THE DEATH PENALTY
Death penalty is an issue that brings a lot of controversy in our society, this is an important topic because the life of a person is on the hands of a group of people that decide whether this individual should live or die. Different opinions exist in our society about this action, because some citizens believe that these murderers should pay with their lives for the crimes they committed. On the other hand, another group of people think that the death penalty is a cruel and unnecessary punishment that should not exist, because two wrongs does not make one right.
If we kill a person no matter what crime he or she committed, we become murderers. Anthony G. Amsterdam wrote in his article Capital Punishment “death penalty is a fancy phrase for legally killing people” and I agree with his statement. The principle of an eye for an eye should not exist, because ...view middle of the document...
A mistake of this magnitude is really a catastrophe to our society, because our laws are meant to protect the innocent, not kill him or her. This could easily translate into people taking the law by their own hands because they no longer trust our court system.
Some might argue that having a criminal for a lifetime in our jail system is a financial burden to our society, however "A 1991 study of the Texas criminal justice system estimated the cost of appealing capital murder at $2,316,655. In contrast, the cost of housing a prisoner in a Texas maximum security prison single cell for 40 years is estimated at $750,000."
The death penalty is a topic that has been around for years, John Locke (1632-1704) wrote in one of his essays “a person forfeits his rights when committing even minor crimes”. This point of view deserves respect as any other point of view or opinion, however as human beings we can’t and should not decide when another human being has forfeited the right to live.
Up to this point I’ve only cited moral reasons, but as a catholic I believe that God is the only one who has the power to take somebody’s life, are we God? The answer is no, then why should we act as we were God. Once again, people who defend death penalty could try to turn this point of view around, and my answer is that because a criminal committed a crime doesn’t give me the green light to do the same. It is our responsibility as a society to put that criminal behind bars, let God do the rest.
The death penalty brings many negative aspects to our society that can provoke rejections between our citizens. As a society we should all respect each other, if a person is killed under the death penalty how can we ask that person’s family to respect our society If our society couldn’t respect the life and rights to live of the person. These rejections could lead to conflicts and deaths if our court system does not make the correct decision. Further more, we all make mistakes some cannot be fixed, however whether a criminal should live or die must not be determine by their mistakes.