives, but the real debate is over how many and if alternative approaches are any better. According to the Bureau of Investigative Journalism, a non-for-profit news organization based in London, nearly 900 non-combatants, including nearly 200 children, were killed by U.S drone strikes in 2011

Argumentaive Drones Essay

2744 words - 11 pages for and my comrades to get us in aid when we were in bind? Now that is when I saw the first drone lay its great aid as they said in the articles, I remember after the first attack we had lost a few people due to injuries and deaths and I had hoped it would not happen again. But who am I kidding I was a soldier in a combat zone and the missions still had to continue with or without a full team of soldiers by my side. The second time we were in

Does Using Drones to Attack Terrorists Globally Violate Interenational Law?

1584 words - 7 pages intelligence with Americans and also allegedly allowed the drones to operate from Shamsi Airfield in Pakistan. Assessments of the results of the attacks differ. Daniel Byman from the Brookings Institution suggests that drone strikes may kill "10 or so civilians" for every militant killed. The Pakistani military has stated that most of those killed were hardcore Al-Qaeda and Taliban militants. The Bureau of Investigative Journalism based on extensive

Obama Administration

934 words - 4 pages -haven’. Barack Obama has received widespread criticism due to its support of government surveillance On the third day of Barack Obamas Presidency, the new commander-in-chief had launched his first drone strike. Soon after, reports of civilian casualties began to emerge; the strike was far from a success as at least nine civilians had died most of them from one family. Later that day, the CIA has attacked again, proving another mistake as this

Three Strikes Law 2

1022 words - 5 pages and crimes committed by young adults. Also, when an offender plea bargains his first two convictions, he or she is not aware, according to some that he or she is still subject to the three strikes law. If an offender is arrested again after two convictions he is already guaranteed to 25 years to life. The opponents of this ask what the purpose of pleading guilty is and so therefore the offender will most likely ask for a trial which will cost

intelligence

1063 words - 5 pages the CIA is when you hear about drone strikes that have killed a certain amount of innocent civilians, drone strikes are usually done by the CIA. The most talked about negative effect is the amount of money used to continue running the CIA’s operations in various countries. Last year alone the CIA committed over 40 billion dollars to its covert and clandestine operations in various countries. Implications Do the negative effects outweigh the

Terrorism in Afghanistan - Negotiation

2854 words - 12 pages successful in surveillance usage, and to some extent striking at leaders of the Taliban, the increasing civilian casualties have stoked anger and anti-Americanism - Although the UN says it recorded no civilian deaths from drone strikes in Afghanistan last year, because the drones have been mainly used to attack low-level Taliban fighters in remote places it is hard to tell actual figures - However, report by Washington-based New America Foundation

Book Review

1741 words - 7 pages We live in a world, where we no longer maintain faith in the United Nations; a year away from its deadline for the millennium development goals, we see how the UN has again failed to fully achieve even a single goal so far. We have survived the two world wars and the deadly cold war, but we still question the future of international politics. The Syrian conflict, the separation of Crimea from Ukraine, the drone strikes in Pakistan and the slow

The Reagan Doctrine

2315 words - 10 pages massive amounts of money and rebel fighters to ensure the Soviets were broken and demoralized when they pulled out in the late 1980’s. Now the United States is mired in a war they cannot possibly win in Afghanistan. The Afghanistan people are becoming increasingly anti-American and Hamid Karzai has threatened to align Afghanistan with Moscow. (BBC News 2009) Relations become even more strained when drone strikes kill innocent civilians. Most of

Obama

1824 words - 8 pages Middle East, for example, but his vow proved elusive. Though US troops were withdrawn from Iraq in 2011, a decision that was met by otherwise rare consensus in Congress, the security situation in the country has deteriorated since. The Middle East as a whole remains volatile. The war in Afghanistan is still going on, Israelis and Palestinians are further apart than ever and bones of contention such as drone strikes and the Guantanamo Bay

The Us Constitution Is No Longer Fit for Purpose

1642 words - 7 pages and arguably illegality as illustrated by his excessive use of drone strikes in the Middle-East which exceeds 2,400 as of last year which Congress does not supervise. Obama created the Internal Revenue Service which has come under a lot of controversy recently after it was discovered that the IRS selected key conservative political groups (especially ones with ‘Tea Party’ in their name). In other words, Obama set up an agency to get rid of

Related Essays

Argument Paper For Drone Warfare

1411 words - 6 pages exporting to places such as Yemen and the Horn of Africa. While used in attacks, drones are also used for surveillance, reconnaissance, and intelligence. Until recently drone warfare was one of the most secretive programs of the U.S. government, though it is now under the scrutiny of the media worldwide. The “New America Foundation” claims that the U.S. has been responsible for 2,903 drone strikes in the Afghanistan-Pakistan border region since

Reactions From People In Waziristan On Drone

697 words - 3 pages Reactions from people in Waziristan on DRONE Between November 2008 and January 2009 Pakistani Aryana Institute for Regional Research and Advocacy conducted a survey of the public opinion about the drone strikes in Federally Administered Tribal Areas. 5 teams of 5 researchers each interviewed a total of 550 people from all walks of life. Most people thought that the drone attacks were accurate and did not lead to anti-American sentiment and

Legal Issues Surrounding Defense Drones Essay

3513 words - 15 pages danger. The defense prefers to operate unmanned vehicles in hostile environments to carry out strikes, rescues or even just routine surveillance. The technology has helped up the risk that either party are willing to take in opposing scenarios. The most effective example of drone employment by the defense is their use in striking militant/terrorist cells and targets in Pakistan and Afghanistan. Pakistan’s government and public strongly oppose these

Drones Technology Essay

1173 words - 5 pages Drone Technology at Workplace: The development of Unmanned Aerial Automobiles permitted the world to consider of innovative techniques to implement mutual tasks. From transporting packages from corner to corner in a city in under 15 minutes, delivering first aid help in some minute’s accident, to harvesting whole fields, donating to an innovative range of pictures for TV & cinemas. We have been facing the advantages of drone age, without