Should We Be Allowed To Break The Law

671 words - 3 pages

Should we be allowed to break the law?

John Smith


September 14, 2013

Philosophers, scholars, activists and judiciary officials, among others, have often concerned themselves with whether or not breaking the law can be justified. Some questions through which this query has been posed include, Should people be allowed to break the law? Should individuals be able to ignore the laws in which they do not believe? Can breaking the law ever be justified, morally or ethically?

In his situation, King discusses how many other countries are moving forward in how they develop and treat others. He criticizes the United States as they creep forward with the pace of a horse and buggy when it comes to civil rights. He discusses how those who were not while have been lynched, beaten, killed, prosecuted, turned away from and denied access to certain places and ridiculed with mean language. King and his followers supported the de-segregation ...view middle of the document...

Rawls believed that there must be a clear injustice, the act of disobedience must be a public act which is both non-violent and non-threatening in nature and the perpetrator(s) must be willing to accept full responsibility, including the penalties, for acting in their proposed manner. In addition, the acts must be carried out with fidelity to the law. These guidelines can be viewed as a reasonable set of criteria in determining whether or not an act is civil disobedience, which would be justifiable, or a blatant disregard of the law, which would not be justifiable (Grant, 2007, p. 2-3). To this extent, people should break laws that they do not believe in if they are unjust. However, individuals who do this should be prepared to and be willing to accept all responsibility for their actions, including the punishments and any other judicial consequences.

Non-violent civil disobedience, such as that practiced by Martin Luther King, Jr. and many others, including the environmental organization Greenpeace, can be said to be justified as “there is a history of long-standing harm or violation of people’s fundamental rights, when legal and policy means have failed to reduce the harms and violations, and when there is little time remaining to address the problems” (Zerbisias, 2011). Breaking the law for the sake of breaking the law is not justifiable. However, when it is performed within the specific criteria discussed herein, it may be justified. “People do not have the right to harm others who have not given their consent”, but civil disobedience, which is non-violent and non-threatening by its very nature, can be justified (Zerbisias, 2011).

Grant, S. (2007). Should we ever disobey the law?. Richmond Journal of Philosophy, 14 pp. 1-7. Retrieved from: [Accessed: 15 Sep 2013].
The Atlantic (2013). Martin Luther King's 'Letter from Birmingham Jail'. [online] Retrieved from: [Accessed: 15 Sep 2013].
Zerbisias, A. (2011). When breaking the law is justified. [online] Retrieved from: [Accessed: 15 Sep 2013].

Other Papers Like Should We Be Allowed To Break The Law

Should Cell Phones Be Allowed in School?

518 words - 3 pages Should Cell Phones Be Allowed in School? As society grows older and develops, technology seems to advance and augment with it as well. Many teachers hate the idea of phones at school. Unsurprisingly, the younger generation support the idea. There are several valid reasons as to why cell phones should be allowed in school. Firstly, cell phones can help salvage money. According to MediaSmarts who surveyed around 5400 school kids in each

Smoking Should Not Be Allowed on Campuses

771 words - 4 pages Smoking Should Not Be Allowed On Campuses Because of the improvement of technology, it is easier and more affordable to buy cigarettes. Smoking becomes general phenomenon. According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (US CDC), there are an estimated 42.1 million adults in the United States currently smoke cigarettes. However, the report also said that more than 2.4 million people died in the USA annually, and over

Should They Be Allowed in Public Schools?

2026 words - 9 pages Unvaccinated Children: Should they be allowed in public schools? Assignment 5: Persuasive Paper Part 3: Possible Disadvantages, Answers, with VisualsYour Name Lisa Teitler Eng 215 March 13, 2016 Unvaccinated Children: Should they be allowed in public schools? Today’s vaccinations are regulated by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) in order to ensure their effectiveness and safety to the general public. Currently there are no federal

Why Teens Should be Allowed to buy Contraceptives Without Parental Permission

623 words - 3 pages Ben Frey Why Teens Should be Allowed to buy Contraceptives Without Parental Permission According to, there are 750,000 teen pregnancies each year in the U.S. With numbers like this, teenagers should be allowed to obtain birth control without their parents' permission in order to reduce pregnancy and orphan rates and because privacy is a constitutional right to all Americans. Teens are at an awkward time of

Should Elementary Schools Be Allowed To Teach Children About Controversial Political Issues?

655 words - 3 pages Elementary schools should not be allowed to teach children about controversial political issues. When children are in their preteen years they are the most vulnerable in believing the information that is provided to them. In addition, children get into conflicts with parents over the issue that has been thought to them in school. As well it gives the children long-term political ideology, that their side is always superior to the other.When

Should We Give Credit To The Writer

1329 words - 6 pages DQ Week #2 When you speak or write, do you own the words that you have created? If I am to think that we don’t own what we speak or write, why is it important than, to always cite or give credit to someone else. Thus, this must be the question…………”Why do we cite or give credit?” Who does the words belong to? Let’s take the biblical argument “In the beginning God created the heavens and the earth. The earth was without form, and void; and

Gay Marriage This Is An Essay On Why Gay Marriage Should Be Allowed In The United States. It Covers Several Reasons Why Gay Marriage Should Be Allowed Including Constitutional Reasons

555 words - 3 pages able to marry but should be allowed to have civil unions. This idea has prompted some states to enact civil unions as a substitute for gay marriages. However, civil unions do not offer the same benefits as marriage does such as heath care benefits. In addition, only allowing homosexuals to have civil unions are reducing them to second-class citizens. I find this to exhibit several parallels with how African-Americans and women were treated as

Should the Drinking Age Be Lowered to 18?

1640 words - 7 pages twenty-one finally legal to drink in a bar. Unfortunately, I was two-and-a-half years into serving my country and was living in a combat zone, and I found it odd that until then I was still not allowed to drink alcohol in the States. A law I hope will be changed in my lifetime.” Different cultures and societies respond different to alcohol in terms of how much they can drink and what their bodies can handle. The legal age to consume alcohol in the

Should The Voting Age Be Lowered To 16?

1060 words - 5 pages Who can vote and who can't?This question has been debated nationwide during these past years. A fundamental element in the success of a democratic society is the willingness of the people to be self-governing. In today's modern society, to say that we have a government that is for, by, and of the people does not mean that each citizen is dictatorial. It does not imply that each citizen takes the law into his or her own hands, but rather that

When Is It Acceptable To Use A Cell Phone? Should We Be Punished For Having Bad Manners?

978 words - 4 pages consideration for other people either through thoughtlessness or indifference or perhaps lack of attention to what they're doing. If we can convince people to make them selves aware of how their actions are affecting other people, the cell-phone problem will go away by itself, along with a lot of other annoying behavior. Even so, I do not believe that someone should be fined for having bad manners.Even with my own experience with cell phone users, I

Should the Warehousing Function Be Outsourced to 3rd Party Logistics

2559 words - 11 pages Should the warehousing function be outsourced to 3rd party logistics? Justify your decision. Contents Introduction 3 1. Industry Trends 1.1 Global Business Communication 4 1.2 Just In Time 4 1.3 Technology Innovation 4 2. 3PL Concept. Why the Need for Outsourcing 2.1 Focus on Core Competency 5 2.2 Proven Track Record? 5 3. Solutions

Related Essays

Should Homosexuals Be Allowed To Marry?

1125 words - 5 pages others, and be together until death do us part. Should it matter that the couple doesn't fit into what society is used to? I say no. To disallow marriage on the basis of homosexuality is simply discrimination against an undesirable lifestyle. A. Thesis Statement Men and women who are attracted to partners of the same sex should be allowed the same Constitutional rights as any other human being. Same-sex marriage is a reality; it is a social

Parents Should Be Allowed To Lie To Their Children

992 words - 4 pages Name Professor PHI 102 20 February 2016 The question that crosses our minds time and time again is whether or not parents should always tell their children the truth. We must first ask ourselves the definition of truth. Truth in this case will be defined as that which is in accordance with fact or reality.In discussing the reality of situations with children, each case differs. Christians have been celebrating the birth of their lord and

Should Public Sector Employees Be Allowed To Strike

4461 words - 18 pages -sector union. Second, both the biggest union in 2007 (the NEA) and the fifth-biggest union in 2007 (the UFCW) were substantially larger than the first- and fifth-biggest unions in 1974. This trend has shifted as we see almost no private sector unions, and the ones in the public sector constantly under attack. Throughout this paper, I will argue for the need for public sector employees to be allowed to strike as part of the negotiation process

Should College Students Be Allowed To Get Married

722 words - 3 pages should still be forbidden. This also takes the further development of us students into consideration. In order to have a more brilliant future, we should pay more attention on studies rather than things such as daydream of marriage. ----------------------- [1] The Chinese law has clearly stated that any legal male citizen above (and including) 22 and female citizen above (and including) 20 is allowed to get married. [2] Cite from the internet. The URL is “”