This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Clinton Administration Essay

4182 words - 17 pages

Whatever we might think of the reasoning Greenspan used in convincing Clinton that deficit reduction was an essential policy goal, it still remains a fact that deficits were reduced and (briefly) turned into surpluses over the eight years of the Clinton Presidency. In January of 2001, the Council of Economic Advisers made the following argument:
The Omnibus Budget and Reconciliation Act of 1993 was the right policy package at the right time … long-term interest rates remained stubbornly high. … Bond yields were being predictably affected by the forces of supply and demand: the Federal Government was set to run a deficit of almost $300 billion … ...view middle of the document...

As Figure 3 shows, this is a powerful story. There is a clear and inverse relationship between the government deficit (federal, state and local as well) and investment from 1993 onward.

[Figure 3 here]

At the same time, as Figure 4 shows, there is a clear and consistent decrease in nominal long-term rates in the 1990s.
[Figure 4 here]

However, the evidence presented in this brief statement focuses exclusively on nominal values. We are told about the various interest rates in nominal not real terms. We are told about absolute increases in nominal investment but not about the relationship between investment and GDP. We are also told nothing about the direction of causation. The rise in investment might have increased incomes so much that deficits fell as a result of those increases.
The major reason budget deficits are considered to have negative consequences for economic growth is because the extra government borrowing “crowds out” some private borrowing from the credit markets. With only a certain amount of national savings, when government entities increase borrowing that allegedly causes interest rates (the cost of borrowing) to increase. The argument concludes with the assertion that the rise in interest rates reduces private investment. The reduced private investment, in turn, reduces economic growth. Reversing this problem with lowered deficits and ultimately surpluses allegedly creates the virtuous cycle that the Council of Economic Advisers referred to in the post-1993 period. Instead of crowding out private borrowing, the reduced deficits and ultimately surpluses involve “making room” for more private borrowing by lowering interest rates.
Testing the Assertions
How do we determine whether this explanation is accurate or not? The first thing we need to do is to understand what we need to measure. Absolute numbers in economic analysis usually mean nothing. If we say that the budget deficit is $300 billion in a given year we have no idea whether that is a dangerously large deficit or a small relatively manageable one. It is only after we compare it to Gross Domestic Product that we get an idea of its impact. So the first thing we have to do is to measure the budget deficit as a percentage of GDP. Though usually all attention is focused on the amount of federal borrowing, since states and localities often do significant amounts of borrowing for capital projects, it is important to also show the borrowing by both levels of government – again, as a percentage of GDP.
The next step in the argument is the alleged impact on interest rates. Since Alan Greenspan focused his discussion on the long-term interest rate (usually the 10-year Treasury bond), we should too. However, unlike the Economic Report of the President, we believe that information that “the 10-year Treasury rate fell below 6 percent in 1998” leaves out some crucial information – what happened to inflation at that time? The real burden of...

Other Papers Like The Clinton Administration

People of Power and Unethical Behavior

923 words - 4 pages American people that his administration would be the “most ethical administration in the history of the country” (Hearne, 1996). Although he meant well when he made this statement, some immoral actions do not support this statement. The unethical behaviors demonstrated by Mr. Clinton range from the White water scandal (while Governor of Arkansas), to being the second president to be impeached by the House of Representatives due to personal

Organizational Analysis Paper

1193 words - 5 pages . Clinton Foundation, the Occupational Safety and Health Administration, and The American Quality Association. Stakeholders The William J. Clinton Foundation as well as the American Heart Association are already working hard collectively to combat the reasons for cardiovascular disease since 2005 ("William J Clinton," 2005). The Connections between the American Heart Association and the William J. Clinton Foundation referred to as the Alliance for a

Legalization Of Medicinal Marijuana

619 words - 3 pages During the Carter, Reagan, and Bush administrations, eight people in the United States were allowed to use marijuana for medicinal purposes under the Compassionate Investigative New Drug program. However, since the Clinton administration no new applications have been accepted. Therefore, other patients who need marijuana to alleviate the nausea and loss of appetite associated with the AIDS viruses and cancer chemotherapy, as well as to treat

Pestle Analysis

981 words - 4 pages entered the public domain.[7] Environment Securing U.S. congressional approval for NAFTA would have been impossible without addressing public concerns about NAFTA’s environmental impact. The Clinton administration negotiated a side agreement on the environment with Canada and Mexico, the North American Agreement on Environmental Cooperation (NAAEC), which led to the creation of the Commission for Environmental Cooperation (CEC) in 1994. To

Effective Human Resource Management

1223 words - 5 pages (Prabhakar & Ram, 2011). Top down chain of importance is one of the procedure utilized as a part of human asset administration and contemporary individuals administration in which the approaches are shaped and investigated by a board of senior directors and these arrangements are then exchanged and actualized to the downstream workers without the assent of the people (Guest & Clinton, 2013). In spite of the fact that, the strategies of the

Same-Sex Marriage, Equality, and the Decision to Overturn DOMA

3810 words - 16 pages was clear that the President was going to lose this battle. After what was regarded as a fiasco on gays in the military, the Administration entered a phase of deep reluctance to tackle substantive gay-rights issues on the national stage. Although Clinton made a number of first-ever, high-profile appointments of gay leaders to his team, any kind of gay-rights policy agenda seemed stalled as a result of the Don’t Ask Don’t Tell hangover

Ten Trillion and Counting

616 words - 3 pages “Ten Trillion and Counting,” presented by Frontline provides quite a picture of America’s national debt as it surpasses the trillion dollar mark. They ponder the financial well being of current and future retirees while also exposing on how America got into this mess, and what the Obama administration plans to do during his term. America is able to close the gap year to year in its national budget by selling bonds and T-bills. Foreigner

The Crisis of Crimea and Ukraine

3916 words - 16 pages secretary of defense, the partnership effort continued to deepen political and military ties, create joint capabilities, and contribute further to the strengthening of Euro-Atlantic area security. Senior Clinton administration officials—including Defense Policy Chief Walt Slocombe and the late Joe Kruzel, who was killed in a tragic roadside accident in Bosnia—joined their State Department and NATO colleagues in building the key elements of the new

The United States’ Failure Of Battling International Terrorism Under Clinton’S Administration

2371 words - 10 pages continue from everywhere [against the United States]” (Russell, p. 93). Failing to achieve any serious damage to bin Laden’s terrorist network, the bombings of Sudan and Afghanistan have provided these extremists with even more motivation to fight against the United States. Even officers within the Clinton administration admitted the fact that retaliation from bin Laden should be expected, as one high-ranking U.S. intelligence official

Welfare Reform

2683 words - 11 pages both houses of Congress was the threat of Communism. During in 1930's in the US there were mass lay-offs. This caused mass demonstrations by the workers. The administration was scared and felt there was a threat to the American way of life and more importantly a threat to Capitalism. In the 1930's, Communism was a new idea and the negative results of the system was not yet clear. President Roosevelt realized this and did everything in his power

American Passivity: Rwanda Genocide

3055 words - 13 pages vast slaughter occurred which claimed the lives of more that 800,000 Rwandans. This genocide is probably the greatest and gravest crime against humanity in the second half of the twentieth-century; and no group whether foreign or indigenous executed enough force to prevent this from occurring. The United States stood by and watched the horrific events unfold. The Clinton administration, facing what was the clearest case of genocide in 50 years

Related Essays

William Jefferson Clinton Essay

1015 words - 5 pages introduced by Ronald Reagan but was bitterly opposed by Democrats at the time.[9] It was obvious to practically everyone that the welfare system was very nearly out of control by the mid-1990s, and the Clinton administration introduced changes that required the able-bodied to work to continue receiving benefits. This was not a stance that Clinton particularly wanted to take on the issue, but his advisers had “told him that it might impair his

Bill Clinton Essay

2114 words - 9 pages . After 12 years of Republican control of the presidency, Clinton came to office amid high expectations for fundamental policy change. Early in his administration he reversed a number of Republican policies. He ended the federal prohibition on the use of fetal tissue for medical research, repealed rules restricting abortion counseling in federally funded health clinics, and used his appointment power to fulfill a promise to place many women and

Fdr Vs Clinton Essay

784 words - 4 pages increase employment. This includes the Federal Relief Administration, that gave $3 million to states to pay wages for work projects as well as direct dole payments. The Tennessee Valley Act dammed up the Tennessee river and created jobs, inexpensive hydroelectric power, cheap nitrates, improved navigation of the river, low cost housing, reforestation, and the restoration of eroded soil. Clinton has also worked for lower unemployment rates

Bill Clinton About Presidency Essay

1089 words - 5 pages debt. A whopping two thirds will go toward entitlement, one sixth for defense programs and another one-sixth for "non- defense discretionary spending" (Rauch 2). Perhaps the most touted aspect of the initial Clinton administration was its ability to "create" jobs. According to the White House, almost six million jobs have been created in the past four years, and the unemployment rate in Texas has dropped from 7.5% to 5.8% (Progress 1). This