This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Taking Sides Issue 7 Essay

516 words - 3 pages

Taking Sides (Issue 7)

During the colonial period, the issue whether the Founding Fathers were democratic reformers was raised. The historian Roche insisted that the Founding Fathers utilized their powers to create a constitution that supported the needs of the nation and was acceptable to the people. While, the historian Zinn claimed that the northern economic interests and the southern slaveholders made up the Founding Fathers. Also, this self-interested elite group used Shays’ Rebellion as a catalyzation to admit a strong central government into power. Both historians have strong arguments that provide an answer to this issue that demonstrates which argument holds the answer to whether the Founding Fathers were democratic reformers.
Roche’s argument is ...view middle of the document...

Therefore, the people of the nation were always in the Founding Fathers best interests according to Roche. Roche’s argument focused on the Founding Fathers willingness to give the people of the nation acceptable rights and laws. However, in Zinn’s argument, the Founding Fathers are self-motivated and only want what is best for each one of them. Zinn stated that the Founding Fathers were only interested in balancing the dominant forces at that specific time (159). They were not interested in creating equality among slaves, Indians, women, and those who did not own property. If equality was not a motivation than only the interests of the Founding Fathers were looked at. The Constitution can be seen as a document solely focused on giving and preserving privileges to certain groups. This could easily be done by the Founding Fathers. All that was required was to allow the people of the nation just enough rights and liberties to guarantee popular support (156). Zinn’s argument is based upon the self-interest of the Founding Fathers that promoted them to establish a government based upon their wants and requests.
Both Roche and Zinn provided strong arguments; I feel that Zinn posed a stronger argument. The Founding Fathers wanted to appeal to the public, but self-interest was their chief priority. If the northerners needed to make sure their economy was going to survive, the Constitution needed to be reformed. If the southerners wanted to deal with slavery on their terms, the Constitution needed to be reformed. The Founding Fathers used Shays’ Rebellion to make a logical reason for reformation. Although many, like Roche, believe the Founding Fathers wanted to support the nation, others, like Zinn, argued that they were motivated purely by self-interest.

Other Papers Like Taking Sides Issue 7

Critical Analysis Worksheet

623 words - 3 pages all the same. | | |In the article “Common Core” the premises that supports the conclusion is the augments from both sides of the common core issue. | |It has comments from references like common core history, reactions from other states, common core costs, and control choices in | |debate

Crude: the Documentary Essay

593 words - 3 pages a lot about the issues in Amazon and through the interviews of both sides, I have a better understanding of why this issue is so complicated and why it is so hard to fight against a company like Texaco. The film was effective by taking their cameras deep into the Amazon to show the first-hand effects of human rights violation. The interviews from both sides showed the seriousness of this issue and showed that something needs to be done

Psych 555 Week 1 Individual Assignment Social Psychology Paper

373 words - 2 pages a 1,050 to 1,400-word analysis of Issue 5, “Does Cognitive Dissonance Explain Why Behavior Can Change Attitudes?” located in the Taking Sides text. As a part of your analysis be sure to address the following items: Briefly summarize both arguments discussed in Issue 5. Define consonant and dissonant cognitions. Using the arguments made in Issue 5, analyze the influence that consonant and dissonant cognitions have on attitudes and behavior

What Importance Do Women Play In The Watchtower Bible And Tract Society?

1298 words - 6 pages discuss the issue on two sides. The first side will argue the truth in the stereotypes that are gullible in a discouraged society. The other side of the issue will reflect their role in Christianity and their participation in society. Some information may be considered outdated, but it adjusts the points made in this debate. The Stereotypes The main label that began all labels about women is not only coming from The Watchtower Bible and Tract

Overpopulation

2491 words - 10 pages 10/15/12 Eng 201H Overpopulation Since the year of 2011, the world population climbs up the ladder to seven billion people. According to a survey given out by SUNY College of Environmental Science and Forestry, overpopulation is the world’s top environmental issue, followed by climate change (Science Daily). Overpopulation started through the third world countries, where most people are not being educated or given the option of

Detecting Media Bias

1094 words - 5 pages or service. Creating a testimony on paper that both sides have to sign and agree that no one shall create derogatory remarks or actions against their opponent. Fourthly, find new uses for existing things. Taking those already derogatory ads and recycle them. Fifthly, improve things. Nothing in human inventions are perfect, so here is a chance to make things better. Take the new non-derogatory ads; zoom into the body language and the facial

Spaghetti Bridge

2948 words - 12 pages 5 Methodology 5 Calculations 6 Newton’s laws: 6 Forces on the bridge 6 Stability: 6 Truss analysis 6 Structural stability of Final Bridge: 7 Testing: 7 Simulation: 7 Results: 8 Bridge failure analysis: 8 Spaghetti beams: 8 Conclusion 9 Limitations 10 Recommendations 11 List of References 12 Appendix 14 Spaghetti Bridge Activity Report 14 Group productivity and progress 18 Further Calculations 19

Negotiations

2335 words - 10 pages benefits, rules changes, and drug testing. The last point and most fought over concession was testing for human growth hormones (HGH) that enhance athletes performance. As part of the ten year labor agreement, HGH testing was to begin in September of 2011 but could not agree on testing procedures (Maske, 2011). The NFL supported blood testing but the NFLPA balked stating that taking blood was a violation of privacy. Both sides made public relations

Women in Ministry

1804 words - 8 pages the Egalitarian viewpoint. Taking these differing stances into consideration, Beck notes three reasons for this book: to settle “exegetical and theological issues,” a, “…need for amore irenic spirit among proponents on both sides,” and continual “relevant scholarship” to better understand and discern the Scriptures. [1] The main point of contention is whether or not women can or should be allowed to hold any offices of authority, such as elder

Death Penalty Debate

1515 words - 7 pages shaking, guards sometimes botch inserting the needle and veins can be hard to find if the inmate was a drug addict” (Thomas & Brant, 2007, p. 2, para 1). In one case a Florida inmate who was given the lethal injection raised his head and commented that it was not working (Thomas & Brant, 2007). The use of the death penalty is still an unanswered question. This writer sees both sides of the issue. Though it costs the government to house and feed

Balance Between Work And Life

692 words - 3 pages effective communication on both sides. Both sides must also have a clear goal of what they want from one another. Especially in an employer situation, you must understand that it is not you against the employer, but rather to view you and the employer as a whole team. Viewing yourself as one team working for the same goal allows you to better collaborate on a solution that works for all involved. Potential solutions to the issue of work/life

Related Essays

Environmental Issues And Schools Of Thought

377 words - 2 pages hurt businesses for years. Although this is an ongoing threat, the greedy oil industry is still pushing for more offshore drilling which is forcing activists of all organizations to step up and fight their plans for more drilling. There two schools of thought that should be taken into account for people dealing with this issue. The first is pluralism. The state's elected leaders need to see both sides to this issue so they can vote and make an

Weighing Your Options: Pro Life Vs. Pro Choice

1451 words - 6 pages bring about change without passing judgment due to our own personal views on the topic. Once that is accomplished, taking a course of action that will ultimately lead to a peaceful resolution on abortion is the first of many steps. We must delve deep and carefully analyze how abortion has changed throughout history, and why each significant issue in conflict between each side matters. Furthermore, we must also analyze why such conflict makes it

Twelve Angry Men Essay

1263 words - 6 pages conflict regarding his son and choses to do the right thing and vote ‘not guilty’. Other juror’s in the play that were taking the court case lightly were juror 12 and 7. Rose represents these people as men that just want the decision made so they can go home early. The have lack of effort and show some of the flaws of the jury system. Juror 12 is an advertising agent, is bored and keeps switching sides just because he wants to go home early

Animal Testing: A Reasonable Stance Essay

3020 words - 13 pages ongoing battle in our society that deals with both science and animal rights. There are those who favor it because it is allows for scientific progress, and there are those who oppose it because it is the ethically right thing to do. Both sides have valid arguments, which most people choose to side with one or the other. With a better understanding of each side of the issue, animal testing, we can conceive a credible truth. The complex issue