This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Success & Failures Of Stalin's Five Year Plans

591 words - 3 pages

“The Five Year Plans were successful in strengthening the Economy before 1941.” Explain why you agree or disagree with this view.
Though with many flaws Stalin’s five year plans did create a strong industrial base for Russia. Stalin’s aims for strengthening the economy could identify the successes of the five year plans. Stalin wanted to strengthen the economy to increase military strength due to the fear of foreign invasion he needed a well-developed industrial base especially of heavy industry. He also wanted to achieve self-sufficiency, and to improve standards of living of people in Russia to bridge the gap between them and the West. A strengthened economy would fulfil and maintain the promise to international proletariat to develop the country and become the first socialist state by industrialising.
In some ways, the five year plans fulfilled some of Stalin’s aims for example, the focus on rapid increase in ...view middle of the document...


In addition, the plan’s strengthened the economy as there was 4-12% annual growth. USSR’s economic standing in relation to other countries improved. Rapid urbanisation meant new growth. People were made to work hard and the influx of women and peasants into the workforce strengthened the economy as output was increased, wages even rose in cities.
However, despite the huge industrial growth some parts of industry such as consumer goods were neglected throughout each five year plan. This did not help to strengthen the economy or bring in any additional revenue and living standards of people suffered due to shortage of consumer goods. Even growth in the heavy industries was inefficient and poorly organised. Stalin goal of self-sufficiency only reached the extent that Russia was independent only for heavy industry whereas other areas like consumer goods and food were given no attention or priority. Instead of strengthening the economy this accentuated the problems of the working class.
Furthermore, standards of living showed little signs of improvement. The successes of the five year plans in strengthening the economy brought with it downfalls of appalling human cost. The workers were maltreated, forced to work harder, absenteeism faced great punishment, slave labour and labour camps were used. On great engineering projects conditions were terrible and accidents and deaths were prevalent. Eventually famine broke out which devastated the USSR and this weakened the economy as an unfit workforce would work less and produce less. In the cities, overcrowding was very intense in inadequate accommodation as building materials were diverted to factory building. Along with the profound lack of consumer goods and food rationing the economy regressed and morale was low.
Overall, Stalin’s Five Year Plans were undoubtedly successful in increasing the country’s industrial output and making the country more self-sufficient ultimately strengthening the economy. However, the social devastation Stalin’s plans resulted in the, poor working conditions of workers, deficient quality of goods, famine, and millions suffering in due course decelerated industrialisations and weakened the economy.

Other Papers Like Success & Failures of Stalin's Five Year Plans

Measuring The Quality Of Electronic Journals In University Library: Based On Five Year Impact Factor Data In The Journal Citation Reports

2371 words - 10 pages 2006 and 2007 by the number of articles published in Journal X in 2006 and 2007. Conceptually developed in the 1960s, impact factor has gained acceptance as a quantitative measure of journal quality (Saha, Saint & Christakis, 2003). According to Journal Citation Reports, 2010 the 5 year journal Impact Factor is define as the average number of times articles from the journal published in the past five years have been cited in the JCR year. It is

How Successful Would You Consider The 5 Years Plan To Be?

751 words - 4 pages By looking at the sources and using the all of my knowledge, this essay will discuss and conclude on whether the 5 years plans that Stalin had used to industrialized the USSR is successful or not. I will first look at the successful points of the five years plans, and discuss the failures of it, and concluding my views at the last paragraph.The five years plan was successful in a few ways. The main point of view here, is that it did increase the

How Successful Were Stalin's Economic Policies

736 words - 3 pages How successful were Stalin's economic policies? Stalin introduced the Five Year Plans and collectivisation as his economic policies to improve Russia's industrial backwardness. Collectivisation consisted of state controlled farms, as 90% of the produce would go to the state. The peasants would join their small individual plots to form communal farms, leading to larger amounts of food. The five year plans were aimed at industrial

To What Extent Was the Leader (Stalin) of One Single Party State Succesfull in Achieving His Aims?

719 words - 3 pages had planned it partly had just been a personal achievement for him and a disadvantage to the country. In 1926 the Russian economy was about 100 years backward to the rest of Europe. Stalin himself made his aim clear when he said “we have to succeed within 10 years or shall be crushed”. He developed thee 5-year-plans to more Russia to a high industrial standard. He was triggered by the fear of an attack by the western power. This fear was shared

Animal Farm and Politics

1020 words - 5 pages change. His plan to build the windmill reflects Stalin's Five Year Plan for revitalizing the nation's industry and agriculture. Stalin's ordering Lenin's body to be placed in the shrine-like Lenin's Tomb parallels Napoleon's unearthing of old Major's skull, and his creation of the Order of the Green Banner parallels Stalin's creation of the Order of Lenin. Thanks, in part, to animals like Boxer (who swallow whole all of their leader's lies), Stalin

How Has The Movie, Animal Farm Been An Illustraiton Of The Russian Revolution And Its Aftermath?

1353 words - 6 pages the movie by the other animals. When the Windmill gets destroyed, it illustrates how Stalin's Five Year Plan had failed to improve Russia's economy.In conclusion, the aim of socialism was equality by Lenin, as well as Snowball. They both believed it would make the national better place, yet both failed to do so. Even though it was a great ideal, human nature is too uncontrollable to avoid sins that would corrupt this. The true sides are shown of the animals and of Stalin and his political party when power comes in question.

Stalin And Trotsky: Patrons Of World Domination

2087 words - 9 pages and Lenin, Trotsky admitted his error on the issue of organization and decided to join the Bolsheviks. The Petrograd Soviet elected Trotsky as president. Leon then led the October Revolution in 1917 where "he would fight to the limit of endurance" (Flachmann p. 359). A year later, Trotsky was assigned to organize the military. Then he built a Red Army of five million soldiers. Although Trotsky enjoyed prestige as a military leader, Stalin

Uj7Juyuyy

1128 words - 5 pages , and Ketevan Geladze, a Georgian who was born a serf. He was the youngest of their three boys; their two previous sons died in infancy. Stalin's chief aim was to expand industrial production. For this, he developed three Five-year Plans between 1928 and 1938. Gosplan, the state planning agency, drew up targets for production for each factory. The first two plans concentrated on improving heavy industry - coal, oil, steel and electricity. Some

Russian Revolution Analysis, How The Leaders That Came To Power Solely Wore The "Robes Of The Tyrant It Has Disposed."

1003 words - 5 pages risen up against there oppressor; fore they have nothing else to loose but there life. The socially and politically successful NEP under Lenin was mitigated under Stalin's haughty and overly brutal rule. A true staunch communist, Stalin refused to let the capitalist NEP be acceptable economic policy. Once more, a leader disrobed, but in this regard it was not nearly as successful. Via his communistic Five-Year Plan, Alexander's proclamation 70 years

Carter Racing

931 words - 4 pages the thrill of it: beating the odds and winning.” Last night over dinner he had added to this argument forcefully with what he called Burns’ First Law of Racing: “Nobody ever won a race sitting in the pits.” John, Fred and Tom had discussed Carter Racing’s situation the previous evening. This first season was a success from a racing standpoint, with the team’s car finishing in the top five in 12 of the 15 races it completed. As a result

System Fail

865 words - 4 pages System Fail Scott Goretzke POS/355 3/26/14 Gary Smith System Fail According to Webster, a failure is classified as “an omission of occurrence or a state of inability to perform a normal or specified function that ultimately leads to a lack of success.” In the light of operating systems, this topic can be extremely important to a customer and designer of said system. Failures in a system can create

Related Essays

How Far Do You Agree Stalins Five Year Plans (1929 1941) Improved The Russian Economy?

1254 words - 6 pages production rate this first five year plan was ended early in December of 1932. The successes of this plan were that production, the economy and the social mobility increased along with the success the failures of this where that it caused widespread fraud, worthless products and finally malnutrition and bad diets of the people as they were forced into working in such hard conditions and for long hours. The second five year plan began in 1933

How Successful Were The Five Year Plans In Transforming Russian Industry In The Years To 1941?

1741 words - 7 pages conditions). All four of these factors play a key role in the success of Russia's industrial transformation by the Five-Year Plans. I believe the most important factor was World War II, as the country was able to move over 1520 factories to the Eastern regions to stop them being taken over by the Nazi Germans; this meant the workforce were still able to produce weaponry and machinery, eventually leading the Soviet Union to defeat the Nazi Germans

Success And Failures Of The Irish Community

1204 words - 5 pages The Successes and Failures of the Irish Community Sociology of Developing Countries The Successes and Failures of the Irish Community Throughout history many communities were formed for many different reasons. Some communities were able to become successful cultures while others did not. The reasons why communities are successful stem from many different reasons. “Some theories conclude that communities thrive and others do not because of

In The Context Of The Period 1825 1937, To What Extent Was The First Five Year Plan (1928 1933) The Most Successful Change To Russian Economic Output?

4029 words - 17 pages . However, despite overarching economic development, many of the targets set by central panning didn't consider the quality of products or waste of materials and on reflection, highlight a number of fundamental flaws in the measurement of success of the first five year plan. Stalin's idea of collectivisation forced the peasants to move to a commune, share the livestock and equipment whilst having to give the government their share of the