This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Stem Cell Research & The Utilitarian Principle

942 words - 4 pages

Stem Cell Research and the Utilitarian Principle

Human Embryonic Stem Cell (HESC) Research offers hope in alleviating suffering from debilitating diseases and possibly death. HESC are characterized by their ability to self-renew and different into different types of cells (pluri-potency). The main goal of HESC Research is to identify which mechanism governs cell differentiation, and then turn the HESC into the specific cells types which may be used to treat various illnesses. The restorative benefits of HESC are strong factors in favor of the research. Despite the promise of HESC Research, many still oppose it because harvesting of HESC ultimately leads to the destruction of the ...view middle of the document...

Arguments in support of HESC Research invariably incorporate Utilitarian sentiments. We argue that the end result of ‘sacrificing’ embryos to harvest their stem cells is so overwhelmingly positive – because of the large number of illnesses it has the potential to cure – that it must be the right thing to do. Illnesses for which we have no cure such as Parkinson’s, Alzheimer’s, Diabetes or paralysis have the potential to be cured. Proponents of HESC research argue that without the use of HESC the research cannot move forward and the ability to end this aspect of human suffering and save lives is delayed or lost. Consequently, the destruction of the embryos to obtain stem cells is justified; healing the sick is the greater good which results in the most happiness for the greatest number of people, so the research should be pursued at the expense of human embryonic life (Hollinger, 2001).

Embryos, while of value are not equivalent to human life as long as they are still incapable of existing outside the womb. To the Utilitarian, the social, economic and personal benefits to humanity that may be realized through this vital research are more important and of far greater value than personal costs associated with the destruction of the embryo, especially because in most cases the embryos were already slated for destruction.

One critical argument against utilitarianism as it relates to HESC research is that it diminishes human dignity and worth. This is related to Kant’s deontology which states we should never treat people as means to an end, but rather always as ends. There is much debate about when human life actually begins. Opponents of HESC posit that human life begins at fertilization – thus human status is conferred on the zygote and it earns the right not to be killed. If the embryo is considered a person,...

Other Papers Like Stem Cell Research & the Utilitarian Principle

Stem Cell Research Essay

970 words - 4 pages Stem Cell Research Stem cell research has been happening for 30 or more years through bone marrow transplants, but has only been a major debate for about the past ten years with the first isolation of embryonic stem cells (UMichigan). According to a popular issues website the definition of stem cells is, "… contrasted with "differentiated" cells. They offer much hope for medical advancement because of their ability to grow into almost any kind

Stem Cell Research Essay

1603 words - 7 pages WEEK 6: Stem Cell Research Legislation Course Project Abstract Stem cell research while very important in the medical field has and continues to be a source of controversy. Over the years legislation in the United States has gone back and forth over what is deemed acceptable and ethical as it pertains to this research. Due to recent legislation the ability exists to realize the potential of this research both in the United States and

Ethical Research Stem Cell

870 words - 4 pages Imagine a world without disease, or the need for transplants. Have you ever known someone who needed a new kidney, heart, or liver? How about someone with a rare blood type that desperately needed a transfusion after chemotherapy? These are all issue that could theoretically disappear through the use of stem cells. The pros of stem cell research outweigh the cons. So what exactly is a stem cell? A stem cell is a very versatile cell that

Stem Cell Research

1403 words - 6 pages Stem Cell Research Ashford University Alicia Lanier Philosophy 200 [ June 11, 2012 ] Sundie Goulding Stem Cell Research has burst on the national political scene in the United States only within the last decade. The Stem Cells are very special types with the potential for developing into any one of the 200 or more different

Stem Cell Research - 1594 words

1594 words - 7 pages Stem Cell Research Legislation and the Related Legal Issues LAWS 310, Legal Environment Course Project Week 6 October 4, 2011   “In the beginning there is the stem cell; it is the origin of an organism's life. It is a single cell that can give rise to progeny that differentiate into any of the specialized cells of embryonic or adult tissues.” STEWART SELL, Stem Cells Handbook Have you ever thought that humans would eventually see the

Stem Cell Research Paper

1392 words - 6 pages Jean-Marie Lux Biology 121 Stem Cell Research Paper September 12, 2012 Stem cell research is a relatively new field and has made huge advances in the past fifty years. The idea of stem cells was first made public by a Russian-American Scientist named Alexander Maksimov in 1908. However it was not until 1963 that two Canadian Scientists were able to actually demonstrate the existence of self-renewing cells found in the bone marrow of mice

Stem Cell Research 13

1788 words - 8 pages Abstract Stem Cell Research is a controversial issue that revolves around the question of when human life actually begins. Social, political, ethical and religious groups from all around the world view the answer to this question in multiple ways. This leaves the individual governments with the choice of whether to extend government funds to the research and in determining what regulations need to be enforced in an area that could potentially

Stem Cell Research Paper

1261 words - 6 pages , since the adult being treated has given consent (6). Unfortunately, the use of induced pluripotent stem cells still can result in problems. In clinical trials, embryonic stem cells have done a better job at differentiating. Induced pluripotent stem cells have a tendency to gravitate toward their original cell type (3). All types of stem cell research should be equally funded as they all have the potential to help patients suffering from hard

Stem Cell Research Legislation

1461 words - 6 pages Stem Cell Research Legislation Human stem cell research is a very touchy subject. The negative attention it has drawn from the press and politicians has detoured many researchers and scientists from the field. “After the scientific and political obstacles are overcome, it is anticipated that the human stem cell research field will make a tremendous difference in conditions, such as burn traumas and diabetic foot ulcers, as well as a number of

Stem Cell Research - 3164 words

3164 words - 13 pages | STEM CELL RESEARCH LEGISLATION | | | Joshua Dye | 10/9/2010 | | First you have to understand what we are dealing with and the definition of what we are speaking about. Stem cells are cells found in all multi cellular organisms. They are characterized by the ability to renew themselves through mitotic cell division and differentiate into a diverse range of specialized cell types. Research in the stem cell field grew out of

Stem Cell Research - 679 words

679 words - 3 pages A Civil War on Ethics For many years scientists all over the world have been fighting an ethical battle concerning morality of stem cell research. There are various opinions surrounding stem cell research and a vast amount of evidence supporting each side of this controversy. Patrick L. Taylor of children’s hospital Boston describes human embryonic stem cells as the primary cells from which cells in the body ultimately differentiate and

Related Essays

The Importance Of Stem Cell Research

1419 words - 6 pages tissue and can even grow new organs. Currently scientists are focusing on how to treat and even cure cancer, Parkinson’s, spinal cord injury, Alzheimer’s, burns, heart disease, diabetes, and arthritis, all by means of stem cell engineering. As these advances in stem cell research and engineering, coupled with moral obligation and legislative guidance continue we have the potential to treat, cure and for future generations make a lot of the diseases

The Importance Of Stem Cell Research

2721 words - 11 pages “The greatest risk to scientific progress is to stop taking risks”. Dr. Elias Zerhouni from the National Institute of Health gave this quote during an interview to a reporter in 2007. He was referring to Stem Cell research, a controversial medical issue of today. Louise Brown of Manchester, UK owes her life to scientists and doctors taking risks and exploring the world or Stem Cells. In 1978 she became the first baby to be born via in-vitro

Stem Cell Research Essay 1066 Words

1066 words - 5 pages . Utilitarian scientist in the Gerona Corporation are once again pushing those ethical boundaries, using human patients as guinea pigs in their quest for lucrative patents from embryo-destructive stem cell research. Contrary to the impression many people have, research involving human embryonic stem cells is not new, yet human embryonic stem cell research has thus far been unsuccessful in the quest to develop any therapeutic treatments. Stem cell

Stem Cell Research Essay 1625 Words

1625 words - 7 pages law. Should an aborted fetus discarded based on principle? We are torn on that aspect. In all other cases of stem cell research, we find no ethical compromise - only gain for the betterment of mankind.References:Antkowiak, L. (2001). Understanding stem cell research. Retrieved May 2, 2005, from, R.L. (2004). Against embryonic stem cell research: the teaching of the Catholic church. Retrieved May 2, 2005 from http