This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Amnesty Plan Essay

3058 words - 13 pages

The Solution to Illegal Immigration
Michael Mays
ENG 102: Composition II
February 10, 2012

The Plan of Amnesty
How much would it cost to put 10 Million people in busses or airplanes and ship them back to their countries of origin? Is there a better way to deal with illegal immigration in the United States? Is the answer a strict and enforceable amnesty, allowing illegal immigrants to report themselves in order to achieve legal status, or is mass deportation of the estimated 10 million illegal aliens living in the U.S. the solution? A well laid-out, simplified, yet fair and enforceable amnesty plan could solve the multi-billion dollar battle of amnesty, ...view middle of the document...

Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) currently “detains nearly 400,000 immigrants per year at a cost of nearly $1.8 billion” (Greenblatt, 2010). Detaining thousands of immigrants who do not pose an outright threat to the country or community has many groups in a financial and humanitarian uproar.
Illegal immigration and the lack of strong laws enforced by the US government have prompted many states to begin drafting immigration laws within themselves. Arizona passed a very strong law that basically and very simply enforces “failure to carry immigration documents a crime and gives police broad powers to detain anyone suspected of being in the country illegally” (Greenblatt, 2010). South Carolina, Pennsylvania, Minnesota, Rhode Island, Michigan and Illinois have all begun to implement similar laws to Arizona as they feel Congress has not taken a strong enough stance. Lawmakers are calling for help in patrolling and controlling their borders as they feel it will ensure the safety and economy of their state.
Many people, especially politicians such as Republican Presidential hopeful Mitt Romney, will say that amnesty is not the answer but so few give actual solutions to the constant illegal immigration debate. This has resulted in a virtual stand-still in the progress of dealing with the issue is a major reason that no good solution to illegal immigration has been found. Many people feel amnesty is going too easy on illegal aliens yet deportation is costly and inhumane, so where is the middle ground?
What is amnesty? Most people hear amnesty and think that this would be allowing illegal immigrants to be forgiven for illegally entering the United States and achieving legal status even after doing so. This is not fully accurate and the topic can be quite blurred. Not everyone is aware of the full definition or the plans that President Obama and the US Amnesty Organization have outlined. The current proposed immigration amnesty plan would forgive the estimated 12 to 20 million illegal aliens currently living in the US for entering the country illegally, using false documents to drive and gain employment and give them a clear way to become legal citizens. President Obama feels this would strengthen relations with Mexico and bring people out of hiding. The plan is summarized as “a system that requires undocumented immigrants who are in good standing to pay a fine, learn English, and go to the back of the line for the opportunity to become citizens” (Jost, 2009). The hope is also to reduce the number of illegal immigration-related crimes and hopefully create a safer border for everyone.
In what is seen as a cautious step towards amnesty, the cities of Denver and Baltimore are reviewing thousands of deportation cases to determine which illegal immigrants might stay in the country - perhaps indefinitely - so officials can reduce a huge backlog by focusing mainly on detainees with criminal backgrounds or who are deemed threats to national...

Other Papers Like The Amnesty Plan

“Increasing Profits Without The Pain” Essay

542 words - 3 pages EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 1 a. Pick a small or medium-sized business that you know something about. Write a short description of the company followed by a plan of 3-4 sentences in which you describe how you would go about determining which of your products or services are not profitable. Conclude this part of your Executive Summary with a sentence or two to describe the impact on your clients or customers if you stopped offering the unprofitable

Robin Hood Essay

4029 words - 17 pages   office.  If  the  plan  is  successful  they  will  be  granted  amnesty  for  the  crimes  they  committed, otherwise Prince John’s men will pursue them in search for revenge.  13  The  band  is struggling with a lack of food and  it is getting harder for Robin to control the men and   maintain  discipline.  Thus,  a  quicker  plan  will  be  necessary,  such  as  rationing  the  use  of  the  available resources and improving discipline

America’S Post-Civil War Growing Pains

1050 words - 5 pages amnesty to any southerner who proclaimed loyalty to the Union and support of the emancipation of slaves: once 10 percent of a state’s voters in the election of 1860 signed the oath, it could create a new state government and reenter the Union (Schultz, 2012). After he was assassinated, Andrew Johnson became president and scraped the “40 acres and a mule” plan offered by the Freedman’s Bureau and also introduced a tougher pardon for the southern

Different Aspects on Immigration Policies

1819 words - 8 pages never predicted or proposed, will never be formulated into a policy. Immigration on the other hand is a fierce debate nowadays. The immigration problem, like some other challenges (drugs, healthcare reform), can be related to more than one aspect. It can be related as a crime, related to drug trafficking or job losses. This is a highly complex challenge. For example, in the outcome that the new policy will approve amnesty for the

Robin Case

910 words - 4 pages . Cons: is that Robin has little experience in court intrigue. He could be getting himself into something that was beyond his expertise. He could be getting in a little over his head. Not only that, but if it failed, Robin could lose everything -- including his life and the lives of his friends. Pros: if successful, he would be granted future amnesty. That would mean that he'd have his lands, his fortunes, and his status restored in the kingdom

Reconstruction and the West

894 words - 4 pages run a government. In 1863, President Lincoln was more interested in putting together his Ten-Percent Plan that offered amnesty to any southerner who proclaimed loyalty to the union and support emancipation of the slaves (Schultz, 2012, p.3). This was an attempt to bridge the gap between the north and the south with the hopes of gaining freedom for the slaves; however, the war divided the country and left it in peril. Further complicating

Juvenile Justice

1439 words - 6 pages .Referral orders are a must for typical sentences imposed on youthful offenders irrespective of the magnitude of the offense. The important aspect is that the youth performs those crimes, the minors who plead guilty and have no previous convictions. Other concepts include neo-governance, conditional inclusion and remoralization, zero tolerance and incarceration (Amnesty International). The state should guardYouth justice should be at all cost


1153 words - 5 pages America’s Post-Civil War Growing Pains Alyssa Harpster Dr. James Allen History 105 January 27, 2013 There were three major turning points during the period of 1865 -1900. (Schultz, 2012) states that reconstruction is the federal government’s attempt to resolve the issues resulting from the end of the Civil War. Lincoln (Schultz 2012) says issued a ten-percent plan offered amnesty to

Hum 111 - Week 2 - Immigration Reform

705 words - 3 pages come to this country. The irony of the situation is that it may only come after amnesty is granted toward the current ballpark figure of 12,000,000 illegal immigrants in this country. Otherwise, immigration would remain a vehement issue. The scope of issues regarding immigration is immense because of its impact on American productivity and the American way of life for so many people. Individuals and groups from many different walks of life and

America’s Post-Civil War Growing Pains

1327 words - 6 pages all the controversy, Lincoln had the skill to manage the conflict of the Radicals. This was not the case with his replacement, Andrew Johnson, whose plan for reconstruction was completely ignored by Congress. President Andrew Johnson was sworn in to presidency shortly after Lincoln’s death. Johnson implemented his Reconstruction policy initially with two proclamations. One gave recognition to Virginia’s government, the other provided amnesty (a

Robin Hood

1268 words - 6 pages King Richard the Lionheart from his jail in Austria. Robin was invited to join the conspiracy in return for future amnesty. It was a dangerous proposition. Provincial banditry was one thing, court intrigue another. Prince John had spies everywhere and he was known for his vindictiveness. If the conspirators' plan failed, the pursuit would be relentless, and retribution swift. The sound of the supper horn startled Robin from his thoughts

Related Essays

Immigration Inform Essay

2197 words - 9 pages and more than $10 billion increase revenue by 2030. Many Dream Act opponents call it an immigration amnesty. They say the proposal would immediately reward immigrant children with conditional lawful permanent resident status – and, in just a few years, they would become U.S. Citizens. Their criticisms do not reflect how immigration agencies operate immigration reform will be addressed by the Obama administration this year. Republican senators they

Immigration Essay

2187 words - 9 pages study found that when Mexican wages drop ten percent in comparison to U.S. wages, there is a six percent increase in the attempts of illegal immigrants to cross the border illegally (Thornburgh). This is an astonishing result in which shows how complex or corrupt the Mexican economy may be. While Mexico stabilizes itself, there is both political and technological influences to make enforcement a serious part of a new amnesty plan. By enforcing

Dealing With Illegal Essay

1098 words - 5 pages One of the largest legal matters facing our nation is immigration and coming up with a solution on how to deal with Illegal Aliens. The problem that our country is facing deals with not only Illegal Aliens already in our country but illegal’s that will be coming. There have been many plans to deal with the Illegal Aliens in the past and to date there has not been a plan put into place that has worked. It appears that the Federal Government has

About A Boy Essay

942 words - 4 pages with and he is joining a single parents club where he lies about having a son and a former wife who had left him and his son alone. His plan about meeting women at the single club succeeds and he meets Suzie. Will and Suzie plans a picnic together but unfortunately for Will are Suzie taking her friends/Fiona’s 12 year old son Marcus with her. After the picnic Will and Suzie is driving Marcus home they find Marcus’s mom Fiona lying overdosed on