This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Soviet Security Essay

981 words - 4 pages

How far do you agree with the view that the development of the Cold War in the years 1945-8 owed more to Soviet expansionism than to Usa’s economic interests?
I do agree with the view that the development of the Cold War owed more to soviet expansionism than USA’s economic interests in the years 1945-48. All three of the sources show evidence that soviet expansionism played a huge role in the development of the Cold War. Source 7 especially emphasizes Soviet expansionism as the most important factor claiming the USSR were “seeking to expand its influence into Western Europe” causing Western Attitudes to harden. However there is evidence in the sources to support the view that the USA’s ...view middle of the document...

The view that Soviet expansionism caused American involvement is backed up by source 8 which claims American involvement in Europe with the Marshall plan was to “prevent the spread of communism into Western Europe”, by providing a stable and prosperous Western Europe. The evidence given in these sources would greatly support the view that Soviet expansionism did owe more to the development of the Cold War than the USA’s economic interests.

However there is substantial evidence in the sources to counter that argument and claim it was the USA’s economic interests, which owed more to the development of the Cold War in the years 1945-8. Source 8 claims that the US wanted a war with the USSR due to the “important economic advantages” and “feared a depression after the Cold War”. Source 8 claims that the US government with pressure from the “military Industrial complex”which “portrayed the USSR as aggressive and threatening” to allow huge spending on arms. For example Churchill’s Iron Curtain speech in Fulton Missouri, 1946 and Kennan’s Long Telegram, 1946, which threatened the USSR causing a huge increase in tensions between the two nations which was hugely important in the development of the Cold War in the years 1945-48. Source 9 also supports the view that American economic interests owed more to the development of the Cold War. The source claims America’s economic might, forced the USSR into expanding into Europe to try and gain a “new defensive European barrier”. It also claims that Stalin was “suspicious and uncooperative” about the German question as he was afraid that the USA’s introduction of the new German Mark and the...

Other Papers Like Soviet Security

End of Cold War Essay

5921 words - 24 pages had an especially stark impact on the Soviet Union. Most of the measures the Soviets adopted to enhance their security resulted in less security because they provoked countermeasures by the more powerful United States and its allies that preserved or increased Western supremacy. Why did the Cold War last so long? Ideology and the prolongation of Cold War conflict During the Cold War, the direction of social and economic development was the

political science Essay

1471 words - 6 pages behind Sweden and Finland not joining the treaty while they were part of the North Atlantic area and faced some threat of attack. Vaahtoranta and Forsberg (2000, p.3) states that since the end of the cold war in the early 1990s, Finland and Sweden changed their national security, defense, and foreign policies. This was in order to respond to changes in their environment. Keep (1995, p.6) states that the Soviet Union collapsed in 1991 and that

How Far Do You Agree with the View That the Development of the Cold War in the Years 1945-8 Owed More to Soviet Expansionism Than to Usas Economic Interests?

1044 words - 5 pages was afraid that the USA’s introduction of the new German Mark and the merger of the 3 western zones would endanger the security of the Eastern Bloc. This caused the Berlin blockade of 1948 where Stalin blocked roads and rail from the West into Berlin to protect Soviet interests. However this can also be interpreted as an attempt to take over West Berlin as part of Soviet expansionism. The Marshall Plan as mentioned in source 8 led to a split in

Which Country Deserves More Blame for Its Role in the Cold War

1811 words - 8 pages overreacted to Soviet Union expansionist policy. Soviet Union was only looking for a national interest and a way to boost its economy due to the damage it had experienced during the Second World War. Furthermore according to Williams (1959, p.219) Stalin was more concerned with Soviet security and a creation of soviet sphere of influence in Eastern and Central Europe rather than domination of world power and aggressive ambitions towards Western

Cuban Missile Crisis

2894 words - 12 pages he asked, “He’s initiated the danger, really, hasn’t he? He’s the one that’s playing [his card, or God?], not us” (Weldes, 1999). Nonetheless, Soviet aggressiveness formed the taken-for-granted background to these discussions. Axiomatic within the postwar U.S. security imaginary was a representation of the Soviet Union as both “the inheritor of Russian imperialism” and a “world-wide revolutionary movement” (Weldes, 1999). As a result, it was

The Cuban Missile Crisis

1125 words - 5 pages highest state of readiness ever and the Soviets in Cuba were prepared to use battlefield nuclear weapons to defend the island if it was invaded. Luckily, thanks to the bravery of two men, President John F. Kennedy and Premier Nikita Khrushchev, war was averted. In 1962, the Soviet Union was desperately behind the United States in the arms race. Soviet missiles were only powerful enough to be launched against Europe; but U.S. missiles were

Hungarian Revolution 1956

1199 words - 5 pages representative to negotiate with the Soviets about the withdrawal of their troops on November 3. That night The Soviet’s Security Police arrested the representative and the next day Soviet forces again attacked Budapest codenamed “Operation Whirlwind”.By 9:30PM on November 3, the Soviet Army had completely encircled Budapest. By 3:00AM on November 4 Soviet tanks had practically split the city in half by having tanks penetrating the Pest side

Civil War 1960

1169 words - 5 pages The Cold War began at a time when America thought that they would be war free. A once peaceful alliance between The United States and The Soviet Union had turned backwards; this was the basis of the Cold War. The controversy of the Cold War began in 1945, but in actuality, the war did not actually start until 1947. It lasted over 40 years, ending in 1991. The Cold War was thought of by many as the longest running war in United States history

Revolutions

2525 words - 11 pages a Peaceful crowd formed outside of a radio station in Pest (the eastern half of Budapest), the ¡°lam Vð[lmi Osztᬹ¡± (?O), the Hungarian Internal Security Police, began firing on the crowds unprovoked. The O would have easily triumphed over the crowd had it not been for the intervention of factory workers from Csepel Island who supplied the crowd with arms. Soon, all hell had broken loose . In response, the Soviet government ordered an

How Far Do You Agree That Without Soviet Interference, Eastern Europe Would Not Have Become Communist in the Post War Years?

1164 words - 5 pages paved the way for the communists under Stalin to take control of internal security and police to persecute any opposition. Clearly within Poland in the post-war years a large amount of Soviet interference occurred as Stalin was quick to establish a soviet government within Poland and then manipulate the votes in communist favour paving the way for all opposition to communist rule to be eliminated, giving the people little choice. One may also

The Cuban Missile

2550 words - 11 pages Hesbon ogeka LA history &politics 4/12/2013 The Cuban Missile The Cuban Missile Crisis remains an example of one of the most terrifying events in history for the people of the world. A very real threat existed for the crisis to escalate and create World War III, which would include the annihilation of countries and cause unimaginable damage from the use of nuclear weapons by the United States and the former Soviet Union. The conflict

Related Essays

“The Soviet Union Developed Its Influence In Eastern Europe In The Years 1945 1949 Because It Wanted To Guarantee Its Security In The Future”. How Valid Is This Assessment?

1241 words - 5 pages The standard view in the West during the development of the Cold War was that the Soviet Union conducted an expansionist policy which was seen to threaten peace and collective security. The provocative and expansionist nature of Stalin’s foreign policy after 1945 was singled out as the prime cause of the Cold War and, as the Soviet Union sought to expand world communism, the West was forced into taking action to safeguard the free world. However

Soviet Union Essay

564 words - 3 pages provided incentives for workers to move from job to job and the possibility of getting fired provides an incentive to work hard. In the former Soviet Union with a planned economy, incentives do not exist, therefore, employees have job security but are all equally paid with little to none incentives. Pollution: Factory managers preoccupied with meeting their quotas in command economies were not realizing the impact of mass production had on the

The Early Cold War Essay

2641 words - 11 pages Lecture six: The Early Cold War: 1948-53 The Soviet Union was controlled by Nato. The US security state * The meaning and application of National Security - the bureaucratic functioning of the National Security Council and the Department of Defense * The relationship of American foreign policy to international requirements in the Cold War - the greater Cold War need for external economic and political links due to - the wartime

Do You Agree With The View That The Sino Soviet Split Was Caused Primarily By The Political Rivalry Of Khrushchev And Mao?

1744 words - 7 pages China and demonstrating direct conflict, because of this direct action Mao began to compare Soviet leaders to the Tsar, Hitler and the KKK. Therefore, each leader’s personality links directly to their choice of actions and the breakdown of the Sino Soviet Split. National security was the basis of many tensions between the Soviets and China. Through this each was set to keep safe through strategic actions. For example, in the Korean war 1950-3, the