The Carpenter's Wife A Critical Essay

667 words - 3 pages

The Carpenter’s Wife

During the telling of “The Miller's Tale” within The Canterbury Tales, Chaucer goes to great lengths to describe the character of Alison, the carpenter's wife. This is done not only so readers will have a detailed physical portrayal of her in their minds, but also so they can make inferences as to her character by the way she chooses to presents herself. The vivid depiction of Alison implies that she has very little value except as an object to be used for sexual gain by men. Furthermore, the lengthy, highly descriptive examination of her character when weighed against the almost nonexistent description of her husband creates such a contrast that the reader feels as if it is wrong for the two to be together.

Chaucer begins by very briefly detailing the aspects of herself that she has no control over: she is 18 years old, fair, slender, and delicate. He follows this with a description of each article of ...view middle of the document...

The unstained white of her apron and undergarments give her the outward appearance of purity, while the reader knows that internally she is far from pure.

Following the account of Alison's clothing comes a brief personality description. Rather than humanize her, the personalities attributed to her give her an animalistic nature. She is compared to a calf in the way she enjoys skipping and playing games, and then to a colt because of her skittishness and high spirits. Her voice is also said to be as sweet as any bird's, and she is compared to a “pimerole, a piggesnye” (line 160), all three of which were animal traits considered desirable in a woman at the time. Adding to her dehumanization are lines between the detailing of her clothing and those of her personality that describe her as more aesthetically pleasing “than is the newe perejonette tree” (line 140). Even though she is depicted as something between animal and object, Chaucer by no means considers her worthless. On the contrary, he describes her as having a radiance that is brighter, and therefore more desirable, than gold.

Upon completing the full description of Alison, the reader is left with the overall impression that such a woman could never be meant to be kept inside by her much older husband. It then becomes practically expected for the young scholar to steal her away from the always jealous carpenter, and it makes Nicholas's actions seem to be the right and natural thing to do, cementing his role as the story's hero.

Works Cited
Chaucer, Geoffrey. “The Miller’s Prologue and Tale.” The Norton Anthology of English Literature, Volume A The Middle Ages. 8th ed. New York: W. W. Norton, 2005. 239-55. Print.

Forbes, Shannon “‘To Alison Now Wol I Tellen Al My Love-Longing’: Chaucer’s Treatment of the Courtly Love Discourse in The Miller’s Tale.” Women’s Studies: An Interdisciplinary Journal 36.1 (2007): 1-14. MLA International Bibliography. EBSCO. Web. 7 Oct. 2009.

Jordan, Tracey “Fairy Tale and Fabliau: Chaucer’s The Miller’s Tale.” Studies in Short Fiction 21.2 (1984): 87-93. MLA International Bibliography. EBSCO. Web. 7 Oct. 2009.

Other Papers Like The Carpenter's Wife - a Critical Essay

Chaucer's Canterbury Tales Essay - Dominance And Control In The Wife Of Bath

1373 words - 6 pages Dominance and Control in Chaucer's The Wife of Bath's Tale      The Wife of Bath, the main character in Geoffrey Chaucer's "The Wife of Bath's Tale" recognizes dominance over her husband as the main purpose of her life and her story.         The Wife of Bath is a controlling and headstrong woman.  She craves dominance over her husbands.  She believes that, in order to be her husband, the man must be subservient and that she is the

The Manager as a Critical Thinker

1451 words - 6 pages October 17, 2010   Purpose The purpose of this paper is to evaluate the position of a memo from the Human Resources Vice President of Triad Insurance Company of Indianapolis (TICI) applying the 10 steps of critical thinking. To begin, the authors of asking the right questions, a guide to Critical thinking define values “as the unstated ideas that people see as worthwhile.” They also identify four primary values of a critical thinker

Defending The Free Market: A Critical Analysis

634 words - 3 pages Defending the Free Market: Critical Analysis Defending the Free Market written by Rev. Robert Sirico is a book about how being a leftist seems like a very moral and right thing to do for people but in turn is not very economically sound. He talks about how back in his younger days he was a socialist and leftist but in turn with many talks with people and intense fact searching he figured out how the free-market system is the only way to

This Essay Is Talking About How It Is Significant That A Miller Tells "The Millers Tale" And How It Is Significant That The Wife Of Bath Tells Her Tale

1476 words - 6 pages "The Millers tale" and "The Wife of Baths" tale are both part of "The Canterbury Tales"Written by, Geoffrey Chaucer. Chaucer removes himself from these tales by saying that he is just repeating the tales that were told to him. "For, as you all must know as well as I, to tell a tale told by another man you must repeat as nearly as you can each word, if that's the task you've undertaken, however coarse or broad his language is; or, in the telling

To What Extent Do You See the Wife of Bath as a Feminist or Masaganist

814 words - 4 pages To what extent do you see the wife of bath as a feminist or misogynistic caricature? Throughout the prologue, The Wife of Bath is often shameless of the way she has exploited herself in a sexual manor and how she gains power and status. However, by doing these things, she confirms negative stereotypes about women and shows them to be deceitful. Although at some points her actions may seem to be justified as they are a rebellion against a

Literary Analysis: "The Man Who Mistook His Wife For A Hat"

2134 words - 9 pages A narrative is constructed to elicit a particular response from its audience. In the form of a written story, authors use specific narrative strategies to position the ‘ideal reader’ to attain the intended understanding of the meanings in the text. Oliver Sacks’ short story The Man Who Mistook His Wife for a Hat is an unusual short story because it does not display conventional plot development; the story does not contain conflict or resolution

Oliver Sacks's The Man Who Mistook His Wife For A Hat

1283 words - 6 pages Oliver Sacks's The Man who Mistook his Wife for a Hat As a child, I watched Alfred Hitchcock Theater, The Twilight Zone and other science fiction or horror shows. Often times the storyline was based on a victim's mental problems or their skewed perception of the world. Looking back, I remember the fascination I felt when watching one specific episode of the Twillight Zone. In this particular episode, a man turned into a zombie by some type

Oliver Sacks, The Man Who Mistook His Wife For A Hat

1651 words - 7 pages The Man Who Mistook His Wife for a HatMr. P, a music teacher, whose associates have questioned his perception, is referred by his ophthalmologist to the neurologist Oliver Sacks. During the first office visit, Sacks notices that Mr. P faces him with his ears, not his eyes. His gaze seems unnatural, darting and fixating on the doctor's features one at a time. To begin with, there are only a few quirks about him that Dr. Sacks notices. There was

Critical Essay. the Poor Economic Climate in the Uk and the Affect's on the Marketing Mix of a Start-Up Retail Venture in the High Street

1955 words - 8 pages Assignment 1 Critical Essay Introduction: This essay will attempt to critically explain how the poor economic climate in the UK might affect the marketing mix of a start-up retail venture in the high street. This essay will walk through the processes of starting a retail business venture in the high street and discuss how the economy and the marketing mix directly effects each step. To do this it will be vital to explore the current

The Relationship Between Critical Thinking And Ethics Essay

620 words - 3 pages The Relationship between Critical Thinking and Ethics GEN/201 July 27, 2014 The Relationship between Critical Thinking and EthicsCritical thinking is when exercising or involving careful judgment or judicious evaluation. (Version 3.0.3)  This means you take all the facts to narrow down the decisions of a situation or problem. In critical thinking there are six types of thinking, as described by psychologist Benjamin Bloom. They are

Critical Essay of Dunbar's Poem "We Wear the Mask"

1553 words - 7 pages life to the fullest. A CRITICAL ANALYSIS OF DUNBAR’S POEM “WE WEAR THE MASK” _______________ Presented to: DR. ANGEL O. PESIRLA Cebu Normal University Osmeña Blvd, Cebu City In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements of the Course LITERATURE 4002 (Research in Literary Theory, Criticism and Historicism) _______________ By Geraldine L. Bejoc 3 Critique A LITERARY ANALYSIS OF THE FABLE THE MONKEY AND THE

Related Essays

The President’s Wife And I: A Comparison

1979 words - 8 pages CWV101 - GCU August 26, 2013 The President’s Wife and I: A Comparison How in all of space and time can I legitimately compare myself to President Franklin D. Roosevelt’s Lady, Eleanor Roosevelt, without becoming overwhelmed by the magnitude of her greatness? A comparison between her and I is ill-advised for so many reasons. I might discover that Eleanor Roosevelt is more than a million times fantastic than I am. On the other hand, I might

An Essay On "The Doctor And The Doctor's Wife"

1221 words - 5 pages An Essay on ”The Doctor and the Doctor’s Wife” By Ernest Hemingway Seemingly, masculinity is a big part of men’s identity. Masculinity is usually associated with courage, independence, and assertiveness, and if a man’s pride is discriminated or somehow threatened, he will often do whatever is necessary to regain his pride. Thus, this might result in unethical behaviour. This is dealt with in Ernest Hemingway’s short story “The Doctor and

Essay Written By Marilyn Yalom, "The Wife Today"

692 words - 3 pages A popular essay written by Marilyn Yalom, "The Wife Today", focuses on the latest trends in the role of the wife against the background of traditional expectations. In her essay, Yalom argues that many common perceptions about today's women are inaccurate.Yalom's essay makes it clear to the reader that the main point of her writing is to raise women's awareness of their ability to choose wifehood. American wives today have many reasons to work

A Critical Reflective Essay On My Roles And Contributions In The Task Of “Business”

2320 words - 10 pages A Critical Reflective Essay on My Roles and Contributions in the Task of “Business” The residential weekend was a really delightful holiday and a meaningful experience in my postgraduate study. That teamwork training was very unforgettable, even though time passing so long. During those three days training, there are lots of impressive events happened. Through looks at those events with a critical eye, those make me changed and certainly I