This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Social Justice Essay

1246 words - 5 pages

Running Head: Social Justice- Dhimmitude

Social Justice Project- Dhimmitude in Health Care
Lindsey Weber
LA 105 –Professor McKinnis
November 9, 2011

I found the oddities in the healthcare bill to be quite intriguing. There has been some major controversy over the health care bill as it is, and the deeper one delves, the more one finds about its details. I was particularly curious about a section that supposedly entitles Muslims in this country to practice “Dhimmitude” as part of their health care. It is easy to see the varying opinions on the matter, so I researched these and came to my own conclusion.

The actual meaning of the word “dhimmitude” is the ...view middle of the document...

Insurance is considered gambling, risk-taking and usury in their eyes, and therefore the U.S. government pays for it (“”). Religious tolerance is important to be a democracy, but the freeloading of healthcare is unfair to those with a different religion.
Bat Ye’or introduced the entire concept of dhimmitude in 1983 to describe the conditions of Jews and Christians under Islamic Jihad laws. The Arabic word “dhimmi,” meaning protected, was the word it is derived from. This word was used when a treaty was made with people conquered by Arab-Muslim tribes (“The Status of…”). All of these concepts of governing conquered peoples come from the idea of shari’a law (“Sharia Law:”). This acts as a religious guide to life, something like the Bible is for Christians.
While none of the words including “dhimmitude,” “shari’a law,” “Muslim” or “Islam” appears in the healthcare bill; enough of the ideas are present as to set some people on edge. There are parts of Shari ‘a Law especially that disrespect women’s rights and some basic respect that Americans sometimes take for granted. It is because of these differences that any concepts from the laws of Muslim people are under heavy criticism.
Some may argue that the concept of an agreement between a conquered people and their conquering party is a sound and fair practice. While in some cases this is true, when translated correctly, “dhimmi” is a demeaning term. It speaks of vulnerability and humiliation (Review of Islam…”). Pride is a major part of one’s devotion to their country. If a concept such as this is part of one of the American government’s most prided responsibilities, who’s to say it won’t spread to more drastic measures?
Islam’s foundations do not tolerate any religious aspects of the jihad-conquered “infidels.” Therefore, the idea of tolerance is an historical falsehood. This means a hope of coexistence between Muslims and Christians is not actually possible. It would more realistically be the slow disappearance of Christianity from these regions. Now isn’t that a scary thought? If there is truly a separation of church and state, this part of the bill comes close to crossing that line.
While this may seem unreasonable in the present, it is clearly a relevant issue in Europe. People there are slowly giving way to the more assertive ways of the Islamic populations. As the minority grows, it may become a majority. America is a melting pot and adapts concepts and laws from around the world. If Europe is undergoing something so drastic as we speak, who’s to say it couldn’t happen elsewhere? If Muslim people wish to practice their religion in harmony with others, there is nothing to stop them. If...

Other Papers Like Social Justice

Social Justice Essay

700 words - 3 pages Social Justice Essay Ashley Seeram Most will agree the public needs an educational system beneficial to all, but many people have different opinions on how this can be done and what a beneficial educational system is. There are groups that say division says privatize education, and another group of people who believe charter-schools are not the solution to this problem. Is it important to give the public an option to what they want or need

Ottawa Charter Promotes Social Justice Essay

958 words - 4 pages The Ottawa Charter and its five action areas promote the principle of social justice. The charter aims to build a positive approach towards health for all members of society through the five action areas. Social justice is a primary principle of the Ottawa charter as it aims to communicate equal opportunities and enable Australians to achieve their fullest health potential. Through the Ottawa charter, social justice is promoted. The Ottawa

Social Justice and the Bible

4943 words - 20 pages Social Justice and the Bible While it appears one is compassionate when this term of “social justice” is used we now know where it comes from. You find neither the term nor the principle in the Bible; nor in the US Constitution. There are liberal/progressive Christians that claim “social justice” is part of the gospel. We are not commissioned to transform society and make sure everything is equal. We are called to rehabilitate sinners by the

Profiles in Social Justice Research—Morton Deutsch

2217 words - 9 pages Social Justice Research, Vol. 19, No. 1, March 2006 ( C 2006) DOI: 10.1007/s11211-006-9997-4 Profiles in Social Justice Research—Morton Deutsch John T. Jost1 Morton Deutsch has been a leading figure in the social psychological study of social justice for more than 50 years. His experimental and field research on such pivotal topics as conformity, intergroup relations, cooperation and competition, trust and suspicion, conflict

Justice And Social Order In Antigone

1600 words - 7 pages as Scene magazine, The Gazette (The University of Western Ontario’s daily publication), as well as having edited and wrote for the B’nai Brith Youth Organization’s publication in Alberta. I do hope you will be interested in this story, I believe that this article will add further dimensions to the issue of an increasingly obese generation. I look forward to hearing your reply. Justice in “Antigone” is torn between social order in terms of

Jackson Browne: Musician And Advocate Of Social Justice

900 words - 4 pages Jackson Browne has been a vocal and eloquent advocate of social justice for over three decades. He has spoken out against US foreign policy, particularly as it applies to Central America, and his music has affected change through the increased social awareness of his large fan base, fans who are also voters. Clyde Jackson Browne was born on October 9, 1948 in Heidelberg, Germany to Jack Browne and Beatrice Amanda Dahl. Jackson's father

Explain How the Notion of Social Harm Is Connected with Ideas of Social Justice

1682 words - 7 pages Explain how the notion of social harm is connected with ideas of social justice. In order to explain how the notion of social harm is connected with ideas of social justice it is important to identify how these concepts are defined in order to use supporting evidence. There are many forms of social harm, ranging from physical harm of violence, rape, child abuse which show the entanglement between harm and crime, and other forms of social

Comparison And Analysis Of Social Justice In The United States And India

1256 words - 6 pages Comparison and Analysis of Social Justice in the United States and India Jessica M. Alstad Argosy University Author Note All correspondence pertaining to this work should be directed to: Jessica Alstad, 4305 Grayson Drive, Indianapolis, IN 46228 Abstract Social justice has multiple definitions depending on the country a person resides in. The definition of social justice in the United States differs from that definition in India. Some

Watched the movie "Romero" and wrote about the Social Justice in Romero

556 words - 3 pages "The government should not consider a priest who takes a stand for social justice, as a politician, or a subversive element, when he is fulfilling his mission in the politics of the common good". - Oscar RomeroOscar Romero was not only a man of love, dignified faith, valor, and hope; he was a man of social justice. Social Justice is the equal right for every member of society. Oscar knew he had to defend his people and if that meant dying, he

Key Social Issues Contributing to the Service of the Criminal Justice Practitioner

1258 words - 6 pages Markisha Harris CJ 100: Preparing for a Career in Public Safety Prof. Hadley Unit 7 Assignment 23 July 2013 What is the role of a criminal justice professional? There are numerous amounts of roles that a criminal justice practitioner plays. Depending on which section of the criminal justice system you are certified in, your studies ensures your specialty in your career field. In this particular essay, we will focus on the key social

Justice System

1027 words - 5 pages Constitution. The Constitution outlines laws, freedoms and power to several governmental agencies. Government first plays a role in making laws. Then insure enforcement of laws by various and appropriate departments. Next, there are courts and high courts to support laws. The government knows laws are not always perfect and has a system of checks and balances to equally weigh personal freedom and social justice. For example FEMA handles natural disasters

Related Essays

Social Justice Essay

824 words - 4 pages Alec Showalter Teacher Philosophy 101 30 April, 2014 Social Justice The main Key to studying philosophy is by opening you’r eye’s and especially you’re mind. Philosophy is the study of general and fundamental problems that investigate the ideas about truth, knowledge, and the meaning of life. Now that you have a clear look at what philosophy is. I would like to introduce to you a certain topic that revolves around philosophy, and this

Social Justice Essay

961 words - 4 pages write about the area of Social work that interests me the most. It is also something that I feel I have had some experience in working with. So I chose to write about the concept of Social Justice and the social worker. So let’s first take a look at the definition of Social Justice in chapter 4 of our book it defines Social Justice. However I would like to sum it up in my own words Justice simply stated means fairness and equality. So that

Social Justice Versus Criminal Justice Essay

5843 words - 24 pages Running head: SOCIAL JUSTICE This is a sample paper for Dr. Matthew Robinson’s class … CJ 5150, “American Justice System and Social Justice” at Appalachian State University The paper is not be used for any purpose other than illustration for students in the class!!! Social Justice versus Criminal Justice Appalachian State University Social Justice versus Criminal Justice In

Social Justice In India Essay

1172 words - 5 pages The term "social justice" implies several sound and eminently desirable concepts enunciated for the good of society in general, and of course it covers fair play for every section, especially the weaker groups in the popu¬lation. The reckless flouting of the concept of social justice, and the denial of equal opportunities in life which this postulates, all reflect a tendency that is anti-national and marks totally unfair and unjustified