This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Star Dreck: Paranoia & Patriotism In Alien Invasion Films

2463 words - 10 pages

Star Dreck: Paranoia & Patriotism in Alien Invasion Films

My premise is really quite simple: aliens are among us.And they're bad.But they're not the aliens you think they are, and they're not bad for the reasons you might imagine.In order to understand who these aliens are and why they're bad I want to begin by reaching back into the dark heart of the McCarthy era, when American paranoia in its most popular incarnation as American patriotism was at its peak.The year is 1951 and the film is Howard Hawkes' The Thing: From Another World.

For those of you who have somehow come this far in your otherwise admirable education without once seeing this influencial film, a brief synopsis: a ...view middle of the document...

We might see in Carrington an enthusiasm for other ways of thinking and being taken to suicidal extremes, a sort of multicultural mania.

The soldiers, on the other hand, understand the mortal threat the Thing represents from the very beginning; in fact, they can't even stand to look at it--a deep-seated aversion which sets the plot in motion, as it causes a soldier to put a blanket over the block of ice which contains the Thing, thus melting the ice and setting it free.Throughout the film, while the intellectuals stand about debating endlessly about how to deal with the Thing, the soldiers resolutely do what is necessary to first exclude the alien from their midst, and then annihilate it, without wasting a moment worrying about whether the Thing and its culture are worth getting to know.As their commander says at the end, he doesn't want "any part of it."

In traditional readings of this film, the Thing is seen as a stand-in for our fear of Communism as a de-humanizing ideology, a system which made people into unfeeling, replaceable, souless plants.But I find this argument unconvincing.After all, the Thing does not represent the real threat in this film; rather, that distinction goes to Dr. Carrington, the intellecutal, who works at every turn to betray his fellow Americans because he believes in the superiority of the Thing and its culture.At most the Martian represents brute strength, while Carrington embodies the cunning arrogance of deceptive rhetoric and ideological fervor, which I would argue are the true trademarks of the demonized Communist.While the intellectual carrot, as the reporter Scotty calls it, is an enemy the American soldiers can understand, it is Dr. Carrington who is the true alien to them.As Margaret Sullivan, the commander's love interest and Dr. Carrington's secretary puts it, "he doesn't think the way we do."Thus, not only is Carrington saddled with the blame for creating nuclear weapons, but his desire to understand foreign ideas is figured as inherently fanatical, dangerous, crazy--and, most importantly, traitorous.Lastly, I would point out that Dr. Carrington--with his goatee and fur hat--looks a lot more Russian than the Martian does.

Of course, much has been written about The Thing as an expression of 1950s American paranoia, especially given the last line of the film, when the reporter Scotty warns the world to "Watch the skies!Keep watching!Watch everywhere!"Clearly Scotty is heralding the coming seige mentality of the Cold War.But I believe, given Carrington's intellectually amoral commitment to selling the whole bunch of them down the river, Scotty was also warning his fellow Americans to keep their eyes peeled closer to home; to watch not just the skies, but their neighbors.The American paranoid of the 1950s understood that the real threat to American ideology wasn't the brute strength of the Red Army, but the theorized tendency of certain intellectual internationalists to misread the mentality behind...

Other Papers Like Star Dreck: Paranoia & Patriotism in Alien Invasion Films

Did John Woo's Style Of Directing

1222 words - 5 pages , friendship, honour and patriotism. I think this kind of morality might be a bit old-fashioned but I think it's worth trying for because there is a lot good things in the past. People were a lot more caring about each other, they knew how to respect each other and they use to love their family and their country and somehow that changed. I like to bring back all those good old things in the films

The Monolith Essay

970 words - 4 pages i’ve watched 2001 along with other Kubrick films over ten times and as a prime of what I state of what my interpretion of the monolith it would be useful to highlife some details, one of them being that there are no aliens in the movie and there is no dialogs specifically describing dialogs. this is as close as we get “18 months ago the first evidence of intelligent life off the earth was discovered.” The briefing scene on the moon contains no

The Cold War and the War on Terror

1024 words - 5 pages genocide. The graphic novel series Watchmen is also quite critical of America during the Cold War. In Watchmen, Richard Nixon is in his fourth term as President, and nuclear war with Russia is becoming more and more likely. In order to maintain peace on earth, one of the characters simulates an alien invasion. The idea was that America and Russia would never resolve their problems and destroy the world, unless they could find a common enemy

Analysis of Coppola's "The Conversation"

2528 words - 11 pages emphasizes the audiences understanding of the pervasive nature of voyeurism, the destructive power of paranoia, and the illusion of security. The editing of the final scene, although perhaps the least notable of the four aspects, still plays an important role in heightening the tension of Caul’s downfall. The first half of the scene consists primarily of longer, steady cuts, allowing the tension to simmer before it explodes. It is not until Caul

Racism In Star Wars

4074 words - 17 pages In a galaxy far, far away… racism existBy Domenico MisceoFinal: MulticulturalismMarch 14th 2012Wodziak` The movie I chose to relate to our multiculturalism class was Star Wars; while this may seem trivial I will show how a seemingly innocent movie contains prevalent racial themes. Although most of the racial themes throughout the movies are abstracted notions that underlie characters and scenes, they exist and can been seen in every one

Postmodernism In Lost In Space

820 words - 4 pages film, photographs, and text available for use. Dead actors like Fred Astaire and John Wayne appear in new commercials for vacuums and beer. The 3-season experimental child Star Trek grows up and has innumerable progeny that can parody its 1950's vision of the future. In a cultural environment based on the marketable, malleable tastes of postmodern consumers, what sells, is artistically viable. To make a movie out of the TV series Lost In Space

Through Trials and Tears

888 words - 4 pages something nearly impossible to reach, something only reached in a dream. Many Americans don’t feel the depth of America; they see problems in the government, problems in their jobs, and problems in their lives. But for those outside our borders, it is a life of perfection. Two of the most important parts of our nation are the patriotism we share and the rights our forefathers have granted us. Words cannot express the love and appreciation I have for

Mccarthyism and the Media

2545 words - 11 pages America. Some of these films such as Invasion of the Body Snatchers (1956) portray the infiltration of society by aliens a.k.a Communists, and how only the people who are weary of the outsiders and posses a sense of paranoia of what is happening around them survive. This can be interpreted as the idea that one should always be on the look out for Communism in society and should be quick to take action. Other films dealt with the idea of

Science Fiction: Close Encounters Of The Third Kind And Independence Day

1095 words - 5 pages from space, these films are not that similar. But there are a couple noticeable resemblances. The first of which is that they both employ a government cover-up. Independence Day’s version of a cover-up played on the real-life superstitions many people have of the secret military installation known only as Area 51, in the film not even the president of the United States was aware of the base or the existence of an alien space ship in the United

Film Noir

1057 words - 5 pages light and shadow, oblique camera angles, and the ways characters are placed in unconventional or awkward positions with particular shots. (Conrad, 2006, pp1-8) Themes that characterize Film Noir include inversions of traditional values, the feeling of alienation, paranoia, presence of crime and violence, and the feelings of despair, fear, mistrust and loss of innocence. (Conrad, 2006, pp1-8) Many argue on whether or not film noir is a genre

The Cinematic Adventure That Changed The World

1077 words - 5 pages world. A film that would change the way people act, think, and live. A cinematic adventure that would do more than just entertain the audience for an hour and thirty-one minutes. A film with a name would be known throughout the globe, Star Wars. The first Star Wars movie spawned forth a universe in which fans dreamed they could become a part of. Despite all of its box office success, the greatest accomplishment of the Star Wars universe, was the

Related Essays

Horror Themes Essay

4842 words - 20 pages horror-of-the-demonic film.[10] A stream of (usually low-budget) productions featured humanity overcoming threats from "outside": alien invasions and deadly mutations to people, plants, and insects. In the case of some horror films from Japan, such as Godzilla (1954) and its sequels, mutation from the effects of nuclear radiation were featured. The Hollywood directors and producers sometimes found ample opportunity for audience exploitation, with

A Conspiracy Phenomenon: Alien Abductions In The U.S

3823 words - 16 pages media both nurtures and feeds off the growing phenomena; it produces films and books based on popular beliefs about aliens and abduction, but also seems to inspire new claims. Part of the credibility of the conspiracy theories surrounding alien abductions is the similarity of the detailed accounts from abductees, even from those who were not notably interested in the phenomena before their experience. (page 167, Bullard) In fact the narratives

Hollywood Paranoia In The 50s Essay

2095 words - 9 pages dangerous between the world of espionage and entertainment. While it doesn’t point to any particular examples in film, this text will be useful in my essay as it demonstrates the political climate and fear that existed in the 50s and the hysteria that acted as the catalyst for many 50s era films. 3. https://books.google.com.au/books?id=8BcjzzQyQa8C&pg=PA127&lpg=PA127&dq=film+during+50s+paranoia&source=bl&ots=VNvKP_afZY&sig

Film Critique Essay

765 words - 4 pages attempting to find a newborn alien creature, Brett was killed by fully growing organism.He masterfully played short, but psychologically stressful role and brilliantly performed his acting role Actor: Sigourney Weaver Actress Sigourney Weaver is known as a leading actor for her roles in films sequel Aliens ,Ghost Busters, Working Girl and super blockbuster –Avatar. Her role in the movie Alien .At the beginning of the movie Ripley with a role as a