This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Submarine Essay

3588 words - 15 pages

Rear Admiral Hugh Scott (MC) USN (Ret.) 3707 Merlin Way Annandale, VA 22003-1326 (703) 204-9146 (h); (703) 346-7767 (c) The Honorable Ike Skelton Chairman, House Armed Services Committee U.S. House of Representatives 2206 Rayburn House Office Building Washington, D.C. 20515-2504 11 March, 2010

Subject: The Assignment of Women on Submarines: Issues of Concern Enclosure: Memorandum Assignment of Women to Submarines–Issues and Concerns Dear Congressman Skelton, Ten years ago, I had sent a letter to the HASC in which I expressed my concerns about making any changes to the submarine all-male assignment policy. There are many quality of life issues to consider, but my letter focused on ...view middle of the document...

Based on that experience, I have serious concerns about the risk to the safety and normal development of an embryo-fetus in the submarine environment. The significant number of operational deferments granted to women for the occurrence of unintended pregnancies, while serving on sea-duty, suggests that this pattern would also occur with the assignment of women on submarines. However, unlike surface ships, the sealed environment of the submarine atmosphere poses an increased risk to the normal development of a woman’s embryo-fetus. In addition, the nature of the operational mission coupled with a very limited medical capability aboard a submarine will significantly increase the risks of survival for women who may be stricken with complications of abnormal pregnancies while underway. These health-related issues argue against any change in the current submarine allmale assignment policy. Congressman Skelton, I ask that you and other members of the House Armed Services Committee ask the Secretary of Defense to answer a

series of specific questions, starting with these: How does the Navy intend to resolve the unintended pregnancy problem? How does the Navy plan to manage the consequences of abnormal pregnancy complications occurring while underway, and out of range for a timely medevac? How will the Navy protect the embryo-fetus from the risk posed to its normal development if a pregnancy is detected while the boat is deployed? If the Navy cannot resolve these problems, why are officials planning to assign female sailors to submarines? I hope you will agree that the lack of sociological or psychological research on the effect of gender mixing on individual and group dynamics during submarine operations is reason for concern and immediate intervention by Congress. Health and safety issues must take precedence over matters of career and equality. No change in the policy should be considered unless the Navy can give categorical assurances to women that service in submarines will not cause any increase risk to their health (female fertility), or injure a product of conception, i.e. the embryo/fetus. Such assurances cannot be given, due to the unavoidable risk of fetal exposure to carbon monoxide, carbon dioxide, aerosol trace elements, and other hazardous substances found in the submarine atmosphere. The predicted rate of ectopic pregnancy, 4 per 1000 Navy women per year, poses a serious risk under the best conditions; however, if that pregnancy complication occurs while deployed on a submarine, the likelihood of a fatal outcome is greatly increased. Finally, although there are no available studies on the socio-psychological effects of gender mixing on submarine operations, it would be reasonable to expect that the proposed assignment policy change would alter the existing dynamic and quality of life in the hazardous and demanding undersea environment. Considering that unit cohesiveness, morale, and combat effectiveness of the U.S. Submarine Force...

Other Papers Like Submarine

How to Design Injection Molding Plastic Gates and Runners

573 words - 3 pages . This is critical for injection molding plastic parts. Round parts, such as gears, should be gated centrally. Use a diaphragm gate or three plate mold. This will ensure that the parts are balanced and round. Parts that are cup-shaped, such as capacitors, should be gated near the base. This will help avoid gas buildup and burning. Cosmetic parts or those that cannot show gate marks should be tunnel or submarine gated. Always gate into the part

Bibliography Essay

592 words - 3 pages multiple routes for pushing traffic on Internet resulting high uptime and minimum latency for customer TTSL MEIS Network Architecture TTSL Network – ISP backbone network TTSL has procured bulk bandwidth on different submarine cables having capacity in multiples of STM through Internet bulk bandwidth suppliers resulting in an uninterrupted and efficient data flow over the internet. TTSL has predominantly deployed its network fiber in mesh

What Caused the Us to Break Neutrality and Enter Ww1

563 words - 3 pages retaliated by blocking British ports. The Germans had a new weapon, a submarine called a U-boat, which gave them a new advantage. They could sneak up on ships underwater and attack them. On May 7, 1915, a U-boat sank the Lusitania, a British passenger liner that was loaded down with ammunition killing almost 2000 passengers, 128 of which were American citizens. The United States and President Wilson were outraged. Wilson still remained neutral

The Great War

1254 words - 6 pages -Hungary and Turkey). On April 2, 1917, President Woodrow Wilson went before a joint session of Congress. Wilson wanted to declare war against Germany. Wilson noted that Germany’s violation of its pledge to suspend unrestricted submarine warfare in the North Atlantic and the Mediterranean, also commenting on its attempts to entice Mexico into an alliance against the United States ( On April 4, 1917, the U.S. Senate voted in


1592 words - 7 pages melting of the mantle causing volcanism and creating new oceanic crust. Most divergent plate boundaries are at the bottom of the oceans, therefore most volcanic activity is submarine, forming new seafloor. Black smokers or deep sea vents are an example of this kind of volcanic activity. Where the mid-oceanic ridge is above sea-level, volcanic islands are formed, for example, Iceland. b)Convergent plate boundaries Subduction zones are

Nuclear Brinkmanship

592 words - 3 pages massive nuclear attack against the Soviet Union if they were to invade Europe. It was only with the advent of ballistic missile submarines, starting with the George Washington class submarine in 1959, that a survivable nuclear force became possible and that a second strike capability became credible. It was generally assumed that any combat in Europe would end with apocalyptic conclusions.      An idea that has not sunk

Vice Admiral Al Knetzni

1256 words - 6 pages Leader/Follower paper Vice Admiral Al Knetzni Vice Admiral Al Konetzni was known throughout the submarine force as “Big Al the Sailor’s Pal”. His thoughts on leadership showing concern and care from the Captain of a Submarine down to the lowliest Seaman made him one of the most well liked and remembered flag level admirals of the modern Navy. He retired from the Navy as a three star Vice Admiral holding the position of Deputy Commander of

Comparison and Contrast of the Steps That Led Russia to Leave Ww1 and the United States to Enter Ww1

1814 words - 8 pages though their actions claimed the opposite. Another step that paved the way for the USA to enter the war was the German Submarine warfare. It was generally known that Britain held the control of the seas and because of that Germany developed submarine or U-boats to challenge the British. At the very beginning, the American did not care about this new weapon as long as the German avoided attacking American ships without warning. The German

Timeline: a Nuclear World

1660 words - 7 pages 400,000 homes. The APS-1 remained in service for 48 years and was decommissioned in April of 2002. There are now 441 nuclear power plants throughout the world in 30 different countries. 1958, U.S.S. Nautilus travels under the polar ice cap As the world continued to seek practical uses for nuclear energy, the U.S.S. Nautilus was breaking records. The Nautilus, built in 1954 for the U.S. Navy, was the world's first nuclear powered submarine

Yellow Button

6008 words - 25 pages hunger and fullness cues before, during, and after meals. Use them to recognize when to eat and when you've had enough. 7% of intake 6% of intake 5% of intake 5% of intake 4% of intake 4% of intake 8. Cake, white, with icing, homemade or purchased 4% of intake 9. Baked beans, (Boston baked beans) 10. Cake, chocolate, devil's food or fudge, with icing, from mix 11. Chicken submarine sandwich, with lettuce, tomato, and teriyaki sauce

Pearl Harbor

801 words - 4 pages incoming Japanese attack planes were detected by the radar and reported, but were mistaken for an incoming group of American planes due from the mainland that morning. While on practice maneuvers outside the harbor that morning, an American destroyer spotted a Japanese submarine attempting to sneak into the harbor. The submarine was fired upon, immediately reported — and ignored. Pearl Harbor is located on the south coast of Oahu Island. At the

Related Essays

Collins Class Submarine Essay

1813 words - 8 pages The Collins Class Submarine Story: Steel, Spies and Spin is the joint production of Peter Yule and Derek Woolner, and is a project commissioned by Cambridge University Press with support from the Department of Defence. It cites its aim as ‘simply to tell the story of the submarine project from its origins to about 2005.’ The book itself is based upon a combination of unclassified, open source and specially declassified material and, perhaps

Capital Allowance Essay

2715 words - 11 pages of years for which the IRU is acquired. This is to encourage telecommunication carriers to hub their networks in Singapore. The WDA is effective from the Year of Assessment (YA) 2004. An “Indefeasible Right of Use” or “IRU” refers to an indefeasible right to use an international telecommunications submarine cable system1. An international telecommunications submarine cable system is often built and owned by a few parties, commonly known as a

Influences On America To Enter World War I: Three Of The Major Events And Reasons That Influenced America To Go To War

894 words - 4 pages entrance onto the field of battle was inevitable. Three of the several reasons that the U.S. did enter the war are: Germany's naval policy (unrestricted submarine warfare), American economic interests, and propaganda from the Allied powers.The major reason that war was declared on Germany in 1917 was its naval policy. Germany perfected the submarine, or U-boat, and developed it into the one of the most lethal and decisive weapons in the Great War

Case Study

1845 words - 8 pages CASE STUDY – COLLINS CLASS SUBMARINE PROJECT EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Background The Collins Class Submarine (CCSM) Project has been the subject of intense media scrutiny since it was first announced that Australia was to undertake a project on this scale. Over the years, the notion that Australia would attempt to manufacture a system as complex as a submarine has been scoffed at by a number of senior politicians and military commanders. The notion