This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Stuart Mill And John Locke Conception Of Freedom

2373 words - 10 pages

Introduction
John Locke (1632-1704) and John Stuart Mill (1806-1873) are two important thinkers of liberty in modern political thought. They have revolutionized the idea of human freedom at their time and have influenced many political thinkers afterwards. Although their important book on human freedom, John Locke’s The Second Treatise of Government (1689) and John Mill’s On Liberty (1859), are separated 170 years, some scholars thinks that they are belonging to the same conceptual tradition, English Liberalism. In this essay, I will elaborate John Locke and John Stuart Mill view on human freedom and try to find the difference between their concept of human freedom despite their similar ...view middle of the document...

He briefly summarizes this view by saying that:

“...how any one should ever come to have a property in anything: I will not content myself to answer, that if it be difficult to make out property, upon a supposition that God gave the world to Adam, and his posterity in common, it is impossible that any man, but one universal monarch, should have any property upon a supposition, that God gave the world to Adam, and his heirs in succession, exclusive of all the rest of his posterity.”

If people other than the feudal lords were capable of owning the land they worked, the Aristocracy would lose it means of control. Locke stated that “whatsoever then he removes out of the state that nature hath provided, and left it in, he hath mixed his labour with, and joined to it something that is his own, and thereby make it his property.” The peasant deserve the land of his labor. Working a field is what made the field owned, not some privilege from Scripture.
Mill lived from 1806 to 1873, the period of drastic social change and industrial revolution in England. Britain’s society mostly live in a town because of the industrialization. People are moving from the rural area to the big city. Social condition in Mill’s era was different from Locke’s era, because at Mill’s time the Aristocracy began to fall. At that time, England experienced big change because the traditional Aristocracy that own land and monarchy position were disturbed by wealthy merchants. Wealthy merchants begin to took their place in society and operate industrial factories. The power associated with ownership of land started to crumble as agrarian economies shifted more toward industrial economies.
Meanwhile, the low and middle class had to suffered. They have to work hard and endured physical labor in factories to earn their living. Living standards of worker at that time was worse than during the feudal period. Voth indicates that during the Industrial Revolution “[h]ousehold budget surveys and altenative indexes of living standards such as the human development index (HDI) strongly suggest that gains in living standards, broadly defined, were very small.”
The working conditions of the poor in England during the Industrial Revolution were nothing short of a new form of slavery. Like the peasants of Locke’s time, factory workers needed their job in order to live. But workers also needed their children to work in order to put food on the table and pay rent for the shoddy home they most likely shared with as many as four other families. While it is true that children had worked in the fields of their parents during feudal times, fieldwork was a far cry from factory work.
While governments had a hard time in overcoming this new society problems, there began to emerge a number of political ideas which many were convinced would solve the economic problems of the age. The root of these ideas can be traced to two school of thought, the Political Economist and the Philosophical Radicals....

Other Papers Like Stuart Mill And John Locke Conception Of Freedom

John Locke- Second Treatise Of Civil Government

725 words - 3 pages Locke believed that it is the natural right of all people to be free. Unfortunately, in a state of nature, the weak become deprived of their rights by the brutish. Locke states that government is necessary to protect the life and property of ordinary citizens, only because without it, the people cannot be free. Locke also advocated a strong set of checks and balances. He believed that the citizens themselves were the final set of checks and

John Locke: The Role Of Private Property In One's Life

1771 words - 8 pages In the Second Treatise of Government by John Locke written in 1690, he writes about the right to private property. In chapter V which is titled "Of Property" he tells how the right to private property originated, the role it plays in the state of nature, the limitations that are set on the rights of private property, the role the invention of money played in property rights and the role property rights play after the establishment of

Conception And Birth Of Heroes In Greek Mythology

1268 words - 6 pages be as special as their lives will prove to be. A mundane birth is simply not an option for a hero, whether by the machinations of the gods or prophecies from an oracle, even the events surrounding their conception must be spectacular. From Perseus and Danaë to Theseus and Aethra, the myths surrounding their births have different settings and details but many common threads that bind them together (Leeming). Aethra, daughter to Pittheus king of

Utilitarianism And Omelas Applying John Stuart Mill's "Utilitarianism" To Ursula Le Guin's "The Ones Who Walk Away From Omelas"

1330 words - 6 pages people of Omelas' decision to be perfectly moral. For Mill says that morals are grounded in the fact that pleasure and freedom from pain "are the only things desirable as ends" (Mill 55). The only thing people should strive for is happiness and pleasure; which is all the people of Omelas were doing. Unfortunately, when a deeper analysis is taken of Mill's "Utilitarianism", one may discover many statements contradictory to this belief.Every one who has

The Improvement of Performance Level of Jaw Crusher and Mill

518 words - 3 pages formation of square-shaped, the bulk density can be used for stone shaping, and in the production process, the stone can be formed protection layer, and the device body has no wear and it is durable.The hydraulic efficient cone crusher, VSI sand making machine, 5X series sand making, the HCS90 efficient cone crusher, R-type tilting Mill (Raymond Mill), high pressure mill, high pressure micro powder S ultra-fine grinding mill, medium speed trapezium

Freedom of Speech, Dissent and Truth

1366 words - 6 pages Friedrich Struensee.[25] However Struensee himself imposed some minor limitations to this edict in October 7, 1771, and it was even further limited after the fall of Struensee with legislation introduced in 1773, although censorship was not reintroduced.[26] John Stuart Mill (1806–1873) argued that without human freedom there can be no progress in science, law or politics, which according to Mill required free discussion of opinion. Mill's On

Pros and Cons of Freedom of Speech

1301 words - 6 pages Name Instructor: Course Date: Pros and Cons of Freedom of Speech The freedom of speech is a political right of every human being to communicate their own ideas or opinions, using their body, or property to any other person who is ready and willing to receive them. This right is also synonymously used with the freedom of expression. Under the freedom of rights, the right to seek or receive information or impart any information regardless

Freedom Struggle of India and Non Violence

1633 words - 7 pages AHIMSA AND OTHER MYTHS IN THE HISTORY OF INDIAN FREEDOM STRUGGLE ABSTRACT 1. History, whether ancient or modern is not a disinterested exercise narrating the events of the past. The historian selects events which suite his or her perspective and interpret them in the light of the current concepts or the historians pre-dialections. So much so that one theoretician recently called history a “mythistory” (Joseph Mali, Chicago University

Japanese Internment Camps and Freedom of Speech

2422 words - 10 pages actually “relocated to separate Depertment of Justice internment camps” (Ostgaard et al. 200). However, on the grounds of these camps not only were religious freedoms taken away but administrators of the camps officialy encouraged Christianity as the religion of choice. Ostgaard et al. (2000) found that “Japanese Americans were denied the guarantee of freedom of speech and press with the prohibition of using the Japanese language in public

The Concept Of Happiness According To Kant ( With The Categorical Imperative) And Mill (With The Utilitarianism)

1096 words - 5 pages Kant vs. MIll"Happiness"In two words the concept of happiness exemplifies the "American dream". People go to any means by which to obtain the many varied materials and issues that induce pleasures in each individual, and ultimately in the end, the emotion remains the ultimate goal. John Stewart Mills, a nineteenth century philosopher, correctly supported the pursuit of happiness, and maintained the concept that above all other values, pleasure

"The Tragedy of Othello Stems from Men's Misunderstandings of Women and Women's Inability to Protect Themselves from Society's Conception of Them"

2492 words - 10 pages  "The tragedy of Othello stems from men's misunderstandings of women and women's inability to protect themselves from society's conception of them". Shakespeare's views on women and their roles in the world at this time has been highly debatable for centuries. Feminists have been especially interested in the character of Desdemona, her actions and finally, her fate, in analysing the position, roles and views of women in society and how

Related Essays

John Stuart Mill: On Liberty The Nature And Limits Of The Power Which Can Be Legitimately Exercised By Society Over The Individual

1553 words - 7 pages Liberty for John Stuart Mill is defined as "the nature and limits of the power of which can be legitimately exercised by society over the individual". Mill argues that society can only use authority over behaviour that harms others; anything else is an end of human freedom. He links liberty to the ability to progress and to avoid social inactivity. Free discourse is a necessary condition for intellectual and social progress. The only time humans

Socrates And John Locke Essay

787 words - 4 pages universal agreement)? Is he right? In John Locke’s Essay Concerning Human Understanding, he addresses his argument against innate ideas, and how exactly our ideas are not innate, but rather gained from experience. His basic argument against innate ideas was that if we were to have innate knowledge, then the same type of knowledge would be imprinted in everyone’s head. He brings up that children and “idiots” do not possess, nor do they have the

Contrasting Thomas Hobbes And John Locke

1042 words - 5 pages Contrasting Hobbes and Locke Nearly two-hundred and twenty-five years ago the United States of America chose to fight a Thomas Hobbes government, with the hope of forming a John Locke institution. The ideas of these men lead to the formation of two of the strongest nations in the history of the world: Great Britain followed by the United States. Thomas Hobbes viewed the ideal government as an absolute monarchy, due to the chaos of

Social Contract Theory Of John Locke

1278 words - 6 pages land better. This concept allows man to stand up and breathe freedom and accept that change is possible through them. John Locke loved the idea of man as a whole and he loved the notion that man had passion and believed that with the proper direction one could essentially change government forever with just an idea. In many countries the notion of freedom is no more than a whisper on the evening breeze that cools the cruel dictator of the land