This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Battle Over Safe Injection Sites

1960 words - 8 pages

Insite: The Battle over Supervised Injection Sites

In the 1990’s there was an epidemic of HIV outbreaks in the Downtown Eastside of Vancouver. Injection drug users were found to be the leading cause of this, and a public health emergency was declared (Fafard, 2012). The “mortality and morbidity” resulting from this increasing injection drug use became a major political issue. This resulted in the adoption of harm reduction by the government as one of their four pillars of their drug strategy (Fafard, 2012). Harm reduction “is a set of practical strategies and ideas aimed at reducing negative consequences associated with drug use” (Boyd, 2013). In September 2003 Insite, North Americas ...view middle of the document...

There seems to be a serious disconnect between advocates of harm reduction strategies and the Canadian Government when it comes to the implementation of Safe Injection sites. Safe injection site advocates seem to draw on rational knowledge and scientific evidences whereas the Conservative government arguments draw on reasons that are more moral/ideological in nature. The main claims made by the Conservatives are that SISs encourage drug use instead of providing treatment, they are harmful to our communities and promote associated crime, they are not cost effective, and that it is not ethical for health care professionals to support the administration of illegal drugs (Collier, 2008). The overall intent of my essay will be to explore the ongoing Safe Injection Sites debate in Canada by looking at the government’s arguments and comparing them with the body of scientific evidence available.
One of the arguments presented by the Conservatives is that SIS facilities encourage or facilitate the use of drugs (Elliott et al., 2002). The underlying concern is that SISs send out the wrong messages to the wider public. By reducing harm individuals may be more enticed and more will engage in use, which will lead to the community of drug users increasing. Studies were done to evaluate whether the opening of Insite was accompanied by a worsening community of drug use patterns (Kerr et al., 2006) Unfortunately for the Conservatives all the studies done have shown no increase of drug users in the community (Potier et al., 2014). Taking away the harms of injecting drugs did not encourage increased drug use and did not increase their risks of overdosing (Kerr et al., 2006). There was also no increase of users relapsing into injection drug use, nor did it negatively influence those seeking to stop drug use (Kerr et al., 2006). The research shows that Insite has not promoted increased illicit drug injection, but rather it has attracted individuals with histories of injection drug use.
Another claim put forth by the Conservatives is that SISs are harmful to communities. They believe SISs create public nuisances, and threaten public safety (Broadhead, Kerr & Alice, 2002). Research on the other hand argues that SISs can address issues related to public. Since Insite opened the public has noticed less public injections, less syringe droppage, and less complaints about drug user nuisances (Potier et al., 2014). It also cleans up public environment such as streets and alleyways. Drug use is still an illicit activity and it takes place in unsterile environments such as behind dumpsters and shooting galleries. SISs provide sterile environments for users and are a lot safer than shooting up in the streets. This leads to less public injection and a better community environment (Potier et al., 2014). Local police data was also evaluated and there has been no increase in crime, violence, or drug trafficking around Insite. There were no significant statistical changes...

Other Papers Like The Battle over Safe Injection Sites

Computer Network Essay

2859 words - 12 pages noncompeting users of a trademark can lawfully register the same mark, these companies are not able to spot their sites with an identical incorporation of the mark into a domain name notwithstanding the fact that the two companies sold dissimilar goods and operated in different countries. Cyberspace is used in disseminating information, expanding networks and generating commercial opportunities. Cyberspace engenderstransboundary disputes over trademarks

Diesel Engine Essay

3799 words - 16 pages injection system applied by Herbert Akroyd Stuart for his hot bulb engine. The indirect injection engine could be considered the latest development of these low speed hot bulb ignition engines. 2 Mechanical and electronic injection Many configurations of fuel injection have been used over the past century (1901–2000). Most present day (2008) diesel engines use a mechanical single plunger high-pressure fuel pump driven by

Sec571 Security Concerns Regarding

1697 words - 7 pages and Microsoft Exchange. Security Vulnerabilities The two Security vulnerabilities that I am going to document are VPN Tunnel potential security breaches as well as SQL Injection attacks. These are the two areas that I believe the organization has not looked at as potential risks for issues. Security Vulnerabilities The first threat that I want to elaborate on is a hardware vulnerability that is inherent in the use of VPN Tunnels. The main

Stem Cell Therapy

936 words - 4 pages developed at the injection sites, moreover, hemodialysis and hematuria were noticed. Patient’s symptoms gradually deteriorated and finally died of sepsis after 2 years have passed (Thirabanjasak et al, 2010). These cases raise even more questions in stem cell therapy. Although there are some risk factors in using stem cell for therapeutic approaches, hematopoietic stem cell therapy by bone marrow transplantation has already been proofed to be

Euro 4 - Role of Diesel Fuel Injection Systems

4445 words - 18 pages Euro 4 and Beyond –Role of Diesel Fuel Injection Systems Dr. Gerhard Ziegler General Manager (R&D and Application) Motor Industries Co. Copyright © 2004 SAE International ABSTRACT The Euro 4 emission norms can be achieved by the wellnd rd known 2 and 3 generation Common Rail Systems of BOSCH. The beyond Euro 4 emission legislation is a challenging goal for diesel engine manufacturers. Lowest emissions with highest engine performance


488 words - 2 pages industry tried everything possible to draw viewers to their sites. Children were exposed to explicit harmful material during school hours. Pornographic images by leaving library terminals open and print outs on printers. Congress became very concerned .and tried many times to protect children from the dangers of the internet. Children’s Internet Protection Act of 2000 was passed, but continuously became an ongoing battle. This laws purpose

Web Application Attack Scenario

1111 words - 5 pages information gathered through scavenging include, server software, type of operating system firewall and the application software. This risk highly lies at the client side with information travelling over the HTTP channel listened to, such as SOAP messages and WSDL files (Shema, 2010). Tampering: This involves monitoring of data on communication channel, data residing on the client’s computer or on the server side. This is done to uncover passwords or

Hepatitis B

971 words - 4 pages series of three to four shots over the course of a six month period. The consequences of people not taking precautions and steps to keep themselves safe from Hepatitis B will in turn create more and more infected people who will continue to spread the virus and cause an epidemic. Many people could potentially be chanced with potentially life threatening illnesses. There are many community and health organizations that have information on

Security Issues and Solutions in E-Commerce Applications

2185 words - 9 pages origination will be made with the goal emphasizing the prevention of attacks. There are numerous tactics that exploiters use to gain access to user personal and financial information on ecommerce sites. One common attack is SQL injection, which is a tactic where a hacker inserts SQL query data into user input fields on a web site, with the goal of that query being executed by the database. With the strategic placement of apostrophes, dashes and semi

Comm/156 Research Essay

838 words - 4 pages For 22 years, John Doe assumed the identity of a man whose wallet was stolen from his car in 1989. This form of identity theft will change over time to evolve to possibly affect any one who accesses the World Wide Web. Even though crime exists in the real world equally as it is online, The Internet is solely responsible for most of the Identity theft crimes. Crime exists in the real world equally as it is online. As much as

Motorcycle Safety

579 words - 3 pages motorcyclists to be seen on the road to be a vital cause for motorcycle accidents on the road (Wells , et al , 2004 The study was conducted over a period of three years in Auckland , New Zealand where the authors selected 150 survey sites on major motorways The study was conducted on random times between six in the morning and midnight on different days of the week and different directions of travel . The participants of the survey were randomly selected on

Related Essays

The Battle Over Talk Shows Essay

1542 words - 7 pages and not facts. He said that he had asked his staff to provide a list of some of the show's topics which concludes that he never really2watched any of them himself. Bennett also puts all talk shows in the bottom of his so called "television barrel" because they go over the line of decency. Personally, I do not think that all talk shows are bad at all. (Bennett 24). I think that Bennett should get facts and also he should view the shows content

Cyber Crime Essay

1364 words - 6 pages use of attacker-supplied data. Insufficient input validation and improper construction of SQL statements in web applications can expose them to SQL injection attacks. SQL injection is such a prevalent and potentially destructive attack that the Open Web Application Security Project (OWASP) lists it as the number one threat to web applications. [4] This particular attack occurred over a number of months, targeting two banks

Toothbrush Manufacturing Process Essay

632 words - 3 pages properly packaged so that they remain sterile until they are ready to be used. Packaging machines will form the container to the correct size and seal it around the toothbrush so that dirt and germs cannot get into the packaging. Justification and Conclusion Injection plastic molding process has many advantages over other plastic molding processes as listed below: Ø Once a job is set up, injection molding can produce very high production output rates

Computer Tricks Essay

3238 words - 13 pages . Cookies can be used as tokens, which servers hand over to clients in order to allow access to Web sites; however, cookies are not perfect in terms of security, because they can be copied and stored on the client’s local hard disk so that users do not have to request a token for each query. Figure 3-1 shows the Web applications running on servers to provide services to client Web applications. The presentation layer takes input and displays the