Technology In The Human World Essay

1778 words - 8 pages

Atheists have argued that if there is a God who is omnipotent, omniscient and omnibenevolent, then God would have made a better world than the one in which we live. Many different possible worlds are better than this one. Some have less natural or moral evil than this world, and some even have no natural or moral evils at all. Consequently, there is no God who is omnipotent, omniscient and omnibenevolent because such a God would have made one of those worlds that is better than this one.1
Philosophical theists typically reply to the problem of evil by focusing on one aspect of it, namely on the claim that there are better worlds without moral evil. There are possible worlds with no moral ...view middle of the document...

Alvin Plantinga has challenged this assumption, and this challenge is widely considered to be the definitive reply to Mackie’s critique of the Free Will Defense.2 Plantinga grants that there are possible worlds with freedom and no moral evil, but he argues that it is possible that although God is omnipotent, it is not within God’s power to actualize a world containing freedom and no moral evil. Plantinga believes that the atheologian assumes that it is necessary that it is within an omnipotent God’s power to actualize these better worlds, but in fact, Plantinga argues, this is demonstrably not the case.
Plantinga aims to demonstrate the following proposition:
(P) It is possible God is omnipotent and God does not have the power to actualize a possible world in which there is freedom but no evil.4
It will be immediately noticed that the locution “a possible world” in (P) is ambiguous. It can mean that it is possible God is omnipotent and there are possible worlds W in which there is freedom but no evil and God does not have the power to actualize W. To show this, all Plantinga needs to do is show that there is at least one such possible world. A stronger reading of (P) is that it is possible that God is omnipotent and for any possible world W in which there is freedom but no evil, God does not have the power to actualize W.
Plantinga needs to argue for the stronger reading.5 An argument that shows the weaker existential proposition that there are possible worlds that an omnipotent God does not have the power to actualize fails against the atheist. What about the other possible worlds? After all, the atheist claims against the Free Will Defense that there are possible worlds in which there is 4
freedom and no moral evil that God has the power to actualize. An argument, even if sound, whose conclusion is that there are possible worlds with freedom and no moral evil that an omnipotent God does not have the power to actualize is not a refutation of this claim. The two existential claims are compatible. So a successful refutation of Mackie's problem of evil must arrive at the stronger conclusion that it is possible that an omnipotent God does not have the power to actualize any of the worlds with freedom and no moral evil.

PLATINGA
Robert Adams avers that "it is fair to say that Plantinga has solved this problem. That is,
he has argued convincingly for the consistency of [God and evil]."2 And William Alston
writes that "Plantinga...has established the possibility that God could not actualize a
world containing free creatures that always do the right thing."3
platingas defense
A defense is like a theodicy—it specifies reasons that would justify God's permitting evil--but, unlike a theodicy, it does not aspire to specify reasons which involve actual good states of affairs; rather, the reasons specified in a defense need only involve possible good states of affairs.7 More accurately, a Plantinga-style defense aims to show that
G. God...

Other Papers Like Technology in the Human World

Technology in a Brave New World

1341 words - 6 pages Technology in a Brave New World First let me state that Edwin Jonestown’s article has some truths and some falsehoods in it. Aldous Huxley is trying to envision a world that is so far advanced that it does not parallel our world, but some technology has advanced in today’s society. It is ever present that in the novel Brave New World, there is proof that technology controls humans from the time it is in the test tube. Technology is so good

Adult Learning in a Technology Influenced World

909 words - 4 pages Adult Learning in a Technology Influenced World Summary Adult learning is a hot topic today amongst educators. They must learn to deal with adults across varied age groups, cultural classes and philosophical spectrums. It is not as simple as it was a century ago. Education was structured for the institution and teacher and not the learner. In her article, Sharan Merriam writes that over the last decade adult learning methods and

Hr Design in a Volatile World – Human Resource Planning in the 21st Century

1143 words - 5 pages HR design in a volatile world – human resource planning in the 21st century The increasing globalisation of the marketplace combined with an increasing shortage of skilled staff and advances in technology have resulted in large scale changes in recruitment practices. Recruitment is the process of finding and attracting appropriate job candidates capable of effectively filling the job vacancies available within an organisation. For successful

Technology in the Workplace

772 words - 4 pages Technology in the workplace Technology is an ever increasing aspect of our lives in all facets of society. It is hard to say where we will be in regards to technology in the future, but it is apparent that where ever we go we will always be in contact with a new technological advancement. This increase in technology is touching every part of our lives, from making a cup of coffee, to the way we work. Technological advancements have not just

Techniques - Discuss in Detail How Guterson Uses the Weather and Other Aspects of the Natural World as a Reflection on the World of Human Kind

1062 words - 5 pages Guterson uses many literary techniques in his novel to reflect on his views of the nature of human kind. Through his descriptions of the natural setting of the novel Guterson conveys the significance of San Piedro as a microcosm of the world of human kind, reflecting on the universal thoughts and emotions felt by all of humanity. Particularly, the descriptions of the weather establish parallels between the emotional turmoil of the characters

Women in the Technology Field

1537 words - 7 pages issues. If there was an easier way to encourage women to enter this field it should be done. There are plenty of male dominated work forces throughout the entire world and just a little encouragement from one female can do wonders for the next female to enter the world of technology. There are groups that help young women become more interested in pursuing a career in the technology field. One group is Girls in Technology(GIT), which helps

Technology in the Business Field

1086 words - 5 pages "The New Art of Making Ruins" Havana is a city located in Cuba and it is the capital of the country. It is essential and necessary to explore Havana's history because people can learn about it and understand the culture. The city used to be a role model for other cities in Latin America and may be a role model for other cities around the world. It is a historical city and it used to have a wonderful architecture. Unfortunately, houses

Stereotypes in the World

890 words - 4 pages “Stereotypes in the world” Thesis Statement The world would be a better place to live without the various stereotypes in our society. “Stereotypes in the world” Recently over the past decades television shows have shown off a lot of stereotypes. Some shows like “Family Guy, The Big Bang Theory, and 2 Broke Girls” have shown off stereotypes threw comedy. Did you know that a stereotype is a thought that can be adopted about a specific type

Will in the World

2699 words - 11 pages In Will in the World, Shakespeare scholar Stephen Jay Greenblatt, Cogan University Professor of the Humanities at Harvard, looks to tell the vast audience how a young man from Stratford-upon-Avon became the greatest playwright not only of his own age, but also of all time. Chapter 1: Primal Scenes The first chapter of Will in the World: How Shakespeare Became Shakespeare discusses the scenes that Greenblatt considers to be the

Human Condition in The Plague

793 words - 4 pages what it takes sometimes? Personal pain to help us see and change? The three characters who most depict the human condition are Dr. Bernard Rieux, Joseph Grand, and Cottard. In a sense, each possesses characteristics which illustrate both positives of the human condition. Dr. Rieux embodies the definition of a hero. However, even though he realizes that the plague he is fighting cannot be stopped, he refuses to quit. Emotionally, he feels for his

Human Motivation in the Workplace

2016 words - 9 pages Human Motivation WLJ 1 Motivating an individual to improve performance has always been without disregards one of the most difficult philosophy to comprehend. There has been several research conducted to determine what best motivate employees, and how they can improve performance while decreasing turnovers. According to Dan Pink, a career analyst; he believes that intrinsic motivation can be more effective than incentive motivations. In his

Related Essays

Meeting Human Services Challenges With Technology Bshs 352 Technology In Human Services

1574 words - 7 pages The human services field is confronted by challenges from various aspects which include sufficient fundraising, retention of competent staff and implementation of training course for personnel. Moreover, human service professionals are facing difficulties in reaching out to clients in the rural areas. In order to meet the demands of their profession, human service professionals utilize technology which includes software applications, computing

The Human Side To Introducing New Technology; A Historical Perspective

5852 words - 24 pages Industrial Management. The Human Side of Introducing New Technology; From a Historical Perspective. Assignment Paper as part of the Advanced Diploma Course in Manufacturing Technology and Management; Department of Mechanical, Manufacturing & Software Engineering; Napier University, Edinburgh. Original Version Compiled 1995; Revised January 2014. Author: Peter J. Moore The Human Side of Introducing New Technology; From a

Biology And Technology In The Real World

922 words - 4 pages Non-GMO Project, up to 80% of processed foods in the United States contain food items that are genetically modified. The issue as to whether or not genetically modified organisms are safe is a huge point of contention, at least in this country. With the majority of foods being produced today containing some genetic modification, one could certainly point to anecdotal evidence as proof that the foods are certainly safe for human consumption

Technology Change The World Essay

1572 words - 7 pages Technology change the world In China, we have a saying that “Science and technology is the first productive force”. Technology affects people’s daily life, with the innovation of technology, the world developed rapidly in recent centuries. Image that if our forefathers do not create new technology, how our life will be today; we will not have lots kind of food like today; we will not have vehicles such as car, train, aircraft, and we will not