The Case Of Paying For Organ Donation

616 words - 3 pages

Outline Critical Analysis
The Case of Paying for Organ Donation

Opening summary
Article’s purpose
and thesis:

Dr. Sally Satel is a psychiatrist and professor at Yale University. Dr. Satel’s essay on

“The Case of Paying for Organ Donors,” shows how there is a shortage of organ donors in

society. Dr. Satel, suggests that financial and other incentives should be introduced to raise more

transplant organs. In The Case for Paying Organ Donors, legalizing a through, well structured

and stringently monitored compensation program for organ donation will aid in significantly

reducing the two major reasons that allow for the successful existence of underground markets

and corrupt organizations. There would be a dire shortage of organs available and the

desperation that patients experience waiting for a transplant. In conjunction with a well

organized enforcement of a ban on the trafficking of human organs is the best solution to ...view middle of the document...

B. The incentives would be provided by a third party such as a governmental entity,

charity or insurer; not by individual patients. Such a program would help reduce

the amount of people from wealthy countries seeking the assistance of illegal brokers,

while increasing the amount of lives saved through legal and reputable protocols.

I. A successful reduction in the illegal trafficking of human organs can best be

accomplished by eliminating the illegal product and replacing it with legally donated

organs within a diverse rewards program.

A. Cracking down on organ trafficking, while prohibiting compensation to legally

acquired donations fails to address the newly created shortage in the amount of

organs available.

B. An effort to eliminate illegal trafficking alone will only force these illegal

organizations to become more secretive and elusive, increasing the risk to

recipients of receiving an inferior organ. In paragraph 16, Satel admits that

altruism in not enough. Twelve citizens in the European Union die daily because

they could not survive the wait for a transplant. In the U.S., 18 people die each


Conclusion: Satel has a strong argument, stating that those opposing organ donation fear that the

option of offering an organ for payment purposes will likely attract the poor and needy in

society. Therefore, the poor and needy are more likely to be exploited. In order to avoid such

scenarios, Satel emphasizes the need to empower the poor with education and relevant

information to avoid exploitation. Satel’s reasoning that giving incentives would raise the

amount of donors is a strong argument that cannot be dismissed without critical evaluation.

Awarding incentives not only benefits the donor it will save the life of the recipient. On the

other hand her argument that ethical consideration should not be considered when seeking organ

donation is a weak point, society is made up of ethics and people must respect these ethics.

Other Papers Like The Case Of Paying For Organ Donation

Innovating for the Bottom of the Pyramid - Case Study

863 words - 4 pages Innovating for the bottom of the pyramid 1. Why are companies such as Siemens, GE and Procter and Gamble targeting the “bottom of the pyramid”? These companies are targeting the bottom of the pyramid because this segment represents two-thirds of the world’s population (4 billion people). However, those people live on less than $2 per day and 1.5 billion people have no access to electricity. Companies such as the ones mentioned above have

A Case For The Leagalization Of All Drugs

2305 words - 10 pages A Case for the Legalization of DrugsThe beginning of the twenty first century has brought upon a new age of optimism and wonder. Despite all of the announcements on television, our world is far from being drug free. Our societies have given in to the modern war on drugs, which is being fought against our own citizens across the United States. An international effort to stop drug production and use has failed, leaving distress and political chaos

The Case For Work For The Dole

857 words - 4 pages retirement. And competition is strong. Each year it becomes stronger - each year thousands more students join the ranks of the unemployed, and long term unemployment, especially amongst youth, is a real problem. The Government's "Work for the Dole" Scheme is a much-needed positive step that is helping youth make the transition from student, to unemployed, to employee. Each year 25,000 places in the Scheme are available, 20,000 of which are

Case For C Of C

605 words - 3 pages has to meet. In the case, Janet Mortensen prepared the annual cost of capital estimates for Midland Energy Resources Inc. and each of its three divisions. Estimates of the cost of capital were used in many analyses within Midland, including asset appraisal for both capital budgeting and financial accounting, performance assessments, M&A proposal, and stock repurchase decisions. No, they were using the formula for WACC to estimate the

The Case for, or Against New Orleans

2527 words - 11 pages Jason Coleman 06-11-12 New Orleans Recommendation Paper The Case For, or Against, New Orleans Management Decision Models B6025 Dr. Usha Dasari We will look at many factors in our case for rebuilding or not rebuilding New Orleans. This recommendation will be reviewed by state and local governments for their decision. We will perform a Cost-Benefit Analysis which will represent the residents of New Orleans, the residents of the surrounding

The Case For And Against Drug Testing

982 words - 4 pages policy. The cause for this dilemma is the fact that upper management has been notified of two separate incidents in the past two months of possible drug abuse (Ivancevich, 2010). In this case study, I believe that the company should establish a drug-testing program. I believe that every company or business should have a drug-testing policy. There are many pros and cons to utilizing a drug-testing program but the biggest positive out ways everything

The Case For And Against Buffer Stocks

825 words - 4 pages Evaluate the case for and against using a buffer stock scheme to stabilise the price of a commodity such as sugar or tin. A buffer stock scheme is an intervention carried out by the government which aims to limit fluctuations in the price of a commodity. But is it the best way to stabilise the price of a commodity like sugar or tin? Consider what would happen if there was no intervention in a commodity market, such as sugar: In the

Case of the Man

2588 words - 11 pages whole group, whether it is to be done in a training session, or a mandatory meeting. I recommend that the executives of the company that make the decision or rules, need to get with a member of the Human Resource Department and put it together in an official memo, or have it Donna Tuman Organizational Behavior Week # 7, Case Study 3 incorporated into the SOP’s for the company. This was done in my company by the HR manager going around

The Summary of Carrefour Case

572 words - 3 pages denominated in euro currency. Over the past five years, the euro had depreciated against most major currencies. So it leads to an increase of expense for Carrefour’s domestic operation as it has to deal with exchange rate movement. Moreover, the company has to consider other economic factors that influence the firm’s cash flow which are inflation and interest rate. However, the company might face with exchange rate movement when the firm

Case Of The Unpopular Pay

7368 words - 30 pages , much of that advice is wrong. disk drive manufacturer in Milpitas, California, for example, demonstrates its eommitment to teamwork by placing all employees, from tbe CEO to bourly workers, on tbe same bonus plan, tracking everyone by the same measure-in this case, return on total capital. Compensation is also a concept and practice very mucb in flux. Compensation is becoming more variable as companies base a greater proportion of it on stock

The Case of Billy Tushoes

1072 words - 5 pages circumstances? If not, why not? 2) Identify the stakeholders and their interests in this case. 3) Evaluate the alternative courses of action for Billy using ethical reasoning. What should Billy do? Why? You may wish to refer to pgs. 70-73 of the supplemental text and pgs. 78-82 of your textbook when developing your answer. The case of Billy Tushoes is a common ethical dilemma that many people are faced with when considering the acceptance of

Related Essays

The Principal Of Family Determination In Organ Donation

4064 words - 17 pages PART A: The Principal of family determination in organ donation ABSTRACT: This article is written by Mingxu wang,, Wen zang, Xueliang Wang. In this article the point which is stressed upon is that wether family should be given the right to give consent for organ donation of a person if he himself has not stated any statement regarding his will on organ donation. Many ethical views of different societies are discussed

The Current Organ Donation System Is Not Working

651 words - 3 pages work, so they each kept a record of their journey times for a few weeks. Janet's daily journey times, x minutes, for a period of 25 days, were summarised by = 2120 and = 180 044. Calculate the mean and standard deviation of Janet's journey times. [3] John's journey times had a mean of 79.7 minutes and a standard deviation of 6.22 minutes. Describe briefly, in everyday terms, how Janet and John's

Case Study Of “The Quest For Innovation”

1205 words - 5 pages history.  Case Study of “The quest for innovation” Cultures of Technology Culture matters—this has been one of the most often-heard messages. It matters in its attempts to explain why economic opportunities have been seized in one country or region, and why economic failures have occurred in another. It matters not only for economic development, but also for political development. It promotes change—or impedes it. It matters when corporations with

The Case For Christ Essay

2068 words - 9 pages The Case for Christ: A Journalist’s Personal Investigation of the Evidence for Jesus A Critical Book Review Lee Strobel, New York Times bestselling author of twenty books, including four which received ECPA awards, is an atheist turned Christian after a two year investigation of Jesus. He became a Christian in 1981. Strobel worked at the Chicago Tribune for 14 years as an award winning legal editor. He has a Bachelor of Journalism which he