This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Taxation And Cigarettes Essay

3038 words - 13 pages

Cigarette tax measure may have unintended consequences


Matt Evans
On the surface, this November's Ballot Measure 44 is simplicity itself. The measure will increase taxes on cigarettes by 30 cents per pack, as well as on other tobacco products, and the revenue raised will be dedicated to the Oregon Health Plan and tobacco use reduction programs. What could be more straightforward?
However, the measure raises a host of interesting issues that voters should weigh prior to casting their votes. Most important, of course, is the core of the measure, its purpose: to raise money for the Oregon Health Plan, ostensibly to offset costs the plan incurs from smoking-related ...view middle of the document...

Naturally, some of these decreases in usage are attributable to social conditions, and most Oregonians wouldn't see decreased cigarette smoking as cause for great lament. The percentage of the population that is smoking has declined significantly over the years, and will likely continue to do so regardless of the state's tax policy. However, a 4.5 percent decrease in cigarette usage after the 79 percent tax increase contained in Measure 44 may seem optimistic given history's teachings.
If there is a dramatic decrease in cigarette smoking, such as has happened every other time cigarette taxes have been raised, the Oregon Health Plan can expect to continue to face a fiscal shortage.
A second factor that may affect the state's ability to collect its expected revenues has to do with the smoking public's willingness to avoid paying the tax. At what point does the tax become so onerous that smokers will go to great lengths to avoid paying? There are certainly examples where tax increases on cigarettes led to the development of a "black market" in smuggled, lower tax or untaxed cigarettes.
For Oregon, what happened in Nevada in recent years is particularly instructive. The last time Nevada raised cigarette taxes, the amount of new revenue was slight. However, it was not because people reduced their smoking in response to the tax. Rather, in Nevada, Native American reservations and other tribal lands sell untaxed cigarettes at tribal stores. OTR's sister organization, the Nevada Taxpayers Association, performed a study that showed that the cigarette tax increase did not decrease smoking, but instead drove smokers onto tribal lands to buy their cigarettes. It was a windfall for the tribes, but not for the state of Nevada.
Currently, the Oregon tribes OTR has been able to buy already-taxed cigarettes for sale on their tribal lands and at Oregon's numerous Native American gaming casinos. Native Americans are not subject to either federal or state excise taxes, although they may voluntarily pay them.
One has to wonder at what point Oregon's tribes might consider that buying untaxed cigarettes to sell to gambling tourists, with the opportunity to make up to 68 cents per pack profit on the tax portion alone, is simply too good a deal to pass up. Perhaps that point does not exist.
Finally, there is the issue of the regressive nature of all sales taxes, such as the cigarette excise tax. Studies show that those with lower incomes are more likely to be smokers. They are also less able to afford increased taxes on their purchases. For example, a person with a two-pack-per-day habit who earns the minimum wage will have to spend more than a full week's take-home pay just to pay Measure 44's tax increase.
It is interesting, however, to have a tax that will be paid, perhaps disproportionately, by low-income Oregonians dedicated to a program that serves low-income Oregonians. At the federal level in recent years, it is the wealthy who have been paying about...

Other Papers Like Taxation and Cigarettes

Addressing Risk Behaviors Essay

759 words - 4 pages and also to discourage the behavior in an effective manner. Upstream Intervention Upstream interventions are critical for reducing cigarette smoking among adolescents. Nevertheless, in upstream intervention, there has to be a combination of initiatives since one initiative cannot be effective on its own. Higher taxation on cigarettes is one way of reducing the prevalence of cigarettes since many teens will be discouraged to spend money on

Legalization of Marijuana Essay

789 words - 4 pages The arguments for and against the legalization of marijuana in the United States has been going on for many years. The valid points for both arguments are plentiful and each party feels strongly about their position on the matter. Marijuana should be legalized because the money the state and federal governments would make, and save, would ease or possibly eliminate any deficit they have. The average state and federal tax on cigarettes add up to

Tabocco Tax

3614 words - 15 pages Society, the American Heart Association and Americans for Nonsmokers Rights, to name a few. But is it necessary for the government to step in and heavily tax tobacco for the good of the people? The United States citizens have said yes, time and again by approving taxation on tobacco. In 1967 the average price for a pack of cigarettes in the United States was 41 cents. The average cost of a pack of cigarettes in 2009 was $5.09 (Hu, Sung

Impact of Sin Tax Law on Cigarette Consumption

3809 words - 16 pages Chapter 1 Problem and Review of Related Literature Introduction Assessing the Main Effects of population strategies, such as tobacco taxation and pricing, on high-risk subpopulations is important for understanding the reach and effectiveness of such strategies. Increased tobacco taxes, passed on to consumers in the form of higher cigarette prices, provide an economic disincentive to those who smoke or may be contemplating smoking. Indeed

Tax Environment

5962 words - 24 pages Hooria Majid ABSTRACT Taxes affect citizens, economy of the country, businesses, governance mechanisms, etc. Not only revenue mobilization, an effective system of taxation helps in formalizing the economy, encourages economic growth, shapes political cohesion between tiers of the Government, and results in increase in social sector service

Public Sector Economics

4463 words - 18 pages percentage of lower-income individuals overall tax liability with respect to income. Arguments in support of the progressiveness of cigarette taxes are presented later. e. The $0.48 tax on a gallon of beer is also REGRESSIVE in the same manner as gasoline, cigarettes, perfume, and tobacco. At first glance these regressive taxes may appear to be a fair way of taxation on citizens because everyone, regardless of income level, pays the same

Cross Cultural Mgmt Plan

3320 words - 14 pages counterfeits. Most of these counterfeit cigarettes, especially from China, enter the country illegally and therefore are not subject to the heavy taxation that is faced by the genuine products. As a result the prices of this counterfeits are too low offering an unfair competition to the genuine products. The population does not have efficient means of identifying them since they use the same brand names and logos just like the genuine cigarettes

Health Economic Costs of Tobacco Smoking in Canada

3692 words - 15 pages countries that sign this treaty are required to set common goals to combat against tobacco consumption. They also agree to implement minimum standards for the control of tobacco. This treaty also binds the member countries to cooperate with each other in the cross-border smuggling of cigarettes (WHO, 2012). Taxation Many governments of the world are using taxes to prevent the consumption of tobacco. There have been studies that

Effect Smoking Has on Our Society

3341 words - 14 pages suit with this type of restrictive labeling. The ruling was welcomed by Australian officials, with hopes to drive cigarette sales down even further, coupled with the extremely high taxation already imposed on the sale of tobacco in Australia. Today smokers in Australia spend on average, $16.80 (us dollars) on one pack of cigarettes. The new law will require health warnings to cover 75 percent of the front of the cigarette package and cover 90

Should Cannabis Be Legalised in Australia

1917 words - 8 pages illicit substances such as cocaine and hallucinogens due to availability and accessibility to these drugs on the market (National Drug Strategy and Household Survey Report 2010). A common argument for the legalisation of marijuana is the comparison of marijuana to cigarettes and alcohol. Based on the Australian Institute of Health and Welfare statistics, 'In 1998, around 19,000 deaths were attributable to the use of tobacco, accounting for 80

Many Countries Have Recently Imposed a Ban on Smoking in Public Areas, Including Restaurants and Bars

1988 words - 8 pages will explore economic arguments and solutions relating to the externalities caused by smoking. The central problem at the heart of this issue is the over-consumption of cigarettes and the problem that the externalities of smoking cause for the general public and therefore this essay will show that efforts to curb total level of cigarette consumption can be approached from a variety of different perspective (see graph below). The essay will begin by

Related Essays

Effect Of Cigarette Taxes Essay

908 words - 4 pages Cigarette Taxes There are around 50 million smokers in the United States today, and the taxes collected from the cigarettes purchased by this large group of people greatly contribute to the social programs the government provides. One of the biggest services the taxes go into is healthcare. The revenue obtained also goes to balance each state’s personal budgets. Without the taxation of cigarettes, the United States would lose more than $7

Vapor Strain Rws 200 Essay

1709 words - 7 pages Rachel Beck Professor Carr RWS 200 2/27/14 Electronic Cigarettes: the Future of Smoking? Today, if you were to sit at a bar on the Lower East Side, you may find yourself next to a guy smoking a light-up plastic tube that smells like cherries and think to yourself, even Humphrey Bogart couldn’t make one of those look cool. Or if you haven’t seen the 1941 film, Casablanca, you may still chuckle a bit. But could these vaping devices be the

Itc Why Small Cigarettes Have Been Launched

1475 words - 6 pages bottom and top-end of the market which are growing. However, the increase in taxation on cigarettes is a concern and it can indeed impact our volume growth. We are worried, but as of now we are doing well. Cigarettes contribute over 74% of tax revenue, while accounting for less than 15% of tobacco consumption. In fact, non-filter cigarettes are cheaper than bidi without taxes. Unless government recognizes this anomaly, consumers will go for

A Fire In The Global Village: Teaching Ethical Reasoning And Stakeholder Interests Utilizing Tobacco

4238 words - 17 pages hundred countries.4 This production has flourished, in part, due to the demand for cigarettes, the leading form of tobacco consumed in the global marketplace. The World Health Organization (WHO) has estimated that 1.2 billion people over the age of fifteen are regular cigarette smokers.5 In developed countries, 35 percent of men and 22 percent of women smoke cigarettes on a regular basis.6 In developing countries, 50 percent of men and 9 percent of