Socrates On Piety Essay

1107 words - 5 pages

Socrates on Piety in Justice

Towards the end of Plato’s dialogue The Euthyphro, Socrates takes the lead in a debate regarding what defines pious action and uncharacteristically gives significant insight to his own thoughts on what he believes piety to be and its relation to justice. As Socrates poses leading questions on the subject, Euthyphro attempts to reach a concrete definition of piety. At one point he comes very close to doing so, but Socrates quickly and perhaps deliberately changes the direction of the argument back towards uncertainty and confusion. As is the case with most of the Socratic Dialogues, The Euthyphro ends before an agreed conclusion is reached.
Towards the end of ...view middle of the document...

Instead he declares that pious action is done through prayer and sacrifice, and makes a very interesting correlation. He says that acts similar to piety “preserve both the private welfare of households and the common welfare of the city, whereas those that are the opposite… destroy everything.” (14b) This sentence is a clear description of what justice aims to do, and it comes close to providing a satisfactory answer to Socrates’ question.
Socrates even goes so far as to admit that Euthyphro nearly arrived at an acceptable answer, but then immediately redirects the focus toward the first half of Euthyphro’s response concerning the “knowledge of sacrificing and praying” (14c). Had Euthyphro continued to list what is common to both just and pious acts, it would have been possible for him to discover what is specific to piety alone while maintaining his definition of it as an act of service. To do this, he should have given the following reply:
“While justice is concerned with every aspect of preserving the welfare of a population, the sub-set of piety aims to preserve the population of man only in regards to man’s relationship with the gods. It is through prayer and sacrifice that man provides service to the gods and remains in their good grace. In return, man asks for mercy from the gods and at times even for their assistance. This is not to say that the gods are in need of our prayer and sacrifice; but it is nonetheless pleasing to them, just as it is pleasing to any being to be both respected and appreciated for one’s power and achievements. On the other hand, the benefit man gains from pious action is absolutely necessary for his existence, for without the mercy of the gods all of mankind would perish. In this way it is evident that while both may benefit from one another, only man requires the service of the gods, whereas the gods do not require the service of man.”
This reply maintains Euthyphro’s position that piety is a service as well as a subset of justice, and even specifies the intended goal that piety seeks to accomplish. It also avoids making any statements that could be considered heresy. Consequently, it would have adequately answered all of the questions posed by Socrates up to that point in the dialogue and left him without many options to refute...

Other Papers Like Socrates On Piety

Euthyphro-Plato Essay

1157 words - 5 pages Euthyphro’s well-known impasse pertaining to the characteristic of piety is one of the many dialogues written by the Greek philosopher Plato detailing the pursuit for wisdom by his mentor, Socrates. This well-known impasse regarding the nature of piety presents the question of whether or not piety is an act or thing loved by the gods? Regardless if an act is considered right or wrong, the truth or a lie, just or unjust, and holy or unholy, all

Plato Five Dialogues Essay

520 words - 3 pages about his ideology of the pious and impious. Euthyphro then claimed that what is pious is what is dear to the gods and Socrates ironically agrees that Euthyphro finally answers his question but yet the idea of it is still incorrect. Socrates then begins to have a debate with Euthyphro and manipulates his mind to the right path of main question. On the same token, Euthyphro begins to only agree with what Socrates says. He convinces Euthyphro that

What Is Philosophy According to Socrates?

1074 words - 5 pages of what philosophy is today. Socrates actually wrote nothing, because he felt that knowledge was something to be gained by living and interacting in the world. So most of what we do know about Socrates comes from the writings of another very important person in Greek history, Plato. Socrates’ philosophy was based on pursuit of truth through the questioning of beliefs, virtue being defined as knowledge and talking about the elements that make up a

"The Trial And Death Of Socrates" By Plato

1389 words - 6 pages A true mirror to the visage of humanity and its qualities and downfalls, The Trial and Death of Socrates, by Plato, uses its complex and profound themes to create a stark image in the mind of the reader and presents many simple to complex, controversial issues that the human race only pretends to understand, yet acts on. The book itself was written nearly two thousand and four hundred years ago in ancient Greece, yet it still can point out

Socates V. Perpetua

1812 words - 8 pages who understands justice and injustice, the one, that is, and the truth itself”. In the story of Perpetua, the majority would be the non-Christian Romans. Perpetua’s fate was decided by the state but her opinion is arguably the same as Socrates, because she pays no mind to the majority people. The evident distinction is that her reasons are based on her piety. The majority mean nothing to the calling of God since “…whatever God wills shall happen

Question Of Morality

2664 words - 11 pages Throughout ages of human society, the question of morality has always been hotly debated. Many famous philosophers of iconic lands, such as Socrates, Voltaire, Confucius, and Swami Vivekananda have written and spoken volumes on the meaning of morality and its impact on human society. Their actions and judgments have helped society, such as Socrates impact on Ancient Greece or Vivekananda’s impact on Medieval Indian Society. Because of their

Vegetable

1439 words - 6 pages Running Head: Vegetarianism Vegetarianism [Name of Writer] [Name of Institution] Vegetarianism Introduction The habit of living exclusively on vegetables, fruits, grains, cereals and not including meat is known as vegetarianism (Beardworth, 2005). Vegetarianism has been practiced for various reasons. They may be ethical, austere or health reasons. Vegetarians do not include any kind of meat in their diet. Studies have shown that

Freedom And Responsibility

2141 words - 9 pages Built within the Constitution of the United States are specifically defined freedoms that are guaranteed to all citizens. Conversely, with every constitutional freedom there comes a corresponding responsibility. On September 25, 1789, the state legislature’s twelve proposed amendments were transmitted by congress, the first two dealing with congressional representation and congressional pay. The following numbers three through twelve were

Hate Crime Laws

2348 words - 10 pages On June 7, 1998, 49-year-old James Byrd Jr. of Texas accepted a ride from three white men, who then beat him severely, urinated on him, chained him by his ankles to the back of their pick-up truck, dragged him for three miles into the countryside, and dumped his corpse in front of an African-American cemetery (Graczyk). A little over a year later, a jury sentenced ring leader John King to death by lethal injection (“Man Executed for Dragging

Rational Emotional Behavior Therapy Case Study Conceptualization And Treatment Plan

2140 words - 9 pages the secret, Sarah is questioning her relationships and views of her family members. Sarah is unsure of what to do with the information she has been presented and is reevaluating her childhood, which she once thought had been near perfect. She is feeling confused, frustrated, angry, and isolated and these feelings and emotions have brought her to seek counsel over the situation. Case Conceptualization Based on the assumption that Sarah is

Holidays In Albania

1636 words - 7 pages popular northwestern Albanian beaches of natives of Kosovo. More southwards, Lezha is the western Albanian city whose beach is Shëngjin. The most important characteristic of Shëngjin beach is that its sand contains too much iodine. Consequently, it has curative impact on its tourists. Along the western Albanian seaside, the next touristic city to visit is Durrës. It has the biggest seaport in Albania. Many hotels with the main view towards the sea

Related Essays

Piety In Ancient Greece Essay

806 words - 4 pages . (2003). Plato the last days of socrates. Humble piety. (2010, July 29). Retrieved from http://humblepiety.com/2010/07/19/on-piety-part-1-of-2/ Mark, J. J. (2012, January 18). Plato's euthyphro: Piety and pretension . Retrieved from http://www.ancient.eu/article/54/

Phi208 Week3 Assignment 1

1083 words - 5 pages will end with a definition of my own for piety given in a Socratic response. The concept of holiness emerges in the story when Socrates is waiting for his trial for impiety to begin, when he sees his friend Euthyphro also waiting for a trial to begin; his own father is on trial for impiety and Euthyphro is the one that is prosecuting him. Socrates stated these words to Euthyphro, “A man must be an extraordinary man, and have made great strides

The Life Of Reason Essay

676 words - 3 pages Throughout Plato's "Euthyphro" and his "Apology," the young Graecian examines the words and testimony of Socrates. From the ancient philosopher's debate with Euthyphro over the persecution of his father, to his trial in Athens, the readers learn much in the views and reasoning of Socates within the two short stories. Moreover, Socrates discusses many subjects, including piety, knowledge and the value of living a closely examined life

Euthyphro Dilemmo Essay

1037 words - 5 pages , Euthyphro mentions that "I think, Socrates, that on this subject no gods would differ from one another, that whoever has killed anyone unjustly should pay the penalty." (8-A) In conclusion, what was considered as good or bad, right or wrong, ugly or beuaty, pious or impious based on what gods, accordingly man, do.As we see, these terms piety and impiety are enough to put a person to death even if that person is a relative.How we should think at